STI testing given the current legal situation

  • Thread starter Thread starter Moderator
  • Start date Start date
Good to know and more proof of an industry being forced underground. It's shameful what this proposed legislation is about to do.
 
Cripes. Shameful for both the legislation but also the ignorance on the part of clients. Sheesh.
 
the SCC has to step in. how they can let the Harper regime violate their decision?
 
the SCC has to step in. how they can let the Harper regime violate their decision?

It doesn't really work that way. And, as I've said many times before, C-36 isn't a direct violation. It's arguably a violation of the spirit of the decision. The previous regime criminalized the sexworkers for practicing their trade and therefore endangered their safety IF THEY CHOSE TO OBEY THE LAW.

The proposed laws do not criminalize sexworkers for practicing their trade. However, their safety is endangered IF THEY CHOOSE TO HELP CLIENTS BREAK THE LAW.

That's a fundamental and significant difference in fact and principle.

Of course, the issue of criminalizing the purchase of sex goes right back to the issue of whether we as a society want to accept prostitution (and if we do, why any law that indirectly jeopardizes its willing participants can be just and fair).
 
The proposed laws do not criminalize sexworkers for practicing their trade. However, their safety is endangered IF THEY CHOOSE TO HELP CLIENTS BREAK THE LAW.

if one side is criminalized sexworkers will be still criminalized.
 
if one side is criminalized sexworkers will be still criminalized.

Is that an existential assertion?

They will still be at risk for personal safety, but they won't be at risk of criminal prosecution.

Let's look at it another way - can anyone identify a situation or set of facts where it an individual is permitted (or indeed protected by law) to aid and abet another person in committing a crime?
 
Is that an existential assertion?

They will still be at risk for personal safety, but they won't be at risk of criminal prosecution.

Let's look at it another way - can anyone identify a situation or set of facts where it an individual is permitted (or indeed protected by law) to aid and abet another person in committing a crime?

in Sweden after the nordic law was passed. Sexworkers are being stalked by police if they are identified as one they are watched looking to arrest their clients. and this summer landlords are warned not to rent thier places to sexworkers.
 
in Sweden after the nordic law was passed. Sexworkers are being stalked by police if they are identified as one they are watched looking to arrest their clients. and this summer landlords are warned not to rent thier places to sexworkers.

In all over the world, criminalization means threat of criminal prosecution.

Are you referring to landlords in Canada? Yes, it is certainly an issue. I am involved with a large urban housing organization. We have a group of clients who are known street level sexworkers. At some point, we will need decide whether to permit incall activity. It's not going to be an easy or clear decision.
 
in Sweden after the nordic law was passed. Sexworkers are being stalked by police if they are identified as one they are watched looking to arrest their clients. and this summer landlords are warned not to rent thier places to sexworkers.

I was in Sweden on business just after the Nordic law was passed. We were warned by our host company not to stop if approached by any female as the police had undercover female officers on the street who would approach men, start a conversation, quickly switch the conversation to sex and then arrest the guy for attempting to purchase sexual services. Arrest statistics needed to be high to satisfy feminist groups that controlled the Swedish government. We stayed together as a group when out at night in Stockholm so no member was ever approached by I know the hosts were plenty worried.
 
In all over the world, criminalization means threat of criminal prosecution.

Are you referring to landlords in Canada? Yes, it is certainly an issue. I am involved with a large urban housing organization. We have a group of clients who are known street level sexworkers. At some point, we will need decide whether to permit incall activity. It's not going to be an easy or clear decision.



landlords in Sweden

http://www.thelocal.se/20140610/summer-apartments-used-for-prostitution
 
I was in Sweden on business just after the Nordic law was passed. We were warned by our host company not to stop if approached by any female as the police had undercover female officers on the street who would approach men, start a conversation, quickly switch the conversation to sex and then arrest the guy for attempting to purchase sexual services. Arrest statistics needed to be high to satisfy feminist groups that controlled the Swedish government. We stayed together as a group when out at night in Stockholm so no member was ever approached by I know the hosts were plenty worried.

That is disgusting/worrisome to hear and I hope it doesn't happen here.
 
I understand the obviously helpful information about anonymous testing that was included in that thread .... BUT .... big BUT...

I almost wonder if that post planted a seed of doubt and distrust in people who didn't previously feel that way. Did you see how many "I never thought of that!" type comments there were?

Why scare people by posting info like that?

Who's to say that everyone who now reads that thread gets tested less often and those that didn't read it get tested just as they always did?

Exactly. I'd like to think that my fellow man is responsible and intelligent. But, as I type this, it occurs to me that STIs have to be reported to public health, and public health may well undertake an investigation, which if we were to be honest about would disclose our pending illegal activities.

Come to think of it, this aspect needs to be addressed ASAP. It would certainly be against public interest to discourage johns from seeking medical attention or to be dishonest about sexual encounters.
 
Info in this thread is for BC residents but some of the general points raised in the thread may apply to Ontario also.
https://perb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?203279-STI-testing-given-the-current-legal-situation
No threat here, unless anyone wants it to be. Just another cause for unnecessary grief and worry. Your medical history and condition are proof of nothing, except for the fact that you (may) have contracted an STI from someone, somewhere.

As posters in the above thread have pointed out, the biggest concern is that of increased feelings of marginalization among sex workers/clients, and hence, less willingness to get tested - nothing more.
 
If wondered that...if you are a member of the SCC, certainly u watch the news, read the papers....i wonder what they think.

It doesn't matter, the Supreme Court doesn't just come out of nowhere and make rulings. They can all read the newspaper one morning and say "Hey, that's not what we meant" and it means nothing until such time as a case is presented before them, after however many years of working it's way through the lower courts.