investments

Ordinary people shouldn't be investing in individual companies. Leave that to Warren Buffet, otherwise you WILL lose ALL your money.

Investing is all about indexes.

That is not accurate
Lots of people are more than smart enough to recognise good companies with smart management and products with future demand
Buy them & hold them and diversify (20-30 for most folks)
That is all Warren does

Investing is not all about indexes
If you have success there, good for you, however if you invest only via indexes
a) you buy the lower quality companies along with the good ones
b) no double / triple baggers or 600% over 5-10 years
c) diversification while very extensive far exceeds what might be necessary
d) sector / index rotation is market timing & that is something Warren does not do
e) you are not buying based upon the fundamental drivers of growth cash flow and valuation within a business. (if you are using charts I would just shake my head)
 
That is not accurate
Lots of people are more than smart enough to recognise good companies with smart management and products with future demand
Buy them & hold them and diversify (20-30 for most folks)
That is all Warren does

Investing is not all about indexes
If you have success there, good for you, however if you invest only via indexes
a) you buy the lower quality companies along with the good ones
b) no double / triple baggers or 600% over 5-10 years
c) diversification while very extensive far exceeds what might be necessary
d) sector / index rotation is market timing & that is something Warren does not do
e) you are not buying based upon the fundamental drivers of growth cash flow and valuation within a business. (if you are using charts I would just shake my head)

That can work, it's just not the safest strategy and is more time consuming. There are very few Warren Buffet's for that reason.
 
That can work, it's just not the safest strategy and is more time consuming. There are very few Warren Buffet's for that reason.

Actually doing the homework to increase the probability you are buying only high quality companies with growing demand for their products & growing cash flow is far more safe than buying all within a sector or an index

More time consuming????
Lets see, most people spend the majority of their time earning their money.
Why in the world anybody not spend incremental time to minimize the risk of losing that hard earned money ?
oh yes they like the thrill of gambling

How may hours do you spend earning $5 K ?
A couple of extra hours appears reasonable to increase the probability you are buying a quality company with that $5 K
Your alternative is to blindly dump it into a index or sector and hope it goes up ?????

Re Warren Buffet
He has been extremely successful because he is disciplined, patient and buys quality companies (he does not piss about investing in indexes)
While no one should expect to replicate his results, aligning their strategy with his appears to be a sound idea
 
Actually doing the homework to increase the probability you are buying only high quality companies with growing demand for their products & growing cash flow is far more safe than buying all within a sector or an index

More time consuming????
Lets see, most people spend the majority of their time earning their money.
Why in the world anybody not spend incremental time to minimize the risk of losing that hard earned money ?
oh yes they like the thrill of gambling

How may hours do you spend earning $5 K ?
A couple of extra hours appears reasonable to increase the probability you are buying a quality company with that $5 K
Your alternative is to blindly dump it into a index or sector and hope it goes up ?????

Re Warren Buffet
He has been extremely successful because he is disciplined, patient and buys quality companies (he does not piss about investing in indexes)
While no one should expect to replicate his results, aligning their strategy with his appears to be a sound idea

There is no bigger advocate for index funds than Warren Buffet:
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/buffett-most-mportant-investment-lesson-211351601.html
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/warren-buffett-to-heirs-put-my-estate-in-index-funds-2014-03-13

One doesn't have to blindly dump into an index or sector. For example, those who avoided oil/energy have done better than those who invested in it.
 
Actually doing the homework to increase the probability you are buying only high quality companies with growing demand for their products & growing cash flow is far more safe than buying all within a sector or an index

More time consuming????
Lets see, most people spend the majority of their time earning their money.
Why in the world anybody not spend incremental time to minimize the risk of losing that hard earned money ?
oh yes they like the thrill of gambling

How may hours do you spend earning $5 K ?
A couple of extra hours appears reasonable to increase the probability you are buying a quality company with that $5 K
Your alternative is to blindly dump it into a index or sector and hope it goes up ?????

Re Warren Buffet
He has been extremely successful because he is disciplined, patient and buys quality companies (he does not piss about investing in indexes)
While no one should expect to replicate his results, aligning their strategy with his appears to be a sound idea

Oh well, people like smallcock don't get it, so lets not bother with him.
 
