Puritan Harper CONS to "fast track" prostitution bill

I don't know that the sheer volume of one vs the other is the main issue here. The fact that there are more clients than providers doesn't mean the laws should criminalize us instead of them, that's silly.

I get what you're saying, I do. However, there's a much bigger picture, you're only considering you're unique circumstances.

There were people getting busted, and there were also people taking major safety risks, it just wasn't often the client of an established incall provider ....like yourself, for example.

I believe you are assuming the enforcement of the bill will actually happen as the Conservatives say. But honestly, the enforcement will be and always will be driven by nuisance complaints. If you are operating in a condo and people complain, they will find a way to get you to leave. Going after the John's isn't the best way to make that happen. Harassing you however, will accomplish this. Nothing is going to change, providers will still be targeted. Large John sweeps will be too resource intensive and ineffective to do.
 
what do you mean "already" the law has been in effect for the last 15 years in Sweden, it's not like it was passed yesterday.
It is my understanding that there is a lot of travel to other parts of Europe where the laws are different.
 
It just kind of puzzles me how some prostitutes actually think this law will make their lives easier. I've met a few girls who said they have nothing to worry about because they are the victims and the John's are the only ones who are fucked. This kind of thinking is just what the conservatives want. The Justice Minister has already stated that the intent is to make prostitution illegal and to irradiate prostitution. As a worker in the sex trade, if you know this is the direction the government is taking, I would assume the law should be perceived as a bad thing.

If you are in an industry where your service can't legally be bought, guess what? Things aren't aren't going to be great... If a similar law was enacted on any other publicly traded company, their stock would hit zero pretty fast. Girls also don't realize, if a John gets busted, guess who needs to testify in court to get a conviction? Do girls want to be subpoenaed to court to testify? Police know that girls will need to speak up to get the Johns. If they decide they want to crack down, they will find many ways to coerce the girl to confess without using the law. Finding drugs, family services, telling the landlord, etc. could all be used to gain cooperation. I think girls are actually the real losers of this bill. I and many others will just take extended vacations to Germany where I can do whatever I want.
 
So will massage parlours like SRM and AGS be effectively shut down because of this? I see 'masterbation at massage parlours and lap dances' are considered a sexual service.

Air dances as well? AIR DANCES FFS???!!!
 
So will massage parlours like SRM and AGS be effectively shut down because of this? I see 'masterbation at massage parlours and lap dances' are considered a sexual service.

Air dances as well? AIR DANCES FFS???!!!

Actually watching webcams is also illegal. Doubt they will enforce though. Pretty soon porn will be illegal and staring at women will also be.
 
So will massage parlours like SRM and AGS be effectively shut down because of this? I see 'masterbation at massage parlours and lap dances' are considered a sexual service.

Air dances as well? AIR DANCES FFS???!!!

That's precisely the concern. Sexual service is not defined in the Bill (and MacKay has expressly refused to clarify the term). However, the backgrounder to the bill refers to MPs as an intended target of the legislation. Im sure we can all agree that MPs provide service of a sexual nature, and that some are indeed brothels in the biblical sense of the word. But, cities like Toronto have taken a pragmatic approach. MPs are allowed as a social policy matter in order to get sex off the streets. I have no visibility whether this leeway will continue to exist under the new legislation.
 
I don't know that the sheer volume of one vs the other is the main issue here. The fact that there are more clients than providers doesn't mean the laws should criminalize us instead of them, that's silly.

I get what you're saying, I do. However, there's a much bigger picture, you're only considering you're unique circumstances.

There were people getting busted, and there were also people taking major safety risks, it just wasn't often the client of an established incall provider ....like yourself, for example.

Aside from focusing on one point out of several, what you're really trying to say is that you agree with me ;) LOL

The bigger picture is that this industry encompasses a broad spectrum of participants and experiences. C-36 paints us all with the same brush, and that brush has been dipped in the well of the worst parts of this industry.
 
That's precisely the concern. Sexual service is not defined in the Bill (and MacKay has expressly refused to clarify the term). However, the backgrounder to the bill refers to MPs as an intended target of the legislation. Im sure we can all agree that MPs provide service of a sexual nature, and that some are indeed brothels in the biblical sense of the word. But, cities like Toronto have taken a pragmatic approach. MPs are allowed as a social policy matter in order to get sex off the streets. I have no visibility whether this leeway will continue to exist under the new legislation.

