WW II - What Ifs?

So much is in timing. Many things would have delayed the final outcome/cost millions more lives and others could habpve changed the course

Consider if Britain had fallen - The Dunkirk becomes a disaster scenario and they are sidelined or the invasion happens and they are taken out. There is no platform for the bombing campaign and no launch pad for D-Day. German industry is untouched. If Hitler waits to take on Russia, the German machine comes up with two very key weapons - the A-Bomb and the V3 (able to hit the East Seaboard of NA). The U.S. stays out of the European war. Germany can eventually take on Russia (at either ones initiation) with their full military force and industrial machine. Is there Lend Lease? The German might may well have beaten the Soviet manpower.

Might indeed be different
 
There are other speculations as to what would have happened. A more realistic one is that having the war end within months or a year as opposed to 4 years and the resulting bitterness [and without the extra forces of the BEF it would be over fast] that the peace would probably be more a replay of 1870 with an end result being perhaps a German dominated EUish type situation. We are talkign Kaiser Bill's Germany not Hitler's Germany.



Which brings a point about alt histories. It makes a difference how things have changed to allow Moscow to fall. They might have gotten close to the outskirts but that is a big difference from surrounding and then taking a city that size. You can forget taking it by storm. Either you Alien Space Bat the hell out of the situation in which case regardless of what Stalin does Russia loses or you somehow fenegal a very close run thing in which case the Russian counter offensive results in an earlier Stalingrad.



I've seen on line debates on if the UK would have gone in without Belgium and how long it would have taken. The Brits would not be pleased with having France fall yet again in any event. OTOH getting into the war even a victorious one was a real kick in the nards for the UK. Also if entry is delayed enough it could be too late.

A more interesting question is what if Italy joined the central powers. Another front for the Allies, one less front for the CP. Could it have changed things before the Yanks got in.

Impossible. Italy's real objective was to gobble up part of Austria-Hungary when the latter collapsed. They just hung around until GB and FRance got so desperate at the stalemate on the Western Front that they were willing to sign off on whatever Italy wanted.

The more interesting question is whether the Allies could have won without the USA. The Americans' first (and last) attempt at a major offensive in the Argonne was a bad botch-up that got almost nowhere. It did however tie up German troops.

Germany was essentially beaten by GB and the Commonwealth, especially Canada and the Aussies. They shit-kicked the German army into the ground in the 100 Days Battle in September and October 1918 - arguably the finest military triumph in British history.
 
The irony is that 15-20 years after WW II ended, Germany and Japan prospered much more greatly in peace than they ever could have in war. Germans manage to live quite well in their little corner of the world (no need to kill people for more living space). Japan gets their oil and raw material by buying them rather than invading other countries and killing the inhabitants.
 
The best what-if was in the WWII special that aired this past weekend that focused on the leaders of the war and their rise to power. In the Hitler episode, he was caught dead-to-rights in no-man's land by a British corporal who could have shot him dead but let him go instead. Now, he would have been shooting an unarmed man but had he done it then arguably WWII would never have happened at all, or would have been entirely different.

Considering many academics find the 'Great Man' theory to be severely flawed, killing Hitler quite possibly wouldn't have stopped WWI. He wasn't the only anti-communist racist figure in Germany at the time and the living conditions in the 20's and 30's created more than enough anger to drive the Nazi party to prominence. German (Prussian) society still placed a huge significance on military and scientific innovation and still felt themselves as deserving of a role as a superpower that was denied to them by the Treaty of Versailles. The rest of the continent were still worried enough about Germany's capabilities that actions in Berlin were still high on the world's radar.

The exact prosecution of the war may have been different without Hitler's megalomania but him being missing from that point in history wouldn't have precluded someone equally unstable from becoming the leader.
 
...

I've seen on line debates on if the UK would have gone in without Belgium and how long it would have taken. The Brits would not be pleased with having France fall yet again in any event. OTOH getting into the war even a victorious one was a real kick in the nards for the UK. Also if entry is delayed enough it could be too late.
....

