How much edumakation do you have?

What is your level of education?

  • Did not complete high school

    Votes: 9 5.5%
  • Completed high school

    Votes: 15 9.1%
  • Did not complete undergratuate degree

    Votes: 17 10.3%
  • Completed undergraduate degree

    Votes: 46 27.9%
  • Did not complete graduate degree

    Votes: 9 5.5%
  • Completed graduate degree

    Votes: 51 30.9%
  • Did not complete Ph.D.

    Votes: 4 2.4%
  • Completed Ph. D.

    Votes: 14 8.5%

  • Total voters
    165
I have to admit that these results are quite surprising to me as well. I never thought there were so many of us...I was fed the same social misconceptions as everybody else.

It does feel comforting to know that there are so many on here very similar, which is little overwhelming as well. It's kind if starting to make sense now, why we do this, and what this industry does for us and for the society.

I have always said that the industry girls are important to our society and are the glue that holds us together. I thought I was way off with this belief but it makes sense, especially now. For me, these girls help me be the best husband I can, help me be at my optimum at my job, and make me feel normal by helping tame my
urge. I can't recall the last time I felt this normal, and can now have a decent conversation with women without the sexual thoughts polluting my mind. This helps me maintain optimal focus at my job without any distractions, and I am noticing my performance is significantly improved.

If they do this for me, I can only imagine what they do for the rest of you. I have a feeling that we have doctors, politicians, engineers, teachers, professors, religious leaders, people who influence, make change, and keep our society safe, and recharged.

I see some of these women as very smart ppl, and have lots of influence on me. You need to have a very strong character, principles, and know who you are to do what they do, perform at their optimum, and still maintain their personality and identity. I need a strong women to influence my mind, thoughts, and help open my mind to other possibilities and possibly flirt with love at times. They have the ability to stimulate that part of my brain that laid dormant for so long, and finally I feel alive and awake, and feels like I mean something.

Getting all this with mutual respect for each other without the drama is very powerful. I just hope that we don't take away too much of them for our own selfish needs.

So this is why I hobby. It's nice to know that I have lots in common with other hobbyist of similar mindset, not to say that we are similar, but I do find lots in common weather it's your education level, outlook on love, or just bonding over a girl we see, it's also kind of cool.

Anyways hobby hobbying :)

Robin Williams famously said god gave man a brain and a penis, but only enough blood to run one at a time. And with all due respect to ************ Trudeau, it's passion first, reason second. The little guy wants what it wants, and won't stop until he gets it. The first good news is that prostitution is no longer illegal. And as per your comments that the world's oldest profession makes it possible for us to be better workers, the next hurdle is to make these visits deductible expenses. Who will lead the charge?
 
Or pressure from parents, which is a huge problem messing up the kids.

I agree, pressure from parents could really mess up the kids.

In my case, I voted for the last category as I do have a Ph.D. But there was no pressure from anyone - I did it all for my own satisfaction. Fortunately, my degree did help me to attain and reach a position that I deemed rewarding and satifying. In my working life, I also did notice that a person with a higher degree would progress faster and more smoothly than a person without. This has to be in a relevant field of course.
 
that too my point is any path with no plan is doomed

Truer words were never spoken. Knowing exactly or almost exactly what you want is more than half the battle. And yes, parents can be misguided.
FYI, Billionaire Bill's parents weren't exactly thrilled to hear their son announce that he was quitting Harvard to start a company with his buddy in an industry that at the time no one ever heard of. His destiny was to be a lawyer or an MBA. However, he was very persuasive. He told his folks that the PC industry was not going to wait for him to finish his degree. He also convinced them that he had a clear plan, he was serious about it, and if it failed, then he could return to Harvard, which would wait for him. He was very much a man with a plan. He also claims that during his twenties, he never took a day off work.
 
The lawyer's office had a leaking faucet in the men's room. They call the plumber. The plumber arrives, leaving shit covered footprints all over the rug. He looks at the faucet, takes out a wrench and a ten cent washer, and fixes the drip. He writes a bill for $500, and gives it to the lawyer. The lawyer says "Are you kidding me? $500 for two minutes work? I'm a junior partner here, and I can't bill anywhere near that". The plumber says "When I was a lawyer, neither could I".

The two things you need to know to be a plumber:

1) Shit is supposed to flow down.

