Obese people and nutritional knowledge

barnacler

Well-known member
May 13, 2013
1,781
1,304
113
It's amazing!

Every fat person I know is a total know-it-all on nutrition! They are busy lecturing me on how bad the stuff is that I eat (which I don't agree is true), telling me how great thi sstuff that they eat is, (it is typically some kind of 'nutritious muffin or other such crap), how great that is, but meanwhile they are 100 pounds over weight, and I am relatively trim and in shape! Its ridiculous that they are telling ANYONE ANYTHNG about nutrition.

I am so tempted to blurt out, "If you know so much why are you a fat slob then?".

On my bucket list.
 
One thing I noticed, is a lack of education (picking up a basic diet book) or reading a weight loss blog is typically out of reach for the avg person (dumb,fat,slob) but an opposing view is that they lack the overall resources to be healthy. As I walked through an open air area of my office during lunch. Carrying my $14whole foods salad while the whole office munches away at a $5 combo meal, you can't help but think it's also due to financial constraints.

It's a tough one!
 
When my mom was trying to lose weight she said to me, "I can't understand - I'm mostly eating carrots and celery all day" I asked her if she was dipping the veggies in anything - "yeah, sour cream or cream cheese." LOL I still try to teach her about nutrition and she's improving.


I've also seen overweight people eating very nutritious food but they are eating massive portions. That won't work.
 
You touch on one of the mysteries of life. Look at Oprah! She is huge! She has all the information, experts and the money to hire any and all of them. It is not like she is financially challenged. Yet she has struggled all her life with weight. Pretty well everyone I know has the resources to do what is necessary, but don't. Seems to be deep psychological issues here. A friend of mine works for Weight Watchers and struggles every day of her life with this stuff. It never seems to end.
 
You touch on one of the mysteries of life. Look at Oprah! She is huge! She has all the information, experts and the money to hire any and all of them. It is not like she is financially challenged. Yet she has struggled all her life with weight. Pretty well everyone I know has the resources to do what is necessary, but don't. Seems to be deep psychological issues here. A friend of mine works for Weight Watchers and struggles every day of her life with this stuff. It never seems to end.

i dont really look at oprah too often but i see your point. the counter argument to the financial is: with more money, you have much greater access to higher quality food but also higher cost food. ie: i could eat beautiful pasta carbonara with black truffles each and every day. of the best quality and best ingredients yet it wouldnt change that its a high fat high carb meal thats surely going to my tummy and not out my butthole. so its a mix of education and financial. and certainly psychological.

yet what ive found is that skinny tastes alot better then fat, so whole foods salad it is :)
 
The next time you're wandering through the grocery store, look at what's in the shopping carts of the obviously overweight people. You will quickly see why they're overweight.
 
In Japan it's one of the required courses (basic nutrition) students must take to graduate high school. I think that's a good thing.
 
In Japan it's one of the required courses (basic nutrition) students must take to graduate high school. I think that's a good thing.

That culture eats all the parts of the animals the rest of us throw away.yet they live well into their 90's and higher. Maybe they know something the rest of us don't?
 
Yes, but do not miss my point. Very few obese people do not know what is nutritionally good for them and they have all the information regarding health at their fingertips, yet they still set themselves up for failure. This friend of mine "knows" not to shop in certain isles at the store and not to bring home crap food, but does all the time. Why? So she can bitch about being too fat? Methinks she is avoiding the real issues. So courses etc. are irrelevant. What is going on out there? Obesity is one of the biggest problems, from a medical point of view, out there. The human and monetary costs are enormous.
 
I think if you follow the rule of "burn what you eat", and "eat regularly", you should be fine. I actually watching what you eat is less important when making sure you only eat what you burn and eat regularly. Due to my business travel arrangements, I use to fall into that category of eating irregularly. There are days where I would starve until late in the evening due to late flights or chasing deadlines. Days I would skip breakfast because I was rushing to work or the airport. I read in a medical journal that because of this the body ends up thinking "I better store the food while I can since I don't know when my next meal will be" (hence enhanced fat development). Sticking to a regular eating schedule will help. I changed my routine about five years ago to at least have "something" during what I determine to be my regular meal times. I also picked up some exercise routine, though I must admit I am far from being a regular at this - for one I don't own a gym membership or anything of that sort. That said, I have noticed the difference. I no longer gorge myself on epic meal proportions because I would never hit that state of hunger, and also I think my stomach shrank because it doesn't need to accommodate large meals anymore. I would say I am lean, and I felt the difference in the past 5 years.

