Potential counter-measures to Bill C-36

freedom3

New member
Mar 7, 2004
1,430
7
0
Toronto
Here is my summary of the potential counter-measures to Bill C-36. Any constructive comments are welcome.

Overview: Under Bill C-36 women (other than streetwalkers) are never charged. Plus, as long as women are paying reasonable commercial rates to assistants (ie. bookers, guards, drivers, etc.), those people are safe as well. It is only the johns (us) who are at risk. The key, therefore, as I see it, is determining if the woman is truly an escort or an undercover cop.

(1) In another thread, I suggested paying online through an offshore payment company in advance to try to separate the payment of the consideration from the sex, similar to how the buyers on The Wire would pay one person for the drug and another person would give him the drugs. However, I think method this would lead to a huge administrative hassle for the agencies and is impractical.

(2) Another poster (capital hunter) suggested: “Another option would be what I proposed a few weeks ago, the "virtual girlfriend" idea for which no payment of any kind would be made to her (no consideration) though it would be to her landlord (impossible to prove as you will also have your name on her lease). For this you need to already have very trusting long time known SPs who fully trust you and are willing to accept this (adding your name to her lease) for which she has to be single too. In my case I have a few private dancers whom I know for years and know everything about them. If no-sex contact/lap private dancing too becomes illegal I may suggest this to all and hopefully a couple would accept.” However, it is clear that this method would not permit seeing a variety of different escorts and new, future escorts.

(3) Trying to use falizar or preferred411 in reverse, ie. to confirm that the escort is real and not an undercover officer. However, another poster (fuji) pointed out the following: “The easy way to accomplish this is to offer three busted johns a plea down to conditional discharge in exchange for their participation in a police sting. You could easily get a reference from a very prolific reviewer that way, and therefore more "trusted". In fact, the more prolific they are, the more likely they will eventually be snared. Anyone who thinks the police don't know how to do their jobs or can be defeated by some network where everybody mutually confesses to crime is crazy. And once busted your "references" will be subpoenad and used against you in court as proof of a pattern of behavior.” I agree that this method is definitely open to being compromised.

(4) In my view, the best idea (in terms of practicality and efficacy) I have heard to far is from jcpro. Based on his idea, I posted the following in another thread: “If it is legal to pay for a nude massage, then the man comes in and says he is paying for the nude massage [this deals with escorts wanting to be paid in advance of services], then the man and woman undress and the man gropes the woman [something an undercover escort would be unlikely to permit], then they have sex [the man feeling confident at this point that she is not an undercover copy]. At that point, the only risk would be the cops bursting in for a bust but the odds of that happening are tiny and, even if they did, the woman would have no motive to cooperate because she could not be charged and the man would invoke his right to remain silent. ‘sexual services’ are not currently defined in the act, that is true. But, it could still work. This could become the standard procedure: (1) The man calls to book a massage (not a nude massage, only a massage), (2) when he arrives, he pays for the massage, and (3) she undresses and he is allowed to touch her to establish that she is not a cop. It doesn't even need to be a massage. It could be therapy. Or fashion advice. Fashion advisers don't need to be registered.”

Anyways, as I said, if anyone has anything constructive to say, please post.
 
From page 5 of the technical paper that was produced
To determine whether a particular act constitutes a “sexual service for consideration” or
“prostitution”, the court will consider whether the service is sexual in nature and whether the
purpose of providing the service is to sexually gratify the person who receives it. Specifically, a
contract or agreement, whether express or implied, for a specific sexual service in return for
some form of consideration is required.25 In particular, the consideration must be contingent on
the provision of a particular sexual service and the contract or agreement must be entered into
before the sexual service is provided.26 Sexual activity involving no expectation of getting paid
for the services provided does not meet the test.27 Sexual activity in the context of ongoing
relationships also fails to meet the test, unless the evidence shows that the alleged consideration
was contingent on the provision of a particular sexual service.28 In one case, gifts given to the
complainant were not viewed as consideration for sexual favours rendered, but rather as gifts
given “dans le cadre plus large de la relation affective entre l’accusé et le plaignant”.29 Another
case held that the phrase “sexual services for consideration” is not intended to apply to
consensual actions between those having an affinity towards one another.30
The following activities have been found to constitute a sexual service or an act of prostitution, if
provided in return for some form of consideration: lap-dancing, which involves sitting in the
client’s lap and simulating sexual intercourse;31 masturbation of a client in the context of a
massage parlour, whether or not the client climaxes;32 and, sado-masochistic activities, provided
that the acts can be considered to be sexually stimulating/gratifying.33 However, jurisprudence is
clear that neither acts related to the production of pornography,34 nor stripping35 meet the test. In
most cases, physical contact, or sexual interaction, between the person providing the service and
the person receiving it is required; however, acts for which consideration is provided that take
place in a private room in a club and that are sexual in nature, but do not involve physical contact
between the “client” and “performer”, such as self-masturbation, have been found to constitute
prostitution.36
Seems that if you fall in love with a hooker, and there is one of those threads every month, you are off the hook as long as you negotiate and pay after. Or you make porno's
 