2) Don't bite your finger nails.

Yep. A few years ago I needed a plumber. After he finished the job I asked him about his training and stuff. He answered my questions and also mentioned that he had an honors degree in history. He also said he liked this work because he can leave his job at the end of the day.
 
The lawyer's office had a leaking faucet in the men's room. They call the plumber. The plumber arrives, leaving shit covered footprints all over the rug. He looks at the faucet, takes out a wrench and a ten cent washer, and fixes the drip. He writes a bill for $500, and gives it to the lawyer. The lawyer says "Are you kidding me? $500 for two minutes work? I'm a junior partner here, and I can't bill anywhere near that". The plumber says "When I was a lawyer, neither could I".

The two things you need to know to be a plumber:

1) Shit is supposed to flow down.

2) Don't bite your finger nails.

That's cute, but as with most jokes, it's a little off.

Average income for a plumber in Canada: $52,000.
Average income for a lawyer in Canada: $165,000.

Assuming $500/job, that means the plumber only does 104 jobs/year, or 2 jobs a week. I think any plumber would love that schedule. In reality, fixing a leak costs about $150, not $500.
 
The problem with your theory is that it applies mostly to the Canadian system now, and our system most closely mimics the old British method of "buying" a commission. Consider that in Her Majesty's Armed Forces across the pond and the American Military both selecte officers from among their most promising enlisted recruits while Canada maintains only those who come from that class of society that can afford an education (with the exception of those like me who are "hand picked" - so they claim - to have their education paid for) are worthy of consideration. A kid who toughed it out on the streets and had to work to raise money for his family in between avoiding the gangs just might make an outstanding officer, but in Canada he's immediately rejected unless he also managed to pull off the A average with volunteer activities and can demonstrate leadership and teamwork be also having been part of some sports teams. How that kid is supposed to afford the equipment, the time to practice/play and manage everything else is beyond me. I met lots of enlisted in my day who never had a chance due to social status and were therefore not good enough for the Canadian Armed Forces.

As a former commissioned officer in the military that engaged in training with foreign services, how do we stack up? We aren't as good. Don't misunderstand me, when it comes to "doing the job", like a pilot flying a plane or a soldier shooting bad guys, we're pretty damned good. But if we talk about the qualities of our leaders - the ability to inspire and garner respect, the ability to command loyalty and make the tough decisions - we can't keep up. The fact is, we aren't even close. We've got an officer corps of athletic academics, but that doesn't necessarily translate to what it takes to do the job.

We were one of the first military's that changed our operational art of war from attrition to maneuver. Cutting edge. But we still use an antiquated, class-based system for selecting our leaders. You can pretend that a university education makes them better for missions, but I think anyone with time in will disagree. In the US, British, Dutch and Danish military (where I have the most exposure), when a Captain walks by, all the Sgt's snap to attention and throw up a salute without fail. In the Canadian military, the Sgt's see the Captain coming and try to busy themselves, even if it means turning around, to avoid having to do it. There's a distinct lack of respect for our officer corps and that's based largely on the fact that our officers are bookish hokey players, not leaders, and that the class difference is glaringly obvious giving them an attitude of superiority. As a ring-knocker myself, I've seen it first-hand. If it wasn't for the fact that I grew up the son of an enlisted man, I just might have suffered that same arrogance. Luckily, my Dad wasn't a career Corporal but managed to rise up to be an MWO so I was able to improve my "class" from a military standpoint. But the truth is that if my Dad and I were both in uniform and walked past a group of enlisted, they wouldn't turn around and pretend not to see me out of respect for the MWO walking beside me, not because of me. The training I got watching my dad while I was growing up was far better than anything I was taught by the military, and he would've made a far better officer than me or most of my compatriots, but there is no way given his upbringing that he ever could've gotten a degree or succeed in university as a mature student.


Of course, whatever selection method you have, you are bound to reject some positives, and to choose some negatives. The trick lies in having a selection method that is slightly better than drawing names out of a hat.

My point was that selecting candidates on the basis of their IQ scores is better than random. I would agree that selecting officers on the basis of playing hockey is no better (or is worse) than random chance. Selecting who shall be officers on the basis of their school averages, would, in my guess, be much better than random -- on the grounds that the people with A-averages tend to have higher IQs.

