9/11 Fourteen Years Later

Fuji, in a nutshell, and I don't doubt you, how did the entire buildings collapse then, if the exterior supporting exoskeletons were breached in two places high above for each building, and none in Bldg 7?

Eventually the structure gave way and dropped a floor, which fell onto the floor below it causing it to break off, now you have the mass of two floors falling and accelerating at the speed of gravity smashing into the third floor, etc. Which is exactly why it went straight down at the speed of gravity.

A look at any of the YouTube videos shows it was not like a controlled demolition. In a controlled demolition the supports at the base are blown up and the whole building falls into its foundation. In that case you see the whole building from top to bottom move downwards.

Look at a video of the collapse and you can see that is not what happened. You can see that the bottom of the building is intact and motionless until the structure above falls into it. Meanwhile the entire building above the impact site is falling as a single piece.

Not even remotely like the idiotic claims on this thread, and something you can go verify right now by looking at any of the videos on YouTube. Including the ones posted by the idiot conspiracy theorists. Do it, go watch.

The top of the building falls into the bottom of the building, this is not a case of the foundations being blown up. Everyone with eyes can go see this right now.
 
They pulled this off without a hitch, one little alarm won't do shit in the grand scheme of things.
This was pulled off brilliantly enough for gullible people to believe that the "greatest nation" (LOL @ that idea) on earth was brought down by 20 guys and a master planner in a cave.

*cough*bullshit*cough*

And your theory is that hundreds if not thousands of Americans, including everyone who worked on the official report, all conspired to murder thousands of their countrymen and then cover it up, and despite such a huge number of people all involved in this mass murder plot, NO ONE TALKED.

*cough*stupid bullshit*cough*
 
They pulled this off without a hitch, one little alarm won't do shit in the grand scheme of things.
This was pulled off brilliantly enough for gullible people to believe that the "greatest nation" (LOL @ that idea) on earth was brought down by 20 guys and a master planner in a cave.

*cough*bullshit*cough*

Tesla, one alarm is all it takes for a question to be raised. And it's not just momentary. This work would've taken a long time. How many times would you trip that alarm or shut if off. A downed alarm is the most basic call from the monitoring station. It didn't happen for a few seconds or half a minute like you see in the movies during a burglary attempt.

Osama Bin Laden lived in a cave AFTER 9/11, not before.

He was the son of a multi-millionaire, and had the means to train a few hijackers from successfully carrying out this plot. Airline security was lax back in the day.

The multiple hijackings was not a shock and awe plan by the terrorists. Those were secondary plans in case the primary failed.
 
Let's add # 25) Why on EARTH were the Bin Laden family allowed to take flight and leave the U.S.? They were the ONLY flight allowed period, in or out, nobody could fly except them.
If this was Bin Laden's work, why would you let them leave? Why not detain them for questioning?

Bush Sr. was an adviser to the Carlyle Group.
Just a pure coincidence I suppose.

But here's some interesting stuff.
Carlyle's 2001 investor conference took place on September 11, 2001.
In the weeks following the meeting, it was reported that Shafiq bin Laden, a member of the Bin Laden family, had been the "guest of honor", and that they were investors in Carlyle managed funds.[19][20][21][22][23]
Later reports confirmed that the Bin Laden family had invested $2 million into Carlyle's $1.3 billion Carlyle Partners II Fund in 1995, making the family relatively small investors with the firm.
However, their overall investment might have been considerably larger, with the $2 million committed in 1995 only being an initial contribution that grew over time.[24]
These connections would later be profiled in Michael Moore's Fahrenheit 911. The Bin Laden family liquidated its holdings in Carlyle's funds in October 2001.[25]


Just utter sheer pure coincidence.

Bush ties with the Saudis as well as the Bin Ladens.


