Right to Die Decision

If I understood asshole Pete on the steps leading from the House of Commons today this is another SCOC decision he disagrees with and the Canadians suffering through hell can just go fuck themselves. His religious viewpoint is the only one that matters. I can only wish the whole MacKay clan a very, very, very slow agonizing death. And I sincerely hope that whoever forms the next government a corrects MacKay's latest folly includes language to prevent his family from ever benefiting from that which he wants to deny others.

I nursed my wife through a terrible death from cancer in which she begged for someone to assistant her dying. I wouldn't wish a death like that on m y worst enemy except of course asshole Pete and his family.
 
What if shes in debt ??
In that case the loving family loves her and all, but really can't afford her upkeep.


It ain't just religious nuts who oppose this stuff, by the way. There are some who contend that palliative care and the unofficial practice of bumping up that morphine drip when the time is nigh due is already enough. And even if you believe you should have the legally enshrined right to determine your own exit strategy (and absolve anyone who assists you in seeing it through of any criminal taint), if you think right-to-die laws don't come with a whole heaping pile of potential abuses and fuckups, you're daft.
 
Maybe the evangelical reformers will say that it should only be God's will.

That's EXACTLY what they will say.The Christian Right has never had more of a say in this country then it does right now.From sex, to religion(and the wars that come with it), to oil , Canada has never looked more like a Southern States then it does right now.Do some research, you'll find who helped put them in power also.....
 
More reason to have a frank and open discussion with your family long before you wind up on your death bed about when and if to pull the plug, how you want to be buried, etc. Sadly, we don't talk enough about death and it some times brings out the worst in families as they squabble over the estate.
 
All I can say is you wouldn't let your dog or cat suffer. Why should it be any different. I witnessed my parents and in laws suffer terribly before they died. It takes a toll on the family member knowing their is nothing that can be done ( legal wise) only to make them "comfortable" as they waste away in agony.

The most difficult part of this new law to which I agree is trying to find a MD who,will do the procedure now that is "legal"
 
Agreed. There is huge potential for abuse, but that is no reason to take the decision away from someone. There should be some sort of formal guideline, but ultimately the decision comes down to between a person and his/her practitioner.

I never understand why those who oppose this think they have the right to make end of life decisions for me. Suicide is not illegal. This change is to protect doctors who help patients who want to end their life but are not physically capable of doing so.
 
I never understand why those who oppose this think they have the right to make end of life decisions for me. Suicide is not illegal. This change is to protect doctors who help patients who want to end their life but are not physically capable of doing so.

Agree with you totally
 
The court sure didn't hold back in this decision, by allowing assisted suicide for non terminal illnesses and including psychological as well as physical pain they paved the way for assisted suicide for people suffering depression if it has not been remediated by treatment.
 
I never understand why those who oppose this think they have the right to make end of life decisions for me. Suicide is not illegal. This change is to protect doctors who help patients who want to end their life but are not physically capable of doing so.

Because they feel (with some justification) that "legitimizing" this option by making it fully legal can lead to pressure from family members or someone's own conscience to end a life before they otherwise would choose to do so. Because they feel that the already legal practice death by palliative sedation - where the patient chooses to be put into a morphine coma and usually dies of dehydration - is enough. There are good and compelling reasons to be opposed to the "right" to assisted suicide. (for the record, I am for it. Just not comfortable about it and recognize that there are some strong arguments against it)


The court sure didn't hold back in this decision, by allowing assisted suicide for non terminal illnesses and including psychological as well as physical pain they paved the way for assisted suicide for people suffering depression if it has not been remediated by treatment.
And it starts already. That is so fucked in so many ways. Imma starting to think I ain't fer it Imma agin it after all.
 
Agreed. There is huge potential for abuse, but that is no reason to take the decision away from someone. There should be some sort of formal guideline, but ultimately the decision comes down to between a person and his/her practitioner.

Not really. The decision described in the news mentioned that it would be a decision by someone of sound mind and terminally ill and going through intolerable pain and suffering.
 
The court sure didn't hold back in this decision, by allowing assisted suicide for non terminal illnesses and including psychological as well as physical pain they paved the way for assisted suicide for people suffering depression if it has not been remediated by treatment.

Are you sure about that? I haven't heard THAT in the news, including commentary by a legal analyst.
 
Are you sure about that? I haven't heard THAT in the news, including commentary by a legal analyst.

