Those who said here that the legal action was misguided have been proved correct. Even Alan Young has said that in retrospect it was poorly conceived.
I'm not concerned at all. I am an observer in all this. But if you think that this bill won't kill your business you are one ignorant woman. The general public will consider it dangerous to see escorts because they will fear arrest. It's simple. As your old clients naturally disappear new ones won't be replacing them. Clients do not want to be arrested. Today I would say virtually no one fears that in Canada. After the bill everyone will. That's the intention of this Bill and if it doesn't get challenged constitutionally that will be the effect on this industry.
Laugh away Ms. Femme. You're right. The bill won't kill the sex trade. It will just decimate it from its current size to probably 1/4 of it.
:clap2:
incidentally, incalls are now legal, as long as they're far from children.
living off the avails is also now legal, as long as there is no exploitation.
indeed an improvement for me!! I'm sorry that you guys are being criminalized I really am, but I'm happy that my future is safer.
Not rude. Ignorant, misinformed and a little sexist.
Again, you're right. And when those urges overtake guess where those men will go?
Border towns.
Laugh away Ms. Femme. You're right. The bill won't kill the sex trade. It will just decimate it from its current size to probably 1/4 of it.
Yup. The nature of my profession means a criminal record (or even an arrest record, as that would very likely mean I couldn't travel south of the border) would be a serious career limiting move, if I could find work at all.Anyone who thinks men (who have something to lose) will just casually show up to break the law, risk imprisonment and public humiliation is out to lunch.
As someone who has invested a lot of time and money and effort in building up my career and continue to do so, why would I risk millions in future income to break the law? There's a lot of people who will make the same judgement call.
I find the government's actions to be quite surprising. The desire for physical companionship is one of the strongest human urges, perhaps second only to the need to react to hunger. People will go to great lengths to find companionship and people will also take great risks. From Cleopatra to Clinton, we see examples through history of powerful people (men and women) with much to lose pursuing physical companionship. From Elliot Spitzer to Barney Frank, we see examples of the same among government officials, among both straight and gay people. It is simply an undeniable expression of humanity.
Another very strong urge humans have is the urge to intoxicate. Whether it is shamans in far flung villages taking hallucinogens or diners enjoying wine at Canoe, people self medicate. Attempts to prohibit the expression of such urges has been a colossal waste of money and other resources ... witness Prohibition and the War on Drugs in the US.
Laws such as Prohibition or the upcoming C-36 simply create more criminals by defining normal human behavior as criminal.
Alcohol use has a huge cost on society - deaths from drunk driving, liver disease, incidence of date rape on university campuses, violence, workplace absenteeism, the list goes on an on and the impact and costs are staggering. The social cost is far higher than that of prostitution, but it has been accepted. Just as there is no reasonable way to prevent people from drinking, there is no reasonable way to prevent people from seeking companionship in exchange for pay.
Canada seemed to have had a very sensible and pragmatic take on sex services, but C-36 seems like a huge step backwards. Providers will be more at risk than before, and no rational person could think that it will eliminate the sex trade. It is called the worlds oldest profession for a reason.
Laws against trafficking or underage providers and patrons make a lot of sense. Just like laws against underage drinking or driving while intoxicated.
Perhaps even more surprising than the bill is the fact that it is coming from a "conservative" government. True conservative principles are about less government intrusion into the private lives of citizens and smaller government in general. Imposing ones "morals" on others is the type of conservatism that is more akin to the Taliban's approach to conservatism.
If being a client is a crime, then all your clients will be criminals.indeed an improvement for me!! I'm sorry that you guys are being criminalized I really am, but I'm happy that my future is safer.
I was responding to a comment about everybody being at risk under the old regime. Were you? Are you now?
Are you so sure you should accuse me of putting my interests before the "vulnerable"? Let's whip it out and bring the ruler!
This is a pyrrhic victory, at best, for you, I think..
Understood, but many SPs have expressed concern that criminalization will only serve to expose sex workers to a lower strata of client, while inducing the 'safer' client (i.e professionals who have something to lose) out of the hobby for fear of arrest and conviction.I'm not much good to anyone dead or in jail, am I?
Listen, every time I take a new client, I take a risk. EVERY FUCKING TIME. I could end up raped, robbed, assaulted or dead.
NOT YOU.
EVERY TIME you book you can find out IN ADVANCE with a fair amount of certainty, if that lady is gonna rape you, kill you or rob you. EVERY FUCKING TIME.
NOT ME.
SAFETY is kinda a big deal for us.... is that clear enough for you yet?
I'd say this new law is a pyrrhic victory for the prohibitionists. The supply of sex work is inexhaustible, but they can't keep passing the same unconstitutional law over and over again. The Bedford decision seriously reduced their legal possibilities. When this one is thrown out there is nothing left they can try. Decriminalization is inevitable. It's just a big disappointment to have to wait for a few more years.
I'm not much good to anyone dead or in jail, am I?
Listen, every time I take a new client, I take a risk. EVERY FUCKING TIME. I could end up raped, robbed, assaulted or dead.
NOT YOU.
EVERY TIME you book you can find out IN ADVANCE with a fair amount of certainty, if that lady is gonna rape you, kill you or rob you. EVERY FUCKING TIME.
NOT ME.
SAFETY is kinda a big deal for us.... is that clear enough for you yet? quit your blubbering and retire already.