As I stated: "John Tory? You Cannot Trust That Guy."

Anbarandy

Bitter House****
Apr 27, 2006
11,921
4,664
113
John Tory’s SmartTrack: Why his big bet on transit is a real risk

Marcus Gee The Globe and Mail Last updated Friday, Aug. 22 2014, 8:24 PM EDT



Recent polls show John Tory leading the race for mayor. One big reason, his team says, is SmartTrack, his $8-billion plan to use existing rail track to create a 53-kilometre, 22-station “surface subway.” When he unveiled the idea back in May, illustrated with colour-coded transit maps, he said the system could be completed in just seven years and would “break the back of the city's congestion problems.”

But anybody can draw lines on a map. The key question – frankly the only question, when it comes to transit in Toronto – is how to pay for it. A close look at his funding proposal suggests that the biggest, most costly proposal in his campaign for mayor is built on a shaky foundation.

The old-fashioned way to build rapid transit in Toronto is to borrow the money and pay it back by raising property taxes. That is how the city plans to cover most of its share of the proposed Scarborough subway extension, for example.

Mr. Tory proposes something different and, in Ontario at least, so far untried. He would avoid raising property taxes and instead use a method called tax increment financing (TIF). As he put in prepared remarks for a speech in June, this method “would help pay upfront capital costs by capturing ahead of time the increased tax revenues from development on lands near the new stations.”

One big plus for Mr. Tory is that he doesn't have to pitch tax increases during an election campaign and put a target on his back for Mayor Rob Ford and others. “I don’t propose to offer hardworking Torontonians transit relief in exchange for a financial headache that could last for years,” he said in his June speech. “Therefore, I will not raise property taxes to build the SmartTrack line. The city’s one-third portion will come from tax-increment financing.”

But it is far from clear that TIF could work here in Toronto, especially for such a costly project.

Three recent transit studies have looked at TIF and other forms of what experts call land value capture. None has recommended making it a pillar of a transit-funding strategy. City of Toronto officials say the concept is essentially useless to them in its current form. Some experts warn that by counting on a geyser of future property tax revenue that might never materialize, Toronto could be facing a serious risk.

One-third of $8-billion is $2.666-billion. That is a lot of money, however you raise it. TIF has never been used in Canada on anything like that scale. In fact, says former TTC chair Karen Stintz, who pulled out of the mayoral race this week, “there is no example of tax increment financing working to that degree anywhere.” The Tory campaign counters that TIF is sound, safe, backed by a pile of research and already in use around the world.

California pioneered tax increment financing in the 1950s. Since then, it has spread to most American states. Say a city wants to redevelop a rundown part of its downtown. The city creates a TIF zone there and makes plans for improvements. It borrows money, usually by issuing bonds, to pay for those improvements. It freezes regular taxes in the zone at existing, or base, levels and uses any tax money it reaps in excess of that – the increment – to finance the debt.

The Tory campaign says the tax increment from just three areas that will be served by SmartTrack stations – Liberty Village, the East Don Lands and the downtown core – could cover the city’s share of the cost.

But TIF relies on identifying new development that comes from a project. Liberty Village is pretty thoroughly developed already. So is the downtown core. It is one thing to rebuild a blighted area and claim that the bigger tax take is due to redevelopment. It would be trickier to claim that, say, a new cluster of downtown office buildings came from a new downtown transit station, considering that downtown is already well served by transit.

And what if the development never comes? TIF is a gamble that the property-tax income will rise enough to cover the money borrowed to build the project – in this case, the SmartTrack network.

“The real danger here is that those values don’t increase in the way it was predicted at the start,” says Enid Slack, director of the University of Toronto’s Institute on Municipal Finance and Governance. “How do you pay back the loan?” The answer, almost certainly, would be to raise property taxes, the very thing Mr. Tory has promised to avoid for SmartTrack.

New York is using a form of TIF to help pay for a $2.4-billion extension of the 7 subway line, part of a transformation of Manhattan’s Far West Side. A report last year showed that revenue from new development had fallen more than $100-million short of the $283-million expected by 2012. Tax increment financing is “a promising way of financing infrastructure but it’s not working out very well so far in New York,” says David King, an assistant professor of urban planning at Columbia University, who has studied the subject.

Mr. Ford proposed using TIF to fund a Sheppard subway extension before city council shot that project down. The Ontario government brought in legislation in 2006 to permit the financing method. It was to be used in a pilot project to help pay for the Toronto-York subway. But the government has yet to bring in regulations to put the legislation into practice.

