How much edumakation do you have?

What is your level of education?

  • Did not complete high school

    Votes: 9 5.5%
  • Completed high school

    Votes: 15 9.1%
  • Did not complete undergratuate degree

    Votes: 17 10.3%
  • Completed undergraduate degree

    Votes: 46 27.9%
  • Did not complete graduate degree

    Votes: 9 5.5%
  • Completed graduate degree

    Votes: 51 30.9%
  • Did not complete Ph.D.

    Votes: 4 2.4%
  • Completed Ph. D.

    Votes: 14 8.5%

  • Total voters
    165
Dear buttercup. I tend to agree with bluelaser and his points with IQ and the armed forces. He also seems to have some credible experience with our forces.

More and more organisations are relying less and less on IQ.

Some op the top orgs are focusing on other things like behaviour and technical competencies to pick candidates for the position. Also references and your ability to do the job come into play. Some of these companies have a pretty good structure w.r.t their priorities and the competencies they are looking for in candidates. Obviously there are the educational requirements and experience that come into play.

My point with all this is that there are many misconception with the IQ. These tests can also be learned by doing them over again or figuring out how they are structured by people with common intelligence.
 
In Denmark we interpreted the results of the IQ test this way:

Over 110: disqualified
80-109 : enlisted soldiers
under 80: Officers

;) Nice. I remember one of my dad's favourite jokes. What's the most dangerous thing in the world? An officer with a map. I found myself spending a few weeks with time to kill between training so I was attached to a unit conducting a training exercise just as a general operations officer when I was a cherry Lt. The OC handed me a tasking to set up an OP at a given position and assigned me an iltis (jeep) with basic supplies, a map and a compass. So I walk up to the platoon I was "in charge" of and said I needed a volunteer to help me recce the position. Everyone exchanged glances and no one spoke up for a few seconds. Then the Sgt stepped forward and said "Sir, no offence, but there's a life-fire artillery range that's active right around these parts, so no one is going to volunteer so long as you're the one doing the navigating. We've played that game before. If you hand over the map, I'll go with you." That's when I realized it wasn't despite my dad's laughing every time he told it, it wasn't really a joke.
 
;) Nice. I remember one of my dad's favourite jokes. What's the most dangerous thing in the world? An officer with a map. I found myself spending a few weeks with time to kill between training so I was attached to a unit conducting a training exercise just as a general operations officer when I was a cherry Lt. The OC handed me a tasking to set up an OP at a given position and assigned me an iltis (jeep) with basic supplies, a map and a compass. So I walk up to the platoon I was "in charge" of and said I needed a volunteer to help me recce the position. Everyone exchanged glances and no one spoke up for a few seconds. Then the Sgt stepped forward and said "Sir, no offence, but there's a life-fire artillery range that's active right around these parts, so no one is going to volunteer so long as you're the one doing the navigating. We've played that game before. If you hand over the map, I'll go with you." That's when I realized it wasn't despite my dad's laughing every time he told it, it wasn't really a joke.

You may enjoy this joke also:


There is an old story from the heyday of the Soviet Union. As part of their May Day celebrations they were parading their latest weapon systems down the street in front of the Kremlin. There was a long column of their newest tanks, followed by a row of tractors pulling missiles. Behind these weapons were four pick-up trucks carrying older men in business suits waving to the crowds.

Seeing this display, the Communist party boss turned to his defense secretary. He praised the tanks and missiles and then said that he didn’t understand the men in business suits. The defense secretary explained that these men were economists, and "their destructive capacity is incredible."
 
Dear buttercup. I tend to agree with bluelaser and his points with IQ and the armed forces. He also seems to have some credible experience with our forces.

More and more organisations are relying less and less on IQ.

Some op the top orgs are focusing on other things like behaviour and technical competencies to pick candidates for the position. Also references and your ability to do the job come into play. Some of these companies have a pretty good structure w.r.t their priorities and the competencies they are looking for in candidates. Obviously there are the educational requirements and experience that come into play.

My point with all this is that there are many misconception with the IQ. These tests can also be learned by doing them over again or figuring out how they are structured by people with common intelligence.

I also know a lot of people with highly advanced degrees that get it simply through extremely hard work and only an average IQ. My sister is a great example. She has 6 degrees and is working on her 2nd Ph.D. I love her, but she's an idiot. She has less than a thimble of common sense, and she squeeked through high school with an 85% average by working hours upon hours every day to study. No job, no extra-curriculars, no parties, no going out with friends. Her 6 pieces of paper make her educated, they don't make her smart. While there is some casual relationship between the two, you don't need to be smart or in possession of a high IQ to get into university or to complete university credit. She isn't a fast learner, she isn't good at making decisions quickly. If you were stick her on a battlefield, she'd answer the Sgt's question of "What do you want us to do now, Ma'am?" with a blank stare no matter how much training you gave her.

