This is the sort of unscientific nonsense the tobacco companies used to say about smoking, that nobody could predict who would get cancer, that it couldn't be proved. Trouble is their own researchers had ALREADY proven that smoking caused cancer and they were keeping those studies secret while publicly making claims they knew were false.
Now these oil companies are claiming that global warming isn't caused by their greenhouse gas emissions. If they are sitting on studies proving that in fact their emissions DO cause it, while publicly denying it, then they are in deep shit. Potentially criminal shit, and at very least a multi billion dollar lawsuit.
It all boils down to whether they are being honest about what they know. They are entitled to an opinion, but if internally they have concluded their own public statements are false, that's fraud.