Shit, it's fact that Prescott Bush Duh-byas grandpa had ties to the Nazis and profited it from the war. LOL

Fucking idiots. lol


I hear ya, I hear ya. I've seen Fahrenheit 9/11 as well as JFK II. Here's a quick link to George H.W. Bush possibly in Dealey Plaza at the time of the assassination of JFK, and a call by him to the FBI around that time, perhaps to establish an alibi, but he later said, that wasn't him (go about a 1/3 of the way down) => http://kentroversypapers.blogspot.ca/2007/06/dealey-plaza-esoteric-freemasonic.html
 
You did see the December 2000 work proposal correct?

It could have been done then.
It may have been even closer to September 2001. Call it a "follow up" a "check-up", AGAIN, done at night when no one is around or during the day, the stage is set, just set up the thermite my friend.

Again, December 2000 work order, so not a few years. ;)

December 2000 tiles and asbestos project, in case you missed it. Nawwwwttt a few years.
http://www.mediafire.com/?3lzuy4cmemq


I didn't want to download that workorder being 24 MB but when was that work to be done? Do you realize that if it's a cover for other work, nobody will get paid if the actual work doesn't progress?
 
Eventually the structure gave way and dropped a floor, which fell onto the floor below it causing it to break off, now you have the mass of two floors falling and accelerating at the speed of gravity smashing into the third floor, etc. Which is exactly why it went straight down at the speed of gravity.

A look at any of the YouTube videos shows it was not like a controlled demolition. In a controlled demolition the supports at the base are blown up and the whole building falls into its foundation. In that case you see the whole building from top to bottom move downwards.

Look at a video of the collapse and you can see that is not what happened. You can see that the bottom of the building is intact and motionless until the structure above falls into it. Meanwhile the entire building above the impact site is falling as a single piece.

Not even remotely like the idiotic claims on this thread, and something you can go verify right now by looking at any of the videos on YouTube. Including the ones posted by the idiot conspiracy theorists. Do it, go watch.

The top of the building falls into the bottom of the building, this is not a case of the foundations being blown up. Everyone with eyes can go see this right now.


Okay but the pancaking effect is what is being debated.

You cannot have collapse at free fall IF the floors below offer some resistance or increasing resistance to those above it. At some point, a critical mass of debris will slow the rate of descent, but that didn't happen.

I can understand your comparison to actual demolitions, and you are right, the base seems to simultaneously, or nearly so, collapse as well.

However, this scientist argues that the gravity-driven collapse of the twin towers by the top of the buildings alone, was impossible, and that the collapsing structure would've stopped 15 stories beneath.

http://www.academia.edu/13907138/Wo...n_and_the_Problem_of_Variable-Mass_in_Physics
 
Okay but the pancaking effect is what is being debated.

You cannot have collapse at free fall IF the floors below offer some resistance or increasing resistance to those above it. At some point, a critical mass of debris will slow the rate of descent, but that didn't happen.

I can understand your comparison to actual demolitions, and you are right, the base seems to simultaneously, or nearly so, collapse as well.

However, this scientist argues that the gravity-driven collapse of the twin towers by the top of the buildings alone, was impossible, and that the collapsing structure would've stopped 15 stories beneath.

http://www.academia.edu/13907138/Wo...n_and_the_Problem_of_Variable-Mass_in_Physics

The force of a falling object increases by 9.8 meters per second squared. Once a floor is falling it picks up energy as it goes, not to mention gains the mass of additional floors, and as the floors fall they crash into the exoskeleton supporting the building, effectively bringing down the mass of the entire building above the breaking point. That "scientist" is just plain wrong, not to mention basing his claim on ignorance is the fact that the building was suspended, not supported, so no increasing resistance.

You can literally see this in any of the collapse videos, you don't have to take my word for it. You can go see for yourself that the top of the building falls onto and crushed the bottom. The lower part of the building stays intact until the falling part reaches it.

That absolutely and indisputably refutes the claim that charges were set at the base of the building supports (supports that don't even exist in the same way in this type of architecture).

The whole claim on this thread is nonsense being propagated by ignorant people.
 