Toronto and Queen’s Park are locked in a dispute over TIF. The city has asked the province over and over to allow Toronto to tap into the education portion of the local property tax, which goes to Queen’s Park to pay for schools. “If we don’t get the province to agree to waive their portion of the property tax, will this tax mechanism work? From our perspective, no,” says city manager Joe Pennachetti. "It really is going to be of no benefit from our perspective.” That is because, as the city sees it, it would only be tapping into its own future revenue stream, not gaining new resources.

Mr. Pennachetti hopes the discussion about TIF in the campaign for mayor will put pressure on Queen’s Park. But there is no sign of that so far. In an e-mailed statement, the Ministry of Finance said that “before considering programs to divert future revenues away from our education system to fund municipal infrastructure projects, the province will carefully study the implications.” The government, it said, was “taking a careful and prudent approach ….”

Even if the struggle over the education portion of the property tax could be worked out, the Tory campaign admits there is another hurdle. The Ontario legislation says municipalities must keep TIF spending in any given year below 1 per cent of their total property tax take.

The problem with earmarking any amount of future tax revenues for a particular project like SmartTrack is that those revenues won’t be available for other things like filling potholes, or creating new parks for the people who live in the redeveloped area.

Canadian transit authorities have been cautious about the idea of relying on TIF to fund big transit projects. An exhaustive report from Metrolinx, the Ontario transit agency, last year recommended raising hundreds of millions of dollars a year for transit through a five-cent-a-litre tax on gas and a one percentage-point rise in the sales tax. It estimated that various types of land value capture could reap only a modest $20-million a year, though the sum could be higher with the right policies in place.

A second panel, led by Anne Golden, recommended gas taxes, listing land value capture as one of its “smaller” revenue sources. In British Columbia, the mayors of greater Vancouver issued a report this spring calling for tolls, road pricing and a share of the provincial carbon tax. It recommended looking at land value capture, too, “although it doesn’t have the revenue potential of other sources.”

Mr. Tory once said that “transit plans without money are almost worse than no transit plans at all because they create nothing but false hopes.” Now he promises to produce $2.5-billion dollars at no cost to the ordinary taxpayer through the alchemy of tax-increment financing.

This leading candidate for mayor is just feeding more false hopes.




Infuriating to say the least, that Tory has somehow been bestowed with the 'crown of credibility' regarding what is so plainly, patently and obviously a false campaign promise. And that is that his SmartTrack Plan is nothing more than a pie-in-the-sky fantasy to lure gullible, uninformed and 'yearning for hope at the expense of reality', prospective voters.

His promise of SmartTrack funding 'at no cost to the taxpayer' is and/or ought to be known by Tory himself as false and misleading at best, or an outright lie when subjected to the scrutiny of evidence. If he doesn't know this, he ought to know. And if he knows, he obviously discounts reality in order to further his quest for the mayor's seat and in the process is willing to throw taxpayers under his 'fantasy-trains'.

This is exactly the type of nonsense that got The Great Fraud elected and it appears that it may, unfortunately happen again.

Why can't this guy be forthright and honest and thus deserving of 'faith and trust'?

You know the answer if that question is asked of Rob Ford. And it is becoming clearer and clearer that the answer regarding 'credibility and trust', of both Tory and Ford, is about the same as they are both remarkably similar.

Promise 'Pie-in-the sky' fantasies with no hope in hell of being able to deliver.

Ford and Ford protégé Tory: Both willingly will waste and squander +$2billion of scarce resources on The BDL Gravy Train extension. Both willingly promote and promise pure fantasy and wholly deceitful, expensive and brand new shiny toy, mass transit projects at 'no cost'. Both propagate the lie and 'myth of gravy' and that the city has a spending problem both of which are contrary to reality.

Rob Ford and John Tory? You cannot trust these guys.
 
Last edited:
And Chow said it would cost only 15 million per year for buses. TTC says 69 million. Plus 288 million for infrastucture.

The rest of her transit plan, well what I could gather before that nasty attack by one of her lead campaign managers, isn't her plan. Just reiterating others. Nothing really of substance at all.

