The Evidence: MH 017

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
September 4, 2014


The Evidence: MH 017 by Peter Haisenko

Seven weeks have passed since the downing of MH 017 and we have still not been provided with official investigation results. This is an extraordinary circumstance, but ultimately not surprising. Just a few days after the crash of the airliner a short message was published that in this case the debris of the wreck will not be collected to be put together like a puzzle. However, this would have been the normal procedure if there were serious interest to determine the cause of the accident objectively.

When an airplane crashes, within 24 hours there are usually legions of experts at the scene who register everything in detail and start collecting the debris. First of all experts of the plane manufacturer are sent to the scene — in this case Boeing – followed by the NTSB (National Transportation Safety Board), and by specialists and experts from the countries concerned. In addition to the flight recorder, these specialists are responsible for an examination of the debris. Normally, the airplane is reconstructed from the pieces in order to determine the cause of the crash.

Yet in the case of MH 017 normal procedures were not followed. No representatives from Boeing appeared on the site. The airliner was not pieced together in order to determine the cause of its destruction. The information in the black boxes has not been revealed. Therefore, we have to arrive at a conclusion based on experience and the information available.

Investigation is further impeded by the establishment in the media of the Western propaganda line that Russia and the separatists are responsible. This “guilt” has been established by insinuation and repetition of charges unsupported by any evidence. Those who challenge the “official” story that the airliner was destroyed by a missile fired from the ground by separatists are said to be “conspiracy theorists.” In other words, those with experience are discredited before they speak.

The West has control of the investigation and apparently has decided not to investigate. However, we do have two critical pieces of information. One is the report of the Canadian representative of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) that reports bullet holes in the cockpit section of the airliner. Photos are available that clearly show bullet holes in the pattern of machine gun fire on both sides of the airliner’s cockpit. The other piece of information comes from a report in the Malaysian newspaper New Straits Times that intelligence analysts have concluded that one of the airliner’s engines was hit by a heat-seeking air-to-air missile. We know that there were Ukrainian jets armed with such weapons close to the airliner at the time that it crashed. http://www.nst.com.my/node/20925&nbsp

These two pieces of information support my conclusion of what happened based on my experience and my research:

A warplane fired an air-to-air missile which hit the right engine of MH 017. In the cockpit of the MH 017 only a violent shock could be perceived, along with the fire alarm and the failure notice of engine number two. Pilots would be aware of engine failure, not of a missile strike.

IThe missile hit might have caused a strong yawning moment and an immediate drop in speed. The pilots instantly had to initiate emergency procedures for this emergency, and were concentrated on it with full attention.

According to procedural rule, the pilots had to turn the engine off, isolate it, reduce speed and altitude. Afterwards they had to select and head for an emergency landing place and inform the ground control about their emergency situation as soon as possible. A captain in an emergency situation may do everything to save his plane, his own life and the lives of his passengers.

He has the so-called “emergency authority” that allows actions outside of any provision. The nearest major airport for the pilots of MH 017 for an emergency landing was probably Kiev. Rostov in Russia was closer, but in order to go to Rostov the pilots would have had to cope with a change of the control center and a border crossing, which would have meant extra stress.

MH 017 had therefore initiated a curve back towards Kiev in connection with a descent. Now just imagine, that MH 017 would have landed in Kiev. In Kiev it could not have been disguised that the airliner had been hit by an air-to-air missile. The emergency landing procedure had to be prevented – no matter on what airport. This was achieved by machine gun fire.

The fact that an investigation apparently has been stymied is strong circumstantial evidence for the account of the airliner’s demise offered in this article.

© 2014 Peter Haisenko / anderweltonline.com

 
US analysts conclude MH17 downed by aircraft
By Haris Hussain - 7 August 2014 @ 8:20 AM










KUALA LUMPUR: INTELLIGENCE analysts in the United States had already concluded that Malaysia Airlines flight MH17 was shot down by an air-to-air missile, and that the Ukrainian government had had something to do with it.

This corroborates an emerging theory postulated by local investigators that the Boeing 777-200 was crippled by an air-to-air missile and finished off with cannon fire from a fighter that had been shadowing it as it plummeted to earth.

