WW II - What Ifs?

Here is another "what if". What if bad weather delayed the Normany landings for another 2-3 days. What if the "General Patton" ruse did not work and Hitler did not concentrate his troops around Calais?

BTW: Despite Stalin's complaints about the allies delay in landing in Europe, the very threat of such a landing tied up 1 million German soldiers in the west that might have been freed to the eastern front.

I doubt it would have had much impact in the long run. A few months wouldn't have made enough difference on the Eastern Front as the Soviets had essentially pushed the Germans back to their border by then (and allied troops were halfway up Italy).
 
I agree that is an interesting question because it is based on a simple decision that could easily have been different.

I read a WWI speculative fiction based on Germany not invading through Belgium. Without that act, the Brits might not have declared war (which would mean no unrestricted naval campaign which would likely have kept the US out of it). Germany and allies vs. France and an already crumbling Russia wouldn't have been as long a war.

The biggest mistake of the 20th century was the British and American intervention in the German-French conflict. Not only millions of people died in a pointless conflict, but above all, it caused the second world war. Unnecessary and downright foolish. Something we should remember during upcoming Nov.11 observances.
 
The biggest mistake of the 20th century was the British and American intervention in the German-French conflict. Not only millions of people died in a pointless conflict, but above all, it caused the second world war. Unnecessary and downright foolish. Something we should remember during upcoming Nov.11 observances.
But as Sir Max Hastings, among other Historians have pointed out, what would likely have happened would have been an even more powerful Germany coming after a British Empire without allies less than a decade later.
 
The biggest mistake of the 20th century was the British and American intervention in the German-French conflict. Not only millions of people died in a pointless conflict, but above all, it caused the second world war. Unnecessary and downright foolish. Something we should remember during upcoming Nov.11 observances.

The speculation of the book was that continued German expansion (if they had won WWI) would still eventually result in a larger war. To add, England (among others) had guaranteed Belgium's security and was bound by convention to act once Germany invaded.

Now if the Peace of Paris wasn't so hard on Germany then WWII would have been less likely but recession, the fall of Monarchy, nationalism, and emerging political philosophies may have made it inevitable.
 
The battles on the Eastern Front were massive. A unit of the Nazi Army actually got to within 5 miles of Moscow. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Moscow

However, Moscow, Leningrad and Stalingrad held and the tide turned. If Moscow had fell, Stalin might have had to sue for peace with Germany and WW II would have have looked much different.
 
From my university history class. . What if Japan doesn't attack Pearl harbour. She wants till Germans are matching accross USSR. When USSR moves war industry to Ural mountains Japan attacks USSR from the east. Bad news for mother Russia.
What of Rommel et al r successful at assassinating Hitler.
 
But as Sir Max Hastings, among other Historians have pointed out, what would likely have happened would have been an even more powerful Germany coming after a British Empire without allies less than a decade later.
Hastings is wrong because the revolution in Russia still would had happened providing a continental counter force to Germany. Ultimately, the 1870 defeat of France showed that the Imperial Germany was more than willing to deal pragmatically with weaker nations. Worth noting that the Habsburgs, war or no war, were in a state of decomposition. The inevitable break up of the Habsburg Empire would had kept Germany busy for decades in the central Europe and with Russia breathing down their necks. Most importantly, the social democratic pressure would, most likely, led to weakening of the Junker class and its colonial aspirations. The age of empires was mostly dead by the beginning of 20th century. Self determination, nationalism and socialism were the forces driving the events-something the leaders of the European powers failed to notice. The WWI was a war about nothing, that solved nothing, that led to even bigger tragedy.
 
Hastings is wrong because the revolution in Russia still would had happened providing a continental counter force to Germany. Ultimately, the 1870 defeat of France showed that the Imperial Germany was more than willing to deal pragmatically with weaker nations. Worth noting that the Habsburgs, war or no war, were in a state of decomposition. The inevitable break up of the Habsburg Empire would had kept Germany busy for decades in the central Europe and with Russia breathing down their necks. Most importantly, the social democratic pressure would, most likely, led to weakening of the Junker class and its colonial aspirations. The age of empires was mostly dead by the beginning of 20th century. Self determination, nationalism and socialism were the forces driving the events-something the leaders of the European powers failed to notice. The WWI was a war about nothing, that solved nothing, that led to even bigger tragedy.