I was watching the last Heritage debate on CP24. I saw her playing the talking head in it, spouting the platitudes. And trying to score shots on Tory while reading from a script. And I saw Tory handle them all, with real answers. The best part is he wasn't spouting what the crowd(with its narrow focus) wanted to hear, but gave real answers for the needs of balance between the need to preserve property, and property owner rights. The crowd at times didn't agree 100% with what he had to say........

And yet in after interviews.....audience members said they would vote for him.

Because they trusted he was telling the truth.

Several campaign volunteers have already joined Tory's campaign from Stintz's run. And they are starting, perhaps with Warren Kinsella, to leave Chow's.....

I find it hard to believe that the nasty tweet sent out by Kinsella, on the same day as she was talking transit, with a direct comparison to Tory's, is coincidence. But man didn't it backfire!
 
Avoiding the facts, the evidence again I note.

Tory is as 'mathematically', 'reality' and 'credibility' challenged as his mentor, The Great Fraud.

To boldly and bald-facedly lie to the electorate that the +$2billion BDL Gravy Train extension is NOT a total waste and squandering of tax dollars and scarce resources and that his $2.8billion FantasyTrack plan is somehow fantastically 'free and at no cost to taxpayers", is to suspend reality, is disingenuous at best, utter nonsense and pure fabrication.

We do not need another 'Ford More' years of lies and fantasy from the likes of Tory.
 
Not really. I just pointed out that Chow, who you think we should trust with the numbers, has clearly shown that, via public statements, that her numbers are wrong. Vastly wrong.

Tory, has shown clear numbers after actually taking the time to speak to various govts including the Province, the city of Markham, Metrolinx etc. As to how its paid for.....well either way it has to be paid. If the majority comes from TIF and some has to be paid down the road due to unforeseen circumstances, well that occurs pretty much with every project.

At least we end up with an excellent transit component. I'm realistic in my expectations, most people are.

How about a comment on the Chow Campaigns claim that its a "Segregationist train". You seem to love applying over the top labels like that all the time.

Or that Kinseela is just "another volunteer" among thousands. She wouldn't even take any responsibility for this at all. None. How can we trust her to own anything she does while in office if she won't during the campaign?
 
And somewhat lost in your wall of text is that the Vaughn extension was paid for by it. Perhaps TIF will work better than you claim.
 
And somewhat lost in your wall of text is that the Vaughn extension was paid for by it. Perhaps TIF will work better than you claim.
Provide the details of how the Vaughan extension 'was paid for' by TIF and at no cost to taxpayers.

I hope you do understand the "what, when, where, why, who and how's", of TIFs. But I do know that neither you nor Tory have a clue.
 
Provide the details of how the Vaughan extension 'was paid for' by TIF and at no cost to taxpayers.

I hope you do understand "what, when, where, why, who and how's", of TIFs. But I do know that neither you nor Tory have a clue.

You posted the article where it states that...didn't you read it? Its right there. Like I said, lost in a wall of text. Perhaps if you took the time to read everything you post.

But hey I'm realistic. I don't expect 100% coverage. As long as most is covered and we end up with transit infrastructure, sounds good to me.
 
You posted the article where it states that...didn't you read it? Its right there. Like I said, lost in a wall of text. Perhaps if you took the time to read everything you post.

But hey I'm realistic. I don't expect 100% coverage. As long as most is covered and we end up with transit infrastructure, sounds good to me.
From the formidable 'wall of text':

"It was to be used in a pilot project to help pay for the Toronto-York subway. But the government has yet to bring in regulations to put the legislation into practice."


Oh, is this what you meant when you stated, "Vaughn extension was paid for by it", by 'it' you meaning TIF.

As stated, you and he, that being Butler1000 and John Tory haven't got a friggin clue what you both are talking about.
 
From the formidable 'wall of text':

"It was to be used in a pilot project to help pay for the Toronto-York subway. But the government has yet to bring in regulations to put the legislation into practice."


Oh, is this what you meant when you stated, "Vaughn extension was paid for by it", by 'it' you meaning TIF.

As stated, you and he, that being Butler1000 and John Tory haven't got a friggin clue what you both are talking about.

Ah. Misread that. Its unfortunate that they have let a little bit of paperwork get in the way of a good idea. Hopefully Tory can push for this. I'm pretty sure he has the connections and savvy with any level of govt to accomplish his goals. Either way its a good idea. Tell me Anbarandy, did the various LRT transit systems you've touted in the USA, where it is used regularily get paid for this way. I'll assume yes. Sounds like a good idea that can be expanded to a better type of transit.

