Nancy Elgie finally resigns

no way. the only reason it took this long was her stubbornness and belief it would blow over. sorry but i have never accidentally used the n word. it says a lot about that person.

that school board has been in the paper a few times..... trustee pressuring teacher to boost marks of her kid, principal with xenophobic facebook posts, numerous claims of racism..... like an incident where a black kid was beaten by a group of white kids and no suspensions were handed out. the human rights board is investigating on the behalf of a group of parents.
 
Met her once and had quite a wide-ranging and pleasant chat at a social event. I don't doubt that it was an inadvertent slip at a time when a recent head injury had left her confused and addled. But it isn't the sort of thing a public board can overlook, nor can voters simply tolerate such words without sanction, and it reflects very badly on the York Board that they decided they were helpless so early, and confirmed their ineptness for so long. The law may not set out a clear response, but nothing prevented them from proposing something better than a pro forma apology, and nothing forced them to wait in silence, for Elgie to finally come up with something more. The natural inference is that systemic racism does live at the Board.

Not that her proposal worked: It would have deprived her constituents of their representation just as much as if the Board had removed her (which they couldn't by law) and undercut her own argument that she was a worthy Trustee, in spite of her one slip. If anyone had shown any energy towards a solution at the beginning, I'd bet some version of a sincere apology and a serious penalty — like giving all her salary to a Black History Project — could have calmed the waters before the storm. But instead everyone sheltered behind their own little walls of, "they're wrong, not me" until there was no common ground left.

And a democratic institution like the Board has no legitimacy without common ground. They've lost the people's confidence; they should all resign.
 
Met her once and had quite a wide-ranging and pleasant chat at a social event. I don't doubt that it was an inadvertent slip at a time when a recent head injury had left her confused and addled. But it isn't the sort of thing a public board can overlook, nor can voters simply tolerate such words without sanction, and it reflects very badly on the York Board that they decided they were helpless so early, and confirmed their ineptness for so long. The law may not set out a clear response, but nothing prevented them from proposing something better than a pro forma apology, and nothing forced them to wait in silence, for Elgie to finally come up with something more. The natural inference is that systemic racism does live at the Board.

Not that her proposal worked: It would have deprived her constituents of their representation just as much as if the Board had removed her (which they couldn't by law) and undercut her own argument that she was a worthy Trustee, in spite of her one slip. If anyone had shown any energy towards a solution at the beginning, I'd bet some version of a sincere apology and a serious penalty — like giving all her salary to a Black History Project — could have calmed the waters before the storm. But instead everyone sheltered behind their own little walls of, "they're wrong, not me" until there was no common ground left.

And a democratic institution like the Board has no legitimacy without common ground. They've lost the people's confidence; they should all resign.
A very thoughtful post OJ. Also, whatever happened to forgiveness?

Not sure about York Region other than they like to shut down Asian MP's but here is an article about Brampton.
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...ce-power-and-ethnic-enclaves/article30273820/
BTW: Those who are familiar with my posts know that I have a soft spot for Sikhs.
 
This is long overdue, oh yeah, who is Nancy elgie
 
It is tough for me to forgive in this situation because in my own experience i have never let anything worse than shit or fuck slip and bitch in the context of complaining not in reference to women.

racist slurs or sexist terms like cunt are not accidents for me. i would like to think and expect a similar standard from a high ranking official.

but yeah demotion, sensitivity training, fine or something else could have been reasonable punishments. i think people decided they wanted nothing to do with her. i dont blame them if you are an up and coming board official do you want to be known as the person who supported a lady who cant control her racist thoughts?
 
A very thoughtful post OJ. Also, whatever happened to forgiveness?

Not sure about York Region other than they like to shut down Asian MP's but here is an article about Brampton.
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...ce-power-and-ethnic-enclaves/article30273820/
BTW: Those who are familiar with my posts know that I have a soft spot for Sikhs.
Foregiveness is part of the milk of human kindness, it evaporates the longer you leave it untouched without saying you need it and are grateful, even if you don't deserve it.

She was concussed at least; the Board can't use that excuse.
 
SITUATION 1 - If she said it because she is the sort of person who uses that word then she cannot be a school board trustee.
SITUATION 2 - If she is not the sort of person who uses that word - too bad but she did it this time and one time is once too many for a school board trustee. There are others who can do the job without ever uses this word when talking about a parent, so she should have been removed in favour of somebody else.
SITUATION 3 - If the story is she has a medical/mental issue that caused her to use that word - well maybe she does, and maybe she doesn't. Hard to believe she could have a condition like "transitional" or "temporary" Tourettes but even if that is the case it does not make the use of the word any less offensive, or hurtful nor does it mean there hasn't been another incident where racism is perpetuated in our society. If some wish to excuse or forgive, that is fine, but she is still unsuitable for this particular position and should have been removed.
 
SITUATION 1 - If she said it because she is the sort of person who uses that word then she cannot be a school board trustee.
SITUATION 2 - If she is not the sort of person who uses that word - too bad but she did it this time and one time is once too many for a school board trustee. There are others who can do the job without ever uses this word when talking about a parent, so she should have been removed in favour of somebody else.
SITUATION 3 - If the story is she has a medical/mental issue that caused her to use that word - well maybe she does, and maybe she doesn't. Hard to believe she could have a condition like "transitional" or "temporary" Tourettes but even if that is the case it does not make the use of the word any less offensive, or hurtful nor does it mean there hasn't been another incident where racism is perpetuated in our society. If some wish to excuse or forgive, that is fine, but she is still unsuitable for this particular position and should have been removed.
I agree with your options, but the Board had no mechanism to remove her, and abdicated any responsibility to 'solve' their problem. I'm ready to accept that hateful term bubbled out of some long-suppressed corner of her 82 year-old concussed mind, but it's not possible for it to be uttered at all and still have the person hold their position of responsibility, as if nothing had happened.

