Smoking - time for the endgame?

All you are saying is that their initial purchases were voluntary. You agreed that the overwhelming majority of their purchases after that were not voluntary.

These are your words: "after the user becomes addicted its no longer a choice "
But it was their original bad choice that led them to their addiction. Therefore the whole thing can be summed up as a choice.

I'm not a heroin addict because I choose not to be
 
But it was their original bad choice that led them to their addiction. Therefore the whole thing can be summed up as a choice.

I'm not a heroin addict because I choose not to be

You seem to be arguing with yourself.

"after the user becomes addicted its no longer a choice"
 
You seem to be arguing with yourself.

"after the user becomes addicted its no longer a choice"
And what was it that caused a user to become addicted??
 
A very stupid CHOICE!!!

Exactly, what we need to determine is why some one would want to voluntarily inhale smoke in the 1st place.

Is it poor/none existent parenting in the case of the young, and/or irresponsible, live for today adults making a dumb ass decision.

People in their 60's/70's can be excused, as "everybody" did it, and didn't know any better,...but starting today, fricken ridiculous.

FAST
 
First step is to keep FDA agents out of Canada and stop letting the Yanks put economic pressure on us to follow their absurd drug policies

Almost half the states in the US have legalized marijuana to some extent, no provinces in Canada have.
 
If the number of smokers have become very low, it means we're on the right track. Continue restricting and taxing it but keep it legal so it doesn't go underground and in the control of criminals.
 
I don't want to hijack the thread (I agree that this is not the main topic), but to answer your question, not all consumption of alcohol is legal. You are only allowed to operate a motor vehicle if you consume less than the legal limit. There has been a lot of research over many years into the intoxication effects of alcohol that correspond with different blood alcohol levels, and reliable testing procedures have been developed. As a result, society can feel secure that driving a vehicle with alcohol consumption less than the legal limit does not pose a significant safety hazard, and can be reasonably sure that a decision by a driver to drive over the limit can be reliably proved and punished. All of this information, research and testing provides some measure of security to the public about the safety of driving, and a reasonable expectation of arrest and conviction on the part of those who might break the law.

The same cannot be said about marijuana. Although some roadside cannabinoid testing methods do currently exist (swab testing):

1. There is no consensus that existing testing methods are sufficiently reliable (just review a few labour arbitration decisions on this).
2. Current testing methods do not produce an immediate result, so they can't be used to immediately take a driver off the road (in the way that a failed breathalyzer can).
3. There is no consensus as to how to measure the precise degree of impairment arising from specific levels on THC in the bloodstream, or other metrics of use (especially important since THC can stay in your system for much longer than alcohol).
4. The product itself varies widely in potency, making it hard for users to know what safe usage levels are.

In short, the reason pot is still illegal (and the historical commentary is interesting, but I think irrelevant to why pot is illegal today) is that we lack the ability to police its use in the way that alcohol abuse can be policed. I agree that the two are morally equivalent (as examples of self abuse), and that we don't need to legislate against all forms of self abuse.

To bring this back to the original topic, the argument against tobacco is completely different. It's based on second hand impact on non-smokers as well as the cost to the public health system.
Glad you're back on tobacco, because your alcohol history and summary are as flawed as your cannabis one. We made and enforced DUI laws long before there were Breathalysers, and we presently deal with the pot-impaired as we did then. But we didn't make alcohol illegal while we waited for testing machines to be invented, and lack of technology is not why we still haven't legalized weed. Although there are some whose thinking is challenged by that concept. Just on a personal note, your thinking on alcohol and driving — that what counts is some blood-alcohol number not impairment (which you didn't mention — is downright disturbing. No expert would agree that al level below .08 in any way assures safety as you said. Danger begins with the first drink*; .08 is indisputably drunk.

Thanks for pointing out that anti-tobacco arguments have nothing to say on these matters, neither should we.
----------
In the seventies a group I was part of conducted Canada's first tests of alcohol, cannabis and driving. Most of the findings needed further study, the only conclusive result was that even low doses of either drug produced observable effects on driving performance. And they didn't improve it.
 
How about a specific proposal: The sale of products containing nicotine should be banned by the province, with a fine of $25,000 for violators. Smoking itself should be banned in all public places subject to a $1000 fine. The drug should be available on prescription so that doctors can work with addicts in a compassionate way.
In another post I mentioned last Sunday New York Times account of the entirely normal working mother who had chewed nicotine gum for thirty years. Why would you cut her off? Her doctor says she actually benefits; what makes her gum our business that we should punish her for chewing? Or would that be the Tobacco version of the British System of prescribed heroin?

While I'd enjoy never again encountering smokers blocking doorways, and I find second-hand smoke as disgusting on patios as inside, I'd hesitate about such a total ban. First, it does nothing for tenants in buildings with smokers, and second — don't laugh — the more we make the smoke itself into the villain, the more threatened is my wood-burning fireplace and all those summer campfires, and ski-lodge fireplaces. Still, that one we could tweak into something likely even I could live with (and woodburning fireplaces are doomed). But what about smoking products like shisha that contain no tobacco. To say nothing of medically prescribed marijuana. Or First nations sacred ceremonies. Or …

But a tightened rule here, a nudge there and we can reduce the numbers of smokers still further. And more to the point, make the burden they place on all the rest of us that much less. But we all burden society with our own foibles and foolish hobbies <nudge nudge> so we'd best not be stupid and overenthusiastic and imagine we can make smoking disappear because of a few laws we pass.

Time we stopped making that mistake.
 
Her doctor says she actually benefits; what makes her gum our business that we should punish her for chewing?

If her doctor thinks it benefits her specific condition then he will have no problem writing a prescription for her.

