Toronto pedestrian Cross walk protocol question

As a frequent pedestrian and watcher of people ..... I'm going to play devil's advocate as something smells here.

You said "I saw him at the last minute and stood on the brakes" and "He does NOT actuate the crosswalk flashing lights". If you had enough time to observe him not pressing the button, why did you not slow/stop earlier thus avoiding the situation entirely? Alternatively, if you are assuming he didn't press the button because the lights weren't flashing, how can you be sure that the lights worked, did you check the button?

It's medical fact that as we get older our vision gets poorer, especially at night and when it's raining. Complicating this weakness are pedestrians wearing dark clothing that aren't in the driver's center of vision. Also as we age, our focus and attention span gets poorer. JTK, you are older aren't you?

As a pedestrian I try to make eye contact with the driver before I cross, but 30% of the time even that doesn't work. I find that certain ethnic drivers and older people will still just drive right through the crosswalk. Additionally, allot of cars have tinted windows (often illegally dark) so at night, it's almost impossible to catch a driver's eyes, especially so in the rain.

I'm a believer in mandatory bi-yearly MTO eye examinations (including simulating dark and rainy conditions) and evening road tests for people over 55. Every 5 years for people between 16 and 55. As drivers we develop many bad driving habits and we need to be "forced" to address them because we are too arrogant and lazy to do it on our own.

Perhaps I should have been more clear. So "I'm driving down the street and there was a guy using a cross walk walk without the lights flashing and without pointing. (You're actually supposed to point as you walk across the crosswalk). When I first became aware of him, or saw him, he was around the middle of the road, maybe just before the centre line. I'm not exactly sure. What I am sure about was that he was already well into the roadway. As soon as I saw him, I hit the brakes and I didn't enter the cross walk and I didn't hit him. I just had to go full brake to be able to stop."

At night, it's dark and it's only logical that a pedestrian more than ever should activate the light.

I also didn't say that I saw that he didn't push the button, I said that the lights were not flashing. That much is for sure. They were not.

Crossing lights are checked by City of Toronto patrols on a twice a week basis. Bet you didn't know that. I'd say it was a certainty that the lights were working just fine. In addition, I yelled at him to "push the button next time moron" and he yelled back that it was a cross walk and called me fuckhead. I would assume that if indeed he did push the button that he would have yelled back, "I did push the button fuckhead", instead of just, "it's still a cross walk fuckhead" I clearly heard what he said. So my ears are just fine.

I'm driving down the street in the dark and the rain and I simply didn't see him. I'm looking way down the street. He would have been able to see my headlights (assuming that he in fact even bothered to look). He just figured that he had the right of way and fuck you (i.e. fuck me). It's an interesting concept pedestrian right of way. And while I agree with it, common sense should dictate to pedestrians that they do need to be careful whether they have the right of way or not. In his case, he did not actuate the lights, he did not point, he did not wait until it was safe to proceed. He just figured that he was more the most important thing in the world and damn you all.

It's interesting to contrast this North American ideal of the pedestrian always having the right of way no matter what. Go to Europe. I'm thinking of Italy and Belgrade and St Petersberg. Places I've been. Pedestrians definitely do NOT have the right of way. (Or if they do, I never saw it.) Cars will not slow down. Stop lights are just a suggestion. You as a pedestrian are the one obligated to be careful because if you get hit, you're probably going to die. So beware.

But getting back to my original question, "am I obligated to stop for a person crossing in a crosswalk if they have not pushed the button to activate the lights and pointed, etc." no-one has given me a link with respect to what the law says. I know for example, if you hit a jay walker, it's not the driver's fault if you didn't see the jay walker. The jay walker was crossing the road where there was not an intersection or crosswalk.

I don't doubt that there is a law somewhere that says that the driver must stop at a cross walk regardless of whether or not the pedestrian follows the correct protocol or not. But no-one here has posted it. So as far as it goes, buddy crossing the road got the right of way. I hammered on the brakes and did not hit him. So what more did he want? It ended well for him.

As to my age. I'm younger than you. And I did see him. I just would have appreciated if he hit the lights like he was supposed to. I don't think that would have been too much to ask, do you?

I'll take a closer look at that cross walk next time I drive by it.
 