If you combine the above with nutrition diet, I imagine it would be all the better. And I do realize that it is necessary for those whose biology is susceptible to specific nutrients (sugar, peanut, etc.) to pay such attention to. But otherwise, I'm of the opinion: why bother watching over those when I don't have to and all I have to do is be active and eat regularly.

Probably doesn't work for everyone. What do you guys think?
 
See post #7.

People know what's good for them, but that doesn't mean they'll make the right decisions when the moment comes.

Minor correction. Some people .....................

And then there are some people who are afflicted with medical conditions that lead to serious obesity.
 
That culture eats all the parts of the animals the rest of us throw away.yet they live well into their 90's and higher. Maybe they know something the rest of us don't?

Asian cultures typically eat more vegetables and and seafood and less red meat. That is starting to change though with fast food outlets moving out to those countries.
 
One thing I noticed, is a lack of education (picking up a basic diet book) or reading a weight loss blog is typically out of reach for the avg person (dumb,fat,slob) but an opposing view is that they lack the overall resources to be healthy. As I walked through an open air area of my office during lunch. Carrying my $14whole foods salad while the whole office munches away at a $5 combo meal, you can't help but think it's also due to financial constraints.

It's a tough one!

The cost difference is definitely a problem especially for families. If you multiple mouths to feed, you go with the cheap, processed and quick to make food instead of buying raw vegetables and meat and cooking yourself.
 
Maybe obese people should try the same scam alcoholics have and call their condition a disease.
 
i dont really look at oprah too often but i see your point. the counter argument to the financial is: with more money, you have much greater access to higher quality food but also higher cost food. ie: i could eat beautiful pasta carbonara with black truffles each and every day. of the best quality and best ingredients yet it wouldnt change that its a high fat high carb meal thats surely going to my tummy and not out my butthole. so its a mix of education and financial. and certainly psychological.

yet what ive found is that skinny tastes alot better then fat, so whole foods salad it is :)


People are so blindsided by Oprah it's insane, you bring up an excellent point.
 
Or how about all those fat people at the office eating soup, salad and water. Yet somehow don't lose weight..... "I don't get it. It must be my metabolism".

Bull.

It is impossible to gain or maintain weight by seemingly eating only 800 calories a day.

I bet any money that behind every salad bowl they eat, they have a stash of potato chips, or pig out at breakfast or dinner out of sight.
 
Yes, but do not miss my point. Very few obese people do not know what is nutritionally good for them and they have all the information regarding health at their fingertips, yet they still set themselves up for failure. This friend of mine "knows" not to shop in certain isles at the store and not to bring home crap food, but does all the time. Why? So she can bitch about being too fat? Methinks she is avoiding the real issues. So courses etc. are irrelevant. What is going on out there? Obesity is one of the biggest problems, from a medical point of view, out there. The human and monetary costs are enormous.
I think people are smarter than that.

I don't think many fat people are fat because they are ignorant at the basics of caloric intake and burning it off.

I think it's a case of either uncontrolled eating, or they simply don't care and eat what they want.
 
You touch on one of the mysteries of life. Look at Oprah! She is huge! She has all the information, experts and the money to hire any and all of them. It is not like she is financially challenged. Yet she has struggled all her life with weight. Pretty well everyone I know has the resources to do what is necessary, but don't. Seems to be deep psychological issues here. A friend of mine works for Weight Watchers and struggles every day of her life with this stuff. It never seems to end.
She's a big phony. All her Book or the Month promotions, diet swings due to this diet or pills or whatever is all money motivated. She doesn't do this just for the heck of it.

But considering her weight swings every few years +/- seemingly 50-100 lbs shows total lack of control. It's actually pretty hard to gain so much weight in such short timelines. You got to be eating so much so often, that it slowly builds.

There have been years I pigged out more than usual. There was a stretch where I wanted to try all kinds of buffets all over the GTA. Asian, Indian, etc..... I think I gained 10-12 lbs that year. And I never work out. So for me to gain another let's say 50 lbs? I can't see how that's possible unless I was literally eating buffets every other day.

So for anyone to have such wild swings in weight (excluding someone with a medical disease where drugs are retaining fluids) is an obvious case of pigging out like animals at a trough.