I spent a fair bit of time with average non-coms. Both aviation types, like mechanics and ground crew, and army types, like infantry and artillery. I even worked with a few sailors in my day. The sharpest, smartest and best leaders I knew were all NCOs. And to a man, they enlisted because University wasn't an option for them. They didn't get the grades in school because of their family's economic station. If the military had bothered to actually evaluate these men, they would have seen rather quickly that these guys should be the ones climbing the Officer ranks. But because they had been busting their balls as teenagers helping the family pay the bills, and enlisted to make enough money to help pay for their little brother's to not have to work, to focus on school, and to go to University, they lacked the educational foundation to be successful in University. So they are career Sgts.

Even if there is a casual relationship between education and IQ, there is no relationship at all between education and the ability to command troops. The Canadian system, that Buttercup praised, ensures that only the privileged can be officers and command troops. It's the antiquated British system of nobility being commissioned and no one else with a shiny coating that makes it look modern. I'm sure if you wanted to, you could show people with high IQ's do better in University than those without, but my sister is an example of an average IQ being able to manage it. But what you can't do is convince me based on some mathematical or logical theory that educated people do better as commanders in the military. That's a pile of horseshit, and the sooner Canada does away with the system of recruiting officers from the upper classes and accepts that someone who can barely pass grade 10 math just might be a better candidate to command his platoon, they better off they'll be.

The idea that the military needs to weed down officers so they picked University because it's a good indicator of IQ or performance or anything is absolutely bullshit. They picked it because officers are supposed to be gentleman and gentleladies. As part of basic officer training, you learn how to eat a meal properly and how to plan a dinner for multiple guests taking into account their various dietary requirements for religious or ethnic reasons. They picked University because University is an indicator of sophistication. If you spent all day and all night working in the coal mines, you probably didn't get in to University so they don't have to worry about anyone seeing your rough, coal-stained hands at a Mess Dinner. Anyone that thinks the military requires a University education because it indicates anything but a person's class is wholly mistaken. The vast majority of officers I served with were the children of engineers, architects, lawyers, etc. People who got a free education despite the fact that their families could've easily afforded it. They joined to do minimum service and get out, scamming a full education for free. People who looked down on the non-coms as somehow not as good as them. Upper class each and every one of them. And these are the people who decide what military selection standards will be. For the record, I fully intended to serve an entire career in the military. I wanted to be a fighter pilot since I was a kid. As I got older and learned more about it, I believed in the cause and integrity of the military. It was what I knew. By the time I applied, I figured if I can get 3 flying tours out of my career, a stint instructing and maybe a stint doing demos, either the fighter jet air show demo or with the Snowbirds, I'd happily sit at a desk for the balance of my career. But then I had to deal with the officer corps, and after a decade, I just couldn't take it. Halfway to pension, and I'd had enough. Incompetency right to the top.

Did you know that Canada has roughly 90 Generals at any given time? For a force of about 90,000 active and reserve. 1 general for every 10k men. The UMSC, which complains about the bloat of it's upper-echelon, has 33 generals commanding just under 235,000 active and reserve. I think that should tell you where the priority of the Canadian Armed Forces is. These are the decisions your educated officers are making. Their education is worth shit. And that complete disregard for the 3M's, (The Mission, The Men, Me, supposedly in that order) is why I left early. I didn't get to do demo flying, I didn't get to teach. I did two flying tours and was staring at a desk surrounded by yesmen and politicians or a pay-out from major airlines, a big bump in pay and better benefits. I don't even care about the money, I still want to be a career airman, but the military we have isn't a military I want anything to do with.

We have a broken system here in Canada, based largely on this "University Education" requirement. It's the dumbest thing the military ever did. It's a failed experiment but unfortunately it has ensured the decision makers all went through this system and very few have exposure to what it was like before. I'm not saying it can never change, but it's going to be hard to do.
 
I had a feeling that when I started this thread that it might take on a life of its own. And I'm happy to see that it has.
I'm sure that we've all met smart people that don't have an education, and stupid people who do. Now the latest twist in this thread has to do with IQ and leadership ability. It seems to be a question of book smarts and street smarts- can a person have lots of both or is it always either/or?

Please indulge me in a small correction or two on the previous post. The third paragraph says 'Even if there is a casual relationship...' I'm betting the intent was to say causal. And the 90 Generals and 90,000 troops would be 1 General per 1,000, not 10,000 men. I'm convinced that these were careless errors, because the post is too articulate to be anything else.

Finally some thoughts of my own- which I don't really have, so I stole from someone else. Whether you're street smart or book smart, educated or not, one of the biggest predictors of success, no matter what you do, is persistence. But having some kind of smarts won't hurt.

"Nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not: nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not: the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent." -Calvin Coolidge

I do wonder if the incompetence at the top that the last poster talks about is due to incompetence or ignorance. Could it be that the folks at the top are just too far removed from the ground level to be able to manage effectively? Or could it be that they have a different agenda than the guys on the front lines? If the incompetence displayed by the top guys ends up benefiting themselves, then they're not incompetent. They are just assumed to be having the same agenda as the bottom guys, and since their decisions don't benefit the bottom guys, that's why they are seen as incompetent. It's an incorrect perception. Whenever you come across a situation that doesn't make any sense, ask yourself who benefits, and usually that clears things up. There are no accidents.
Of course, maybe the guys on top are incompetent. And in that case, we're screwed.
 
I had a feeling that when I started this thread that it might take on a life of its own. And I'm happy to see that it has.
I'm sure that we've all met smart people that don't have an education, and stupid people who do. Now the latest twist in this thread has to do with IQ and leadership ability. It seems to be a question of book smarts and street smarts- can a person have lots of both or is it always either/or?

Please indulge me in a small correction or two on the previous post. The third paragraph says 'Even if there is a casual relationship...' I'm betting the intent was to say causal. And the 90 Generals and 90,000 troops would be 1 General per 1,000, not 10,000 men. I'm convinced that these were careless errors, because the post is too articulate to be anything else.

Finally some thoughts of my own- which I don't really have, so I stole from someone else. Whether you're street smart or book smart, educated or not, one of the biggest predictors of success, no matter what you do, is persistence. But having some kind of smarts won't hurt.

"Nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not: nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not: the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent." -Calvin Coolidge

I do wonder if the incompetence at the top that the last poster talks about is due to incompetence or ignorance. Could it be that the folks at the top are just too far removed from the ground level to be able to manage effectively? Or could it be that they have a different agenda than the guys on the front lines? If the incompetence displayed by the top guys ends up benefiting themselves, then they're not incompetent. They are just assumed to be having the same agenda as the bottom guys, and since their decisions don't benefit the bottom guys, that's why they are seen as incompetent. It's an incorrect perception. Whenever you come across a situation that doesn't make any sense, ask yourself who benefits, and usually that clears things up. There are no accidents.
Of course, maybe the guys on top are incompetent. And in that case, we're screwed.

Wrong in the first case, right in the second. "Even if there's a casual relationship" meaning if you can find any link at all, let alone a "causal" link where one implies the other. My math was wrong though. Which is sad considering how much I love and do math.

If you want to talk about success in general, that's one thing. I'm speaking directly to the comment that the military selects high IQ applicants because they perform better. They don't. The proof is in the pudding. Is that also the case in a Fortune 500 company? No clue. I have no experience there. I'm just speaking to the military. Brains don't equal leadership, and an officer corps is, to a large extent, about leadership.
 
article in macleans from 2011

http://www.macleans.ca/news/canada/a-man-of-action/

i doubt the plan was implemented

Not the first time that's been suggested either. The same report comes out every few years from various sources, politicians never implement it. Because their "advisers" like officers. Officers seem respectable and presentable on TV and in interviews. Large because they are taken from the "gentleman's" class and taught to be civil. There's also the fact that all the decision makers at the top end of the military scale would be the first to go. If you trimmed down the military's upper-staff, you'd restructure it into a steeper pyramid, more at the bottom less at the top. Is a 3-star general going to recommend downsizing when he realizes that means there will cease to be a need for a half the 3-star generals we have? From the army side, we could easily get by with a 3-star in charge, a handful of 2 star, and a dozen or so 1 star. Colonels and below could handle the rest. Colonels SHOULD handle the rest. Think about it, a 1-star general is a "Brigadier General". Why are they running things smaller than brigade formations? For that matter, why are generals doing basic administrative work. For example, we have a 1-star generals that are "Chief of Staff" to other generals. How does that make any sense? We have a General in charge of financial operations, what? Why isn't that a colonel?

And don't forget, almost all these reports come from "former" generals. Currently serving generals can only say what they're told to say. Like police, military personnel don't have freedom of speech when it comes to the job. They can only say what they're told they're allowed to say. So if you take a document saying the military top-end should be downsized, even if you're the PM, and you walk into an office filled with Colonels and Majors, and you ask them for their opinion, they'll all look around for the PR Officer. And if they can't find one, they'll defer comment until they do. Anything else risks not only their job, but jail time. Pretty hard to get an honest opinion that way.
 
Brains don't equal leadership, and an officer corps is, to a large extent, about leadership.
No argument there. Did you know that Albert Einstein was asked to be the first Prime Minister of the newly born state of Israel? He said thanks but no thanks. I guess he found it easier trying to understand the nature of the universe than to understand people.
People are persuaded by reason, but moved by emotion. A leader is someone who can get people to do things. If anything, this takes a 'people smart' kind of brains. IQ tests don't measure that. But then, they were never supposed to. This is one of the things EQ is for, at least it should be.
 
Check out the Ontario Sunshine List under colleges and universities. See how much edumacation can pay!!!!!

One MacMaster prof makes over 300K

You're talking about outliers again though. We're back to the people who brought up Jobs and Gates as examples of how not having an education can pay. You can't look at the outliers. On average, an education doesn't equate to 6-figure salaries.