One of the reasons we don't have sting operations in Canada - they could be illegal
An Overview of Canadian Misleading Advertising Law
The federal Competition Act is Canada’s principal, but by no means only, legislation governing misleading advertising. In addition to this federal legislation, a broad array of other federal and provincial laws can apply to advertising and marketing practices, including provincial consumer protection laws, sectoral legislation and federal packaging and labeling legislation.
The Competition Act contains both civil and criminal misleading advertising provisions that apply to false or misleading claims made to promote the supply or use of products (including services).
For a claim to be misleading, it must be proven that: (i) a representation has been made, (ii) to the public, (iii) to promote a product or business interest, (iv) that is literally false or misleading (or with a false or misleading general impression) and (v) that the claim is “material” (i.e., likely to influence a consumer into buying or using a product or otherwise altering their conduct).
Criminal misleading advertising is substantially similar, but also requires that a claim be made “knowingly or recklessly” (i.e., with intent).
Some important points to note about misleading advertising law in Canada include:
1. The misleading advertising sections of the Competition Act are broad enough to apply to claims made relating to both services and “any business interest”.
2. A representation to a single person may be caught.
3. Both the literal meaning and the “general impression” of a claim are relevant in determining whether a claim is false or misleading (i.e., a representation that is literally true may, nevertheless, be false or misleading if the “general impression” of the claim is false or misleading).
4. It is not necessary to show that any person has actually been deceived or misled as a result of a claim.
5. It is also not necessary to show that a claim was made to Canadian consumers (i.e., as opposed to cross-border marketing) or was made in a publicly accessible place (i.e., the sections can apply to “private” marketing events, telemarketing activities, etc.).
The Competition Bureau has issued an Information Bulletin (Misleading Representations and Deceptive Marketing Practices: Choice of Criminal or Civil Track under the Competition Act) that outlines its approach to determining whether to pursue the criminal or civil track in relation to misleading advertising. In general, the Bureau will in most cases follow the civil track unless certain criteria are satisfied including clear and compelling evidence that misleading advertising was engaged in intentionally and that a criminal prosecution would be in the public interest.
Penalties for misleading advertising include “administrative monetary penalties” or “AMPs” (essentially civil fines) of up to $750,000 (for individuals) and up to $10 million (for corporations) and orders to stop the activity or compensate consumers harmed by misleading claims. The penalties for criminal misleading advertising include fines of up to $200,000 and/or imprisonment for up to one year (on summary conviction) or fines in the discretion of the court and/or imprisonment for up to 14 years (on indictment).
In addition to the “general” misleading advertising provisions, the Competition Act also contains a number of other criminal and civil provisions that prohibit or regulate specific types of marketing practices, including deceptive telemarketing, deceptive prize notices, double ticketing, multi-level marketing, pyramid selling schemes, representations not based on adequate and proper tests, false or misleading ordinary selling price claims, misleading or unauthorized use of tests and testimonials, bait and switch selling, the sale of a product above its advertised price and promotional contests.
I believe I have read in the past court orders requiring the offender upon conviction to provide the services as advertised to the victim. What female undercover cop wants to take a chance on that.