In a damning report dated Aug 3, headlined “Flight 17 Shoot-Down Scenario Shifts”, Associated Press reporter Robert Parry said “some US intelligence sources had concluded that the rebels and Russia were likely not at fault and that it appears Ukrainian government forces were to blame”.

This new revelation was posted on GlobalResearch, an independent research and media organisation.

In a statement released by the Ukrainian embassy on Tuesday, Kiev denied that its fighters were airborne during the time MH17 was shot down. This follows a statement released by the Russian Defence Ministry that its air traffic control had detected Ukrainian Air Force activity in the area on the same day.

They also denied all allegations made by the Russian government and said the country’s core interest was in ensuring an immediate, comprehensive, transparent and unbiased international investigation into the tragedy by establishing a state commission comprising experts from the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) and Eurocontrol.

“We have evidence that the plane was downed by Russian-backed terrorist with a BUK-M1 SAM system (North Atlantic Treaty Organisation reporting name SA-11) which, together with the crew, had been supplied from Russia. This was all confirmed by our intelligence, intercepted telephone conversations of the terrorists and satellite pictures.

“At the same time, the Ukrainian Armed Forces have never used any anti-aircraft missiles since the anti-terrorist operations started in early April,” the statement read.


Yesterday, the New Straits Times quoted experts who had said that photographs of the blast fragmentation patterns on the fuselage of the airliner showed two distinct shapes — the shredding pattern associated with a warhead packed with “flechettes”, and the more uniform, round-type penetration holes consistent with that of cannon rounds.

Parry’s conclusion also stemmed from the fact that despite assertions from the Obama administration, there has not been a shred of tangible evidence to support the conclusion that Russia supplied the rebels with the BUK-M1 anti-aircraft missile system that would be needed to hit a civilian jetliner flying at 33,000 feet.

Parry also cited a July 29 Canadian Broadcasting Corporation interview with Michael Bociurkiw, one of the first Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) investigators to arrive at the scene of the disaster, near Donetsk.

Bociurkiw is a Ukrainian-Canadian monitor with OSCE who, along with another colleague, were the first international monitors to reach the wreckage after flight MH17 was brought down over eastern Ukraine.

In the CBC interview, the reporter in the video preceded it with: “The wreckage was still smouldering when a small team from the OSCE got there. No other officials arrived for days”.

“There have been two or three pieces of fuselage that have been really pockmarked with what almost looks like machinegun fire; very, very strong machinegun fire,” Bociurkiw said in the interview.

Parry had said that Bociurkiw’s testimony is “as close to virgin, untouched evidence and testimony as we’ll ever get. Unlike a black-box interpretation-analysis long afterward by the Russian, British or Ukrainian governments, each of which has a horse in this race, this testimony from Bociurkiw is raw, independent and comes from one of the two earliest witnesses to the physical evidence.

“That’s powerfully authoritative testimony. Bociurkiw arrived there fast because he negotiated with the locals for the rest of the OSCE team, who were organising to come later,” Parry had said.

Retired Lufthansa pilot Peter Haisenko had also weighed in on the new shootdown theory with Parry and pointed to the entry and exit holes centred around the cockpit.

“You can see the entry and exit holes. The edge of a portion of the holes is bent inwards. These are the smaller holes, round and clean, showing the entry points most likely that of a 30mm caliber projectile.

“The edge of the other, the larger and slightly frayed exit holes, show shreds of metal pointing produced by the same caliber projectiles. Moreover, it is evident that these exit holes of the outer layer of the double aluminum reinforced structure are shredded or bent — outwardly.”

He deduced that in order to have some of those holes fraying inwardly, and the others fraying outwardly, there had to have been a second fighter firing into the cockpit from the airliner’s starboard side. This is critical, as no surface-fired missile (or shrapnel) hitting the airliner could possibly punch holes into the cockpit from both sides of the plane.

“It had to have been a hail of bullets from both sides that brought the plane down. This is Haisenko’s main discovery. You can’t have projectiles going in both directions — into the left-hand-side fuselage panel from both its left and right sides — unless they are coming at the panel from different directions.