Poor Chow. Fiscal Austerity is so 4 years ago. A Ford Idea. What people want is transit planned and built. With fiscal responsibility. That's the difference.
 
Ah. Misread that. Its unfortunate that they have let a little bit of paperwork get in the way of a good idea. Hopefully Tory can push for this. I'm pretty sure he has the connections and savvy with any level of govt to accomplish his goals. Either way its a good idea. Tell me Anbarandy, did the various LRT transit systems you've touted in the USA, where it is used regularily get paid for this way. I'll assume yes. Sounds like a good idea that can be expanded to a better type of transit.

Poor Chow. Fiscal Austerity is so 4 years ago. A Ford Idea. What people want is transit planned and built. With fiscal responsibility. That's the difference.
It's not paperwork that has gotten in the way. It is the wisdom of 'giving away the whole store', 'lock, stock and barrel' to developers as inducements in such TIF scenarios as the Vaughan extension and Tory's FreeTrack, 'no cost' choo-choo train fantasy.

TIF is applicable and more likely to provide benefit when applied to 'brownfield' and 'blighted areas', not in areas that are plump and ripe for the picking. Thus, utilizing TIF as an inducement for development of areas that private developers otherwise would not touch with a ten foot pole makes sense.

Utilizing TIF based upon already developed and known 'property tax rich' areas as an inducement for development by private developers and then borrowing upfront against an increased 'future' property tax base increases and directing that funding towards transit is nothing but a Robin Hood financing strategy, whereby the poor, that being property taxpayers, are robbed to pay the rich, that being 'private developers'.

The effect of such scenarios, is that the property taxpayer swallows the 'forgiven' development fees and the forgone property tax in addition to picking up the cost of infrastructure to service TIF districts and alas, in the end as a final indignity, is left holding the bag of debt while the developers laugh all the way to the bank.

This is what you support.

You like?
 
Last edited:
So once again your only issue seems to be with the city footing their part of the bill on transit. No issues with the Vaughn extention. Just the Scarborough.

Again I have no issues with a property tax raise for good transit. And Smart track will go through underdeveloped areas in Scarborough(as well as the subway). It will go through areas of Etobicke in need as well.

Why doesn't Smart Tack go to Jane/Finch. Because of the planning to use rail. And because it makes sense for getting it out to the airport. I say scrap the finch LRT and extend the Sheppard Subway west. A far better idea.

But again.....why are you against the city footing part of the bill? Its all the same taxpayer anyway. But we gain the most benefit.

TIF will work in some areas if done correctly. And it will be an ongoing thing over decades if planned right. That's the key. It isn't just the initial amount. Its the continued development over time that pays for it.

A lot better than Chow's fuzzy numbers on something as simple as buying buses, and no real plan for the future.
 
Chow's bus plan has been widely endorsed. That Scarborough subway will likely be shut down by a future council on the grounds that it is prohibitively expensive to operate and will never come even remotely close to being cost effective.

The existing "IKEA subway" really should be mothballed as well. Nobody uses it.
 
So once again your only issue seems to be with the city footing their part of the bill on transit. No issues with the Vaughn extention. Just the Scarborough.

Again I have no issues with a property tax raise for good transit. And Smart track will go through underdeveloped areas in Scarborough(as well as the subway). It will go through areas of Etobicke in need as well.

Why doesn't Smart Tack go to Jane/Finch. Because of the planning to use rail. And because it makes sense for getting it out to the airport. I say scrap the finch LRT and extend the Sheppard Subway west. A far better idea.

But again.....why are you against the city footing part of the bill? Its all the same taxpayer anyway. But we gain the most benefit.

TIF will work in some areas if done correctly. And it will be an ongoing thing over decades if planned right. That's the key. It isn't just the initial amount. Its the continued development over time that pays for it.

A lot better than Chow's fuzzy numbers on something as simple as buying buses, and no real plan for the future.
^^^^^

Wha?

But Tory says we won't have to pay for his FreeTrack and now you say we will.

Which is which?

Why pay for something that is going to be free?

????
 
Chow's bus plan has been widely endorsed. That Scarborough subway will likely be shut down by a future council on the grounds that it is prohibitively expensive to operate and will never come even remotely close to being cost effective.

The existing "IKEA subway" really should be mothballed as well. Nobody uses it.