My understanding is that precedent in other law cases has already declared what sexual services is considered to be so there is no need to define it in the bill.

and I have to agree with others about the "my cock is happy" comment. Honestly, how do you think it would fly if ladies said now that their pussy will be on easy street laughing all the way to the bank since they can't get busted anymore? A little selfish to be thinking only about you.

 
Hmmm, who was at risk? Everybody, you say? My cock and many others were just fine doing our thing and not worry about getting arrested before, as were many ladies who plied their trade within the grey zone.

Shed light, yes. Regulated and exit programs, yes. None of those are achieved through through a court challenge of existing law. We need social policy change for that, not new laws.

Very selfish comment. Fuck the vulnerable. As long as your cock is happy, that's all that matters right?

Barf!
 
My understanding is that precedent in other law cases has already declared what sexual services is considered to be so there is no need to define it in the bill.


If that's the case, we're done like dinner. The courts have defined it very broadly. It doesn't require release. MPs count. I gotta stock up on Jergens.
 
If that's the case, we're done like dinner. The courts have defined it very broadly. It doesn't require release. MPs count. I gotta stock up on Jergens.

Apparently no. Sexual services is defined enough that dances are not sexual services, massage is not, web cam is not, porn is not, etc. Blow jobs, intercourse etc is. This has been established already.
 
Very selfish comment. Fuck the vulnerable. As long as your cock is happy, that's all that matters right?

Barf!


Did you read the rest of my sentence or did you just want to jump on the half-cocked train today?

btw, I was responding to a comment about everybody being at risk under the old regime. Were you? Are you now?

Are you so sure you should accuse me of putting my interests before the "vulnerable"? Let's whip it out and bring the ruler!
 
That's precisely the concern. Sexual service is not defined in the Bill (and MacKay has expressly refused to clarify the term). However, the backgrounder to the bill refers to MPs as an intended target of the legislation. Im sure we can all agree that MPs provide service of a sexual nature, and that some are indeed brothels in the biblical sense of the word. But, cities like Toronto have taken a pragmatic approach. MPs are allowed as a social policy matter in order to get sex off the streets. I have no visibility whether this leeway will continue to exist under the new legislation.

A sexual service is any activity provided for the sexual gratification of the client, including jerking yourself off while having a lapdance, even if she never makes physical contact with you.
 
So if I go full turgid during my monthly ball waxing.... dammit.

Terb used to be an amusing distraction. Now it's like hanging out at the Olivia Chow election headquarters....hopeless.
 
incidentally, incalls are now legal, as long as they're far from children.

living off the avails is also now legal, as long as there is no exploitation.

indeed an improvement for me!! I'm sorry that you guys are being criminalized I really am, but I'm happy that my future is safer.
But clients will be less likely to go to your nice, well-staffed incall. They will want to be the ones controlling the location to avoid police surveillance. Also, you ARE committing a crime; you just have an immunity from prosecution. Not from police harassment, surveillance, etc.

My point is that for the world in which we live, the old system was ok (not good, but livable as long as you didn't frequent human trafficking joints).
The old laws were ''OK'' because they were not enforced. It will be the same with new laws. It's almost ''legalized'' in a sense. Local LE and authorities set the terms and so long as we don't bother anyone we are left alone.
 
Did you read the rest of my sentence or did you just want to jump on the half-cocked train today?

btw, I was responding to a comment about everybody being at risk under the old regime. Were you? Are you now?

Are you so sure you should accuse me of putting my interests before the "vulnerable"? Let's whip it out and bring the ruler!

Technically, I was as vulnerable as every other sex worker to the same unconstitutional laws that were struck down for good reason.

Your last paragraph...are u implying I put my interests before the "vulnerable"? as in Peter MacKay's definition? If that's the case then I too am of no right mind to even know what I'm doing, being a victim & unable to consent & all. *rolling my eyes*

I've never met a non-consensual sex worker. I'm part of the consensual side.

Sorry TP, ur barking up the wrong table legs.

I get your point, but your choice of words was tacky.