Actually, Germany was more afraid of Russia than France. France was an inconvenience that had allied itself with Russia, the real enemy. The Schlieffen Plan postulates defeating France within a couple of months and then uniting with Austria-Hungary to come after Russia and kill it.
 
From my university history class. . What if Japan doesn't attack Pearl harbour. She wants till Germans are matching accross USSR. When USSR moves war industry to Ural mountains Japan attacks USSR from the east. Bad news for mother Russia.
What of Rommel et al r successful at assassinating Hitler.

Actually, Japan and Russia carefully kept away from war until Japan collapsed in 45 and the Russians piled on to seize Manchuria. USSR had badly shit-beaten Japan in Manchuria in 37 and the Japanese were scared shitless of USSR. While the Soviets had difficulty competing with Germany, they were far more advanced militarily than Japan. Japan's real interest was seizing Indonesia for the oil and other raw materials and that meant fighting the USA. So Pearl was inevitable.

I recently learned that Japan refrained from attacking US shipping carrying lend-lease to USSR via Vladivostok. The only stipulation was that those ships flew the Hammer and Sickle as a flag of convenience. The ships would pass within a hundred miles of so of Japan. Regularly.
 
The battles on the Eastern Front were massive. A unit of the Nazi Army actually got to within 5 miles of Moscow. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Moscow

However, Moscow, Leningrad and Stalingrad held and the tide turned. If Moscow had fell, Stalin might have had to sue for peace with Germany and WW II would have have looked much different.

I think that Stalin realized at that point that Hitler was waging a war of extermination against all Slavs and that peace was not an option.
 
Here is another "what if". What if bad weather delayed the Normany landings for another 2-3 days. What if the "General Patton" ruse did not work and Hitler did not concentrate his troops around Calais?

BTW: Despite Stalin's complaints about the allies delay in landing in Europe, the very threat of such a landing tied up 1 million German soldiers in the west that might have been freed to the eastern front.

The Normandy landings would have failed. Or more likely, the Allies would have found out about the troop transfers via Ultra and simply relocated the landings to Calais.

Hitler was toast anyway. In late June and early July, the Soviets smashed 2 of the 4 German Army Groups on the Eastern Front - Army Group Centre and Army Group South Ukraine - and pocketed Army Group North on the Kurland Peninsula. That basically takes out of play 75% of the German troops in the East. The Germans had nothing left to fight with in Eastern Europe and the last year or so was simply the Soviets taking a deep breath and then invading Germay.
 
Friser's theory about France 1940 is that the Germans could have ended the war and forced Britain to sue for peace if they had smashed forward towards Dunkirk.

Friser's account says that Allies were led to expect another Schlieffen Plan with a wide right hook through the Low Countries along the North Sea Coast. As a result, the French C-in-C, Gamelin reinforced the Allied left wing along the sea to the point of absurdity and pushed it forward aggressively into Belgium to stop the anticipated German offensive dead in its tracks. It was a hopelessly wrong move.

The German plan - conceived by Von Manstein and Guderian - involved a feint along the coastal sectors with relatively weak forces. As the Allied army was held back at the Belgian border until the actual invasion by request of the king of Belgium, they would not initially realize how weak the Germans were in that sector. When the Allies over-committed along the North Sea areas, the main German blow would come in the centre of the entire front in the Ardennes. This would hit almost no opposition, as the Allies had switched all their mobile forces to the North Sea sector. The Germans would race west to the Channel Ports and cut the Allies off in a huge pocket along the North Sea.

Pretty much what happened. The Allies threw their attack along the North Sea coast into a panic reverse when they realized that they had been played and tried to pull everything into a position to block the German main offensive. But it was hopeless. The panzers were cruising forward against almost no opposition and the Allies were in chaos. The German could have seized Dunkirk and the Channel ports before the Allies could even get there. However, a split in opinion between the leading German generals led to von Rundstedt ordering a halt because he was worried about flank attacks (which never materialized). Hitler backed von Rundstedt and the Germans held off until the British army and many French troops had reached Dunkirk, fortified it and had been taken off the beach.