The plan put forward isn't "Chow's". What she stated was it would only cost 15 million per year and would involve refurbishing and extending the life of some of the existing buses. That's all her "plan" was. Andy Byford shot it down the very next day as impossible.

Since then the TTC put together a recomendation for 288 million in infrastructure, including new buses and starage and maintenance bay, with an operating cost of 69 million extra per year, to accomplish the 10% increase in bus service she wanted.

That's a damn big difference. That Marie Augimeri, the caretaker, tried to allude its Chow's plan, or for the credit to in anyway acrue to her is laughable. Even the name Transit Now is a mis-nomer as it would take 5+ years to source and build the buses and new facilities.

I do like the idea, its a good start, and in keeping with the increase on population coming to the city.

But so is more Subways and Smart-track. We need that too. It isn't either/or. Its all of it needed.
 
^^^^^

Wha?

But Tory says we won't have to pay for his FreeTrack and now you say we will.

Which is which?

Why pay for something that is going to be free?

????

I'm realistic in that no matter what its going to end up costing money. Whether it comes from the city, the Province, or the Feds its all tax money. Any money from developers comes from people too. There is no freebees.

I don't care about that. What I care about is building. More buses, more subways, the Smart-track idea. All of it. And I believe that Tory is the best person to secure the funding from the various sources to do it.

Go ahead, raise my taxes 10%. Put it all to transit. Please.

Anyone with a lick of sense understands about the real cost. And how difficult it is to put something like this together. Chow obviously doesn't or she wouldn't have put forth her 15 million per year for buses which has been thoroughly shot down. Her campaign has now resorted to claims of racism. Low dirty politics this. Very low. Shameful. And smacks of desperation.

You might be able to sling that crap at Ford. But not at Tory. She keeps these tactics up, instead of sticking to real issues, and she will lose badly, both the election, and her reputation.
 
I'm realistic in that no matter what its going to end up costing money. Whether it comes from the city, the Province, or the Feds its all tax money. Any money from developers comes from people too. There is no freebees.

I don't care about that. What I care about is building. More buses, more subways, the Smart-track idea. All of it. And I believe that Tory is the best person to secure the funding from the various sources to do it.

Go ahead, raise my taxes 10%. Put it all to transit. Please.

Anyone with a lick of sense understands about the real cost. And how difficult it is to put something like this together. Chow obviously doesn't or she wouldn't have put forth her 15 million per year for buses which has been thoroughly shot down. Her campaign has now resorted to claims of racism. Low dirty politics this. Very low. Shameful. And smacks of desperation.

You might be able to sling that crap at Ford. But not at Tory. She keeps these tactics up, instead of sticking to real issues, and she will lose badly, both the election, and her reputation.
Ah so sweet is thy admission that Tory's FreeTrack plan is anything and everything but free, is obviously NOT 'at no cost to taxpayers' and obviously, patently and wholeheartedly a blatant bald-faced lie.

Now that you have finally admitted this fact and thus the basis of funding is so obviously flawed and false we now can delve into the real issues of Tory's lack of credibility and thus placing our blind faith and trust in a candidate who has so willingly, freely and repeatedly placed self-political gain above all else and at the expense and with deeply, disturbing disrespect for taxpayers and the residents of Toronto. He sounds quite similar to Rob Ford. I don't see a difference.

This is not the formula necessary for expunging and erasing the legacy of the last 4 failed years nor is it the pathway for creating a environment for addressing 'real' issues' for 'real people' and creating a 'vision' of Toronto that can be supported. When the basic premises of his campaign promises are built on lies, then supporting him dooms us to repeat the mistakes of the past FORD MORE years and will prove to be a legacy of utter failure.

Good lord man, a candidate who supports the waste and squandering of +$2billion of property taxes and scarce resources on the purely political BDL subway GRAVY TRAIN should by default tell us that he is not a candidate worthy of support. And then to compound further indignity and injury to taxpayers, to residents and the city of Toronto he proposes and promotes his FreeTrack fantasy transit plan as a viable 'free', 'no cost', 'no pain to the pocketbook' solution to our transit woes' when all evidence is contrary to his claims.

Hell no!

Enough of FORDMORE years.

"Say NO to JOHHNY 'STORYTELLER' TORY, the teller of tall tales with his Magical Mystery Dream Weaving campaign promises!"

We need to support candidates that actually have the courage to speak the truth, as Frank Di Giorgio, Joe Pennacheitti and the U. of T. study authors state is necessary if we are to successfully address the issues that are truly facing the city and thus move forward.