I for one am not looking for those +600% increases in 5-10 years, I am looking for 7-10% a year. The S&P 500 index has been here since the 40s and since then it has been doing around 10% a year. No matter what you say I am not convinced that individually picking stocks is less time consuming or smarter than just letting your money stew in an index fund. I get to sleep sound at night knowing that the index I've invested in has been performing at +10% a year since the 1940s. You on the other hand have to check daily, weekly, read the newspapers on your 20 or 30 stocks like a part time job. You also have more broker fees. The time and peace of mind I save goes towards the only thing I trust for a year on year increase bigger than 10%: my businesses. Expecting more from the stock market is plain speculation.

You are NOT "blindly dumping it into an index-fund" and you don't just pick any index. Do you think they just blindly pick whatever 500 companies to put into the S&P? If so, they are pretty lucky to be doing 10% a year! You have to invest in the bad companies they pick too? So are you saying somehow you have the ability to only pick good companies? Truth is the indexes don't pick anything, its all about market cap. The market picks whatever goes in the indexes.

It's also foolish to think that you can invest like Buffet. The guy can purchase stocks at wholesale, has a building of lawyers/analysts/accountants, and billions in cash/available credit.
 
Oh well, people like smallcock don't get it, so lets not bother with him.

My advice is Warren Buffet's advice.

But I'll leave you to your superstar stock picking strategy.
 
I for one am not looking for those +600% increases in 5-10 years, I am looking for 7-10% a year. The S&P 500 index has been here since the 40s and since then it has been doing around 10% a year. No matter what you say I am not convinced that individually picking stocks is less time consuming or smarter than just letting your money stew in an index fund. I get to sleep sound at night knowing that the index I've invested in has been performing at +10% a year since the 1940s. You on the other hand have to check daily, weekly, read the newspapers on your 20 or 30 stocks like a part time job. You also have more broker fees. The time and peace of mind I save goes towards the only thing I trust for a year on year increase bigger than 10%: my businesses. Expecting more from the stock market is plain speculation.

You are NOT "blindly dumping it into an index-fund" and you don't just pick any index. Do you think they just blindly pick whatever 500 companies to put into the S&P? If so, they are pretty lucky to be doing 10% a year! You have to invest in the bad companies they pick too? So are you saying somehow you have the ability to only pick good companies? Truth is the indexes don't pick anything, its all about market cap. The market picks whatever goes in the indexes.

It's also foolish to think that you can invest like Buffet. The guy can purchase stocks at wholesale, has a building of lawyers/analysts/accountants, and billions in cash/available credit.

Correct. I understand chasing the 600% returns but that's just not a feasible nor safe strategy for most people. For those with the skill to do it, I applaud (and envy) them.

But I prefer the comfort of 100 years of data showing that I can't lose money in the S&P if I keep my money in it (a history littered with 2 world wars, a great depression, a 2008 catastrophe, brexit, 9/11, the cold war, etc), and that I'm essentially guaranteed a return of 6 - 8%. Re-balancing is necessary but other than that it's managment on a consistent basis rather than checking the rise and fall of a company's stock every day.
 
My advice is Warren Buffet's advice.

But I'll leave you to your superstar stock picking strategy.

I have no idea what are you talking about. I have never said anything about some superstar stock picking strategy that I have. You should get your eyes check before you read.
 
It's also foolish to think that you can invest like Buffet. The guy can purchase stocks at wholesale, has a building of lawyers/analysts/accountants, and billions in cash/available credit.

That individuals can't invest like Buffett on their own I agree but that everyone should settle for the index I don't agree.

If you want to invest in Buffett, buy a single solitary unit of Berkshire. Or buy a hedge fund of some of the proven value investors that have beaten the index by a country mile. They're not hard to find.

On this forum I often see the argument that investment pools like funds are stupid. This is an incorrect statement because it generalizes all funds as being equal. They aren't. There are good funds and bad funds. Good managers and bad managers. By doing some good due diligence, an investor can basically "invest like Buffet" without doing any hard work themselves.

Is anyone here really going to argue that if they invested in Berkshire over the past 30 years they wouldn't be happy? He's not the only one, although he is the most high profile.

I'd never begrudge someone investing for themselves. But I have never seen any amateur beat a good professional long-term.
 
There is no bigger advocate for index funds than Warren Buffet:
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/buffett-most-mportant-investment-lesson-211351601.html
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/warren-buffett-to-heirs-put-my-estate-in-index-funds-2014-03-13

One doesn't have to blindly dump into an index or sector. For example, those who avoided oil/energy have done better than those who invested in it.

