Originally Posted by whitewaterguy
Mandatory snow tires are underway. Ontario government is already in discussions with insurance companies about this
Welcome to the nanny state of Ontario. Ugh.
Not even that much. A good nanny would have done a better job of thinking it through so that at least it had a net benefit.
In principle I'm against making such things mandatory by law unless that includes providing a subsidized or price controlled option to ease the burden and prevent gouging. Or at the very least low income individuals & households should be able to claim something like 30% of the expenditure on their tax return (although that doesn't help them come up with the money for the purchase). Also mandatory insurance rebates upon proof of winter tire installation.
Why? Because what;s going to end up happening is the following:
1) Being forced into complying, some people will just opt to drive the winter tires all year round, destroying the cold-weather properties of the rubber within 1 or 2 summers, making their winter tires no different from any mediocre all season with an aggressive tread - only wearing faster and with greater risk of blowing from heat stress and other safety drawbacks when driving on dry or watery pavement (which is what city people drive on 90% of the time, even in the winter...)
2) Even many of those who accept the extra expense of doing changeovers will roll the dice with safety in other ways, mostly trying to "stretch" the tires way too long. I have no doubt that there are far more accidents & damages from people driving around with tires in horrible condition as opposed to less than optimal type of tire for the season.
Phase one of improving tire related road safety is to adopt more sensible standards for what is considered a road-worthy tire, and then to enforce it.