Ford and Tory have proven time again that they are obviously not capable of doing this.

Chow and Soknacki have demonstrated that they are.

This has become so evident and clear.
 
Last edited:
And it will make no difference my"admission". Oooo. So I stated that NO politician can ever really come through with their exact promise. Oh my what an admission! Stop the presses! Quick some one forward this thread to all the news organizations so they can print this and completely de-rail the Tory campaign! The jig is up!

Yup...I'm mocking you.....

And Chow has promised buses at 15 million per year. So she is a lier to. Actually a bigger one because she is attempting to Co-op the origional plan for LRT and the TTC properly budgetted plan as her plan. She can't even come up with anything origional. Nothing.

And she used Warren Kinseela to play dirty politics and then ammepted to disavow him when it backfired.

As to the origional title I do trust Tory. To get things done without partisan politics, dirty attacks, divisiveness. To bring levels of govt and other funding sources together to accomplish things. That's why he has my vote. And so many more.

Come oct 27 you will be disapointed. She is being out campaigned. She is a spent force. She offers nothing to improving the city beyond vague promises for the children. I've watched her in three debates now, she is generally uninformed, requiring her scripted noted constantly.

She was fine as back voice on council and in Ottawa, riding on Jack's coat-tails. On her own?

She is simply lacking.......
 
I truly hope she is not our next Mayor!

Olivia Chow's grasp of Toronto issues weak at best.

TORONTO - Trying to pin down mayoral candidate Olivia Chow as to where she stands on key issues is kind of like fighting to catch an errant hot-air balloon that, repeatedly propelled by sudden wind gusts, keeps floating off to a higher altitude.

This is not to suggest she's any more full of hot air than the average politician. In fact, during our hour-long sit-down interview earlier this past week, she showed a very tender side when questioned about the loss of husband Jack Layton from cancer three years ago and a recent debilitating bout of shingles that killed her facial nerves, from which it took her 18 months to recover.

Chow said she still can't wear contact lenses because her tear ducts are gone and when she smiles she looks "mean sometimes."

As for Layton, she said when it was his birthday a few days prior to our interview, she went through the day "trying not to cry."

I have no doubt she works hard. I saw her in action during her years at City Hall prior to 2006.

But, after trying to prod her for answers, it became clear to me that much of her platform is being delivered from 30,000 feet and that her grasp of detail on current city issues is considerably lacking. That is despite her 28 years in politics, 20 of them as a Toronto school trustee and city councillor in the downtown ward of Trinity-Spadina.

I find it hard to believe that being away from City Hall-- up in Ottawa since early 2006 when she was first elected as an MP--is the reason.

For instance, I was surprised with her response when I asked how she'd handle the Pan Am Games file as mayor of the host city.

"Isn't it mostly provincial?" she asked between bites of her egg-white-only omelette and fries. "It seems like they are the ones who hired and fired."

When I pressed her for a more, shall we say, fulfilling answer on the Games, she said she hoped there would be local benefits sparking young kids to "learn the game." She didn't elaborate what game she meant but added she hoped there would be a legacy program from the Pan Am Games to "make it so much more affordable and easier" for volunteers to have good tournaments to keep young people out of trouble.

Chow appeared to have no idea what the city was doing in the way of Pan Am legacy projects--$20 million worth to be exact --some of which will include the kinds of things to which she referred. The bulk of the money will not be spent on kids but on pet projects to light the Bloor viaduct (at least $2.8 million); to host dignitaries ($1 million); and to prop up starving artists/entertainers (close to $5 million).

When I asked how she'd handle traffic chaos that will ensue with "Pan Am only" lanes, she asked why they needed to close lanes. She didn't seem to know that, from July 10 to 26 next year, one lane will be closed to regular traffic on the DVP, the Gardiner, Hwy. 407 and all major highways around Toronto to get athletes and Pan Am poobahs to events faster.

I wanted to know if she supports a renewal of police Chief Bill Blair's contract for a further five-year term, another hot-button issue. After all, she was a member of the Toronto Police Services Board in 2000, until she was forced to resign for interfering in a violent protest at Queen's Park by the Ontario Coalition Against Poverty.

She said she'd push for renewal of the contract now but wanted to do a "round of consultations" before making a final decision.

"I haven't looked at the Police Services Board ... I would consult with members on the PSB," she said.