It is controversial just what aspect of intellectual prowess the IQ test actually measures. What is not controversial is that selecting a group of engineers, lawyers, doctors, professors, army officers, etc, on the basis of their IQ scores will be significantly better than chance. The people who perform best in the intellectual professions (and gain the most fulfilment therefrom) tend to arrange themselves in the order of their IQ scores (not exactly, of course, but that is the trend.) Selecting them on the basis of tests that do not measure intellectual prowess will be no better than chance.

Selecting officers on the basis of their playing hockey is likely as accurate as selecting hockey players on the basis of their IQs.
 
If their IQ was very high or if they were that intelligent would they really end up in the army???Don't they need ppl of certain character to control their mind/belief and maintain the top down management style. I an not in the army but logically, I would assume that intelligence is one aspect, character and their ability to "lead" would be another. Sometimes IQ and character or ability are way off. I would also assume that politics plays an important role, and finding people to fill this position that will be of the mindset you look after to maintain your politic. In theory you explanation makes sense but in practice I would be very surprised if it actually does and that the most deserving people get picked.

Intelligence is only one aspect to measure a person or their ability. There are many intelligent ppl around us despite how we tend believe that they are rare.


Of course, whatever selection method you have, you are bound to reject some positives, and to choose some negatives. The trick lies in having a selection method that is slightly better than drawing names out of a hat. My point was that selecting candidates on the basis of their IQ scores is better than random. I would agree that selecting officers on the basis of playing hockey is no better (or is worse) than random chance. Selecting who shall be officers on the basis of their school averages, would, in my guess, be much better than random -- on the grounds that the people with A-averages tend to have higher IQs. It is controversial just what aspect of intellectual prowess the IQ test actually measures. What is not controversial is that selecting a group of engineers, lawyers, doctors, professors, army officers, etc, on the basis of their IQ scores will be significantly better than chance. The people who perform best in the intellectual professions (and gain the most fulfilment therefrom) tend to arrange themselves in the order of their IQ scores (not exactly, of course, but that is the trend.) Selecting them on the basis of tests that do not measure intellectual prowess will be no better than chance. Selecting officers on the basis of their playing hockey is likely as accurate as selecting hockey players on the basis of their IQs.
 
Did you know that most General practitioners are coming out, knowing more about prescription drugs than diet???
Makes you wonder.
Its been said, thier wives know more about diet than they do.
 
If their IQ was very high or if they were that intelligent would they really end up in the army???Don't they need ppl of certain character to control their mind/belief and maintain the top down management style. I an not in the army but logically, I would assume that intelligence is one aspect, character and their ability to "lead" would be another. Sometimes IQ and character or ability are way off. I would also assume that politics plays an important role, and finding people to fill this position that will be of the mindset you look after to maintain your politic. In theory you explanation makes sense but in practice I would be very surprised if it actually does and that the most deserving people get picked.
Intelligence is only one aspect to measure a person or their ability. There are many intelligent ppl around us despite how we tend believe that they are rare.

So we are hearing from someone who is actually willing to express his opinion that people with a high IQ would never be in the army!?! And someone who thinks that being in the army is "ending up"!!

You are correct in one thing -- of course, intelligence is only one aspect. Of course we all know someone who is a highly intelligent wanker, and we know someone who shows little intellect but we would trust him with our lives.

But the question remains -- suppose you are looking for people for an activity or occupation that has intellectual content -- you have a batch of a hundred candidates, and you have to select the twenty who will have the best chance of being successful -- which selection method are you, friend pablice, going to use?

Surely, you must know that trying to assess whether a person possesses such qualities as character, and ability to "lead", is nothing more than personal opinion and prejudice -- becasue there is no objective standard for those things. You must know that the people who believe "I just know when he's the right one", as a feeling, are the ones with the worst track record. You must know that most teachers (in the days when IQ testing was done) could, prior to the test, arrange their kids in order of their IQ scores.

The benefit of the IQ test is that it is completely objective and repeatable, irrespective of who is doing the testing.

Forget about what "intelligence" is. The quality the IQ test measures is the quality of being able to succeed, on the average, in the intellectual professions.

Giving the hundred an IQ test, and going with the twenty with the highest socres, is better than drawing the names out of a hat. If you know another reliable, repeatable, easy-to-administer, way of selecting candidates that is better than random chance, your fortune is assured.
 
