The Evidence: MH 017

http://news.ca.msn.com/top-stories/...report-says-jet-struck-by-high-energy-objects

Malaysia Airlines Flight MH17 was likely struck by multiple "high-energy objects from outside the aircraft," causing it to break up over eastern Ukraine, a preliminary report into the deadly aviation disaster concluded Tuesday.

The report by the Dutch Safety Board stopped short of saying the Boeing 777 was shot down by a missile, but its findings appear to point to that conclusion. It also did not say who might have been responsible.

The Boeing 777 suddenly plunged out of the sky July 17 over territory held by pro-Russian rebels in Ukraine, killing all 298 passengers and crew on board.

"The damage observed in the forward section of the aircraft appears to indicate that the aircraft was penetrated by a large number of high-energy objects from outside the aircraft," the report said. "It is likely that this damage resulted in a loss of structural integrity of the aircraft, leading to an in-flight break up."

The board is leading the international investigation into the cause of the disaster. Its full report is expected within a year of the crash.

"The initial results of the investigation point toward an external cause of the MH17 crash," the board's chairman, Tjibbe Joustra, said in a statement. "More research will be necessary to determine the cause with greater precision. The Safety Board believes that additional evidence will become available for investigation in the period ahead."

Christopher Yates, an aviation safety specialist at Yates Consulting, told the AP the report "is extremely consistent with damage from a missile for the simple reason there are penetration marks.

"It must have been moving at very high velocity to create the damage," he said. "It could only be a missile of the type that would reach the altitude that would have struck the aircraft, potentially a Buk missile."

He said the report gave no indication whether the missile had been fired from the ground or from another aircraft, but it likely came from the ground as there were no military aircraft known to have been flying at the time. The missile could not have been shoulder-fired because it would not have reached the necessary altitude, he added.
 
New evidence has been found that shows the Buk missile system that was used to shoot down MH17 on the 17th of July came from Russia, and was most likely operated by Russian soldiers. Using videos posted by locals in Russia’s Belgorod region back in June it has been possible to identify the Buk missile launcher seen in Ukraine on July 17th as part of a convoy of Buk missile launchers. It has also been possible to identify the Russian brigade the Buk is likely to have belonged to, and who may have operated the Buk missile launcher when it was in Ukraine.

The Buk launcher can be identified because of a number of features, including white markings on the left side side of its chassis, and what looks like the traces of a number that has been painted over. Here is a comparison of the Buk seen in previously unpublicised video taken in Russia on the 23rd of June with a well known image from Paris Match, which shows a Buk in Donetsk at 9am on July the 17th.
https://bellingcat.com/news/uk-and-...7-inside-russia-controlled-by-russian-troops/

Ukrainian article today claims to have located the Buk which killed MH 017 back in Russia.
 
??? Uh, no. The purpose of "shrapnel" is to maximize the opportunities to destroy an enemy target by maximizing the number of projectiles hitting that target. Good grief.

Do you know that your statement does not contradict mine, don't you? ;)
 
I was looking at the photos again, and what stands out to me is the pockmarked areas between the supposed "bullet holes". They are in similar size and shape to some of the holes, and are very densely packed. Certainly not the kind of thing you'd get from a cannon, but looks very much like shrapnel. Also, the closer I look, the more I don't see two-directional bulletholes. All the regular holes of about the same size appear to be going in, and the larger, irregularly shapes ones are the only ones that seem to be "going out". Makes me more and more convinced the "exit holes" are exactly that: shrapnel coming back out, whether from the warhead itself or bits of internal aircraft components being propelled out by explosions, even the liquified aluminum could create a similar pattern as it "blows" out the fuselage coverage (which is much, MUCH weaker than the pressure vessel on the other side).
 
I am going to assume the fuel tanks in the airliner were wing mounted and adjacent to the engines. You would get a flame up or an explosion taking off the wing with lots of burn scarring.

And stalking the plane and killing it at close range with prolonged gunfire is a ridiculous procedure when you could stand of at a km with a modern guided missile, get your lock on and a 100% probability kill in a second or two.


I thought all passenger jets had a bigger tank at the bottom of the fuselage?

If given a choice, yes, a fighter aircraft would use an air-to-air missile.

What is the range of anti-aircraft machine guns (if they still use them) or anti-aircraft cannons?
 