It is a shame you have not reaped the benefit of researching a company , buying its stock and watching as it quadruples over a period of years while paying you an ever increasing dividend.
You will not get that indexing

Like many things in life the reward is often proportional to the effort invested & as you say indexing is not that time consuming

It s also not that difficult to reduce commodity price risk by truly understanding what companies you are buying
In Canada the primary indexes carry huge amounts of commodity price risk ( oil, gas, metals gold) & are overly exposed to financials as well
After that the sectors are relatively thin & in some cases (health care) are very volatile
 
That individuals can't invest like Buffett on their own I agree but that everyone should settle for the index I don't agree.

If you want to invest in Buffett, buy a single solitary unit of Berkshire. Or buy a hedge fund of some of the proven value investors that have beaten the index by a country mile. They're not hard to find.

On this forum I often see the argument that investment pools like funds are stupid. This is an incorrect statement because it generalizes all funds as being equal. They aren't. There are good funds and bad funds. Good managers and bad managers. By doing some good due diligence, an investor can basically "invest like Buffet" without doing any hard work themselves.

Is anyone here really going to argue that if they invested in Berkshire over the past 30 years they wouldn't be happy? He's not the only one, although he is the most high profile.

I'd never begrudge someone investing for themselves. But I have never seen any amateur beat a good professional long-term.

Well said
However
I have never seen any amateur beat a good professional long-term
there many pros who do not beat the market on a net basis
And there are lots of individuals who do beat the market over the long term

Comparing returns vs Warren? It is not really important to me
Growing wealth & beating the market over the long term while reducing risk are reasonable and achievable goals
 
Well said
However
there many pros who do not beat the market on a net basis

Absolutely true. A large percentage in fact. That's why I believe regular joes should spend their efforts on finding good managers rather than learning how to invest which is substantially harder and requires a greater ongoing effort.

And there are lots of individuals who do beat the market over the long term

You and I may have a disagreement over the term "lots". What I have seen is that MOST non professional investors cannot and do not beat professional money managers, on a risk/return basis. Period.

Anyone can beat the market if you have $1000 and you're taking bets on the market. But that's not investing. That's gambling. But once you have a portfolio of legitimate size, gambling like that more than likely winds up blowing up an account.

The reality is that the percentage of novice investors that crash their accounts compared to professional managers isn't even in the same ballpark. The likelihood of a portfolio getting pummelled increases substantially when it's in the hands of non-professionals.

Comparing returns vs Warren? It is not really important to me
Growing wealth & beating the market over the long term while reducing risk are reasonable and achievable goals

Reducing risk is not a common trait of non-professional portfolios. They tend to have substantially higher risk than managed money.
 
Absolutely true. A large percentage in fact. That's why I believe regular joes should spend their efforts on finding good managers rather than learning how to invest which is substantially harder and requires a greater ongoing effort.

One can waste a lot of time & money thinking you have found a good manager, only to latter determine what he/ she was really good at was salesmanship


You and I may have a disagreement over the term "lots". What I have seen is that MOST non professional investors cannot and do not beat professional money managers, on a risk/return basis. Period.
after fees ? Come on, who are you trying to fool ?
Most pros do not beat the market after fees

Anyone can beat the market if you have $1000 and you're taking bets on the market. But that's not investing. That's gambling. But once you have a portfolio of legitimate size, gambling like that more than likely winds up blowing up an account.

Buying a good solid company you plan to hold for many years / decades is not gambling
Trusting someone else to make you wealthy is gambling

The reality is that the percentage of novice investors that crash their accounts compared to professional managers isn't even in the same ballpark. The likelihood of a portfolio getting pummelled increases substantially when it's in the hands of non-professionals.
I will agree that having money managed by pros is defiantly better than investing without doing the homework or betting hard earned $ based upon reading charts & then hoping!

However there are some who have an interest, can recognise what makes a great business and are willing to do the homework


Reducing risk is not a common trait of non-professional portfolios. They tend to have substantially higher risk than managed money.