I am proud of the ppl in our army giving their life for our country. Many of these people are brave and have a lot more character then I could ever imagine. If all you had was a high IQ you would not really care about anybody else or the country but only your needs.

For choosing people it depends on what your priorities are an developing a test or method to pick out the ones that align with your priorities.

You can have people with very high IQ but very little street smart or common sense. Perfect example is the Big Bang Theory, even though exaggerated, we all know people like that who are very smart but would not want them on our "team". If I needed them to do something very technical like design a new jet engine, a tallest skyscraper, most complex bridge, ect., then yes education, experience, and yes IQ are huge.

If I wanted to build an army to fight for me, I would put these IQ people in a position to provide me with technical solutions not lead. I would not want somebody to challenge my leadership style, I would want somebody well rounded, who is strong, brave, loyal, humble, smart yes, ect...

Also what defines a person and their worth, is it smarts or their ability to be well rounded have a wide emotional range, and the ability to adapt to many situations, fit in, change and touch peoples life, inspire, motivate, and make or inspire social change or even revolutions. IQ is only one aspect, there is so much more to people that define their worth to other people and to their society.

BTW I am not pulling this stuff out of my ass I have experienced war and have seen and felt the horrors of it. I had two family members who were generals and we did have many interesting discussions about similar things. Their ppl were made of mostly farmers and working men!



So we are hearing from someone who is actually willing to express his opinion that people with a high IQ would never be in the army!?! And someone who thinks that being in the army is "ending up"!! You are correct in one thing -- of course, intelligence is only one aspect. Of course we all know someone who is a highly intelligent wanker, and we know someone who shows little intellect but we would trust him with our lives. But the question remains -- suppose you are looking for people for an activity or occupation that has intellectual content -- you have a batch of a hundred candidates, and you have to select the twenty who will have the best chance of being successful -- which selection method are you, friend pablice, going to use? Surely, you must know that trying to assess whether a person possesses such qualities as character, and ability to "lead", is nothing more than personal opinion and prejudice -- becasue there is no objective standard for those things. You must know that the people who believe "I just know when he's the right one", as a feeling, are the ones with the worst track record. You must know that most teachers (in the days when IQ testing was done) could, prior to the test, arrange their kids in order of their IQ scores. The benefit of the IQ test is that it is completely objective and repeatable, irrespective of who is doing the testing. Forget about what "intelligence" is. The quality the IQ test measures is the quality of being able to succeed, on the average, in the intellectual professions. Giving the hundred an IQ test, and going with the twenty with the highest socres, is better than drawing the names out of a hat. If you know another reliable, repeatable, easy-to-administer, way of selecting candidates that is better than random chance, your fortune is assured.
 
. . . If I wanted to build an army to fight for me, I would put these IQ people in a position to provide me with technical solutions not lead. I would not want somebody to challenge my leadership style, I would want somebody well rounded, who is strong, brave, loyal, humble, smart yes, ect...
Also what defines a person and their worth, is it smarts or their ability to be well rounded have a wide emotional range, and the ability to adapt to many situations, fit in, change and touch peoples life, inspire, motivate, and make or inspire social change or even revolutions. IQ is only one aspect, there is so much more to people that define their worth to other people and to their society.

Perhaps you think we've all been lying on the ground with straw in our hair, waiting for you to tell us what qualities would be good in a military officer.

Of course, now we see it!! We want people who are well rounded, strong, brave, loyal, humble, smart, have a wide emotional range, the ability to adapt to many situations, fit in, change and touch peoples life, inspire, motivate, and make or inspire social change. (I don't know whether we would want to test for people who'll challenge your leadership style, nor for an ability to inspire revolutions, but there you go.)

I ask you again -- How do you, friend pablice, when faced with a hundred candidates (many of whom will be seeking to deceive you in order to improve their chances) propose to go about selecting the top twenty? What questions are you going to ask them? What tests will you carry out?

Do you have access to a handbook that articulates objective standards for strength, b**********y, loyalty, humility, etc? and explains how to detect whether or not this or that person (whom you've never seen before) has the ability to reach that standard?

No? You're the same as the rest of us then. So give the hundred an IQ test, and select the twenty with the best scores. Statistically, that is significantly better than random chance.
 
My point like I mentioned in my above post is to pick people based on your priorities. If you want to half ass the process you choose the IQ as the basis. This is as simple as it gets.