First, it does nothing for tenants in buildings with smokers

Given that it will be illegal to purchase nicotine, they won't be many smokers. For the few who can't quit and have gotten a prescription from their doctor you can easily apply the "reasonable accommodation" principle and make an exception for them in specific locations. They would be expected to have a letter from their doctor confirming the medical necessity.


But what about smoking products like shisha that contain no tobacco.

Most shisha is tobacco. It would be subject to the ban on nicotine.

To say nothing of medically prescribed marijuana. Or First nations sacred ceremonies. Or …

Medically prescribed anything is fine. The goal is to end mass consumption, not interfere with decisions made by doctors. First nations may need to find ways to celebrate without nicotine.
 
I'm not at all comfortable with turning doctors into our nicotine nazis, nor am I convinced we need any, although you've certainly shown how we can refine a crude over-broad ban into something more practical and detailed. To me the public health issue is the smoke itself, not the substance smoked, even if regulating that substance is the easy way to eliminate the fumes and fug. But I can't go with you on the need to control people's choice to the extent of banning all forms and use of that substance we've managed reasonably well over several centuries. The real public health issues were the result of industrial production, aggressive mass marketing and corporate greed, not the drug itself. Just as the real evils of cannabis were the hysterical over-reaction to it's use, and the criminal enterprises that ham-handed prohibition created, not the drug itself.

We have enough trouble and more on the way as medical MJ collides with recreational, and I can't see MD's or government handling tobacco/nicotine with any fewer missteps. We're already confused enough about whether doctors are hired mechanics or benign guardians of the best interests of their ignorant patients. I can't see why adults can't make these decisions for themselves.

But the smoke … . So it's good to see the Ontario government get off the fixation with individual drugs and recognize it's the 'peeing in the pool' aspect of how they're self-administered that is the proper focus of government.
 
Glad you're back on tobacco, because your alcohol history and summary are as flawed as your cannabis one. We made and enforced DUI laws long before there were Breathalysers, and we presently deal with the pot-impaired as we did then. But we didn't make alcohol illegal while we waited for testing machines to be invented, and lack of technology is not why we still haven't legalized weed. Although there are some whose thinking is challenged by that concept. Just on a personal note, your thinking on alcohol and driving — that what counts is some blood-alcohol number not impairment (which you didn't mention — is downright disturbing. No expert would agree that al level below .08 in any way assures safety as you said. Danger begins with the first drink*; .08 is indisputably drunk.

Thanks for pointing out that anti-tobacco arguments have nothing to say on these matters, neither should we.
----------
In the seventies a group I was part of conducted Canada's first tests of alcohol, cannabis and driving. Most of the findings needed further study, the only conclusive result was that even low doses of either drug produced observable effects on driving performance. And they didn't improve it.

For someone who strongly criticizes prohibition, you have some pretty "absolutist" thinking. I didn't say that alcohol blood levels below the legal limit were perfectly safe. I said they were reasonably safe. Given your apparent libertarian views, I would have thought that you would accept that some measure of risk is generally accepted in our society. Society is free to redefine what the acceptable level of risk is, but it will never be zero.

Secondly, I have not offered an historical analysis of substance abuse laws, you have. I have analyzed the issue based on the current state of the science and related policing issues. You should really rethink your flawed fixation on the historical reasons for laws. That history is interesting, but really is beside the point. The proper focus in law reform is always whether there is a current and foreseeably ongoing need for legislation, not whether there used to be a reason, and what that reason used to be.

And yes, the police try to deal with impairment from substances other than alcohol as best they can, including using sobriety tests that were available to them prior to the development of breathalyzers. However, and this should be obvious, breathalyzers were developed because they are far more reliable and provable than such tests. Likewise, such tests to determine intoxication from marijuana are similarly unreliable and unsatisfactory. Society's assessment of risk always occurs in the context of the times. Perhaps people didn't worry about the need for breathalyzers (or similar technology to test for other intoxicants) when there was a lot less traffic on the roads and fewer fatalities that could be directly linked to impaired driving. That's not where we are today.
 
I'm not at all comfortable with turning doctors into our nicotine nazis, nor am I convinced we need any, although you've certainly shown how we can refine a crude over-broad ban into something more practical and detailed. To me the public health issue is the smoke itself, not the substance smoked, even if regulating that substance is the easy way to eliminate the fumes and fug. But I can't go with you on the need to control people's choice to the extent of banning all forms and use of that substance we've managed reasonably well over several centuries. The real public health issues were the result of industrial production, aggressive mass marketing and corporate greed, not the drug itself. Just as the real evils of cannabis were the hysterical over-reaction to it's use, and the criminal enterprises that ham-handed prohibition created, not the drug itself.

We have enough trouble and more on the way as medical MJ collides with recreational, and I can't see MD's or government handling tobacco/nicotine with any fewer missteps. We're already confused enough about whether doctors are hired mechanics or benign guardians of the best interests of their ignorant patients. I can't see why adults can't make these decisions for themselves.

But the smoke … . So it's good to see the Ontario government get off the fixation with individual drugs and recognize it's the 'peeing in the pool' aspect of how they're self-administered that is the proper focus of government.

The reason why it is not the smoke itself, but the substance, is because that substance is addictive.

I don't buy for a second that smoking is a choice. It is an addicted behavior and most smokers wish they could quit.
 
The reason why it is not the smoke itself, but the substance, is because that substance is addictive.

I don't buy for a second that smoking is a choice. It is an addicted behavior and most smokers wish they could quit
Fuji, by implying smoking is not a choice you're basically saying a tobacco addict is powerless to quit. I briefly smoked in HS and into my early 20's but still managed to quit.

My point is even though its a tough habit to break you CAN do it