The judgment explicitly says psychological suffering is grounds and that the illness need not be terminal. It doesn't explicitly mention depression but it certainly paves the way for someone to make that argument. The only barrier would be whether the depression is "irremediable".
 
The judgment explicitly says psychological suffering is grounds and that the illness need not be terminal. It doesn't explicitly mention depression but it certainly paves the way for someone to make that argument. The only barrier would be whether the depression is "irremediable".

Really? Wow. But the check is that they will need a doctor who agrees if such conditions are met, assuming new laws also allow this.
 
Ditto. Even if the decision opened the door to what Fuji said, I doubt the government will allow it in any new legislation.

Why would new legislation be required? The SCC has set the bar, the only question is whether depression meets it. Clearly it can be "intolerable" as it already drives people to suicide. The question really will only turn on whether it is remediable with treatment.
 
Really? Wow. But the check is that they will need a doctor who agrees if such conditions are met, assuming new laws also allow this.

Yes, and to prove it is irremediable they will likely have to show that several attempts at treatment have failed, etc., but it is one of the worms in the can that this opens up.

Expect a legal challenge by someone confined to an institution "for their own safety" that rather then prevent their suicide the institution should assist it.
 
Why would new legislation be required? The SCC has set the bar, the only question is whether depression meets it. Clearly it can be "intolerable" as it already drives people to suicide. The question really will only turn on whether it is remediable with treatment.

Everybody knows that the Supreme Court has given the government one year to change the law, just like they did for C-36. How could you have missed that point?
 
Yes, and to prove it is irremediable they will likely have to show that several attempts at treatment have failed, etc., but it is one of the worms in the can that this opens up.

Expect a legal challenge by someone confined to an institution "for their own safety" that rather then prevent their suicide the institution should assist it.

Ok but I'd like to read this myself too.
 
Ok but I'd like to read this myself too.

(c) The Feasibility of Safeguards and the Possibility of a “Slippery Slope”

[114] At trial Canada went into some detail about the risks associated with the legalization of physician-assisted dying. In its view, there are many possible sources of error and many factors that can render a patient “decisionally vulnerable” and thereby give rise to the risk that persons without a rational and considered desire for death will in fact end up dead. It points to cognitive impairment, depression or other mental illness, coercion, undue influence, psychological or emotional manipulation, systemic prejudice (against the elderly or people with disabilities), and the possibility of ambivalence or misdiagnosis as factors that may escape detection or give rise to errors in capacity assessment. Essentially, Canada argues that, given the breadth of this list, there is no reliable way to identify those who are vulnerable and those who are not. As a result, it says, a blanket prohibition is necessary.

[115] The evidence accepted by the trial judge does not support Canada’s argument. Based on the evidence regarding assessment processes in comparable end‑of-life medical decision-making in Canada, the trial judge concluded that vulnerability can be assessed on an individual basis, using the procedures that physicians apply in their assessment of informed consent and decisional capacity in the context of medical decision-making more generally. Concerns about decisional capacity and vulnerability arise in all end-of-life medical decision-making. Logically speaking, there is no reason to think that the injured, ill and disabled who have the option to refuse or to request withdrawal of lifesaving or life-sustaining treatment, or who seek palliative sedation, are less vulnerable or less susceptible to biased decision-making than those who might seek more active assistance in dying. The risks that Canada describes are already part and parcel of our medical system.

... And ...

Underlying both of these rights is a concern for the protection of individual autonomy and dignity. Liberty protects “the right to make fundamental personal choices free from state interference”: Blencoe v. British Columbia (Human Rights Commission), 2000 SCC 44, [2000] 2 S.C.R. 307, at para. 54. Security of the person encompasses “a notion of personal autonomy involving . . . control over one’s bodily integrity free from state interference” (Rodriguez, at pp. 587-88 per Sopinka J., referring to R. v. Morgentaler, [1988] 1 S.C.R. 30) and it is engaged by state interference with an individual’s physical or psychological integrity, including any state action that causes physical or serious psychological suffering (New Brunswick (Minister of Health and Community Services) v. G. (J.)

===========

In short they relied on Morgentaller, where psychological suffering created justification for abortion, and extended that principle to suicide. Note the "or" in "physical or psychological". The government raised the depression point and the court answered somewhat obliquely that the correct test was competence, and it is had to see how this ruling doesn't create a right for depressed people to suicide IF a doctor determines their is no reasonable prospect of remediation AND they are judged to express that desire competently.