If I point at a crossing, cars should stop (assuming they see me). Right?

Theoretically yes but if you try that on the 404 I think you are looking to commit suicide or cause a pile up.

Actually in all serioussness I think there is a difference between city roads and highways.

I think the pedestrian also need to use common sense and look for an ideal time to cross rather than acting like Moses parting the red sea.
 
He does have the right of way, but if you killed him because he didn't activate the button in the dark of night or inclement weather, then he has some blame too if not all the fault.

Like TeeJay said, that kid unwittingly was bucking for a Darwin Award. I would've told him the next time might turn him into a paraplegic and wish him well.

Actually, he wasn't a kid.

I would have guessed his age at 50'ish. He had a grey beard and glasses.
 
Theoretically yes but if you try that on the 404 I think you are looking to commit suicide or cause a pile up.

Actually in all serioussness I think there is a difference between city roads and highways.

I think the pedestrian also need to use common sense and look for an ideal time to cross rather than acting like Moses parting the red sea.

Ok lol, but I did say "at a crossing".

(Wasn't this taught to some of us old hands here by Elmer The Safety Elephant?)
 
A driving examiner failed a student once for not stopping at the crosswalk. Some teenagers were waiting for the car to pass by first, but apparently it was enough for them to look like they might want to pass at some point that the driver was supposed to stop. I don't know.

So, lesson is, driver is always at fault. All drivers are killers until proven innocent.

1l4ast.jpg
 
A lot depends upon whether as a pedestrian you want to be right or dead.

All these years later I still remember the comment of the grizzled old police sergeant who delivered one of the Freshmen Orientation talks when I arrived at University - - probably by now slightly paraphrased but in general "If you don't want to be injured by motor vehicle during your time here, always act like no vehicle can see you and no vehicle is able to make successful panic stops. Yes, vehicles are supposed to stop for pedestrians in cross walks, but when a 1,590 kg - 3,497 pd vehicle starts to skid on the ice and hits you you are going to be injured - likely severely injured, regardless of the law. But if you live according to what I've told you, that won't happen to you!
 
Last edited:
Perhaps I should have been more clear. So "I'm driving down the street and there was a guy using a cross walk walk without the lights flashing and without pointing. (You're actually supposed to point as you walk across the crosswalk).
Can you provide a reference that supports that statement? I checked both the MTO and Toronto bylaws and nothing. It's a recommended safety action in some cities when crossing in a roadway, but it doesn't appear to be the law.

I also didn't say that I saw that he didn't push the button, I said that the lights were not flashing. That much is for sure. They were not.
Your exact words were "He does NOT actuate the crosswalk flashing lights". So in truth, you don't know if he pressed the button or if the lights worked or not.

Crossing lights are checked by City of Toronto patrols on a twice a week basis. Bet you didn't know that. I'd say it was a certainty that the lights were working just fine
Really? Couldn't find proof of that on the net so I called 311. They confirmed many (but not all) traffic lights are self sensing for failures, but she wasn't sure specifically about crossing lights. She did say city personnel inspect traffic/crossing signals and buttons, but she couldn't confirm your claim of 2 x weekly (she asked her supervisor). She did say that people often call in to report light and button failures, so it's 100% possible the lights or button had failed and not yet reported/detected. Can you back-up your 2 x weekly?

In addition, I yelled at him to "push the button next time moron" and he yelled back that it was a cross walk and called me fuckhead. I would assume that if indeed he did push the button that he would have yelled back, "I did push the button fuckhead", instead of just, "it's still a cross walk fuckhead" I clearly heard what he said. So my ears are just fine.
So, from the 50 year old pedestrian's point of view, some idiot almost ran him down in a legal crosswalk, then the idiot has the balls to roll down his window and swear at him. Maybe he was a bit shocked by the situation, wasn't prepared to get into a fight and just wanted to get away from you. You afterall were the aggressor.

As to my age. I'm younger than you.
Another assumption on your part. I've pointed out to you in the past how much personal information you tend to give out, so assuming you don't lie, you are definitely older than me. Even if you were younger than me, it wouldn't change anything. Even at my age I know my reaction times are poorer and my attention span shorter than when i was 18.

