Toronto pedestrian Cross walk protocol question

james t kirk

Well-known member
Aug 17, 2001
24,059
4,068
113
So I'm driving home the other night and I almost run this guy over crossing the street in a crosswalk.

It's dark, it's raining, it's late and he's dressed in jeans and a black coat.

He does NOT actuate the crosswalk flashing lights, nor does he point.

I saw him at the last minute and stood on the brakes. Not even close, but he gives me the one finger salut and so I roll down the window and tell him, "push the button moron"

And he tells back, "it's still a crosswalk fuckhead"

Technically he's right.

But what does the law require?

Does he or does he not have to stop, hit the lights, point, and when it's safe to cross, cross.

This guy just walked and didn't give a fuck.

But it is a cross walk. He's right.

I've always hated Cross walks, you need to be so extra careful around them.
 
Good question especially if you slammed on the brakes, which caused you to lose control of the car and crash. IMHO, it is a waste of your time and energy trying to educate other people on what they are supposed to do. No one will ever admit that they are at fault.
 
It cuts both ways. I've seen motorists just blow through a crosswalk without a care in the world. On the other hand I've pedestrians stick out their hand at the last second.
 
I thought that the pedestrian has the right of way so even if he jumps out into traffic you have to show that you made reasonable effort to

a) be aware
b) avoid him

However if it is an animal you are advised to not swerve or stop unless you can do so safely.

A lot of responsibility falls on the driver. Much like if you rear end someone it is likely your fault as you were either not paying attention, following too close or driving too fast.
 
I thought that the pedestrian has the right of way so even if he jumps out into traffic you have to show that you made reasonable effort to

a) be aware
b) avoid him

However if it is an animal you are advised to not swerve or stop unless you can do so safely.

A lot of responsibility falls on the driver. Much like if you rear end someone it is likely your fault as you were either not paying attention, following too close or driving too fast.

sounds right

if a dog runs out in front of you it is the dogs owner that is responsible for the accident

if I rear end you as a result it is my fault

in the OPs case I say the pedestrian is at fault
 
Get a dash camera.

Pedestrian can claim the button was pressed but did not work.

Pedestrian has the right of way.

If you hit the pedestrian you would be at fault.

Your insurance would go up, pedestrian would be right but dead.
 
As a pedestrian all the time I'm hyper aware when crossing. I don't trust drivers. I'm just skin and bones and won't win in a collision.

I think technically you are in the wrong but cripes common sense should still be the order of the day.

Oh and when it's dark and raining and please slow down. I was on the receiving end. Of a hit in a crosswalk waking on the green. And he still nailed me making a left. On the other side of the median. With fogged windows.

Like I said. Common sense on both sides helps. A lot.
 
I know that I have to wait until he completes his walk across the cross walk. That rule changed just a year or two ago.

I just didn't know if he still has the right away even if he completely disregarded the protocol. I do not understand why he would not have at least pushed the damn button to activate the lights.

I think cross walks are dangerous under any circumstances. When people drive they tend to look quite far down the street and you are processing information past the crosswalk... When I use them, I always push the button AND make sure that drivers are going to stop. In his case he didn't do any of that. . It's was dark, and raining .

I didn't hit him, but it was close.
 
While I think you were in the right, I'm afraid the law is on his side. He had the right of way because he could have been killed by any impact; you didn't because you would have survived within your car. You would get to make your case to the Coroner's Jury, or after you were charged with unsafe operation causing death and you could hope that it would mitigate the penalty.

Good on you for driving with the appropriate alertness and at a speed that allowed you to protect the idiot from the consequences of his stupidity.

The evolutionary price we'll eventually pay as a species is for another thread, but let's all hope he doesn't reproduce.
 
I'm working off old rules which have possibly changed now. That being said, it was the responsibility of the person crossing the road to signal their intent by stopping at the curb, sticking your hand out pointing to the other side and making eye contact with drivers. This signaled their intent to cross, but did not give them the right of way and drivers had to safely come to a stop. Once traffic stopped, the pedestrian was to make sure that it was safe to cross, having made eye contact with the drivers who have come to a stop. Then they had the right of way to cross the street. If the pedestrian crosswalk was on a two way road, multi lane or otherwise, the opposing traffic could keep going until the pedestrian reached the middle of the road and the pedestrian had to ensure traffic stopped before proceeding by signaling their intent to these drivers, then proceed when safe to do so. I don't think that people are taught to be pedestrians anymore. I've witnessed what has happened to you. I've seen morons just keep walking and traffic has had to adjust to their stupidity. There is no eye contact by pedestrians anymore, nor is there any regard for their responsibilities as a pedestrian, putting their own safety at risk. They don't take their eyes from their phone, with their ear buds in, they are in their own little world.

This used to work quite well and it put the onus on pedestrians to ensure their own safety and as drivers, we were more aware and respected their right to cross the street.