Yea you can just film it and be protected under freedom of expression. That's really the best and only real defense. Everything else is technically illegal so u could get caugjt
 
Yea you can just film it and be protected under freedom of expression. That's really the best and only real defense. Everything else is technically illegal so u could get caugjt

So setup a porn studio - kinda like boudouir pohotography, except you get to interact with the model.
 
Freedom, that is not correct about hiring other people to work with indoor sex workers.
They can hire people who do not materially benefit "in the context of a commercial enterprise that offers sexual services".
So they can hire a maid or handyman but not anyone like a booker or driver etc. who helps them with there sex services job.
 
If you book with known agencies, SPs & MPAs, the risk for the customers will be about the same after the new law comes in as it is now, ie minimal.

TOFTT with a new backpage girl could become more of a danger rush, same with picking up a streetwalker.
 
From page 5 of the technical paper that was produced

Seems that if you fall in love with a hooker, and there is one of those threads every month, you are off the hook as long as you negotiate and pay after. Or you make porno's

Scary shit, if this is how the law is actually going to work:
The following activities have been found to constitute a sexual service or an act of prostitution, if
provided in return for some form of consideration: lap-dancing, which involves sitting in the
client’s lap and simulating sexual intercourse;31 masturbation of a client in the context of a
massage parlour, whether or not the client climaxes;32 and, sado-masochistic activities, provided
that the acts can be considered to be sexually stimulating/gratifying.33 However, jurisprudence is
clear that neither acts related to the production of pornography,34 nor stripping35 meet the test. In
most cases, physical contact, or sexual interaction, between the person providing the service and
the person receiving it is required; however, acts for which consideration is provided that take
place in a private room in a club and that are sexual in nature, but do not involve physical contact
between the “client” and “performer”, such as self-masturbation, have been found to constitute
prostitution.36

In one fell swoop, Canada will become a puritanical paradise.
 
...and the man gropes the woman [something an undercover escort would be unlikely to permit]

Yep. Unlikely indeed.

And just like that you've hanged yourself. Purchasing prostitution be damned - now you're instantly arrested for sexual assault. Of a police officer, no less. Best case you drop to your knees to desperately beg and cry to PLEASE be allowed to plead guilty to a buying prostitution charge.

More likely, life will never again be a shadow of as good as it was a minute ago. Criminal record, life destroyed AND welcome to the sex offenders registry...

I'll be having a large fries with that.

(IF - you're LUCKY enough to be graced with even with menial wage-slavery work ever again.)
 
If you book with known agencies, SPs & MPAs, the risk for the customers will be about the same after the new law comes in as it is now, ie minimal.
Tend to agree.

The following activities have been found to constitute a sexual service or an act of prostitution, if
provided in return for some form of consideration: lap-dancing, which involves sitting in the
client’s lap and simulating sexual intercourse;31 masturbation of a client in the context of a
massage parlour, whether or not the client climaxes;32 and, sado-masochistic activities, provided
that the acts can be considered to be sexually stimulating/gratifying.33 However, jurisprudence is
clear that neither acts related to the production of pornography,34 nor stripping35 meet the test. In
most cases, physical contact, or sexual interaction, between the person providing the service and
the person receiving it is required; however, acts for which consideration is provided that take
place in a private room in a club and that are sexual in nature, but do not involve physical contact
between the “client” and “performer”, such as self-masturbation, have been found to constitute
prostitution.36
Complete and utter bullshit.
 
You hire a companion. You meet, you pay the fee, go out on an evening, return to her place, chat a little and leave. Nothing illegal about that. You hire the same companion again, pay herthe fee but this time, decide to have sex instead of going out. Then you give her some money before you leave. Illegal? Yes. But how would you ever get caught? If the cops were waiting outside to intercept you, how would they ever prove that you paid for sex since they could not get a warrant to enter the premises of a person that never broke the la w and get evidence? Is a sting from a pseudo escort agency going to go on for more than a few days? Is it going to be worth to keep going for a measly 500 dollar fine?

There is going to be a proliferation of indy Massage places. There is an advertised fee for straight massage. You get the massage, then the MA points to your little head and the big one nods yes. Did you break the law yet since you did not initiate the request and you didn't offer money for the extra?. Would a ladycop give you a HJ so that she can nail you when you give her the tip?

I think that this law is unenforceable. They cannot prevent the ppurchase of sex through prosecution.