And your theory is that hundreds if not thousands of Americans, including everyone who worked on the official report, all conspired to murder thousands of their countrymen and then cover it up, and despite such a huge number of people all involved in this mass murder plot, NO ONE TALKED.

*cough*stupid bullshit*cough*


Fuji, let's assume that many people were involved in a conspiracy. NOBODY would talk because to do so would be incriminating, even as an accessory. (This argument is used against a JFK conspiracy, although the truth is, some did talk and some were going to talk, but they didn't live long). Murder has no statute of limitations.

I can also tell you that the Warren Commission involved many, and some were quiet dissenters, but nobody would go against the grain at the end of the day. Same with the HSCA in the 70s (as one example, would you believe that a Forensic Pathology Panel, altered the location of the alleged wound to the back of JFK's head by 4 inches!!!!!! This was done to support the alignment for a single bullet theory, and yet how on earth could they do that just based on photos and x-rays (dubious I might add but that's another topic), and supersede the original pathologists? Only one dissenter, Dr. Cyril Wecht, had the balls not to agree. As he put it, the FPP would not say that the Emperor had no clothes.

I don't believe in a 9/11 conspiracy. Bush Jr. would've found another excuse maybe to attack Saddam Hussein. AQ or OBL helped him find an easier excuse.
 
Fuji, let's assume that many people were involved in a conspiracy. NOBODY would talk because to do so would be incriminating, even as an accessory.

We are talking about the murder of thousands. Somebody would have a guilty conscience and willingly incriminate themselves.
 
The force of a falling object increases by 9.8 meters per second squared. Once a floor is falling it picks up energy as it goes, not to mention gains the mass of additional floors, and as the floors fall they crash into the exoskeleton supporting the building, effectively bringing down the mass of the entire building above the breaking point. That "scientist" is just plain wrong, not to mention basing his claim on ignorance is the fact that the building was suspended, not supported, so no increasing resistance.

You can literally see this in any of the collapse videos, you don't have to take my word for it. You can go see for yourself that the top of the building falls onto and crushed the bottom. The lower part of the building stays intact until the falling part reaches it.

That absolutely and indisputably refutes the claim that charges were set at the base of the building supports (supports that don't even exist in the same way in this type of architecture).

The whole claim on this thread is nonsense being propagated by ignorant people.


I agree in that I see what you see in the videos, which is different than actual building demolition videos.

That's a good point about the floors being suspended and not supported within or internally. Did Miatello take that into consideration? I don't know. I didn't read his entire article which goes into crazy calculations, but I should check if he actually takes that point into account for his calculations.
 
We are talking about the murder of thousands. Somebody would have a guilty conscience and willingly incriminate themselves.

I'd rather believe that there was no conspiracy in the first place, then to believe, that if people were in on it, that they would admit to it.

As an analogy, there's no way in hell that someone would publicly admit to being involved in the JFK murder conspiracy, lest they be executed (what's the penalty for High Treason in the USA?).
 
The force of a falling object increases by 9.8 meters per second squared. Once a floor is falling it picks up energy as it goes, not to mention gains the mass of additional floors, and as the floors fall they crash into the exoskeleton supporting the building, effectively bringing down the mass of the entire building above the breaking point. That "scientist" is just plain wrong, not to mention basing his claim on ignorance is the fact that the building was suspended, not supported, so no increasing resistance.

You can literally see this in any of the collapse videos, you don't have to take my word for it. You can go see for yourself that the top of the building falls onto and crushed the bottom. The lower part of the building stays intact until the falling part reaches it.

That absolutely and indisputably refutes the claim that charges were set at the base of the building supports (supports that don't even exist in the same way in this type of architecture).

The whole claim on this thread is nonsense being propagated by ignorant people.


Hmmmm. This what he says in his first paragraph which makes sense.

Something very similar happened with the scientific analysis of WTC collapse. Prof. Bazant, a renowned specialist in civil engineering whose analysis are almost totally in agreement with the official conclusion by NIST, wrote [2] :
“…When the next buckle with its group of plastic hinges forms, the upper part has already traveled many floors down and has acquired a much higher kinetic energy” (??).

