Another Win For The Gun Lobby

I wouldn't call this a win for the gun lobby. This was crime reduction legislation by the Tories no? Doesn't affect gun lobbyists much.
 
SCC rules minimum sentence for gun crimes is unconstitutional.

Good. The gun regulations are poorly written and confusing and even firearms lawyers can't figure out what counts as safe storage many cases.

Eliminating the minimums means judges can go easy on people who caused no harm but misunderstood what was required.
 
SCC rules minimum sentence for gun crimes is unconstitutional.

I think of 'gun crimes' the same as 'hate crimes'. A crime is a crime - why would the use of a knife or the motivation of bias affect the sentencing ?
 
"You failed to understand what is meant by a safe in the law and I have to convict you for that, but I can see you honestly tried your best to comply with the law, and that no one was endangered, so I am giving you an absolute discharge. Buy a proper safe now so that I don't see you back in my court." << now possible thanks to this ruling.
 
Don't want to start a new thread so I'll piggyback on here.

Huge anti-sex education protest at Queens Park right now.
 
"You failed to understand what is meant by a safe in the law and I have to convict you for that, but I can see you honestly tried your best to comply with the law, and that no one was endangered, so I am giving you an absolute discharge. Buy a proper safe now so that I don't see you back in my court." << now possible thanks to this ruling.

^this.
 
Good. The gun regulations are poorly written and confusing and even firearms lawyers can't figure out what counts as safe storage many cases.

Eliminating the minimums means judges can go easy on people who caused no harm but misunderstood what was required.


Maybe. But I thought the case at bar was about unlicensed individuals found carrying loaded prohibited firearms. The trial judge wanted a more lenient sentence because the accused had no prior convictions.
 

The gun lobby does not advocate going easy on criminals.

However, they certainly do object when certain uninformed members of the public can't differentiate between individuals licensed to own firearms and criminals who use guns to commit a crime. You can't get a gun license if you have a criminal record or are otherwise a spouse beater.

The gun lobby also doesn't like being treated like persons with criminal intent, when for example their firearms license may have lapsed due to oversight. The Attorneys General of Ontario are notorious for prosecuting licensed people who have used their guns for self defense. The Toronto Police Service were notorious for checking the database of gun licensees in order to visit those persons who's licenses had recently expired, and give them a choice of prosecution for having a gun without a license (which is a criminal offense subject to 3 years minimum in prison), or handing over their guns for destruction. That last action conveniently boosted the seized guns statistics of the police gangs-and-gun unit, who then conflate those statistics into having taken 'dangerous' weapons off the streets, as if they were all seized from street gangs.

The threat of going to jail for 3 or 5 years is a powerful tool to get people to plea bargain to a lesser charge, just so the crown attorney can take away their guns.

The Harper Government was not particularly friendly to gun owners in this case, and more and more gun owners are turning away from his Conservatives, as he's simply using them to engage in wedge politics and taking them for granted.
 
The gun lobby does not advocate going easy on criminals.

However, they certainly do object when certain uninformed members of the public can't differentiate between individuals licensed to own firearms and criminals who use guns to commit a crime. You can't get a gun license if you have a criminal record or are otherwise a spouse beater.

The gun lobby also doesn't like being treated like persons with criminal intent, when for example their firearms license may have lapsed due to oversight. The Attorneys General of Ontario are notorious for prosecuting licensed people who have used their guns for self defense. The Toronto Police Service were notorious for checking the database of gun licensees in order to visit those persons who's licenses had recently expired, and give them a choice of prosecution for having a gun without a license (which is a criminal offense subject to 3 years minimum in prison), or handing over their guns for destruction. That last action conveniently boosted the seized guns statistics of the police gangs-and-gun unit, who then conflate those statistics into having taken 'dangerous' weapons off the streets, as if they were all seized from street gangs.

The threat of going to jail for 3 or 5 years is a powerful tool to get people to plea bargain to a lesser charge, just so the crown attorney can take away their guns.

The Harper Government was not particularly friendly to gun owners in this case, and more and more gun owners are turning away from his Conservatives, as he's simply using them to engage in wedge politics and taking them for granted.

+100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
 
SCC rules minimum sentence for gun crimes is unconstitutional.

I thought the same- that damn harper is anti- gun. In fact this law was a lot worse than the gun registry- at least that's how the ndp and liberals should play it.