When I brought up bad blood on the board and recent attempts to muzzle vice-chairman Michael Thompson over his criticism of Blair, Chow said she hasn't gotten into the "dynamics" of the board.

Then she asked me if council had voted for Blair's contract renewal yet, even though the PSB has yet to even discuss the contract.

Questions about how she'd tackle the bloat on the police force didn't serve up much more.

"You need to look at the contract ... there may be places where we can negotiate," she said, asking me if the police still have a compressed work week, something they'd tried to tackle years ago.

(The answer is yes. I also mentioned the overlap in shifts which KPMG identified in 2011 as a highly inefficient way to do police business. She knew nothing about that.)

Ditto for her grasp of how to bring entrepreneurship and innovation back to Toronto.

She told me she's hoping to make Toronto the trading hub of Chinese currency and would create Global Toronto (an agency to sell Toronto that would combine the work of the city's Economic Development department and David Miller's creation, Invest Toronto). She also talked about reducing red tape, although again she didn't elaborate.

When I suggested it was taxation and gridlock driving business out of Toronto (and Ontario), she claimed former premier Dalton McGuinty had put a stop to lowering business taxes.

I think she meant education taxes but, in any event, business taxes have been reduced every year courtesy of a plan devised by her opponent in the mayor's race, David Soknacki, when he was budget chief under Miller. This year the residential tax hike was 2.71% while the business hike was 0.77%, one-third of the rate increase for residential properties.

It became obvious as the hour went on that Chow has not progressed beyond her days at City Hall under Mayor Mel Lastman and Miller when she kept herself busy as the Children and Youth Advocate.

In fact, when I asked her what she and Premier Kathleen Wynne have in common besides being former Toronto school trustees, she said they are both committed to children's issues and better after-school programs.

"You know the kinds of things that get me excited," she said.

When I asked her to elaborate on her drive for more after-school programs, she was the most detailed on that file--which wasn't saying much. She said she hopes to find teenagers who have a skill--art, writing, singing or swimming--and who could teach kids anywhere, whether it be at Regent Park, through boys' and girls' clubs and at mosques.

"That's where (we get) our next generation of athletes, writers or artists ... we need to develop their skills," she said.

Chow also hopes to create her own version of Section 37 agreements, in which developers building infrastructure projects valued at more than $50 million have to create apprenticeship programs for youth.

"We have $18.6 billion of capital budget ... we can use that to work for us," she said. (For the record, I have no clue where she got the $18.6 billion.)

Even when I asked how she will convince the suburbs to vote for her, she mentioned her "modest and practical" idea to increase the number of buses serving places like Scarborough-- and then she returned to her children's services mantra.

I even tried to suggest taxpayers want the basics done like potholes filled and roads repaired on a timely basis-- without having to struggle through endless construction as we are this summer.

But no, she insisted residents really want their kids to have good programs.

"I've stood before at least 44 if not 60 Food Basics and Walmarts ... all the parents tell me their kids can't find a job," Chow said. "When I talk about after-school activities they say, 'Oh wow that's really good.'

"There's lots that can be done in terms of the suburbs ... let's just have City Hall deliver the kind of services that are needed, especially to those who need it the most; ensure they are not left behind."

I didn't have the heart to tell her I heard David Miller express the same mantra about ensuring no one is "left behind" in 2006.





OUT OF THE MOUTH OF OLIVIA

ON HER LACK OF PRIVATE-SECTOR EXPERIENCE:
"That's not true. I've been cashier at Shoppers Drug Mart for two or three years and a waitress for six years ... I sold paintings, photos ... I had a business when I was an artist. I had three or four contracts."

ON HOW SHE, AN AVID CYCLIST, GETS AROUND TO CAMPAIGN:
"I have a car ... Equinox ... you don't think I can do 10 activities on one day. Do you think I can fly?"

ON HER PLANS TO SCRAP THE SCARBOROUGH SUBWAY IF ELECTED:
"I have the courage to say what needs to be done ... I have the courage of my convictions ... just because Rob Ford and John Tory think it is the right thing to do doesn't mean it's right."

ON THE T-SHIRTS WITH ROB FORD QUOTES (DELIVERED AFTER HE GOT OUT OF REHAB) GIVEN TO MEMBERS OF THE CITY HALL PRESS GALLERY:
"It was Jamey Heath's thing (her communication adviser) ... I didn't go around handing them out. We weren't doing anything with it."