That is an opinion
Your opinion may be correct however you would be hard pressed to back that up with facts as I doubt anyone aggregates non pro performance or non pro risk parameters
 
One can waste a lot of time & money thinking you have found a good manager, only to latter determine what he/ she was really good at was salesmanship

True. In fact this is often the case.


after fees ? Come on, who are you trying to fool ?
Most pros do not beat the market after fees

Depends on what you mean by pro. Pro as in just anyone who works in the industry or pro as in a certified portfolio manager and/or analyst like a CFA? I disagree with you.

If a pro can't beat the market, what kind of reasoning is it to think a novice can do better? A pro can and does do everything a novice can but has additional advantages non-professionals don't have, particularly when it comes to access to information, tools and support. Amateurs are on their own. Professionals have entire teams behind them. Who would I rather have operating on me? The guy who read a book on appendectomies or the doctor with an operating room, staff and equipment?

Why do we recommend the sensible option for others but for ourselves we take unnecessary (and arguably silly) risks?


Buying a good solid company you plan to hold for many years / decades is not gambling
Trusting someone else to make you wealthy is gambling

Not if you've done good due diligence. It takes just as much effort to find a good manager than it does a good company and is far more scalable to produce an entire portfolio of good companies rather than making the effort to research each company now, duplicate the effort for the amount of companies you want to diversify the portfolio and then continue the research and analysis on an ongoing basis. It's silly to think an amateur can do that at the same level as a professional. This is the case in every industry. Whether it be finance, hospitality, medicine etc. You'll always have some novice with a natural ability, but they're the exception to the rule. This is why I don't change my own oil.


I will agree that having money managed by pros is defiantly better than investing without doing the homework or betting hard earned $ based upon reading charts & then hoping!

However there are some who have an interest, can recognise what makes a great business and are willing to do the homework

Agreed. But it takes great effort and diligence and most can't and don't put in that effort. But they'll still buy into the narrative that an amateur can do it. And suffer for it.


That is an opinion
Your opinion may be correct however you would be hard pressed to back that up with facts as I doubt anyone aggregates non pro performance or non pro risk parameters

True there is lack of data on this. All I have is 20 years experience in the industry where I have yet to see one person ever truly become wealthy investing their own portfolio but many, many portfolios blown up.

The same can be said for advocates of DIY portfolios. No one has ever been able to prove that going your own way actually provides better returns. It sounds appealing. But there is no evidence that doing your homework and investing for yourself will get you better results than having a professional, with all the backing and resources behind him, do it for you.
 
I suspect that the vast majority of amateur non-index investors who think they're beating the market have consistently lost money when you average out all their gains and losses.
 
Depends on what you mean by pro. Pro as in just anyone who works in the industry or pro as in a certified portfolio manager and/or analyst like a CFA? I disagree with you.

Since Institutional money (run by pros) makes up the vast majority of the market, by (loose) definition half the pros win & half lose
After taking the fees how many clients are beating the market ?

If a pro can't beat the market, what kind of reasoning is it to think a novice can do better?
Different set of incentives for the pros
As a professional you must know the emphasis in brokerage houses is to drive commissions & build up a book
Portfolios returns for clients?? Nobody's bonus is driven by that

A pro can and does do everything a novice can but has additional advantages non-professionals don't have, particularly when it comes to access to information, tools and support. Amateurs are on their own. Professionals have entire teams behind them. Who would I rather have operating on me? The guy who read a book on appendectomies or the doctor with an operating room, staff and equipment?
It is astounding how information is available on the internet

Why do we recommend the sensible option for others but for ourselves we take unnecessary (and arguably silly) risks?
I do not know why you would do such a thing


Not if you've done good due diligence. It takes just as much effort to find a good manager than it does a good company
No way
In the end if you have your money managed by someone else you are hoping you picked the right one.
You have to give them at least two years to prove what they can do
If you are wrong , there goes two years & possibly a slice of your pie

Finding companies with a long track record of increasing dividend is not that difficult

and is far more scalable to produce an entire portfolio of good companies rather than making the effort to research each company now, duplicate the effort for the amount of companies you want to diversify the portfolio and then continue the research and analysis on an ongoing basis. It's silly to think an amateur can do that at the same level as a professional. This is the case in every industry. Whether it be finance, hospitality, medicine etc. You'll always have some novice with a natural ability, but they're the exception to the rule. This is why I don't change my own oil.