Sadly for Bazant, but the mechanism he described is a blatant violation of the main laws of Physics! Actually, it is simply impossible that a mass A which impacts a mass B in rest could acquire more kinetic energy. On the contrary – as any textbook of Physics can tell you and we shall see – the final energy after impact will always and mathematically be lower than before! An error such as that is so big that all the following analysis becomes fatally spoiled
 
Whoever wrote that doesn't have a clue what they are talking about. Falling objects accelerate at a rate of 9.8 meters per second squared. Newton's law of gravity.

If that is enough energy for the first floor to knock offe second it is a provable mathematical fact that the doubled falling mass will hit the third floor with more than twice the energy that the first floor hit the second: twice the mass is now falling. And all that falling mass is picking up energy at a rate of 9.8 meters per second squared.

Kooks!
 
Whoever wrote that doesn't have a clue what they are talking about. Falling objects accelerate at a rate of 9.8 meters per second squared. Newton's law of gravity.

If that is enough energy for the first floor to knock offe second it is a provable mathematical fact that the doubled falling mass will hit the third floor with more than twice the energy that the first floor hit the second: twice the mass is now falling. And all that falling mass is picking up energy at a rate of 9.8 meters per second squared.

Kooks!


Fuji, I'm sorry but you're not a physicist. Ironically, this guy Miatello says that the collapse did not take place at gravity's free fall rate, but nearly half that rate. He also includes videos in his link of other controlled demolitions, and measures the rate of collapse as HALF the free fall rate, similar to 9/11.

He also says that pancaking did not occur with 9/11.

However, I don't see the similarity of his controlled demolition videos to that of 9/11.

Ironically, he said that he initially didn't believe in controlled demolitions, and said that those scientists who say otherwise, have failed to see the forest for the trees.

He also calculates that the bottom floors did not heat up to cause buckling like the top floors.

So in short, you don't have increasing kinetic energy when a moving floor collides with a floor at rest (for every reaction, there's an opposite and equal reaction).

He concludes explosives in the basements.

I still say I dunno.


P.S. The WTC were previously attacked many years ago in the basement. You'd think that there would be more security in the basement area.

P.P.S. He doesn't mention the suspension-type construction of the Twin Towers. I should email him about that.
 
Fuji, I'm sorry but you're not a physicist. Ironically, this guy Miatello says that the collapse did not take place at gravity's free fall rate, but nearly half that rate. He also includes videos in his link of other controlled demolitions, and measures the rate of collapse as HALF the free fall rate, similar to 9/11.

He also says that pancaking did not occur with 9/11.

However, I don't see the similarity of his controlled demolition videos to that of 9/11.

Ironically, he said that he initially didn't believe in controlled demolitions, and said that those scientists who say otherwise, have failed to see the forest for the trees.

He also calculates that the bottom floors did not heat up to cause buckling like the top floors.

So in short, you don't have increasing kinetic energy when a moving floor collides with a floor at rest (for every reaction, there's an opposite and equal reaction).

He concludes explosives in the basements.

I still say I dunno.


P.S. The WTC were previously attacked many years ago in the basement. You'd think that there would be more security in the basement area.

P.P.S. He doesn't mention the suspension-type construction of the Twin Towers. I should email him about that.

I'm sorry but anyone who says the mass of two floors falling five meters isn't hitting with at least twice the energy as the mass of one floor falling five meters isn't a physicist either. Go ahead, apply common sense. Two floors have twice the mass of one, now landing on a third. The structure holding each single floor wasn't designed to hold three floors weight, much less that much mass accelerated by gravity.

The official report, written by people who are experts, can give you the details if you need them from physicists.

But there are two things here for you:

1. A five year old can tell you that two bricks weigh twice as much as one, and

2. You can see for yourself in the YouTube videos that pancaking did occur. You don't need any physicist to tell you, GO LOOK AT THE VIDEOS.
 