She apologized promptly, but clearly without settling the matter. She and the Board then went silent, as if it was all someone else's problem, not theirs. That left the community with no option but to make them and her see things differently. Eventually her son and daughter — lawyers both — took to print to try to explain away what she hadn't, to repeat the apology more emphatically, and to ask for the understanding and sympathy her condition and many years of service meritted. On her behalf they made the first and only proposal of sanctions: For her to step aside for a long period — as if leaving her constituents unrepresented would make them feel better about her. That offer failed, as indeed it should have. But it need not have been the only oroposal

Since the Board had no power to remover her, and supposedly represents the people of York who were insulted and aggrieved it was for them to promptly apply themselves to finding a solution for all. Instead they let their citizens stew and the nasty issue fester. She finally took the only course she had left, one that she could have taken earlier, with less pain. Now they should do likewise.

Because, like her, they have clearly lost the confidence of their people.
 
Some reports indicate that Elgie is a good old girl and that hit on her head must have happened years ago...

https://www.thestar.com/yourtoronto...ork-school-board-over-use-of-racial-slur.html

Part of the story from the Star. The hit on the head thing is a poor excuse at best...

"How can an elected official who called a black woman “nigger” (I use this word explicitly so readers can appreciate its harmful impact) remain in her position?

I have fielded this question dozens of times since we learned that Nancy Elgie, a school trustee for the York Region District School Board, used this word to describe Charline Grant, a black parent whose son is a local student.

Specifically, board officials told Grant, who did not hear the comment herself, that Elgie saw her speaking to media at a November board meeting and asked colleagues, “is that the nigger parent speaking to the media again?”"

https://www.thestar.com/opinion/com...lings-trump-nancy-elgies-intentions-cole.html

Nancy Elgie...Another one of Wynn's good old southern school trustee buddies.
 
Perhaps it was her age, but even if you had a concussion, using that word rather than something like 'mindless half wit.' Was just asking for huge trouble.
 
Nobody has said that Miss Elgie has a history of using the "n" word. This does appear to be a one off situation. In that case, I think the "punishment" should be a warning and an apology to the "victim" plus a letter of reprimand in her personnel file. But, it was obvious that the mob was out for blood (maybe a hanging?) and they got it.
 
Perhaps it was her age, but even if you had a concussion, using that word rather than something like 'mindless half wit.' Was just asking for huge trouble.
Absolutely, and failing to realize that once said it needed more than a perfunctory, "I'm so sorry, I can't imagine where that word came from," to make things right again was a big mistake. But once they realized that something wasn't about to come from her, the Board lost the confidence of its voters by passively waiting for someone else to fix this problem at the school board.

That's what they were elected to do.

A Trustee is elected to exercise the power of the Board, in trust on behalf of the citizens, they're not simple employees you reprimand or whose file you look up when considering a promotion. Likewise you don't serve the citizens by suspending yourself so they have no representation. Resigning so they can choose someone they do trust is drastic but does remove the issue. So does passing a motion of censure calling on that Trustee to resign. It's for those who think a lesser consequence is appropriate to propose one, and have it accepted by the community. No one did, for far too long. When at last Mrs Elgie's kids did, it was too little, misdirected, and far, far too late for anyone to accept.

And the real problem is that none of the fourteen Trustees came up with anything.
------------------
Responding to SkyRider, it was indeed my impression of Mrs. Elgie that she would never use the N-word in conversation; she was 'far too well brought-up', and too well-intentioned to use such a vulgarism.

That said she is 82, and that word was in common use in all sorts of catch-phrases, popular sayings and nursery rhymes that she, would have grown up with, as I did. Though never accepted in polite speech, they only passed out of casual use (and that's overstating the case somewhat) at the very end of the last century. And while the polite usage has wandered from negro to colored, to black, to persons of color, to African-American, the casual has just gotten ruder.

I can readily accept that a bruised brain might cough up something from childhood when it couldn't locate the latest and greatest word. Only to shock and horrify the person whose mouth then opened and said it aloud.
 
She waited too long. The stain will remain with her.

She sounds a lot like many older folk, who let racial epithets invade their speech. In their younger years they weren't racist in any way, but in later years, the vernacular of their youth pervades their speech. She was getting too old for her position, like many older folk, she thinks she's still relevant.
 
I believe that she didn't mean it and I believe that she immediately corrected her speech.

That said, being a school board trustee is a public position. It's not the end of the world for her that she's resigned over it.
 
I believe that she didn't mean it and I believe that she immediately corrected her speech. /QUOTE]

Supporting flimsy excuses for inappropriate behavior will only pro-long the current state of affairs.

Nancy is an old school type and in a moment of anger voiced her true feelings (I call 100% bull-shit on her head injury excuse). I have seen too many of these types of people in the line of work I am in and this type of behavior and verbal outburst is consistent with what happened.

It has been mentioned that this may be a systemic problem in the school board, which provides more reason that sweeping changes should be made immediately. Funny thing is, Wynn, who has publicly stated she is not in favor of booting Nancy off the board was once a trustee of that same board. Wynn even went so far as to say if the same situation happened with her government she would not terminate the person. I guess that old mentality will never change.

I really cannot see how anyone can support this racist old bag.