I know I'm nitpicking and probably everything you said is true. I 110% agree that pedestrians should take more responsibility for their actions regardless of what the law says about fault. Better to be alive than right. The new Bill 31 has one interesting statement: "No pedestrian shall leave the curb or other place of safety at a pedestrian crossover and walk, run or move into the path of a vehicle that is so close that it is impracticable for the driver of the vehicle to comply with subsection". But as you said, he was already at the middle of the road .......

http://www.ontla.on.ca/web/bills/bills_detail.do?BillID=3057
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/glob...-and-whats-the-reason-for-it/article28392316/
http://www.toronto.ca/311/knowledgebase/68/101000049368.html
http://www.mto.gov.on.ca/english/safety/pedestrian-safety.shtml
http://www.citynews.ca/2016/01/04/drivers-facing-new-rules-pedestrian-crossovers/
 
Perhaps I should have been more clear. So "I'm driving down the street and there was a guy using a cross walk walk without the lights flashing and without pointing. (You're actually supposed to point as you walk across the crosswalk). When I first became aware of him, or saw him, he was around the middle of the road, maybe just before the centre line. I'm not exactly sure. What I am sure about was that he was already well into the roadway. As soon as I saw him, I hit the brakes and I didn't enter the cross walk and I didn't hit him. I just had to go full brake to be able to stop."
...

Clearly shows you are 100% in the wrong as far as the law goes, especially if he was already half way crossed. You should have been paying more attention. If you were in the right lane and he just stepped out as you were nearing I would have some sympathy but as you say, that wasn't the case.

He just figured that he had the right of way
He did. There is no question about that.

Of course having the lights on would have been a better idea but as he was already half way across, you have no idea if the lights were simply not working. And yes, it would have been safer if he was brightly clothed but the sad thing is the self preservation is only needed because we know that there are many drivers who are too busy "looking way down the street", on their phone or just bad drivers.
 
If I point at a crossing, cars should stop (assuming they see me). Right?

Not if you're on your front porch.It's one of those "don't try this at home" maneuvers.
There are many Pedestrian crosswalks, the obvious ones at Traffic intersections,and those between intersections with the cross walk flashing signs etc.
The flashers are because the pedestrian crossing is not at an intersection but between to intersections and so an additional level of caution is needed by both pedestrian and driver.
Whether the pedestrian uses the additional facilities at their disposal I would think it's still essentially a pedestrian crossing, and the pedestrian is more vulnerable than the person in a moving piece of metal and so should have the right of way.
Prudence would dictate that as a driver, one approach all pedestrian crossings the same way, regardless of whether there is the flashing amber lights or not.
Especially seeing that lots of Pedestrian crossings and crosswalks are usually situated in school zones as well.
 
...But getting back to my original question, "am I obligated to stop for a person crossing in a crosswalk if they have not pushed the button to activate the lights and pointed, etc." no-one has given me a link with respect to what the law says....

Google Bill 31, Transportation Statute Law Amendment Act (Making Ontario's Roads Safer), 2015


Pedestrian crossover

Duties of driver
(1) When a pedestrian is crossing on the roadway within a pedestrian crossover, the driver of a vehicle approaching the crossover,
(a) shall stop before entering the crossover;
(b) shall not overtake another vehicle already stopped at the crossover; and
(c) shall not proceed into the crossover until the pedestrian is no longer on the roadway.
(2) Subsections 140 (3), (4) and (6) of the Act are repealed and the following substituted:
Passing moving vehicles within 30 metres of pedestrian crossover
(3) When a vehicle is approaching a pedestrian crossover and is within 30 metres of it, the driver of any other vehicle approaching from the rear shall not allow the front extremity of his or her vehicle to pass beyond the front extremity of the other vehicle.

Duty of pedestrian
(4) No pedestrian shall leave the curb or other place of safety at a pedestrian crossover and walk, run or move into the path of a vehicle that is so close that it is impracticable for the driver of the vehicle to comply with subsection (1).


It says absolutely nothing about a pedestrian having to make sure lights are lit or even point.
 
That's the crux right there, and the problem. All responsibility is put on the driver, even in cases where a pedestrian is far more able to avoid or cause an incident.