I'm sorry but anyone who says the mass of two floors falling five meters isn't hitting with at least twice the energy as the mass of one floor falling five meters isn't a physicist either. Go ahead, apply common sense. Two floors have twice the mass of one, now landing on a third. The structure holding each single floor wasn't designed to hold three floors weight, much less that much mass accelerated by gravity.

The official report, written by people who are experts, can give you the details if you need them from physicists.

But there are two things here for you:

1. A five year old can tell you that two bricks weigh twice as much as one, and

2. You can see for yourself in the YouTube videos that pancaking did occur. You don't need any physicist to tell you, GO LOOK AT THE VIDEOS.

My question to you is are you really serious. or is your only motive, is to be right. Very sad state of affair.
 
I'm sorry but anyone who says the mass of two floors falling five meters isn't hitting with at least twice the energy as the mass of one floor falling five meters isn't a physicist either. Go ahead, apply common sense. Two floors have twice the mass of one, now landing on a third. The structure holding each single floor wasn't designed to hold three floors weight, much less that much mass accelerated by gravity.

The official report, written by people who are experts, can give you the details if you need them from physicists.

But there are two things here for you:

1. A five year old can tell you that two bricks weigh twice as much as one, and

2. You can see for yourself in the YouTube videos that pancaking did occur. You don't need any physicist to tell you, GO LOOK AT THE VIDEOS.


One floor is moving but the other is at rest AND is suspended while attached to the walls, therefore, there is resistance. The one below would slow down the one above.

If you read his article, he describes the 9/11 attack in great detail, claiming that certain floors, namely 98 and 92 were causing a slowdown of floors collapsing from above.


Note: He's not claiming what conspiracists say - that the towers collapsed at the free fall rate but nearly half that which is sufficient to cause demolition. He does conclude, however, that basement explosives were involved, but I don't see that.
 
My question to you is are you really serious. or is your only motive, is to be right. Very sad state of affair.

We have debated this topic on terb endlessly. The first time it came up I took the time to refute the conspiracy point by point. I dug into the "credentials" of the claimed experts, read all the materials, watched all the videos, read the official report in detail.

The conspiracy claims don't stand up to even the slightest deep dive into the details.

Most of them have even the most basic facts wrong, and it is easy to verify that. Seriously, go to YouTube and watch the video. The building pancakes. You can see it. It does not fall into its foundations like a controlled demolition.

You can even go get the videos that claim to show it looks like a controlled demolition and watch there: it pancakes.

Those videos are the dumbest because they are based on comparing the collapse of standard compression architecture building as if that were even relevant, with quotes from a bunch of "experts" who appear to not even know the WTC wasn't built that way.

This stuff is pure garbage, nonsense claims from fake experts mindlessly reiterated by people who don't actually have a clue. This thread is a case in point.
 
We have debated this topic on terb endlessly. The first time it came up I took the time to refute the conspiracy point by point. I dug into the "credentials" of the claimed experts, read all the materials, watched all the videos, read the official report in detail.

The conspiracy claims don't stand up to even the slightest deep dive into the details.

Most of them have even the most basic facts wrong, and it is easy to verify that. Seriously, go to YouTube and watch the video. The building pancakes. You can see it. It does not fall into its foundations like a controlled demolition.

You can even go get the videos that claim to show it looks like a controlled demolition and watch there: it pancakes.

Those videos are the dumbest because they are based on comparing the collapse of standard compression architecture building as if that were even relevant, with quotes from a bunch of "experts" who appear to not even know the WTC wasn't built that way.

This stuff is pure garbage, nonsense claims from fake experts mindlessly reiterated by people who don't actually have a clue. This thread is a case in point.

I never new you had a structural engineering degree.
 
I never new you had a structural engineering degree.

Oh... but he is!

6Og8oVz.jpg


And he's reminded the entire "bored" of this... well almost 62,000 times.