“Nobody before Haisenko had noticed that the projectiles had ripped through that panel from both its left side and its right side. This is what rules out any ground-fired missile,” Parry had said.
 
The black boxes take time to decipher. They're being analyzed right now. And the pieces that were recovered are being assembled, they just haven't all been recovered because, you know, it's a warzone. Why didn't Boeing show up? Because it's a war zone is probably a good answer here too. Also, manufacturers aren't always the first on the scene, or even on the scene at all. Manufacturers show up when there's a chance the incident was related to a mechanical or design flaw. They don't show up when it's obviously not their problem. Boeing investigators are there to determine Boeing's liability and, if there is any, find the source and work with the engineering teams to put out service bulletins to reduce or eliminate their liability going forward. If there's no chance it's a Boeing problem, why would Boeing send people out? And what exactly would they be able to do?

Also worth noting, Russia has radar installations for Air Traffic Control that extend into the region where MH17 was flying, and military radars that see well beyond it. If there was a Ukrainian jet attacking MH17, Russia would have radar tapes showing its interception. If Russia had such tapes, why would they be blaming a Ukrainian Buk instead of the Ukrainian fighter jet they have evidence of? If there was a fighter jet, Russian radar would be all over the internet showing it. I think it's pretty easy to conclude the likelihood that MH17 was shot down by a Ukrainian jet is non-existent given Ukraine's lack of stealth fighters.
 
The black boxes take time to decipher. They're being analyzed right now. And the pieces that were recovered are being assembled, they just haven't all been recovered because, you know, it's a warzone. Why didn't Boeing show up? Because it's a war zone is probably a good answer here too. Also, manufacturers aren't always the first on the scene, or even on the scene at all. Manufacturers show up when there's a chance the incident was related to a mechanical or design flaw. They don't show up when it's obviously not their problem. Boeing investigators are there to determine Boeing's liability and, if there is any, find the source and work with the engineering teams to put out service bulletins to reduce or eliminate their liability going forward. If there's no chance it's a Boeing problem, why would Boeing send people out? And what exactly would they be able to do?

Also worth noting, Russia has radar installations for Air Traffic Control that extend into the region where MH17 was flying, and military radars that see well beyond it. If there was a Ukrainian jet attacking MH17, Russia would have radar tapes showing its interception. If Russia had such tapes, why would they be blaming a Ukrainian Buk instead of the Ukrainian fighter jet they have evidence of? If there was a fighter jet, Russian radar would be all over the internet showing it. I think it's pretty easy to conclude the likelihood that MH17 was shot down by a Ukrainian jet is non-existent given Ukraine's lack of stealth fighters.

Your request for russian evidence makes sense, if taken by itself. However, while the western media is convicting Russia of shooting down the airliner, why are you accepting that without asking for the ukrainian air traffic voice and radar tapes, and the american surveilance tapes. Surely, the US had the area under close surveilance by satellites and drones.

Your logic will just as well work in the opposite direction, as for example Paul Craig Roberts have pointed out http://www.paulcraigroberts.org/2014/08/20/ukraine-crisis-continues-paul-craig-roberts/, as in: if the russians had shot it down, the americans/russians would have shown the evidence.

PS: as a frequent flyer with something like 5 million miles under my belt, I would simply like to know what happened to the plane. I would not be any happier if it was the ukrainians who did it than if it was the russians.
 
...
Seven weeks have passed since the downing of MH 017 and we have still not been provided with official investigation results. ...

It's amazing we live in a world where people feel they are so important they must be informed on the progress of everything.

p.s. another of dan's political threads that he wants more attention on.
 
Results will be released in September.
 
danmand;503******** said:
Your request for russian evidence makes sense, if taken by itself. However, while the western media is convicting Russia of shooting down the airliner, why are you accepting that without asking for the ukrainian air traffic voice and radar tapes, and the american surveilance tapes. Surely, the US had the area under close surveilance by satellites and drones.

Your logic will just as well work in the opposite direction, as for example Paul Craig Roberts have pointed out http://www.paulcraigroberts.org/2014/08/20/ukraine-crisis-continues-paul-craig-roberts/, as in: if the russians had shot it down, the americans/russians would have shown the evidence.

