Tchaikovsky's violin concerto

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
 
Interesting if you compare / contrast this post with the one of Paulina Gretzky? I think many women get way too hung up on the whys and wherefores of the attention they receive. Beautiful women get noticed. And almost all women take pains to see that they are noticed.

The point is that once you are noticed................what is your next move. I fear that Ms Gretzky has to keep playing the card of being noticed for her appearance, whereas Ms Jansen has other cards to play. Another woman without the card of physical beauty has to find other ways to be noticed.

Many think this is unacceptable. Ms Gretzky should not gain an advantage from her physical assets and Ms Jansen should advance solely on her musical talents and abilities.

This is the way we are as humans. It probably applies more to women than men but I think we are all subjected to this to some extent. Physically attractive people get an initial advantage.

But I believe that in the long run everyone has to deliver substance or they are gone. Fifteen minutes of fame and flushed.

What about a highly ranked junior hockey star: drafted first overall, showered in fame and fortune, everyone's friend and seemingly invincible. But what does that player really have? All he has is a shot! Sure he gets a lot of chances and no stone will be left unturned to get him on the professional roster, but if he cannot deliver he ends up just like the 10th rounder who couldn't make it.

So I say to Ms Jansen: go for it and use whatever you have to maximize the chance of success. And to Ms Gretzky......................I feel sorry for you parents.
 
Interesting if you compare / contrast this post with the one of Paulina Gretzky? I think many women get way too hung up on the whys and wherefores of the attention they receive. Beautiful women get noticed. And almost all women take pains to see that they are noticed.

The point is that once you are noticed................what is your next move. I fear that Ms Gretzky has to keep playing the card of being noticed for her appearance, whereas Ms Jansen has other cards to play. Another woman without the card of physical beauty has to find other ways to be noticed.

Many think this is unacceptable. Ms Gretzky should not gain an advantage from her physical assets and Ms Jansen should advance solely on her musical talents and abilities.

This is the way we are as humans. It probably applies more to women than men but I think we are all subjected to this to some extent. Physically attractive people get an initial advantage.

But I believe that in the long run everyone has to deliver substance or they are gone. Fifteen minutes of fame and flushed.

What about a highly ranked junior hockey star: drafted first overall, showered in fame and fortune, everyone's friend and seemingly invincible. But what does that player really have? All he has is a shot! Sure he gets a lot of chances and no stone will be left unturned to get him on the professional roster, but if he cannot deliver he ends up just like the 10th rounder who couldn't make it.

So I say to Ms Jansen: go for it and use whatever you have to maximize the chance of success. And to Ms Gretzky......................I feel sorry for you parents.

The last point you are making is valid. With the funds Gretzky had available to him, IMHO, he should have given her a stellar education at one of the best american or canadian universities. The young Gretzky could probably have been a very attractive Ph.D.
 
Fantastic ..... I personally like this version of the Tchaikovsky concerto better than Oistrakh's.
 
Fantastic ..... I personally like this version of the Tchaikovsky concerto better than Oistrakh's.

As Rusty Crowe would say "you've got dead ears mate".

Paulina has that dead Valley Girl look in her eyes. This is her salad days, she'll be barefoot and pregnant in a short while. Jansen and her incredibly talented peer Hilary Hahn use glamour as a side show, they let their talent do the talking:

 
Don't forget Mutter

 
Among the many performances of Tchaikovsky's violin concerto
by the younger generation of violinsts I am very impressed by
Sayaka Shoji's rendition.
 
Interesting if you compare / contrast this post with the one of Paulina Gretzky? I think many women get way too hung up on the whys and wherefores of the attention they receive. Beautiful women get noticed. And almost all women take pains to see that they are noticed.
The point is that once you are noticed................what is your next move. I fear that Ms Gretzky has to keep playing the card of being noticed for her appearance, whereas Ms Jansen has other cards to play. Another woman without the card of physical beauty has to find other ways to be noticed.
Many think this is unacceptable. Ms Gretzky should not gain an advantage from her physical assets and Ms Jansen should advance solely on her musical talents and abilities.
This is the way we are as humans. It probably applies more to women than men but I think we are all subjected to this to some extent. Physically attractive people get an initial advantage.
But I believe that in the long run everyone has to deliver substance or they are gone. Fifteen minutes of fame and flushed.
What about a highly ranked junior hockey star: drafted first overall, showered in fame and fortune, everyone's friend and seemingly invincible. But what does that player really have? All he has is a shot! Sure he gets a lot of chances and no stone will be left unturned to get him on the professional roster, but if he cannot deliver he ends up just like the 10th rounder who couldn't make it.
So I say to Ms Jansen: go for it and use whatever you have to maximize the chance of success. And to Ms Gretzky......................I feel sorry for you parents.

Why does phsyical beauty attract your disdain? You think PG should not be advantaged because of her beaury, and yet JJ should advance solely on her musical talents?? WTF?

If a girl is capable of winning beauty contests, and especially if she has no other way of being noticed, why is that a reason to despise her? She's not doing you, or anyone, any harm. Why is looking good physically to be despised, while playing violin is deserving of advancement?

If a kid is to have any chance at an NHL career, he must spend his whole teenage years focussed on that and nothing more -- because he's competing with hugely talented kids who spend their teenage years that way. You ridicule him because all he has is a shot?

Bit more acceptance and tolerance, please, for people whose talents you don't approve of. Value people, please, for all they have and all they are -- and don't look for what's not there.
 
Good point buttercup.

However in life you get what you deserve and Wayne didn't marry Janet Jones for her intellect. There are probably a number of attractive LPGA players that should have been on the cover instead of someone with no talent to speak of. Golf is an elitist sport with racist and misogynistic traditions and Paulina fits right in with those trademarks.