My wonder though is whether the Germans would have been able to overcome the French fortifications along the border (pretty solid territory for a defensive war) without too high a cost or whether the French focus on offense and the elan of their troops would have led to Bill celebrating in Paris.

As for Italy, their border with France is extremely poor for an invasion so it would be another bloody front favouring the defenders.
 
...
The more interesting question is whether the Allies could have won without the USA. The Americans' first (and last) attempt at a major offensive in the Argonne was a bad botch-up that got almost nowhere. It did however tie up German troops.....

I think that the Ameris impact was as a threat that forced Germany to the peace table, not their actual actions. My guess is that the result would still be the same but Germany may have been able to negotiate better terms. Of course by that time the French and Brits were out for blood and felt the best way to stop future conflict was to neuter Germany so the end result would have been us celebrating victory on Nov. 11 1920 instead of 1918 with a lot more crosses in the fields of Flanders.
 
The irony is that 15-20 years after WW II ended, Germany and Japan prospered much more greatly in peace than they ever could have in war. Germans manage to live quite well in their little corner of the world (no need to kill people for more living space). Japan gets their oil and raw material by buying them rather than invading other countries and killing the inhabitants.

Yet they both have become peaceful participants in world society instead of the over-lordship their prewar cultures expected.
 
Considering many academics find the 'Great Man' theory to be severely flawed, killing Hitler quite possibly wouldn't have stopped WWI. He wasn't the only anti-communist racist figure in Germany at the time and the living conditions in the 20's and 30's created more than enough anger to drive the Nazi party to prominence. German (Prussian) society still placed a huge significance on military and scientific innovation and still felt themselves as deserving of a role as a superpower that was denied to them by the Treaty of Versailles. The rest of the continent were still worried enough about Germany's capabilities that actions in Berlin were still high on the world's radar.

The exact prosecution of the war may have been different without Hitler's megalomania but him being missing from that point in history wouldn't have precluded someone equally unstable from becoming the leader.

True enough. But you could have had someone who was "all talk, no action" and who did nothing. Instead, we got Hitler who never had a crazy-ass theory involving mass destruction that he didn't like so much he had to act it out in real life.
 
There are other speculations as to what would have happened. A more realistic one is that having the war end within months or a year as opposed to 4 years and the resulting bitterness [and without the extra forces of the BEF it would be over fast] that the peace would probably be more a replay of 1870 with an end result being perhaps a German dominated EUish type situation. We are talking Kaiser Bill's Germany not Hitler's Germany.

The recent Max Hastings book about 1914 makes the point that the British were burned out and didn't really participate in the Battle of the Marne 1914. They contributed a small fraction of what the French did and only really got going in 1916. The French might still have held the Germans.

Academic anyway. The Germans were obsessed with the Schlieffen Plan which necessarily involved attacking through Belgium. That was why they were prepared to risk British intervention. They had no other plan to beat France.
 
... They had no other plan to beat France.

They likely wouldn't have had to. If their focus was on Russia and their resources then all they had to do was hold off France (who seemed to have poor military leadership at the start). France on their own facing a Germany (and the Hapsburgs) that already conquered and made peace with Russia would likely have agreed to a neutral peace fairly quickly.
 
They likely wouldn't have had to. If their focus was on Russia and their resources then all they had to do was hold off France (who seemed to have poor military leadership at the start). France on their own facing a Germany (and the Hapsburgs) that already conquered and made peace with Russia would likely have agreed to a neutral peace fairly quickly.

No. The deal was that they figured they had to beat France first because Russia was so large and populous that it would take a lot of work to defeat it.

Russia's population in 1914 was greater than its population today - 140,000,000. By comparison, the 1914 population of the USA was 90,000,000 and IIRC that of GB was 40,000,000. Russia was relatively immense. And in 1914, you WALKED when you were maneuvering. There were no such things as motorized infantry and panzers.

The whole concept of a war against the Entente only works if you kill the smaller enemy quickly and then take a few years to concentrate all your resources against the bigger enemy and kill it.
 