It is not that difficult


Agreed. But it takes great effort and diligence and most can't and don't put in that effort. But they'll still buy into the narrative that an amateur can do it. And suffer for it.
Agreed most do not put in the effort, , however that are many who do & are quite pleased with the results



True there is lack of data on this. All I have is 20 years experience in the industry where I have yet to see one person ever truly become wealthy investing their own portfolio but many, many portfolios blown up.
Well perhaps you meet more of the types who do not want to mange their portfolio

The same can be said for advocates of DIY portfolios. No one has ever been able to prove that going your own way actually provides better returns. It sounds appealing. But there is no evidence that doing your homework and investing for yourself will get you better results than having a professional, with all the backing and resources behind him, do it for you.

There is no evidence as DIY performance is not tracked.
That does not mean above market returns for DIY investors do not exist
 
Since Institutional money (run by pros) makes up the vast majority of the market, by (loose) definition half the pros win & half lose
After taking the fees how many clients are beating the market ?

How many amateurs do?

Different set of incentives for the pros
As a professional you must know the emphasis in brokerage houses is to drive commissions & build up a book
Portfolios returns for clients?? Nobody's bonus is driven by that

Incentives are for both performance and total assets under management. The only way professionals get more commissions is by managing more assets. The only way to manage more assets is to either have remarkable performance or have a sales process that drives more assets. Fees as a percentage of investable assets is pretty consistent around the street so there is no way to drive up commissions by charging more. In fact the industry is facing downward pressure on management fees.

It is astounding how information is available on the internet

Is your position that amateurs have more information than professionals? Professionals don't have the Internet?

I do not know why you would do such a thing

It's the equivalent of what is being advocated here.

No way
In the end if you have your money managed by someone else you are hoping you picked the right one.
You have to give them at least two years to prove what they can do
If you are wrong , there goes two years & possibly a slice of your pie

Finding companies with a long track record of increasing dividend is not that difficult

Is your position that it's easier to find good companies to invest in and provide ongoing monitoring than it is to find a good advisor who can do the same?

It is not that difficult

What is? Changing oil? Do you change yours?

Agreed most do not put in the effort, , however that are many who do & are quite pleased with the results

I am not denying some may be successful. But much like other skills, there are those who can and those who cannot. Is it really something that can be recommended across the board or should it be something recommended only to those who have shown an ability to do so and a willingness to put in an effort? And is that the majority of investors out there or is it a minority?

Well perhaps you meet more of the types who do not want to mange their portfolio

Not really. I meet all sorts of investors. Mostly because as a trader, everyone is always trying to pick my brain. And I pick theirs as well. And what I find is that out of everyone I run into, it's the pros who know what they're doing. More info, more time overseeing things, better access to execution, more resources. If non-pros are succeeding, it's usually against the odds.

Hence my decision that for me, despite being a market professional, I actually leave my own portfolio is the hands of a money manager.

There is no evidence as DIY performance is not tracked.
That does not mean above market returns for DIY investors do not exist

I've already stated that there are those DIYers that can succeed. The real question is whether they're the exception to the rule. If they are, then the better recommendation to the general public is the alternative, despite the fees.

Until this question can be answered, I believe it is not prudent advice to encourage novices to trade for themselves unless they show the qualities I stated above that are the very minimum necessary to succeed at investing for themselves. In other words, it isn't for everyone.
 
How many amateurs do?

Well if there is a significant number , then it kinda shoots your position full of holes.
reading Money sense magazine indicates there are some very successful amateurs



Incentives are for both performance and total assets under management.
Not at the brokerage houses
The only way professionals get more commissions is by managing more assets. The only way to manage more assets is to either have remarkable performance or have a sales process that drives more assets. Fees as a percentage of investable assets is pretty consistent around the street so there is no way to drive up commissions by charging more. In fact the industry is facing downward pressure on management fees.

Please do not try to convince anyone that compensation incentives are more aligned to clients objectives vs. the firms need to generate revenue. It just isn't so


Is your position that amateurs have more information than professionals?
No, my position is amateurs now have access to a lot of information which previously was only available to pros
Professionals don't have the Internet?
I never implied they did not


It's the equivalent of what is being advocated here.

