TPP: Chapter By Chapter Analysis

there are a lot of tariffs on our agricultural products (beef)
The auto industry can move upscale to higher value added parts. i.e. transmissions vs. selling stamped door hinges
There ae a lot of tariffs still in place which shut Canadian products out of markets . Japan in particular
We won't be selling car parts to japan or coal to newcastle. Japan doesn't play fair and this won't change with this agreement.


90 percent of the agreement is about reducing soveriegnty of countries to set own laws and have disputes settled in its courts. Very little about tariff reductions.

What are current japanese tariffs on imports to japan? While japanese tariffs are high on ag products- they will use other methods to exclude our products.

Most of our trade is with the us and will contine that way. We already have access under nafta- we are giving up lots of things under tpp to get virtually the same access
 
whether or not this trade agreement is good or bad for the average guy on the street is irrelevant....if big business and the corporate world want it to happen , it will happen .....for the sole reason of increasing profit...for a corporate big wig to say it is good for the general population would be disingenuous......its good to be all powerful and have govts in your back pocket
 
We won't be selling car parts to japan or coal to newcastle. Japan doesn't play fair and this won't change with this agreement.


Well rejecting the agreement will not fix that & the agreement will be the avenue to hold them accountable and pressure them to open their markets


90 percent of the agreement is about reducing soveriegnty of countries to set own laws and have disputes settled in its courts. Very little about tariff reductions.

What are current japanese tariffs on imports to japan? While japanese tariffs are high on ag products- they will use other methods to exclude our products.
The Japanesse ag market is extremely potectionist

Most of our trade is with the us and will contine that way. We already have access under nafta- we are giving up lots of things under tpp to get virtually the same access

do you think rejecting the deal will automatically revert back to status quo?
Absolutely not
The Americans have a new deal replacing NAFTA & will work with that, they are not going to renegotiate a side deal with us
If we walk away from this deal we will have no recourse with out biggest trading partner

If there is a dispute & we claim recourse under NAFTA. They will just respond with "NAFATa was replaced with TPP, which you signed & then walked away from. too bad so sad"
 
whether or not this trade agreement is good or bad for the average guy on the street is irrelevant....if big business and the corporate world want it to happen , it will happen .....for the sole reason of increasing profit...for a corporate big wig to say it is good for the general population would be disingenuous......its good to be all powerful and have govts in your back pocket

That is what is wrong with the loonie lefts
They start from a position of mistrust and very negative views about corporations.

Increased trade is good for the general population
Money flows into our country with increased trade
Money that is spent on expanding the business, salaries, sales commissions , taxes (lots of personal and corporate taxes for your loonie left wing government programs) .

imagine our economy without corporations
You would not even be able to feed yourself

Your view of the world is negative from the get go & that leads to really poor judgments
 
That is what is wrong with the loonie lefts
They start from a position of mistrust and very negative views about corporations.

Increased trade is good for the general population

This isn't about trade, 90% is about reducing sovereignty of countries over international corporations.
What's good for international corporations isn't necessarily good for citizens.

That's what's wrong with the loonie right wing, they back business interests to a fault and won't consider that their shareholder interests aren't necessarily the same as ours.
Would you give up all of your rights to legal recourses with a company over any wage/contract issue for a job?
 
That is what is wrong with the loonie lefts
They start from a position of mistrust and very negative views about corporations.

Increased trade is good for the general population
Money flows into our country with increased trade
Money that is spent on expanding the business, salaries, sales commissions , taxes (lots of personal and corporate taxes for your loonie left wing government programs) .

imagine our economy without corporations
You would not even be able to feed yourself

Your view of the world is negative from the get go & that leads to really poor judgments

yawn
 
This isn't about trade, 90% is about reducing sovereignty of countries over international corporations.

So you say and we all know the value of what you say

90% is about Reducing sovereignty????
How can anyone take you seriously when you write such garbage

What's good for international corporations isn't necessarily good for citizens.
Increased trade means more jobs world wide period
More so for countries that can compete

That's what's wrong with the loonie right wing, they back business interests to a fault and won't consider that their shareholder interests aren't necessarily the same as ours.
It is in everyone best interest to remove trade barriers . Period.


Would you give up all of your rights to legal recourses with a company over any wage/contract issue for a job?