The Belgian and French armies lost about 500,000 guys trapped in the pocket and unable to be evacuated. That compares with the big Eastern Front pockets, like Kiev and it essentially ended the 1940 campaign.

Had the Germans not halted, the British army would have been destroyed too. As this was Britian's only trained force, Britain would have been forced to sue for peace.
 
The best what-if was in the WWII special that aired this past weekend that focused on the leaders of the war and their rise to power. In the Hitler episode, he was caught dead-to-rights in no-man's land by a British corporal who could have shot him dead but let him go instead. Now, he would have been shooting an unarmed man but had he done it then arguably WWII would never have happened at all, or would have been entirely different.
 
Had the Germans not halted, the British army would have been destroyed too. As this was Britian's only trained force, Britain would have been forced to sue for peace.
This would have allowed Germany to concentrate all its forces on Russia. Would Russia still have been able to defeat Nazi Germany in that scenario?
 
The best what-if was in the WWII special that aired this past weekend that focused on the leaders of the war and their rise to power. In the Hitler episode, he was caught dead-to-rights in no-man's land by a British corporal who could have shot him dead but let him go instead. Now, he would have been shooting an unarmed man but had he done it then arguably WWII would never have happened at all, or would have been entirely different.

My current take is that Germany would have swung hard right politically in the late 20's anyway due to the trauma of losing WW1, the Kaiser's abdication, the inflation crisis, the Red Revolutions in Bavaria and Berlin and the humiliation of the Treaty of Versailles. So some kind of authoritarian regime is probably a given. The unpredictable element is Hitler. The dictator who eventually took power could have been a blustering buffoon like Mussolini, a traditionalist like Franco or pretty much anything else. Hitler's bizarre agenda for conquering Eastern Europe and colonizing it pretty much guaranteed a large war with the USSR and also with France and GB who would not allow an expansionist Germany to simply gobble up other countries.
 
This would have allowed Germany to concentrate all its forces on Russia. Would Russia still have been able to defeat Nazi Germany in that scenario?

I don't think - off hand - that Germany kept a large garrison in the West until about 1943. So it's possible that the removal of GB as an adversary may not have affected the balance of power. However, it may well have affected if the USA could have practically projected power into Europe without a staging post in the UK. There is also the question of whether GB would not have reneged on the peace deal and re opened hostilities as soon as Hitler invaded the USSR and then declared war on the USA. While GB would not have had much of an army, it would still have the RAF and RN to keep it safe from invasion. And a Germany involved in Russia could not have attempted to invade the UK in any event.
 
Japan's real interest was seizing Indonesia for the oil and other raw materials and that meant fighting the USA. So Pearl was inevitable.
I think Japan was interested in Indonesian oil only after the American oil embargo. The conflict with the U.S. was more likely due to Japan needing a base in the Philippines for further expansion in Asia. At that time, the Philippines was an American Protectorate.

Question: Why did Japan feel they needed further expansion in Asia? At the time they already occupied Korea, Manchuria and most of the north eastern coast of China.
 
I think Japan was interested in Indonesian oil only after the American oil embargo. The conflict with the U.S. was more likely due to Japan needing a base in the Philippines for further expansion in Asia. At that time, the Philippines was an American Protectorate.

Question: Why did Japan feel they needed further expansion in Asia? At the time they already occupied Korea, Manchuria and most of the north eastern coast of China.

They wanted to control the sources of strategic raw materials like rubber (Malaya) and oil (Indonesia).
 
"The leaders then turned to the conditions under which the Western Allies would open a new front by invading northern France (Operation Overlord), as Stalin had pressed them to do since 1941. Up to this point Churchill had advocated the expansion of joint operations of British, American, and Commonwealth forces in the Mediterranean, with an eye to bolstering British interests in the region. Roosevelt insisted that Operation Overlord should go forward, however, and the leaders agreed it would be commenced by May 1944; Stalin agreed to support it by launching a concurrent major offensive on Germany's eastern front to divert German forces from northern France.[SUP][5]"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tehran_Conference

I think Stalin threatened a separate peace with the Nazis if the Allies had not agreed to open a second front in western Europe by May 1944.[/SUP]