I am unsure of what you are referring to

Is your position that it's easier to find good companies to invest in and provide ongoing monitoring than it is to find a good advisor who can do the same?
Yes


What is? Changing oil? Do you change yours?
Sometimes



I am not denying some may be successful. But much like other skills, there are those who can and those who cannot
.
Absolutely
Is it really something that can be recommended across the board or should it be something recommended only to those who have shown an ability to do so and a willingness to put in an effort? And is that the majority of investors out there or is it a minority?
That is different from

I have never seen any amateur beat a good professional long-term

Not really. I meet all sorts of investors. Mostly because as a trader, everyone is always trying to pick my brain. And I pick theirs as well. And what I find is that out of everyone I run into, it's the pros who know what they're doing. More info, more time overseeing things, better access to execution, more resources. If non-pros are succeeding, it's usually against the odds
.

again an opinion, not necessarily a fact

Hence my decision that for me, despite being a market professional, I actually leave my own portfolio is the hands of a money manager.

If you are comfortable with that good for you

I've already stated that there are those DIYers that can succeed. The real question is whether they're the exception to the rule. If they are, then the better recommendation to the general public is the alternative, despite the fees.

Until this question can be answered, I believe it is not prudent advice to encourage novices to trade for themselves unless they show the qualities I stated above that are the very minimum necessary to succeed at investing for themselves. In other words, it isn't for everyone.

Nor is it prudent advice to state all armatures must rely on someone else to mange their money

There are some who are defiantly better off with a professional money manager
Some people just do not want their advisor to lose their hard earned wealth and do not care how they do relative to market, just so long as their advisor does not lose money for them
Some just do not have the time so they outsource the money management to a pro
Some do not have any interest in the markets , yet want a return
& then there are some who recognise that their advisor's primary objective is to build his wealth with the secondary objective of building clients wealth. Some will not be completely comfortable with that relationship and will prefer to take matters into their own hands

The long term market return is approx. 8%
If the fees for a Pro managed portfolio are 2% that leaves 6% for the client
Invest $100,000 for 30 years @ 8% = 1,006,266
Invest $100,000 for 30 years @ 6% = 574,349

That is a very significant difference in affordable retirement lifestyle
 
Well if there is a significant number , then it kinda shoots your position full of holes.
reading Money sense magazine indicates there are some very successful amateurs

There is a difference between "significant" and "some". I have never denied that there are "some" investors that can do it on their own. The real question is whether it's the exception to the rule. Given the lack of data, BOTH our positions are full of holes because much like I can't prove whether amateurs can beat pros, you can't prove that that as a rule, they can.

Not at the brokerage houses


Please do not try to convince anyone that compensation incentives are more aligned to clients objectives vs. the firms need to generate revenue. It just isn't so

I've never understood this position. Brokerage houses don't deny their end goal is to make money. I'm not sure anyone is under a different impression. My point is that all of them are a) facing downward pressure on fees (this is a fact) and b) the trend has been to focus on growing assets as a means to increase revenue given that it has become near impossible to charge more. Like I said above, to grow assets you either need to have great performance or great salesmanship. Or both.

No, my position is amateurs now have access to a lot of information which previously was only available to pros

If you only knew how much less information amateurs have compared to pros. It's not even close. This is one disadvantage amateurs have never and will never overcome. Do they have more information than before? Sure. But I don't know a single amateur that has a professional trading terminal for example. Or access to new issues. Or structured products. Or tax and estate planning (without paying for it which defeats the purpose of doing it on your own to save on fees.)


Well I respectfully disagree. I think the effort needed to find a good advisor is much less than what is needed to find, analyze, buy, build, monitor, sell, replace a number of potential securities on an ongoing basis.

The same risks in finding an advisor are there when looking for good companies to invest in. Unless you decide to be a passive investor. Then we're not talking about beating the markets at all.

Sometimes

Doesn't really support your point does it?

again an opinion, not necessarily a fact

Unfortunately due lack of data in general, the reality is BOTH our positions are opinion. Neither one of us have hard data to back up our positions. Your evidence is just as anecdotal.

The only thing left to rely on is simple logic. And to me logic tells us that in general, professionals are better at their activities than amateurs. I can't think of a single activity or endeavor where this rule does not hold true. So in my opinion, to sway the argument in your favour, your position would need substantial evidence to overcome the prudence of this general rule. Yet there barely is any.

Nor is it prudent advice to state all armatures must rely on someone else to mange their money

Of course it's prudent. Prudence is "good judgement that allows someone to avoid danger or risks". How can an amateur make a case that it is more prudent (less risky) to set aside all the experience, resources and tools in the hands of a good professional in favour of DIY? The world is littered with poorly built basements for exactly this reason.