PS: as a frequent flyer with something like 5 million miles under my belt, I would simply like to know what happened to the plane. I would not be any happier if it was the ukrainians who did it than if it was the russians.

What do you think Ukrainian ATC tapes will tell you? What do you expect to say on Ukrainian or US radar? And what exactly do you think satellite will tell you?

In an emergency, a pilot's job is #1) Aviate. Fly the plane. #2) Navigate. Get somewhere safe. Avoid crashing into a city, try to make it to land if over water, find a semi-flat, empty space to attempt to land in if you're going down. #3) Communicate. Tell ATC what's going on and request assistance if needed. In that order. There was an Air Canada with control problems about a month ago that declared an emergency and asked to be taken out over the lake to work out some issues. At one point, ATC asks, "What's your status?" And Air Canada replies: "We've lost all control and we're...we're...standby." The pilots didn't get back to ATC until they had sorted things out enough and were ready to start getting vectored closer in to the airport. It wasn't a short period of time. But the pilots were focused on #1 and #2. Communicating might be important from an ATC perspective, but if the aircraft knows it's in radar coverage, it knows ATC will keep things away from it anyway and not crashing is more important than talking.

If you get hit with a missile and it strikes a control surface, like a wing or the tail, the aircraft will be very hard to control. It will probably require the efforts of both pilots. While reefing madly on the controls, they'll be looking out the window or their instruments trying to find a semi-safe place to put it down. If the missile hits the pressure vessel, like the fuselage, the aircraft will rupture and disintegrate. There will be no way to do 1, 2 or 3. In either case, I would expect Ukrainian ATC to reveal nothing. Unless they were vectoring or talking to the fighter jet. But civilian ATC doesn't do that. The military has their own. And no military is going to release it's CCC systems to review under any circumstance. Have you heard military CCC from 9/11? No, you haven't. And you won't. So the Ukraine ATC tapes aren't likely to reveal anything. Also, the tapes are confidential. What makes you think you have a right to hear what some people's last words on this earth are?

My point remains, you say, "Why ask for Russian data and not Ukrainian data?" I'm not asking for anyone's data. I'm pointing out that if the tapes condemned one side, the other side would've released them already. The fact that no one has means that there's nothing to be proven on them. If Ukraine had MIGs or SUs in the air conducting strafing runs on an airliner that Russian is accused of shooting down, you can bet Russia would've released the tapes already and the world would know. Likewise, if US satellites had any evidence of Russian wrong-doing, they'd be published. I don't know how you think satellite surveillance works, but they take pictures, not video. It's quite possible there isn't a photo from the instant the missile was fired. If there was, and if it showed that missile's exhaust streaking up from Russia, it would've been published already.

That's the point you're missing. If the scenario you presented in this thread had happened, we'd know. The radar tapes would be all over the place and experts would be crawling out of the woodwork to validate the claims your articles made. No Russian radar means no Ukrainian interception. It's that simple. Russia wouldn't hold back if they could prove Ukraine engaged in murder and terrorism in an effort to blame for Russia for wrongdoing. Likewise, if Ukraine and the US could prove it was Russia, that information would be out there too.

Which leaves us with what? Buk launchers. Which are owned by both sides. Which both sides had in the area. Which side did it? Who knows. But we know it wasn't fighter jets because if it was, the proof would be staring us in the face.
 
What do you think Ukrainian ATC tapes will tell you? What do you expect to say on Ukrainian or US radar? And what exactly do you think satellite will tell you?

In an emergency, a pilot's job is #1) Aviate. Fly the plane. #2) Navigate. Get somewhere safe. Avoid crashing into a city, try to make it to land if over water, find a semi-flat, empty space to attempt to land in if you're going down. #3) Communicate. Tell ATC what's going on and request assistance if needed. In that order. There was an Air Canada with control problems about a month ago that declared an emergency and asked to be taken out over the lake to work out some issues. At one point, ATC asks, "What's your status?" And Air Canada replies: "We've lost all control and we're...we're...standby." The pilots didn't get back to ATC until they had sorted things out enough and were ready to start getting vectored closer in to the airport. It wasn't a short period of time. But the pilots were focused on #1 and #2. Communicating might be important from an ATC perspective, but if the aircraft knows it's in radar coverage, it knows ATC will keep things away from it anyway and not crashing is more important than talking.