ON WHETHER THERE WILL BE MORE AFTERSCHOOL PROGRAMS IF SHE BECOMES MAYOR:
"Absolutely. I think it's really important for our children to grow up smart and strong especially in an at-risk neighbourhood and in all communities."

ON THE EXPERIENCE WITH HER HOUSEHOLD GARBAGE BEING PICKED UP BY PRIVATE HAULERS (CONSIDERING SHE TWEETED CONCERNS THE FIRST DAY IT WENT PRIVATE):
"It's worked quite well. My mom likes it. (We have) no issues."

ON HOW SHE'D BRING TOGETHER A VERY DYSFUNCTIONAL COUNCIL:
"By appealing to what they (councillors) are most passionate about ... and let them run (with it) as long as you don't break the piggy bank ... that's the difference between me and John Tory. I know how the city works."

ON WHY SHE WANTS TO BE MAYOR:
"Life is too short ... I want to get things done."

ON HOW MUCH SHE MISSES JACK LAYTON:
"I journey on ... it doesn't get any easier ... just different."

http://www.torontosun.com/2014/07/27/olivia-chows-grasp-of-toronto-issues-weak-at-best
 
And it will make no difference my"admission". Oooo. So I stated that NO politician can ever really come through with their exact promise. Oh my what an admission! Stop the presses! Quick some one forward this thread to all the news organizations so they can print this and completely de-rail the Tory campaign! The jig is up!

Yup...I'm mocking you.....

And Chow has promised buses at 15 million per year. So she is a lier to. Actually a bigger one because she is attempting to Co-op the origional plan for LRT and the TTC properly budgetted plan as her plan. She can't even come up with anything origional. Nothing.

And she used Warren Kinseela to play dirty politics and then ammepted to disavow him when it backfired.

As to the origional title I do trust Tory. To get things done without partisan politics, dirty attacks, divisiveness. To bring levels of govt and other funding sources together to accomplish things. That's why he has my vote. And so many more.

Come oct 27 you will be disapointed. She is being out campaigned. She is a spent force. She offers nothing to improving the city beyond vague promises for the children. I've watched her in three debates now, she is generally uninformed, requiring her scripted noted constantly.

She was fine as back voice on council and in Ottawa, riding on Jack's coat-tails. On her own?

She is simply lacking.......
Your admission of Tory's lies, highlights and reinforces the fact that John Tory is truly unworthy of 'faith and trust' being bestowed upon him.

"John Tory? You cannot trust that guy". "I really don't believe much of what he says and promises, but I will vote for him anyway", appears to be quite f*cked up, dontcha think?

Chow and Soknacki have not co-opted and claimed as their own original ideas, the twice approved LRT plans, they're just endorsing and supporting them, because they make sense.

And Chow's original Transit NOW plan certainly preceded the TTC proposal submitted to council which BTW endorsed her plan amongst other it's many other proposals to address 'real transit' issues for 'real people' in the short and intermediate term, whereas Tory's support for the BDL Gravy Tran extension is not viewed by the TTC as a viable plan and his FreeTrack fantasy choo-choo train plan is not original at all, but a Metrolinx plan, which BTW as you now know will have to paid for by taxpayers and not free as Tory has repeatedly lied about.

So why not be honest, Butler1000?

So why not be honest, John Tory? What have you got to lose? Oh yeah I know, were you to be honest it is a certainty you would not be electable.

It is achingly obvious, that the only two candidates who are speaking truth to the electorate and who are certainly deserving of having 'faith and trust' bestowed upon them, are David Soknacki and Olivia Chow.
 
One. Chow's plan isn't even close to the TTC's. Pretty much just musings with no idea of the real cost.

Two. Smart-track is an extension of the idea of electrifying Go rail, but intergrating it into one line and extending it to the airport, while placing it under the TTC and creating connections to other existing and future TTC projects.

Three. Read Gameboy's article. And keep reading it until it sinks in.

Four. And this is the most important. I would would suggest you take up yoga, maybe meditation, or if neccessary perhaps join a Buhddist temple, because on Oct 27 Tory is probably going to win I don't think you can take four more years of you and your unions not having their way with the city.

But keep posts your little rants. The hyperbole is rather incredible to see, you have to be a Chow campaign volunteer at this point too. The flip-flop where after all of the attacks on Ford over the years you actually said you would vote for him over Tory(once he moved into the lead) was priceless!