There are some who are defiantly better off with a professional money manager
Some people just do not want their advisor to lose their hard earned wealth and do not care how they do relative to market, just so long as their advisor does not lose money for them
Some just do not have the time so they outsource the money management to a pro
Some do not have any interest in the markets , yet want a return
& then there are some who recognise that their advisor's primary objective is to build his wealth with the secondary objective of building clients wealth. Some will not be completely comfortable with that relationship and will prefer to take matters into their own hands

Given that the easiest route for an advisor to build his wealth IS to build his client's wealth, again I have to disagree.

If an advisor earns 1% annually in commissions and fees from his book of clients, would he make more or less money by converting that $1million account into $2million or by doing a poor job and lose money but charge more?

To me it's illogical to argue that the advisor making money is somehow counterbeneficial to the client unless you can first prove that the client can do it better on their own. Otherwise it does not make sense to chastise them for it. Every service on the planet costs money. This discussion board is proof. Would I prefer a beautiful woman jerk me off or should I do it myself? One of those options is less expensive than the other, does it make it better? Does a doctor provide medical care for free? Since they don't, do we question whether their medical care is worthwhile just because they charge for it?

The long term market return is approx. 8%
If the fees for a Pro managed portfolio are 2% that leaves 6% for the client
Invest $100,000 for 30 years @ 8% = 1,006,266
Invest $100,000 for 30 years @ 6% = 574,349

That is a very significant difference in affordable retirement lifestyle

You have made a common mistake in making the assumption that performance numbers for managers do not already account for management fees. They do. Instead of hypotheticals, how about a real world example?

Let's use one of the most widely used mutual funds in the market. I'm not even using some obscure fund nobody has ever heard of. This find is well known and widely used. It is one of the largest funds on the street:

http://quote.morningstar.ca/quicktakes/Fund/f_ca.aspx?t=F0CAN05MUH&region=CAN&culture=en-CA

This fund smokes the index. Clients don't even have to worry about fees but regardless these performance results already accounts for management fees so this is net to client.

With all due respect, your hypothetical example just got smoked by a real life example. Bringing this back to our original discussion, do you really think the average amateur is going to have a 10 year number like Mawer? Again, I'm referring to the rule, not the exception, but even if we were dealing with the exception, have you actually seen someone do it or are you simply defending the concept without any real life example? Most people are not the exception and they fall under the general rule so the prudent choice for them would be to be in this fund rather than try to achieve these results themselves, or beat them. If they could beat them, I'd suggest they apply to become a portfolio manager in their own right and make way more money!

For the record, finding this fund didn't take much effort. Even with an average advisor, any client with this portfolio is already way ahead. Now couple this performance with a good advisor that has all the financial planning resources of a competent firm behind him and I question the need for someone to do it themselves, even if they could. Which I still question whether they can. Between selecting securities, defining sector allocations, setting tactical allocations, rebalancing, overlaying tax considerations (ie. Tax/loss selling, dividend income considerations etc) and then actually executing, I have rarely come across amateurs who come even close to implementing a well built portfolio let alone do it well for 10+ years.

Beyond that, 99% of advisors out there are now also coordinating investment management services with financial planning. So inaddition to that, you get budgeting, tax and estate planning, insurance planning, credit services and in cases like mine, access to private banking. None of which is available to the DIYer. All of which is included in the management fee being paid.

Missing out on so much without any guarantee of greater returns (in fact the opposite is more likely) and on top of that all that time and effort spent? Do these people not have jobs or social lives that they want to spend their free time basically learning a second job when the service is already there available at a reasonable cost? In many cases well below 1%? I don't know about you, but if I have $1million, I don't mind spending under 10Gs to have someone do all of this for me AND probably do better than I can.

P.S. We've been focusing only on a Canadian portfolio. This discussion leans even further away from you when you add the complexity of a more diverse portfolio with US or international holdings.

In my case, my US portfolio has outperformed the index the last 10 years by double-digits net of fees. It's not even close. Proving that having a manager does make a difference and I don't have to worry about "drag" on my portfolio due to fees.

P.P.S. Throughout these discussions, I keep seeing some pretty generous numbers being thrown out there about the performance of the index. Since inception, the TSX60 has returned a little over 7% and in the last 10 years only a little over 5.1%. Let's keep things in perspective folks.