If you get hit with a missile and it strikes a control surface, like a wing or the tail, the aircraft will be very hard to control. It will probably require the efforts of both pilots. While reefing madly on the controls, they'll be looking out the window or their instruments trying to find a semi-safe place to put it down. If the missile hits the pressure vessel, like the fuselage, the aircraft will rupture and disintegrate. There will be no way to do 1, 2 or 3. In either case, I would expect Ukrainian ATC to reveal nothing. Unless they were vectoring or talking to the fighter jet. But civilian ATC doesn't do that. The military has their own. And no military is going to release it's CCC systems to review under any circumstance. Have you heard military CCC from 9/11? No, you haven't. And you won't. So the Ukraine ATC tapes aren't likely to reveal anything. Also, the tapes are confidential. What makes you think you have a right to hear what some people's last words on this earth are?

My point remains, you say, "Why ask for Russian data and not Ukrainian data?" I'm not asking for anyone's data. I'm pointing out that if the tapes condemned one side, the other side would've released them already. The fact that no one has means that there's nothing to be proven on them. If Ukraine had MIGs or SUs in the air conducting strafing runs on an airliner that Russian is accused of shooting down, you can bet Russia would've released the tapes already and the world would know. Likewise, if US satellites had any evidence of Russian wrong-doing, they'd be published. I don't know how you think satellite surveillance works, but they take pictures, not video. It's quite possible there isn't a photo from the instant the missile was fired. If there was, and if it showed that missile's exhaust streaking up from Russia, it would've been published already.

That's the point you're missing. If the scenario you presented in this thread had happened, we'd know. The radar tapes would be all over the place and experts would be crawling out of the woodwork to validate the claims your articles made. No Russian radar means no Ukrainian interception. It's that simple. Russia wouldn't hold back if they could prove Ukraine engaged in murder and terrorism in an effort to blame for Russia for wrongdoing. Likewise, if Ukraine and the US could prove it was Russia, that information would be out there too.

Which leaves us with what? Buk launchers. Which are owned by both sides. Which both sides had in the area. Which side did it? Who knows. But we know it wasn't fighter jets because if it was, the proof would be staring us in the face.

I principly agree with you. "It's that simple. Russia wouldn't hold back if they could prove Ukraine engaged in murder and terrorism in an effort to blame for Russia for wrongdoing. Likewise, if Ukraine and the US could prove it was Russia, that information would be out there too."

The point I wanted to make is that it has not been established that Russia, or Putin personally, downed the airplane, as the (western) media and most people here state over and over again.

I repeat, that personally I am more interested in finding out what happened to the airplane, than who did it.
 
I principly agree with you. "It's that simple. Russia wouldn't hold back if they could prove Ukraine engaged in murder and terrorism in an effort to blame for Russia for wrongdoing. Likewise, if Ukraine and the US could prove it was Russia, that information would be out there too."

The point I wanted to make is that it has not been established that Russia, or Putin personally, downed the airplane, as the (western) media and most people here state over and over again.

I repeat, that personally I am more interested in finding out what happened to the airplane, than who did it.

I'm pretty sure no one thinks Putin personally took down the aircraft. He's former KGB, not former air defense artillery. Many people don't buy the official story, only a handful of Russian-haters here buy into every piece of western propaganda available. It should be noted that the report coming out from the Dutch won't answer the question either. Even if it determines a missile from a Buk launcher did it in, that still doesn't explain whose Buk it came from. We'll likely never know, but if your motivation is, as you said, because you're part of the flying public, it doesn't matter. Someone deliberately shot it down. Why does the who matter in your case? On the other hand, it's very relevant for political reasons, or simply to know how evil one side or the other is in this battle over Eastern Ukraine... but will it drastically change your travel plans?
 
We are picking at straws here. Like in any other investigation of this type. Who had the MOTIVATION and the most gain, for this disaster. Russia or the Ukrainian ? I believe this question, speaks for itself !
 