Not all. As stated in the law I just posted, the Pedestrian at a crossover is at fault if they step into the crossing when cars are too close to stop (not the case for JTK).
 
Google Bill 31, Transportation Statute Law Amendment Act (Making Ontario's Roads Safer), 2015


Pedestrian crossover

Duties of driver
(1) When a pedestrian is crossing on the roadway within a pedestrian crossover, the driver of a vehicle approaching the crossover,
(a) shall stop before entering the crossover;
(b) shall not overtake another vehicle already stopped at the crossover; and
(c) shall not proceed into the crossover until the pedestrian is no longer on the roadway.
(2) Subsections 140 (3), (4) and (6) of the Act are repealed and the following substituted:
Passing moving vehicles within 30 metres of pedestrian crossover
(3) When a vehicle is approaching a pedestrian crossover and is within 30 metres of it, the driver of any other vehicle approaching from the rear shall not allow the front extremity of his or her vehicle to pass beyond the front extremity of the other vehicle.

Duty of pedestrian
(4) No pedestrian shall leave the curb or other place of safety at a pedestrian crossover and walk, run or move into the path of a vehicle that is so close that it is impracticable for the driver of the vehicle to comply with subsection (1).


It says absolutely nothing about a pedestrian having to make sure lights are lit or even point.



I recall pedestrians pointing, making eye contact and waiting for traffic to stop, before crossing the street. That was over 30 years ago, maybe things have changed. I seem to recall that this was taught as well, as a basic road safety fact, somewhere or other.

It may not say it, but if there is a button that actuates lights, then why wouldn't the person use it? It seems prudent, the use of a signalling device that helps ensure your safety. But, let's not waste air on common sense.
While the pedestrian may think they have the right of way, you're not going to see any vehicles in the emergency department. The pedestrian themselves, have a duty to ensure their own safety, as stated in section 4 above. If they choose to not use the signalling lights that are provided, then they have not done so. If they don't ensure that traffic has come to a complete and safe stop, once again, they have not done so. If they are dressed in dark clothing and they do these things, then they are putting themselves at risk.
The police are pretty good at investigating these and clearing drivers, as long as they get enough facts. If you have a corroborating witness, all the better. Simple facts add up, dark night, dark clothing and no signalling devices in operation...
But Saint Peter...I had the right of way...
 
I recall pedestrians pointing, making eye contact and waiting for traffic to stop, before crossing the street. That was over 30 years ago, maybe things have changed. I seem to recall that this was taught as well, as a basic road safety fact, somewhere or other.
From what I understand, it is still taught and is still common sense but it is not required by law. (It would also be sensible to wear a reflective safety vest with LED lights and ringing a bell while walking at night the way some cyclists do but pedestrians don't even think of that)
 
Clearly shows you are 100% in the wrong as far as the law goes, especially if he was already half way crossed. You should have been paying more attention. If you were in the right lane and he just stepped out as you were nearing I would have some sympathy but as you say, that wasn't the case.


He did. There is no question about that.

Of course having the lights on would have been a better idea but as he was already half way across, you have no idea if the lights were simply not working. And yes, it would have been safer if he was brightly clothed but the sad thing is the self preservation is only needed because we know that there are many drivers who are too busy "looking way down the street", on their phone or just bad drivers.

Exactly!
 
I recall pedestrians pointing, making eye contact and waiting for traffic to stop, before crossing the street. That was over 30 years ago, maybe things have changed. I seem to recall that this was taught as well, as a basic road safety fact, somewhere or other.

It may not say it, but if there is a button that actuates lights, then why wouldn't the person use it? It seems prudent, the use of a signalling device that helps ensure your safety. But, let's not waste air on common sense.
Common sense! I've always gotten a chuckle at that phrase.
- It's common sense that drivers signal EVERY lane change, but many don't.
- It's common sense to stop at a stop sign, yet 30%+ of all drivers perform dangerous/lazy rolling stops.
- It's common sense to slow down when it's raining, especially at night, many people don't. Did JFK?
- It's common sense to be vigilant at intersections and crosswalks - yet JFK was looking far down the road.

