House Insurance Premium

James, when you did the house work, the workers should have been covered by WSIB, which would be through the company they work for that you hired to do the renovation. Even if you were acting as the General Contractor yourself and hiring subs, you should have been dealing with WSIB, not your house insurance.

.

Residential contractors are not required to be covered by WSIB.

As such, very few if any residential contractors are WSIB insured. The legislation was recently changed to force all those commercial contractors to be WSIB covered, but not residential.

I was the General Contractor I guess you could say because I was hiring trades as needed and doing a lot of the work myself. I approached WSIB and they stated that I needed to start a company in order for me to be insured and it would have been at great cost.

I did contact my insurer about the liability issue and I did purchase additional insurance but they stated that the injured worker would need to sue me and then I would be covered (or so they said). There was also the issue of jobsite theft and damage to the house (say someone lit it on fire for giggles during my renovation). For all these reasons I contacted my insurance company.

I am reminded of former BC Premier Gordon Campbell who had hired a contractor to work on his cottage and one of the roofers fell to his death through a skylite. Campbell was found guilty of negligence even though all he did was hire a company to renovate his cottage. (In the case where there are multiple contractors on the site, the owner automatically becomes "the constructor" in Ontario.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/briti...-safety-lapse-cited-in-roofer-death-1.1251226

http://bc.ctvnews.ca/gordon-campbell-found-responsible-in-roofer-s-death-1.777808
 
2 questions.

1) How do we know if they are covered by WSIB?

2) If they are not covered by WSIB for whatever reason, does the liability default to the homeowner?

1. You ask them for proof of coverage. (Most residential contractors are not WSIB covered.)

2. I dunno, I'm not a lawyer, but they're always going to go after the guy who can pay. (They're not going to be bothered going after some broke guy, but if you as the homeowner have money, or assets, they will come after you.)

I know if you have hired more than one contractor to work on your house at any one given time, you automatically become the "constructor" in Ontario and as such, you are legally responsible for them.
 
Materials and labour have gone up? The insurance company isn't replacing your land, which is the big driver.

Correct.

And say you did suffer a huge fire, the foundations would still be intact and could be reused. (And I can assure you that the construction of the foundations are the WORST part of any residential construction job - especially in the city where space is tight.)
 
I also had an issue with Meloche Monnex. My bill went up but not by as much as OP and also with no claims. I told them to take a hike and switched to The Personal as well for a slightly lower bill. :frusty:
 
That seems strange considering the U.S. markets are at record highs as are several other markets around the world. Anyone whose lost money over the last few yrs. must be a terrible stock picker.


Sorry, insurance companies are giant bonds funds, you seen the rate of return on those types of financial instruments
 
Anybody ever filed a claim and actually collected money? Also, what happened to your premiums in subsequent years?
 
Sorry, insurance companies are giant bonds funds, you seen the rate of return on those types of financial instruments

That's true for life insurance companies, where they match long term liability timelines with staggered bonds, and balance with equities to hedge against the bond market tanking. Casualty (home and auto) insurance is more of a premium-in expense-out situation I thought, less dependent on long term investment.
 
That's true for life insurance companies, where they match long term liability timelines with staggered bonds, and balance with equities to hedge against the bond market tanking. Casualty (home and auto) insurance is more of a premium-in expense-out situation I thought, less dependent on long term investment.

Not really, since the largest auto & casualty claims can have payouts over decades.
 
Anybody ever filed a claim and actually collected money? Also, what happened to your premiums in subsequent years?

My experience was with Meloche--had a small fire, about $10000 in damage. Jerked me around on the renovation--estimator they hired didn't even get the type of materials correct in his estimate. Next renewal was so high the increase would have covered the loss in 5 years. Now, I realize the companies have to make money--but no way do they need to recover the full $10000 from me. The whole point of insurance is to SPREAD the risk across many, many people. I moved to Desjardin, much better deal. Even lowered my car insurance.
 
I'm with them too, and heartily recommend 'em. I've had a major claim with them which they handled promptly and professionally. Plus my rates have barely budged over the past however many years.

I'm with them also and they're great. My car insurance dropped this year substantially and my house insurance has been about the same for 11 years despite an almost 800K increase in value and a pretty big claim 8 years ago.

Steph