I'm pretty sure no one thinks Putin personally took down the aircraft. He's former KGB, not former air defense artillery. Many people don't buy the official story, only a handful of Russian-haters here buy into every piece of western propaganda available. It should be noted that the report coming out from the Dutch won't answer the question either. Even if it determines a missile from a Buk launcher did it in, that still doesn't explain whose Buk it came from. We'll likely never know, but if your motivation is, as you said, because you're part of the flying public, it doesn't matter. Someone deliberately shot it down. Why does the who matter in your case? On the other hand, it's very relevant for political reasons, or simply to know how evil one side or the other is in this battle over Eastern Ukraine... but will it drastically change your travel plans?

I will make sure not to fly over the Ukraine untill peace has been established.

PS: I agree with you completely. The only thing that puzzles me is the holes in the fuselage that seem to look like bullet holes, and was reported as such by the first member of the osco on site. On the photograph, it looks like some of the bullets have come from the other side. What do you think about these holes. I guess they could have been made on the ground.
 
We are picking at straws here. Like in any other investigation of this type. Who had the MOTIVATION and the most gain, for this disaster. Russia or the Ukrainian ? I believe this question, speaks for itself !

I agree with that. Follow the money or as the french say: "Cherchez la femme". Clearly the downing of the airplane was a massive problem for Putin, and very beneficial to Obama (staying in the media parlance).
 
Ok, Danmand. You clearly need a lesson in logic on this one.

Since there is not going to be any definitive forensic evidence to resolve the issue one way or the other, we have to do it the old fashioned way - by circumstantial evidence and balance of probabilities.

1. In the week or so before the airliner was shot down, the pro-Russian armed groups shot down several Ukrainian govt aircraft in the same vicinity. They were clearly briefed to shoot at planes. Shooting at the wrong target is pretty common in warfare, especially if the weapons crews are half-trained or poorly C&C-ed. The pro Russians were both of those. OTOH, the Uke govt had shot down no planes in the same period and had no targets to fire at, as the pro-Russies were not deploying aircraft. So, balance of probabilities is already strongly that the pro Russian militia shot down the plane.

2. The local leader of the pro-Russes, "Colonel Strelkov" proudly announced the shoot-down wi minutes after it took place. There were no other shoot downs that day. Within 20 minutes, he deleted the incriminating post from his V Kontakte page. Make those balance of probabilities a little more strongly that the militia did the kill.

3. Ukrainian govt intelligence released tapes of the pro Russian militia discussing the kill. Now the Ukes do have a motive to blame the pro Russian militia. OTOH, the tapes are consistent with the 2 chunks of evidence set out above. Make that balance of probabilities a little stronger.

4. Ukes released vid footage of a Buk being driven back towards Russia w 1 missile missing in the day or so following the kill. See #3 above for this one.

5. The Russian media disseminated a variety of wildly implausible explanations for the shoot-down. They claimed that the plane had been stocked with refrigerated corpses by the US and Kiev and blown up in mid air. They claimed that the Ukes were trying to shoot down Putin's private plane - which was 100's of miles away at the time of the incident. They claimed that a "Spanish speaking air traffic controller in Dnipropetrovsk" had spotted a fighter plane following the air liner, only to be told that no such individual existed. The a/c type the Russian media claimed had done the shoot-down turned out to be a ground attack a/c which could not reach 30,000 feet in any event. Russian media also released a shot of what they said was the tail plane of the air liner and indicated that it had machine gun impact traces in it. AFAIK, no current type of warplane uses machine guns in air to air combat and machine guns could not shoot down an airliner in any event - sort of like trying to kill a cow w a BB gun.

If you have two suspects for a crime and 1 of them comes up w a # of wildly implausible and self-contradicting alibis, that strongly indicates that this is the actual perp. So I close my case with an open and shut conviction against the pro Russian militia.

Now Putin got smeared badly with the fallout from the incident. But that is no evidence that the US planned and carried out the attack. What almost certainly actually happened is what I just outlined - some half-assed, untrained yahoos were operating a sophisticated weapon system without proper supervision and let fly on what they assumed was a valid target, but which was anything but.