The pedestrian themselves, have a duty to ensure their own safety, as stated in section 4 above. If they choose to not use the signalling lights that are provided, then they have not done so. If they don't ensure that traffic has come to a complete and safe stop, once again, they have not done so. If they are dressed in dark clothing and they do these things, then they are putting themselves at risk.
The police are pretty good at investigating these and clearing drivers, as long as they get enough facts. If you have a corroborating witness, all the better. Simple facts add up, dark night, dark clothing and no signalling devices in operation..
Irrelevant, section 4 is for a very specific situation which did NOT apply to JFK's situation.

I'm sure the police realize that most nights are dark, a lot of people wear dark clothing and almost nobody wears reflective clothing, nor do they carry foghorns or strobe lights. The police will also realize JFK failed to see a pedestrian that already had been on the road for 4-5 seconds.

But we all agree, better alive than right ..........
 
Can you provide a reference that supports that statement? I checked both the MTO and Toronto bylaws and nothing. It's a recommended safety action in some cities when crossing in a roadway, but it doesn't appear to be the law.


Your exact words were "He does NOT actuate the crosswalk flashing lights". So in truth, you don't know if he pressed the button or if the lights worked or not.


Really? Couldn't find proof of that on the net so I called 311. They confirmed many (but not all) traffic lights are self sensing for failures, but she wasn't sure specifically about crossing lights. She did say city personnel inspect traffic/crossing signals and buttons, but she couldn't confirm your claim of 2 x weekly (she asked her supervisor). She did say that people often call in to report light and button failures, so it's 100% possible the lights or button had failed and not yet reported/detected. Can you back-up your 2 x weekly?


So, from the 50 year old pedestrian's point of view, some idiot almost ran him down in a legal crosswalk, then the idiot has the balls to roll down his window and swear at him. Maybe he was a bit shocked by the situation, wasn't prepared to get into a fight and just wanted to get away from you. You afterall were the aggressor.


Another assumption on your part. I've pointed out to you in the past how much personal information you tend to give out, so assuming you don't lie, you are definitely older than me. Even if you were younger than me, it wouldn't change anything. Even at my age I know my reaction times are poorer and my attention span shorter than when i was 18.

I know I'm nitpicking and probably everything you said is true. I 110% agree that pedestrians should take more responsibility for their actions regardless of what the law says about fault. Better to be alive than right. The new Bill 31 has one interesting statement: "No pedestrian shall leave the curb or other place of safety at a pedestrian crossover and walk, run or move into the path of a vehicle that is so close that it is impracticable for the driver of the vehicle to comply with subsection". But as you said, he was already at the middle of the road .......

http://www.ontla.on.ca/web/bills/bills_detail.do?BillID=3057
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/glob...-and-whats-the-reason-for-it/article28392316/
http://www.toronto.ca/311/knowledgebase/68/101000049368.html
http://www.mto.gov.on.ca/english/safety/pedestrian-safety.shtml
http://www.citynews.ca/2016/01/04/drivers-facing-new-rules-pedestrian-crossovers/

You're way too confrontational on this. (As always.)

You need to step away from the keyboard and relax.
 
Clearly shows you are 100% in the wrong as far as the law goes, especially if he was already half way crossed. You should have been paying more attention. If you were in the right lane and he just stepped out as you were nearing I would have some sympathy but as you say, that wasn't the case.


He did. There is no question about that.

Of course having the lights on would have been a better idea but as he was already half way across, you have no idea if the lights were simply not working. And yes, it would have been safer if he was brightly clothed but the sad thing is the self preservation is only needed because we know that there are many drivers who are too busy "looking way down the street", on their phone or just bad drivers.

I actually wasn't asking for your sympathy.

I was asking in post 1 if a crosswalk is still a crosswalk if one does not press the button to activate the lights as well as point and wait till it is safe to do so.

I freely admitted that I didn't see him until the point where I had to hammer on the brakes. Its not like I'm opposed to crosswalks or stopping at Cross walks. And I did stop, didn't run him over either. And I wasn't on my phone either, so I don't know why you would bring that up.

I checked out the street in question tonight actually. It is 4 lanes, but there is parking on either side so cars can only utilize the 2 Centre lanes. I was in the centre Lane and was not speeding. I didn't see the guy because it was dark and raining and he didn't activate the lights. If he had of activated the lights I would have seen the flashing lights and could have stopped in an easier fashion.