Right to Die Decision

If someone doesn't want to live, do we have the right to force that person to live? My friend worked one Summer on the TTC and was responsible for cleaning up suicide scenes. Not pretty and it affected him as well as the driver and other people. People who don't want to live usually find a way.
 
What if shes in debt ??
What if the family encouraged her to waste ever larger amounts on ever more elaborate, and uncomfortable, 'treatments" because they couldn't bear to talk about dying? Not even if it was someone else doing all the suffering? Not even if that victim of medicine kept pointing out, 'they're not extending my life; they're just prolonging my dying'.

What's wrong with saying that dying has begun when a person says, 'it's my time, I don't want to live any longer'? Why shouldn't true professional caregivers co-operate with that reasonable determination and facilitate it just as they facilitate any other in their field of biological mechanics?
 
That's EXACTLY what they will say.The Christian Right has never had more of a say in this country then it does right now.From sex, to religion(and the wars that come with it), to oil , Canada has never looked more like a Southern States then it does right now.Do some research, you'll find who helped put them in power also.....

My mom told me that her friend at church today said the parish priest read out a letter against the rules insofar that they can be used to terminate life prematurely (sorry, don't have details but that's the gist of it).

I told my mother, don't worry, the Christian Taliban Harper might not change things much when he's coming out with replacement legislation.
 
(c) The Feasibility of Safeguards and the Possibility of a “Slippery Slope”

[114] At trial Canada went into some detail about the risks associated with the legalization of physician-assisted dying. In its view, there are many possible sources of error and many factors that can render a patient “decisionally vulnerable” and thereby give rise to the risk that persons without a rational and considered desire for death will in fact end up dead. It points to cognitive impairment, depression or other mental illness, coercion, undue influence, psychological or emotional manipulation, systemic prejudice (against the elderly or people with disabilities), and the possibility of ambivalence or misdiagnosis as factors that may escape detection or give rise to errors in capacity assessment. Essentially, Canada argues that, given the breadth of this list, there is no reliable way to identify those who are vulnerable and those who are not. As a result, it says, a blanket prohibition is necessary.

[115] The evidence accepted by the trial judge does not support Canada’s argument. Based on the evidence regarding assessment processes in comparable end‑of-life medical decision-making in Canada, the trial judge concluded that vulnerability can be assessed on an individual basis, using the procedures that physicians apply in their assessment of informed consent and decisional capacity in the context of medical decision-making more generally. Concerns about decisional capacity and vulnerability arise in all end-of-life medical decision-making. Logically speaking, there is no reason to think that the injured, ill and disabled who have the option to refuse or to request withdrawal of lifesaving or life-sustaining treatment, or who seek palliative sedation, are less vulnerable or less susceptible to biased decision-making than those who might seek more active assistance in dying. The risks that Canada describes are already part and parcel of our medical system.

... And ...

Underlying both of these rights is a concern for the protection of individual autonomy and dignity. Liberty protects “the right to make fundamental personal choices free from state interference”: Blencoe v. British Columbia (Human Rights Commission), 2000 SCC 44, [2000] 2 S.C.R. 307, at para. 54. Security of the person encompasses “a notion of personal autonomy involving . . . control over one’s bodily integrity free from state interference” (Rodriguez, at pp. 587-88 per Sopinka J., referring to R. v. Morgentaler, [1988] 1 S.C.R. 30) and it is engaged by state interference with an individual’s physical or psychological integrity, including any state action that causes physical or serious psychological suffering (New Brunswick (Minister of Health and Community Services) v. G. (J.)

===========

In short they relied on Morgentaller, where psychological suffering created justification for abortion, and extended that principle to suicide. Note the "or" in "physical or psychological". The government raised the depression point and the court answered somewhat obliquely that the correct test was competence, and it is had to see how this ruling doesn't create a right for depressed people to suicide IF a doctor determines their is no reasonable prospect of remediation AND they are judged to express that desire competently.


If a bi-polar patient isn't taking his meds correctly, they won't permit a doctor-assisted suicide. There will be safeguards. I know a dementia patient who did commit suicide, and he expressed his desire before it happened. I wonder about that since maybe no meds could help him? (He was a very wealthy man and who was respected in the community for his achievements in commerce and philanthropy).
 