For starter that is not on the table
Secondly I manage my career via merit rather than allowing corrupt unions extort for me, so not an issue I lose any sleep over
 
Well rejecting the agreement will not fix that & the agreement will be the avenue to hold them accountable and pressure them to open their markets


90 percent of the agreement is about reducing soveriegnty of countries to set own laws and have disputes settled in its courts. Very little about tariff reductions.


The Japanesse ag market is extremely potectionist



do you think rejecting the deal will automatically revert back to status quo?
Absolutely not
The Americans have a new deal replacing NAFTA & will work with that, they are not going to renegotiate a side deal with us
If we walk away from this deal we will have no recourse with out biggest trading partner

If there is a dispute & we claim recourse under NAFTA. They will just respond with "NAFATa was replaced with TPP, which you signed & then walked away from. too bad so sad"

tariffs for Canadian exports to japan o/s of ag products range from 3% to 6%- so little benefit under agreement. japan is extremely protectionist and tpp won't change it.

we have an agreement with US and it has not been replaced. it is still in force. whether we can enforce anything under NAFTA is questionable as we have lost every trade dispute under NAFTA.

I am all for trade and free trade but this isn't a trade deal.
 
Given that the alternative to TPP, flawed as it may be, is not business as usual but rather the PRC lead FTAAP (Free Trade Area of the Asia-Pacific) I find it curious that four days after the launch of this thread Twizz and Frankfooter have not mentioned this.
 
And that is exactly why you will remain ignorant of the facts and let the loonie left /NDP tell you what you feel strongly about

I am my own man, who owns his political views...don't be a presumptious ass..
 
I am my own man, who owns his political views...don't be a presumptious ass..

You said you have blindly voted NDP all your life
Do not be naïve

You would not recognise your own political view if it bit you on the ass
 
tariffs for Canadian exports to japan o/s of ag products range from 3% to 6%- so little benefit under agreement. japan is extremely protectionist and tpp won't change it.

Do you have a source for those numbers?
You may be correct, however I seem to recall they were much higher

we have an agreement with US and it has not been replaced. it is still in force.
You may wish to get a second qualified opinion about that

whether we can enforce anything under NAFTA is questionable as we have lost every trade dispute under NAFTA.
I am not sure that s accurate either

I am all for trade and free trade but this isn't a trade deal.
You will need to be more specific
 
We won't be selling car parts to japan or coal to newcastle. Japan doesn't play fair and this won't change with this agreement.


90 percent of the agreement is about reducing soveriegnty of countries to set own laws and have disputes settled in its courts. Very little about tariff reductions.

What are current japanese tariffs on imports to japan? While japanese tariffs are high on ag products- they will use other methods to exclude our products.

Most of our trade is with the us and will contine that way. We already have access under nafta- we are giving up lots of things under tpp to get virtually the same access

This is an intellectually dishonest way of saying that protectionist laws will come down and IP will be respected across signatory countries.....
 
You said you have blindly voted NDP all your life
Do not be naïve

You would not recognise your own political view if it bit you on the ass

jerk..i never at anytime said I "blindly" voted NDP all my life......I have voted for them with both eyes open..again you just prove that you are a pompous windbag who has precious little reading skills
 
Given that the alternative to TPP, flawed as it may be, is not business as usual but rather the PRC lead FTAAP (Free Trade Area of the Asia-Pacific) I find it curious that four days after the launch of this thread Twizz and Frankfooter have not mentioned this.

The Americans are not part of any free trade deals the Communist Chinese are negotiating with other countries.

For example, the recent free trade deal between China and Australia, just between the two, just like the recent free trade deal between China and South Korea just between those two.

Then there is the negotiations for future trade deals between the three countries of North East Asia, a rumoured deal between the PRC and the EU, and the free trade initiative you mentioned FTAAP which was a PRC idea.

Well, the point is, where does this leave Canada?

That's a good question.
 
Do you have a source for those numbers?
You may be correct, however I seem to recall they were much higher


You may wish to get a second qualified opinion about that


I am not sure that s accurate either


You will need to be more specific

The source is my experience exporting to japan. I am sure you can google it or check with the federal agencies that deal with trade.

I have gotten a qualified opinion. I spoke with my legal counsel.

Canada has lost all seven disputes filed under nafta.

To be more specific see the document itself. Or many of the analyses of it which say that 90 percent of the text are not about trade. You can easily verify that yourself by a quick review of its table of contents