The link provided doesn't dispute the above and one of my progeny told me I was breaking the law at signaled intersection and I made a safe right hand turn, while the pedestrian was still on the other side of the intersection. I was told that you cannot proceed, as the pedestrian has the right of way of the whole roadway and I must come to a stop. The above link states that this is so, if it is a school crossing with a school crossing guard present or other intersection with a school crossing guard present. I have witnessed drivers who can turn safely, without impeding or endangering the pedestrian, as they are at the far side of the intersection, stop and wait until the pedestrian has crossed the road. That's over 4 to 5 lanes of roadway. I get it if it's just two lanes and a turning lane. It would appear that new drivers have been misinformed of the rules of the road.

Another driver gaff I've witnessed is someone crossing at a school crossing, not a child, but teenagers and older, in after school hours or the summer months. Drivers come to a stop for them, when they shouldn't, almost causing accidents. I have also witnessed pedestrians just walking across these same spots, at a distance, without making sure traffic has stopped. Foolhardy behaviour and once again, drivers not knowing the rules of the road.
 
You must yield the right-of-way and wait for pedestrians to completely cross the road at specially marked pedestrian crossings or crossovers (Diagram 2-22) and school crossings with crossing guards.
Remember, signalling does not give you the right-of-way. You must make sure the way is clear.

Taken from the driver's handbook

http://www.mto.gov.on.ca/english/dandv/driver/handbook/section2.4.3.shtml


This is correct and this is where people are being taught to not turn and to stop, when they actually have the right of way as drivers.

Key words are; pedestrians if they are in or approaching your path . And at specially marked pedestrian crossings; You must yield the right-of-way and wait for pedestrians to completely cross the road at specially marked pedestrian crossings or crossovers (Diagram 2-22) and school crossings with crossing guards.
 
So I'm driving home the other night and I almost run this guy over crossing the street in a crosswalk.

It's dark, it's raining, it's late and he's dressed in jeans and a black coat.

He does NOT actuate the crosswalk flashing lights, nor does he point.

I saw him at the last minute and stood on the brakes. Not even close, but he gives me the one finger salut and so I roll down the window and tell him, "push the button moron"

As a frequent pedestrian and watcher of people ..... I'm going to play devil's advocate as something smells here.

You said "I saw him at the last minute and stood on the brakes" and "He does NOT actuate the crosswalk flashing lights". If you had enough time to observe him not pressing the button, why did you not slow/stop earlier thus avoiding the situation entirely? Alternatively, if you are assuming he didn't press the button because the lights weren't flashing, how can you be sure that the lights worked, did you check the button?

It's medical fact that as we get older our vision gets poorer, especially at night and when it's raining. Complicating this weakness are pedestrians wearing dark clothing that aren't in the driver's center of vision. Also as we age, our focus and attention span gets poorer. JTK, you are older aren't you?

As a pedestrian I try to make eye contact with the driver before I cross, but 30% of the time even that doesn't work. I find that certain ethnic drivers and older people will still just drive right through the crosswalk. Additionally, allot of cars have tinted windows (often illegally dark) so at night, it's almost impossible to catch a driver's eyes, especially so in the rain.

I'm a believer in mandatory bi-yearly MTO eye examinations (including simulating dark and rainy conditions) and evening road tests for people over 55. Every 5 years for people between 16 and 55. As drivers we develop many bad driving habits and we need to be "forced" to address them because we are too arrogant and lazy to do it on our own.
 
A lot of responsibility falls on the driver.
That's the crux right there, and the problem. All responsibility is put on the driver, even in cases where a pedestrian is far more able to avoid or cause an incident.

Legal responsibility falls on the driver.

I agree with your point, pedestrians should be motivated by self preservation. Too many foolish/naive/arrogant people exist on both sides of this equation.
 
Legal responsibility falls on the driver.

I agree with your point, pedestrians should be motivated by self preservation. Too many foolish/naive/arrogant people exist on both sides of this equation.

Sure. The point I was making is that there are situations where pedestrians are in a better position to avoid an incident, regardless of motivation. Vehicles have more momentum than pedestrians, and so take longer to slow down or maneuver. Drivers have an impeded view, whereas pedestrians are unencumbered. Driver's have insulated hearing, whereas pedestrians do not. All this adds up to pedestrians being in a better position to avoid many dangerous situations. And yet our laws act as if the opposite is true. It's not practical!

Regardless of where you think responsibility should fall, the practical application is such that pedestrians should be expected to have more vigilance than the current laws suggest.

In this case, I find the pedestrian 100% at fault. If he had hit the button and waited for the flashing lights, I'd consider it 100% Captain Kirk's fault because at that point it's very clear to him that a pedestrian is present and intends to cross.
 
I know that I have to wait until he completes his walk across the cross walk. That rule changed just a year or two ago.

I just didn't know if he still has the right away even if he completely disregarded the protocol. I do not understand why he would not have at least pushed the damn button to activate the lights.

I think cross walks are dangerous under any circumstances. When people drive they tend to look quite far down the street and you are processing information past the crosswalk... When I use them, I always push the button AND make sure that drivers are going to stop. In his case he didn't do any of that. . It's was dark, and raining .

I didn't hit him, but it was close.


He does have the right of way, but if you killed him because he didn't activate the button in the dark of night or inclement weather, then he has some blame too if not all the fault.

Like TeeJay said, that kid unwittingly was bucking for a Darwin Award. I would've told him the next time might turn him into a paraplegic and wish him well.