Blue Jays: 2016 Edition

So some of your defenses like for Lowe and Hendriks are that the sample size is small yet you can be judge jury and executioner on Shapiro after the quarter pole
Whats Shapiro's record been even before he was hired by the Jays?? Not very good, so this is just a continuation of mediocrity for him.

Mark Lowe was a proven pitcher before he was shipped off.
Unlike Floyd and Chavez who were average pitchers at best their entire careers so far

And they did not let AA go. He had a job offer as the #2 and choose to leave. He said as much
Nah, they were gonna limit AA's GM powers. So AA chose to quit.
That to me is the same thing, we're gonna handcuff your powers and we're pretty sure that will make you quit the organization

Ended up taking a role as the #4 in LA for maybe less money? That's on him. If he could not operate under a management structure like many of the big clubs have adopted where the GM does not make all the baseball decisions (including the one he joined, Andrew Friedman is 1, maybe 1.5 layers above his GM yet is heavily involved in personnel decisions) he is going to probably have to go to a smaller market or an expansion/relocation situation to get the supreme powers he had in Toronto
I dont think AA wanted to leave, thats the whole thing. Then in comes Shapiro and everything goes to shit
 
"Highlights" of Ben Revere 2016 stats:

12 Gm
57 PA
3 Runs
5 Hits
1 Double
1 Triple
0 SB
2 CS
3 BB
10 K
.096 BA
.158 OBP
.154 SLG
.312 OPS

The success the Natinals have had, has virtually nothing to do with Ben Revere.
Rather, it's in spite of him.

Love it! Compared to Ben, Russell Martin looks like Ted Williams.
 
Mark Lowe was a proven pitcher before he was shipped off.

Mark Lowe is a quintessential journeyman.

Seattle Mariners (2006–2010)
Texas Rangers (2010–2012)
Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim (2013)
Cleveland Indians (2014)
Seattle Mariners (2015)
Toronto Blue Jays (2015)
Detroit Tigers (2016–present)


Mark Lowe wasn't "shipped off" anywhere.
 
Can we all agree though that changes need to be made (and soon) before the season is permanently lost??
 
Changes have been made.
Check out tonight's lineup.
 
Wow, Joey Bats leading off! But was our lead off man, whether Pillar or Saunders, really the problem? It's Martin, Goins, and (until recently) Tulo making automatic outs and killing rallies. I suppose Paredes at 2B is the writing on the wall for Goins, especially with Travis rehabbing at AAA.
 
Finally. Barely beat the worst team in extra innings. Tulo with game winning hit. EE hits 2 run HR and gets on base for winning run. Martin strands bases loaded again. Estrada, Osuna and Biagini all did great. Goins makes an error in extra innings to put the tying run on. His game is falling apart, zero confidence.

I don't think Paredes is the answer but he seems to be swinging with confidence, having "good" ABs. The rest of the team seem tense and tentative at the plate. Lots of check swings, taking good pitches and just bad looks. Wonder if Brooks Jacoby has got them over thinking during their slumps.

Superstition being what it is, I suppose Joey Bats will probably lead off again until they lose (or until Travis returns).
 
Why the hell would anyone put their best OBP guy in the spot where he will get most plate appearances? IT"S NOT A STRANGE THING TO DO !!!!
How many more times does the first spot in the order lead off relative to the 3rd spot over the course of a season? The best way to construct a batting order is to have your best offensive players in the spots where they will get the most plate appearances.
 
I agree with the move to bat Bautista first ...probably for a month until we have travis at full strength and some games under his belt..........both Barry and Bobby Bonds batted leadoff sometimes (never at the same time recalling my Cecil Fielder gaffe). But the extra at bats argument is flawed. The only times that the leadoff hitter gets more at bats than the third place hitter...is when the leadoff hitter or second hitter make the final out of the game. Statistically that might be 36 times a year.
 
Finally. Barely beat the worst team in extra innings. Tulo with game winning hit. EE hits 2 run HR and gets on base for winning run. Martin strands bases loaded again. Estrada, Osuna and Biagini all did great. Goins makes an error in extra innings to put the tying run on. His game is falling apart, zero confidence.

I don't think Paredes is the answer but he seems to be swinging with confidence, having "good" ABs. The rest of the team seem tense and tentative at the plate. Lots of check swings, taking good pitches and just bad looks. Wonder if Brooks Jacoby has got them over thinking during their slumps.

Superstition being what it is, I suppose Joey Bats will probably lead off again until they lose (or until Travis returns)
If/when Gibby gets fired they need to fire the hitting coach as well. This guy is a useless tit
 
and (until recently) Tulo making automatic outs and killing rallies.

The good things is that Toronto sports fans are astute enough that they know the shitty players and can try to run them out of town. Please refer to "Larry Murphy isn't good enough to play for the Leafs" for corroboration.

That's all Tulo is, just another HOF'er who isn't good enough for the "knowledgeable" Toronto sports fans
 
The good things is that Toronto sports fans are astute enough that they know the shitty players and can try to run them out of town. Please refer to "Larry Murphy isn't good enough to play for the Leafs" for corroboration.

That's all Tulo is, just another HOF'er who isn't good enough for the "knowledgeable" Toronto sports fans

You are mistaken, I never said run Tulo out of town. I made two factual claims in that quote. 1) Tulo had a rough start. 2) he is coming around.

I don't see how those facts are debatable in the least. But you try to make some leap in logic.
 
I guess all the band wagon riders from last years run have finally jumped off. I found it quite funny how many "fans" there were at the beginning of this year, pre-season and through the first month, and now they're all quiet.
 
I agree with the move to bat Bautista first ...probably for a month until we have travis at full strength and some games under his belt..........both Barry and Bobby Bonds batted leadoff sometimes (never at the same time recalling my Cecil Fielder gaffe). But the extra at bats argument is flawed. The only times that the leadoff hitter gets more at bats than the third place hitter...is when the leadoff hitter or second hitter make the final out of the game. Statistically that might be 36 times a year.

So don't you want your good guys to have those 36 plate appearances? That's about 9 games worth of plate appearances that your best offensive player would add on. I like that.
 
You are mistaken, I never said run Tulo out of town. I made two factual claims in that quote. 1) Tulo had a rough start. 2) he is coming around.

I don't see how those facts are debatable in the least. But you try to make some leap in logic.


Fair enough. There are some people on this board who are saying Tulo should be shipped out.
 
So don't you want your good guys to have those 36 plate appearances? That's about 9 games worth of plate appearances that your best offensive player would add on. I like that.


There's a lot of new-age sabermetrics that say the highest OBP should bat leadoff regardless of speed or power. OTOH, baseball lineups happens to be drawn up by a lot of old-school traditionalists. If you go to fangraphs and put in the Jays lineup, the optimal one is with JB as leadoff so this is not surprising. WHat is surprising is that they are actually trying it.
 
Shuffling of the lineup seems to be working (so far)