Even if Hitler was killed in the famous attempt on his life the war would have gone on. Too many on the Eastern Front were guilty of grievous war crimes and had no choice in there minds but to continue. They had heard for years propaganda about the evils of Slavic Communism and after the war crimes they had committed felt they had to continue or face the consequences. Why else did they fight on in the rubble of Berlin?
 
Russia's population in 1914 was greater than its population today - 140,000,000.
This is a starting statistic. I heard that Russia lost 20-28 million people in WW II and perhaps another 20 million to Stalin purges but one would have thought that they would have replaced those lost souls in the 70 years since 1945.
 
Even if Hitler was killed in the famous attempt on his life the war would have gone on. Too many on the Eastern Front were guilty of grievous war crimes and had no choice in there minds but to continue. They had heard for years propaganda about the evils of Slavic Communism and after the war crimes they had committed felt they had to continue or face the consequences. Why else did they fight on in the rubble of Berlin?

One never knows, apparently some German politicians and officers wanted to negotiate a separate peace with the Western allies as early as 1943. BTW: If Hitler had not killed Rommel the Nazi resistance on the Western Front would have been much more fierce. On the other hand, Rommel (a realist) might have negotiated a surrender earlier than May 1945.

Question: Why did Hess fly into Great Britain during WW II? Was it to try and negotiate a peace treaty?

Edit P.S. "On 10 May 1941 he undertook a solo flight to Scotland, where he hoped to arrange peace talks with the Duke of Hamilton, who he believed was prominent in opposition to the British government" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rudolf_Hess
 
Last edited:
And what would Germany winning the war actually have entailed? Each year as Remembrance Day approaches, you hear such things as "we would be speaking German right now if not for those who fought and died". Would we really? Could Germany have actually taken over North America? I can't see how that could have happened. Would the Americans have ever walked away from Europe?

We would be driving MBs, VWs, Porsches and maybe BMWs?
 
One never knows, apparently some German politicians and officers wanted to negotiate a separate peace with the Western allies as early as 1943. BTW: If Hitler had not killed Rommel the Nazi resistance on the Western Front would have been much more fierce. On the other hand, Rommel (a realist) might have negotiated a surrender earlier than May 1945.

Question: Why did Hess fly into Great Britain during WW II? Was it to try and negotiate a peace treaty?

Fucking Hitler forced Rommel to commit suicide. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erwin_Rommel (I forgot about that).

Rommel never committed war crimes. Was one of the best tank commanders in history.

Hitler was a fucking mad man.
 
Rommel never committed war crimes. Was one of the best tank commanders in history.
The only reason Rommel lost in North Africa was because he was out manned and out gunned. I would place General Patton up there with Rommel. especially since the Americans were fighting with those lousy Sherman tanks. Maybe there is a Russian tank commander who is also Rommel's equal but the Russians had the superior T-34 tanks which gave them an advantage.
 
The only reason Rommel lost in North Africa was because he was out manned and out gunned. I would place General Patton up there with Rommel. especially since the Americans were fighting with those lousy Sherman tanks. Maybe there is a Russian tank commander who is also Rommel's equal but the Russians had the superior T-34 tanks which gave them an advantage.

Patton had one big moment - when he raced across France in 3 weeks in August 44 because the German army had been trapped at Falaise and didn't exist anymore. Otherwise, the guy was all mouth.

Tons of German and Russian tank generals did way more fighting against way tougher opposition.
 
Patton had one big moment - when he raced across France in 3 weeks in August 44 because the German army had been trapped at Falaise and didn't exist anymore. Otherwise, the guy was all mouth.

Tons of German and Russian tank generals did way more fighting against way tougher opposition.

So that scene in Patton (starring George C. Scott) where a German officer refers to him as 'an anachronism', in reference to Julius Caesar, is an exaggeration?
 
I read Philip K. Dick's The Man in the High Castle, a novel about what would have happened if the Axis has won WWII

Being honest, I'm not really a fan of Dick's novels, I prefer his short stories, but if you want to read something that examines a "What if ...?" scenario, I recommend giving it a read.