Initially I had the same thought. I read The Star article in detail and it seems as if he crossed a fine "ethical" line. From the article, I quote:
- "The CBC code of ethics states that employees “must not use their positions to further their personal interests.”"... I am guessing the CBC felt that he did use his position to further his personal interests.
- The article then cites a contract between Solomon and the art dealer he brokered for which says "“Whereas Solomon is a Canadian journalist and has become familiar with collectors and others who might have an interest in purchasing Canadian and other art.” According to the draft, “Solomon agrees to, from time to time, introduce (Bailey) to such persons as Jim Balsillie, Reza Satchu and others who might be interested in purchasing the works of arts carried by (Bailey) or who have a relationship with (Bailey).”" It would appear that the very wording of that contract goes against the CBC Code of Ethics.
- The article then discusses how Solomon formed a journalistic relationship with Jim Balsillie, but immediately introduced the issue of art collection into the relationship, which is against CBC code... "Balsillie, in an email response to questions from the Star, recalled: “Evan first reached out to me to appear on his show and discuss my new role as the chair of Sustainable Development Technology Canada and the organization’s work.”
He opted not to be interviewed but recalled he told Solomon he would be happy to talk to him on background about the federal initiative. The two men agreed to get together for a drink on Wednesday, Oct. 23, to discuss Solomon’s interest in Balsillie’s work with the federal initiative and the Franklin expedition. That turned out to be the day after the Bailey-Solomon contract was signed. Solomon and Balsillie were going to be at the Writer’s Trust event in Toronto, Balsillie as a guest, Solomon as a judge.
They met at a pub across the street from the Art Gallery of Ontario, where the gala was being held. Balsillie recalled that Solomon had earlier asked if he could bring a friend. That friend was Bruce Bailey, the art collector." Based on this, I assume that he crossed an ethical boundary where he entered into a journalistic relationship with these individuals and knowingly used that relationship to profit for himself, given the contract that he had with the art dealer
I think the difference between journalists getting speaking fees is that organizations request journalists to speak to them, as opposed to the journalist INITIATING THE IDEA OF A SPEAKING APPEARANCE WITH CURRENT OR POTENTIAL GUESTS. I assume Mansbridge would be in hot water if it was discovered that after interviewing guests, he said something like "Hey that was a good conversation we had - you know... I give similar talks to large audiences where I get paid tons of money to do so... can we meet to discuss me making an appearance?"