Now this is the 2nd or third time you have played your pathetic little game of raising the topic of the Malaysian a/c and attempting to suggest the US did the kill. I am sick of responding to you. So I am just going to bookmark this response and cut and paste it in a month's time when you try and raise the same topic.
 
We are picking at straws here. Like in any other investigation of this type. Who had the MOTIVATION and the most gain, for this disaster. Russia or the Ukrainian ? I believe this question, speaks for itself !

If only it was that cut and dry. I have good friends who were ground-pounders during the civil war in Bosnia. After the UN had finally established itself, interactions between Serbs, Croats and Muslims was extremely minimal and therefore, cause for fighting was minimal. So one day they were called to a Serbian hospital where reports were that the Croats had broken in and killed all the children to eliminate a "generation of Serbs". Surveillance tapes were reviewed and found that the Serbs themselves had done it in an effort to give cause to hate the Croats and attempt to push international pressure to serve their cause. You might think it actually swayed the international community the other way, but apparently the Serbs were just as guilty of the same type of thing. These people killed their own to fabricate an excuse to war with others. I don't trust any government. Not Putin, not Poroshenko. Besides, who says it couldn't have been an accident that Ukraine tried to turn around and leverage into something more? If Russian rebels shot it down thinking it was something else, why couldn't Ukraine have done it?

There is the other question to be pondered: if Russia really are the ones that did it (and not just ethnic Russian civilians from Ukraine fighting as rebels for a cause they believe in), how would that scenario play out? Why would Russia shoot down a civilian airliner? That doesn't help them at all. Unless you believe the Russian military, one of the more professional ones on the planet, is incapable of using equipment it's had in its arsenal for decades properly. I think this is, most likely, a case of rebel civilians fucking up. No one, not Russia nor Ukraine, benefits from having a civilian airliner shot down. Russia is unlikely to have made this kind of mistake, so is Ukraine. So if either one did it, it was on purpose. The people who gain the most from this being "on purpose" is Ukraine, since the world is so quick to blame Russia for it and believe it no matter what. Russia gains nothing. But a mistake made by civilians... that's infinitely more believable.
 
I will make sure not to fly over the Ukraine untill peace has been established.

PS: I agree with you completely. The only thing that puzzles me is the holes in the fuselage that seem to look like bullet holes, and was reported as such by the first member of the osco on site. On the photograph, it looks like some of the bullets have come from the other side. What do you think about these holes. I guess they could have been made on the ground.

It's just Ukraine, not The Ukraine. This debate has come up before. But trust me, I have family there, I go there regularly... It's just Ukraine. And they can get quite uppity when you call it "The Ukraine" because they compare everything to Russia, and no one thinks it's "The Russia".

If you're flying in the area, you may not have a choice on where to fly. A flight from Turkey to Canada might go over Ukraine. Fuel, weather, etc... A variety of factors are taken into determine aircraft routes. Even before MH17, most flights avoided it whenever possible along with other warzones. But some still went through when necessary (like MH17). After MH17, airlines will try to avoid it even more, but sometimes it can't be helped.

As for the holes... You should research diffraction loading (shotgunning, shrapnel dispersion, etc). Also, look at picture of aircraft there were absolutely brought down by aircraft-mounted cannons vs ones that were absolutely brought down by missiles. You should also consider the results of explosive decompression and note that rivets are circular. Also worthy of note, JETA1 burns hot enough to liquefy aluminium which is often sandwiched between layers of the aircraft pressure vessel and will literally explode out once structural integrity, especially around rivets, is weakened. Also, reports indicate only Su-25s have been in the air to deal with the rebels and Su-25's lack the service ceiling, especially when combat-loaded, to reach FL330.

But, I'm not an expert on bullet holes. Of course, neither is the guy that claims these are and none of the people that actually do have expertise in the field have backed up the claim. Until they do, I'm perfectly content dismissing it, especially given how air defence works and the popularity of diffraction loading.
 
It's just Ukraine, not The Ukraine. This debate has come up before. But trust me, I have family there, I go there regularly... It's just Ukraine. And they can get quite uppity when you call it "The Ukraine" because they compare everything to Russia, and no one thinks it's "The Russia".