I'm going to take a guess at this. 20mm cannon hit on the stabilizer with debris spatter striking the rear fuselage. Or else cannon hit on the stabilizer and shrapnel from an explosive round, possibly missile to fuselage - i.e 2 different hits.

Yeah, it looks more like two separate hits (I made a mistake thinking it was a regular wing - you're right, it's a stabilizer).
 
I thought all passenger jets had a bigger tank at the bottom of the fuselage?

If given a choice, yes, a fighter aircraft would use an air-to-air missile.

What is the range of anti-aircraft machine guns (if they still use them) or anti-aircraft cannons?

Re the location of the fuel tanks, you may well be correct. I am just guessing at some of this stuff.

Aircraft mounted machine guns are effective from about 500 yards. Clearly the closer you get, the moe accurate you're going to be. Theoretically, they could hit from 1,000 yards, but aim would be well off.

Penetration is the issue. Everyone started using at least 20mm autocannons from the mid 50's as .50 cals just do not do much damage. I know that by the 60's, USAF fighter pilots were complaining that they had no guns on their fighters, as the AF had transitioned to an all missile armament for its aircraft. I am guessing that that is still the case and that guns are only used by ground attack planes for strafing.
 
Re the location of the fuel tanks, you may well be correct. I am just guessing at some of this stuff.

Aircraft mounted machine guns are effective from about 500 yards. Clearly the closer you get, the moe accurate you're going to be. Theoretically, they could hit from 1,000 yards, but aim would be well off.

Penetration is the issue. Everyone started using at least 20mm autocannons from the mid 50's as .50 cals just do not do much damage. I know that by the 60's, USAF fighter pilots were complaining that they had no guns on their fighters, as the AF had transitioned to an all missile armament for its aircraft. I am guessing that that is still the case and that guns are only used by ground attack planes for strafing.


Okay great. I was talking about anti-aircraft batteries from the ground (machine guns or cannons or artillery).
 
Yeah, it looks more like two separate hits (I made a mistake thinking it was a regular wing - you're right, it's a stabilizer).

That's Kim "KillerChick" Campbell's A-10. There was small-arms fire to the front of the aircraft, that damage, on the empennage, was caused by a surface to air missile that penetrated the horizontal stabilizer before exploding. Most of the holes are the result of the diffraction loading of a SAM missile (the most common way they're made). Some are from internal damages and parts exploding outwards. The hydraulic system was compromised so severely in the rear of the aircraft that the entire system failed and had to be flown on manual (something not many aircraft even allow for anymore).
 
That's Kim "KillerChick" Campbell's A-10. There was small-arms fire to the front of the aircraft, that damage, on the empennage, was caused by a surface to air missile that penetrated the horizontal stabilizer before exploding. Most of the holes are the result of the diffraction loading of a SAM missile (the most common way they're made). Some are from internal damages and parts exploding outwards. The hydraulic system was compromised so severely in the rear of the aircraft that the entire system failed and had to be flown on manual (something not many aircraft even allow for anymore).

Makes sense. So that stabilizer wing was penetrated (broken opening), then the missile exploded, sending shrapnel to the fuselage like we see?
 
Ant-aircraft shells won't reach FL330. Some missiles will, but not AA fire.

Make sense.

Watching those WWII movies (like Twelve O'clock High), I see shrapnel AA shells exploding in mid-air around the Ally bombers (unless they were hit). What would that general altitude be?
 
Make sense.

Watching those WWII movies (like Twelve O'clock High), I see shrapnel AA shells exploding in mid-air around the Ally bombers (unless they were hit). What would that general altitude be?

IIRC, about 20,000 feet. Machine gun AA is generally very low altitude.
 
IIRC, about 20,000 feet. Machine gun AA is generally very low altitude.

Okay. So those 50 caliber machine guns are good when Zeroes used to dive bomb or fly low to strafe. Didn't Lancaster bombers or B-29s use 50 cal machine guns too?
 
Okay. So those 50 caliber machine guns are good when Zeroes used to dive bomb or fly low to strafe. Didn't Lancaster bombers or B-29s use 50 cal machine guns too?

Yes, for attempting to fight off fighters which were closing in to shoot them down. Lancs actually had .30 cals and those were not that effective at all, being too light.

When I said that mg AA is low altitude, I meant that ground-mounted AA firing upwards doesn't rise very far before falling back to earth. Horizontally fired mg's located in aircraft are still subject to gravity, but can be fired at approaching targets.