Should canada build the next generation Avro Arrow?

canada better build something, because right now it has zero know how in manufacturing anything, and with that lost, might as well write the country to zero.
 
It would cost the federal government their entire national budget for a year to undertake such a thing. And for how many jets? Lockheed has orders for thousands of F-35's and their costs keep skyrocketing. Do we really think we are going to sell enough worldwide to make these jets even remotely close to affordable?
 
canada better build something, because right now it has zero know how in manufacturing anything, and with that lost, might as well write the country to zero.

Your Harper government has already committed to spending $30 billion on having Irving build a new warship on the east coast. Because our biggest threat is from ISIS terrorists :confused:

http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/irv...canadian-surface-combatant-warships-1.2920071
"In other words, $26 billion or so will go to Irving and they will decide who will get to help build these ships, under what terms and conditions.

"Of course, their primary interest and responsibility isn't to the Canadian taxpayer, isn't to the government, isn't to the navy, but it's to their shareholders."
 
No way on a "NEW" ARROW,...would be just another civil servant money pit,...with no results.

Plus,...if we "try" to go it alone,...all sub contracting we currently get by buying US,...would be gone,...net result,...RED for ever.

FAST
 
If we have to spend 35 billion for twenty planes then I would rather it spent here kick starting innovation and the aero space industry but unless we change governments that won't happen- harper has some weird luddite view on technology
 
We should specialize in drones, get ahead of what will be the future of combat both on the ground and in the air.


LOL,

Drones are good for about 2 things.

1. As flying bombs to blow up terrorist camps (and kill 30 innocent civilians at the same time)

2. Spying

Canada has no need for either of those 2 options. We do, however, need good solid long range fighter aircraft to protect our boarders. Nothing is going to replace a human being at the controls any time soon.
 
According to KGB files found after the breakup of the Soviet Union, the AVRO Arrow II was planned. The design speed was between Mach 5 - 5.5.

B8

Ah, no.

The fastest plane that I'm aware of is the SR71 blackbird and it's purely a reconnaissance plane (no weapons) and is capable of Mach 3.5

Unless there is a plane in Area 51, nothing is capable (even on the drawing board) of Mach 5.5. The blackbird's speed created some really wickedly high temperatures as well. On the ground, the fuel wold leak out of the tanks because the seals only sealed once it took off and heated up.
 
Yes that was the Avro Arrow mated with an Iroquois Jet Engine, almost twice the thrust of the engine used in the first 5 test planes.

No.

RL 206 was fitted with the Orenda engine, but was nowhere near capable of mach 5.5.

Supposedly, the Orenda engine was able to just get over Mach 2.2 (which is still pretty damn fast).
 
If we have to spend 35 billion for twenty planes then I would rather it spent here kick starting innovation and the aero space industry but unless we change governments that won't happen- harper has some weird luddite view on technology

Quite correct.

Harper is a short sighted one track pony.

If it isn't black goo that they dig out of a big hole in the ground in Alberta with giant shovels, he neither gets it, or is interested.

Harper would NEVER EVER fund an Arrow resurrection. And neither would Mulcair.

Only the liberals would consider it (IMHO)

Lest we forget that the original Arrow was started under the liberals (St. Laurant and CD Howe)

Part of me thinks that the reason (or at least one of the contributing factors that the Arrow was cancelled) was the fact that it was a successful liberal program centered in eastern Canada and Toronto in particular.

And the thing that KILLS me about the Arrow is that not only did they cancel the entire program, but they chopped up 6 perfectly good planes. That just makes no sense whatsoever.

Diefenbaker. They didn't bury him deep enough or soon enough as far as I'm concerned.
 
Seriously, take all those people laid off from RIM, put them together with the Bombardier guys, and the people who make the LAV's, throw a bunch of money at robotics programs at Waterloo and U of T, and set a ten year goal to be the world's leader in military drone production.

Within the drone field if we focus on long range autonomous aircraft we can achieve air superiority over the arctic.

WE ? Who's we ? Don't you reside in the US now?
 
LOL,

Drones are good for about 2 things.

1. As flying bombs to blow up terrorist camps (and kill 30 innocent civilians at the same time)

2. Spying

Canada has no need for either of those 2 options. We do, however, need good solid long range fighter aircraft to protect our boarders. Nothing is going to replace a human being at the controls any time soon.

Your absolutely right Captain, for anyone who supports Drones you should Maybe watch this movie. Its an eye opener !!!

 
LOL,

Drones are good for about 2 things.

1. As flying bombs to blow up terrorist camps (and kill 30 innocent civilians at the same time)

2. Spying

Canada has no need for either of those 2 options. We do, however, need good solid long range fighter aircraft to protect our boarders. Nothing is going to replace a human being at the controls any time soon.

A drone is a much more efficient long range fighter aircraft, particularly over the arctic. Human piloted planes can only fly very limited arctic missions due to the inability to recover the pilot if he had to bail. A drone can just crash and it is only money.

There will always be a role for human piloted aircraft but we can let somebody else build that. The question is what Canada should build, and we should build drones. We can buy the other stuff we also need.

Note that in the future the human piloted flight is likely escorted by and in control of a squadron of drones. This is not either/or, it will be both, with the drones leading ahead of the piloted flight to minimize risk to the pilot.
 
According to KGB files found after the breakup of the Soviet Union, the AVRO Arrow II was planned. The design speed was between Mach 5 - 5.5.

B8

It would be great to get this done. Put Canada back on the map. My only question.. there's no stealth? The Avro advantage is they fly higher levels then any other jet in the world.
I'm a proud Canadian and to get this new Avro would inspiring to the new generation and old.
 
Your absolutely right Captain, for anyone who supports Drones you should Maybe watch this movie. Its an eye opener !!!


Thanks for the amazing trailer. I'm going to watch this movie..
Past 6 months been looking to buy one in the states. Amazing stuff..
 
Seriously, take all those people laid off from RIM, put them together with the Bombardier guys, and the people who make the LAV's, throw a bunch of money at robotics programs at Waterloo and U of T, and set a ten year goal to be the world's leader in military drone production.

Within the drone field if we focus on long range autonomous aircraft we can achieve air superiority over the arctic.

The main threat for the future, in the Arctic, is that you-know-who might start "visiting' uninhabited parts of what we regard as Canada, and might (if we don't push back) eventually establish 'exploration' or 'scientific' bases of some kind.

Air superiority by drones won't deter that (apart, perhaps, from documenting it).

What we should be doing is establishing our own presence in the Arctic. That needn't be settlements. We could do it by means of regular mobile patrols. We would need amphibious vehicles, capable of roaming round the Arctic. On land, on sea, on ice -- and capable of moving from one to the other. These wouldn't be military, as such, but more like coastguard or police. But blatantly Canadian.

If we are going to fund some R&D, let's direct it to creating a world leadership position in such vehicles. Apart from sovereignty establishment, the developing technology from the R&D would obviously have good spinoff value. And would be a very good area for Canada to be a world leader in.

It's not possible to establish sovereignty over any kind of region by the use of drones -- nor by aircraft of any kind. What we need is presence, on the ground. Vehicles.