If you're flying in the area, you may not have a choice on where to fly. A flight from Turkey to Canada might go over Ukraine. Fuel, weather, etc... A variety of factors are taken into determine aircraft routes. Even before MH17, most flights avoided it whenever possible along with other warzones. But some still went through when necessary (like MH17). After MH17, airlines will try to avoid it even more, but sometimes it can't be helped.

As for the holes... You should research diffraction loading (shotgunning, shrapnel dispersion, etc). Also, look at picture of aircraft there were absolutely brought down by aircraft-mounted cannons vs ones that were absolutely brought down by missiles. You should also consider the results of explosive decompression and note that rivets are circular. Also worthy of note, JETA1 burns hot enough to liquefy aluminium which is often sandwiched between layers of the aircraft pressure vessel and will literally explode out once structural integrity, especially around rivets, is weakened. Also, reports indicate only Su-25s have been in the air to deal with the rebels and Su-25's lack the service ceiling, especially when combat-loaded, to reach FL330.

But, I'm not an expert on bullet holes. Of course, neither is the guy that claims these are and none of the people that actually do have expertise in the field have backed up the claim. Until they do, I'm perfectly content dismissing it, especially given how air defence works and the popularity of diffraction loading.

Sorry about that; I did not know. I was not intending to insult you or your family.

I flew from Delhi to Frankfurt early this year. Must have come pretty close. And I will be flying to Turkey early next year. As for the theory about bullet holes. I am not going to investigate anything. LOL. There are specialists that do that for a living, and I am sure they will have looked at the holes. I will wait for their conclusion. It just looks unusual.
 
Sorry about that; I did not know. I was not intending to insult you or your family.

I flew from Delhi to Frankfurt early this year. Must have come pretty close. And I will be flying to Turkey early next year. As for the theory about bullet holes. I am not going to investigate anything. LOL. There are specialists that do that for a living, and I am sure they will have looked at the holes. I will wait for their conclusion. It just looks unusual.

I'm not insulted, I'm not from Ukraine. I was just letting you know. No offence taken by me.

To ease your curiosity though, don't cheat and tineye or GIS this picture, and tell me if you think the aircraft was struck by bullets or a missile?

Kim_campbell_damage_a10.jpg
 
If only it was that cut and dry. I have good friends who were ground-pounders during the civil war in Bosnia. After the UN had finally established itself, interactions between Serbs, Croats and Muslims was extremely minimal and therefore, cause for fighting was minimal. So one day they were called to a Serbian hospital where reports were that the Croats had broken in and killed all the children to eliminate a "generation of Serbs". Surveillance tapes were reviewed and found that the Serbs themselves had done it in an effort to give cause to hate the Croats and attempt to push international pressure to serve their cause. You might think it actually swayed the international community the other way, but apparently the Serbs were just as guilty of the same type of thing. These people killed their own to fabricate an excuse to war with others. I don't trust any government. Not Putin, not Poroshenko. Besides, who says it couldn't have been an accident that Ukraine tried to turn around and leverage into something more? If Russian rebels shot it down thinking it was something else, why couldn't Ukraine have done it?

There is the other question to be pondered: if Russia really are the ones that did it (and not just ethnic Russian civilians from Ukraine fighting as rebels for a cause they believe in), how would that scenario play out? Why would Russia shoot down a civilian airliner? That doesn't help them at all. Unless you believe the Russian military, one of the more professional ones on the planet, is incapable of using equipment it's had in its arsenal for decades properly. I think this is, most likely, a case of rebel civilians fucking up. No one, not Russia nor Ukraine, benefits from having a civilian airliner shot down. Russia is unlikely to have made this kind of mistake, so is Ukraine. So if either one did it, it was on purpose. The people who gain the most from this being "on purpose" is Ukraine, since the world is so quick to blame Russia for it and believe it no matter what. Russia gains nothing. But a mistake made by civilians... that's infinitely more believable.


I agree with you, thats where the finger points
 
... Who had the MOTIVATION and the most gain,...

That is one question but we also have to consider the other applicable question. Who did something dumb? Examining motivation assumes all people act rationally.