If someone doesn't want to live, do we have the right to force that person to live? My friend worked one Summer on the TTC and was responsible for cleaning up suicide scenes. Not pretty and it affected him as well as the driver and other people. People who don't want to live usually find a way.

Everyone should be able to check-out in a safe pain free manner.
 
The one area now that is most open to abuse is giving the power to "pull the plug" to the spouse. I had heard that Gary Coleman's wife couldn't wait to "pull the plug".
 
If a bi-polar patient isn't taking his meds correctly, they won't permit a doctor-assisted suicide. There will be safeguards. I know a dementia patient who did commit suicide, and he expressed his desire before it happened. I wonder about that since maybe no meds could help him? (He was a very wealthy man and who was respected in the community for his achievements in commerce and philanthropy).

http://www.nationalpost.com/m/wp/bl...ctor-assisted-suicide-raises-ethical-concerns

Possibility that incurable depression meets criteria for doctor-assisted suicide raises ethical concerns

....Now, however, there may be another, darker alternative for those suffering from severe, intractable depression. Though largely overlooked in the debate sparked by last Friday’s Supreme Court of Canada ruling legalizing doctor-assisted death, the decision applies to more than just patients with incurable physical illnesses.

People with treatment-resistant depression — a crippling form of the disease that actor Robin Williams was said to have battled before killing himself last August — fulfil the criteria for assisted-suicide set out by the high court, argues Udo Schuklenk, a leading Canadian bioethicist.

Mr. Ross said he would not have opted for doctor-assisted dying if it had been available to him, but would never begrudge it to others with his condition.

“If we’re going to allow doctor-assisted suicide for other types of intolerable pain, then I would support depression as being included in that category.”

The notion that mental illness might make someone eligible for state-sanctioned assisted death, however, is causing unease elsewhere.

The idea has long been forbidden ground in the assisted suicide debate in Canada. While polls show mounting support for mercy killing of those dying of widespread cancer or “catastrophic” physical illnesses, the public is far more nervous when it comes to mental disorders such as depression. How could the mentally ill be competent enough to provide free and informed consent? Would their thinking not be clouded by the very fact they are depressed?

Depression and other psychiatric illnesses can influence insight and judgment, says Dr. Padraic Carr, president of the Canadian Psychiatric Association. “They can affect the ability to appreciate the situation and manipulate information rationally,” says Dr. Carr, who is also a professor of psychiatry at the University of Alberta.

But Dr. Schuklenk argues depression alone does not automatically make people incapable of making decisions about their life.

‘We know that a large number of these people, at one point or another commit suicide, and it often happens in terrible circumstances’

In his analysis, the high court ruling opens the door to putting assisted suicide within reach of competent adults suffering debilitating and “torturous” treatment-resistant depression.

In its historic and unanimous decision, the Supreme Court justices ruled competent, consenting adults suffering a “grievous and irremediable” medical condition causing intolerable physical or psychological suffering have a Constitutional right to a doctor’s aid in dying.

Dr. Schuklenk said the paralyzing distress of treatment-resistant depression should be given as equal weight as suffering cause by a physical illness.

Depression itself is not terminal. “A patient suffering from treatment-resistant major depressive disorder can live — however miserably — to old age,” he says.

The ethical question is, once the right to assisted suicide is granted to competent adults suffering incurable physical illnesses, how could legislatures or provincial colleges of physicians that will ultimately write the rules for medical aid in dying discriminate against competent, mentally ill adults who have decided life is no longer worth living?

“We know that a large number of these people, at one point or another commit suicide, and it often happens in terrible circumstances,” says Dr. Schuklenk, who headed the Royal Society of Canada’s 2011 expert panel on end-of-life decision-making.

“This [physician aid in dying] is a better way for them to end their lives, once you have confirmed competence and you have established that the condition cannot be improved — that these people have undergone years and years of clinical care involving drugs, involving psychotherapy and literally anything you can think of.”

“Once those conditions are met, and once it is clear that, based on clinical knowledge at the time when the decision has to be made, the condition is not going to improve and they make that call, then I think we should respect that.”

....
 
one of sound mind, should always have full control over his/her body and the life of it.

The SC has made the right decision, this is very important.