Should canada build the next generation Avro Arrow?

WinterHawk

Member
Jan 18, 2004
705
1
18
Cyberspace
So what does Canada need? It's a big country with not a lot of airbases. That means we need a fast, long range interceptor much like the Avro Arrow. That's easy. Most modern multi-role fighters are capable of matching or exceeding the Arrow's range, the addition of drop tanks and air-to-air refueling make it even less of an issue. Of course, when intercepting a hostile, you need more than range, you need to get to the threat as quickly as possible. For many fighters, this means using afterburners. Unfortunately, afterburners drastically reduce range they also make the jet and easy target for infrared sensors. There are a few jet fighters, however, that are capable of exceeding the speed of sound without using afterburners. This feature, called supercruise, can give fighters like the F-22 Raptor and Eurofighter Typhoon a huge advantage.

But what about a next generation Arrow, using almost 60 years of technological advancements to give us a "Made in Canada" solution, plus the economic benefits of both R&D and spin off jobs that the Arrow would provide?


http://news.nationalpost.com/news/c...d-as-alternative-to-f-35-stealth-fighter-jets
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...rrow-make-lazarus-like-return/article4530724/
http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2012/09/09/avro-arrow-f35-canada_n_1869140.html
http://www.superarrow.ca/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S74zf0YZX20
https://www.facebook.com/pages/Avro-Arrow-Bourdeau-Industries-Official/402158416505160
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2014/...uture-Avro-Arrow-Take-Your-F-35-and-Stuff-It#
 
Water under the bridge now, no need to dig up this corpse and try to reanimate it.
 
Bombardier can't even get a relatively simple twin engine passenger jet going anywhere near on time or budget. Who is going to do this fighter jet? The perfect jet for us us the Super Hornet, but no doubt the government wants a flashy new toy.
 
Water under the bridge now, no need to dig up this corpse and try to reanimate it.

The specifications for a new Canadian Fighter/Bomber Jet really haven't changed in 60 years. We're still a LARGE country with just a few air bases to cover the entire country. And the Avro Arrow exceeded those requirement in spades back then and still does now. With current technology and materials, imagine what a next generation Arrow could be?

One company to put forward a proposal was Bourdeau Industries out of Quebec.
 
I'm all for it.

It's going to be a boondoggle no matter what, it might as well be our boondoggle.

Seriously, however, I think it would be a great thing, but I doubt that the political will is there though.

James Floyd (head of Engineering at AVRO for the Arrow project) is still very much alive too.
 
While we are considering building something that we have absolutely no infrastructure to do lets also entertain the idea of a Canadian space colony on Mars.
 
That's the thing. If your going to spend money, spend it where it will do the most good. Support R&D, provide highly skilled jobs to new graduates and those who can retrained. Make sure it's a "Made in Canada" solution to our problems, instead of supporting someone else's economy. And unlike the Bombardier streetcars made in Mexico but assembled in Canada, all parts much be made here to the highest specifications.

Lets get Canadian's dreaming and working again.
 
We should specialize in drones, get ahead of what will be the future of combat both on the ground and in the air.
 
Drones are a component, but can't replace the boots on the ground or the pilot with a birds eye view.
 
According to KGB files found after the breakup of the Soviet Union, the AVRO Arrow II was planned. The design speed was between Mach 5 - 5.5.

B8
 
That is what we should specialize in building an industry around.

Seriously, take all those people laid off from RIM, put them together with the Bombardier guys, and the people who make the LAV's, throw a bunch of money at robotics programs at Waterloo and U of T, and set a ten year goal to be the world's leader in military drone production.

Within the drone field if we focus on long range autonomous aircraft we can achieve air superiority over the arctic.
 
According to KGB files found after the breakup of the Soviet Union, the AVRO Arrow II was planned. The design speed was between Mach 5 - 5.5.

B8

Yes that was the Avro Arrow mated with an Iroquois Jet Engine, almost twice the thrust of the engine used in the first 5 test planes.
 
Bombardier can't even get a relatively simple twin engine passenger jet going anywhere near on time or budget. Who is going to do this fighter jet? The perfect jet for us us the Super Hornet, but no doubt the government wants a flashy new toy.

Simple twin engined jet? What makes you think the Cseries is simple? Also, show me anyone else who has developed a state of the art twin engine jet for less. It amazes me how people rag on Bombardier. Especially considering the two largest aerospace companies on the planet have had disastrous development programs recently
 
Drones are a component, but can't replace the boots on the ground or the pilot with a birds eye view.

Who says? You can send real time HD video now. What more do you need in a plane? The real issue with drones and combat, is they can be jammed or hacked.
 
To me there is nothing patriotic about building war machines, Canadian researchers finding a vaccine for ebola that stirs my patriotism, the 150 million given to UofT for medical research that also stirs my patriotism.
 
I actually agree with Fuji on this one - If we are going to invest military R&D dollars, drones really are the future. That being said, I think we can probably spend our dollars better in non-military sectors.
 
That's the thing. If your going to spend money, spend it where it will do the most good. Support R&D, provide highly skilled jobs to new graduates and those who can retrained. Make sure it's a "Made in Canada" solution to our problems, instead of supporting someone else's economy. And unlike the Bombardier streetcars made in Mexico but assembled in Canada, all parts much be made here to the highest specifications.

Lets get Canadian's dreaming and working again.

Amen to that brother! The amount of engineering & manufacturing jobs lost here is mind boggling, lets put people back to work & start sayin made in Canada again!
 
The military should just be scrapped
Use the funds where they can do some good

Our military is a world joke anyhow
And being next door to USA means we can just use their resources if a war ever pops up