The stuff about being well rounded, loyal, ect. ect. is about what defines a person in general life and not just in an army setting. Don't take my points out of context. IQ is only one measure of what a person is capable of. The other stuff that I mentioned is more important to many. To spell it out for you, I am taking the IQ outside your army setting and applying it to real life.

The truth is in your eyes only.

Perhaps you think we've all been lying on the ground with straw in our hair, waiting for you to tell us what qualities would be good in a military officer. Of course, now we see it!! We want people who are well rounded, strong, brave, loyal, humble, smart, have a wide emotional range, the ability to adapt to many situations, fit in, change and touch peoples life, inspire, motivate, and make or inspire social change. (I don't know whether we would want to test for people who'll challenge your leadership style, nor for an ability to inspire revolutions, but there you go.) I ask you again -- How do you, friend pablice, when faced with a hundred candidates (many of whom will be seeking to deceive you in order to improve their chances) propose to go about selecting the top twenty? What questions are you going to ask them? What tests will you carry out? Do you have access to a handbook that articulates objective standards for strength, b**********y, loyalty, humility, etc? and explains how to detect whether or not this or that person (whom you've never seen before) has the ability to reach that standard? No? You're the same as the rest of us then. So give the hundred an IQ test, and select the twenty with the best scores. Statistically, that is significantly better than random chance.
 
Of course, whatever selection method you have, you are bound to reject some positives, and to choose some negatives. The trick lies in having a selection method that is slightly better than drawing names out of a hat.

My point was that selecting candidates on the basis of their IQ scores is better than random. I would agree that selecting officers on the basis of playing hockey is no better (or is worse) than random chance. Selecting who shall be officers on the basis of their school averages, would, in my guess, be much better than random -- on the grounds that the people with A-averages tend to have higher IQs.

It is controversial just what aspect of intellectual prowess the IQ test actually measures. What is not controversial is that selecting a group of engineers, lawyers, doctors, professors, army officers, etc, on the basis of their IQ scores will be significantly better than chance. The people who perform best in the intellectual professions (and gain the most fulfilment therefrom) tend to arrange themselves in the order of their IQ scores (not exactly, of course, but that is the trend.) Selecting them on the basis of tests that do not measure intellectual prowess will be no better than chance.

Selecting officers on the basis of their playing hockey is likely as accurate as selecting hockey players on the basis of their IQs.

You missed my point. I mentioned academics and bookishness a few times so I don't know how you did, but you missed it. They aren't picking people who are fantastic hockey players but morons, they have select criteria which includes demonstration a prowess in the educational system in addition to using something like hockey or other team sports to show leadership. You can be the best hockey player in the country, that won't get you into Military College. But if you're the best hockey player in the country and have a 90% average or higher in core subjects, you're a shoe in. When I went through, my class had an average of 98% in core subjects. In addition to volunteer work and sports/something to show leadership. We ARE talking about high IQ people. And our officer cadre still sucks as far as officer cadres go.

If you want to select good leaders, you evaluate people on their ability to lead. Not in high school sports because that's more about being popular, but by sticking people in uniform and seeing how they perform. The British way, the American way, the German way, even the French way. Heck, even the Prussian system used that method and that's one reason why you'll find so many more battlefield commanders of note in the Nazi army than you will on the allied side of the war.

Brains don't mean a thing when it comes to commanding soldiers in the field. You can't be a moron, but there are traits much more important than a high IQ. In fact, it's to the point that the CF has changed their recruiting standards. They no longer weight academics as highly as they did in an effort to remedy the problem, but the problem won't be solved so long as you still require leaders to possess a piece of paper that says they learned some book stuff, especially when that stuff can be something as useless to the military as geology.

I will say it so there can be no doubt - as a former commissioned officer in Her Majesty's Canadian Armed Forces, coming from a military family that had a focus on military values and traditions, the Canadian Armed Forces system of selected officers who scored high in academics has been to the detriment of the officer corps and the detriment of the service. High IQ has absolutely no bearing, not even a casual one let alone a causational one, on the quality of leaders that are produced.
 
If their IQ was very high or if they were that intelligent would they really end up in the army???Don't they need ppl of certain character to control their mind/belief and maintain the top down management style. I an not in the army but logically, I would assume that intelligence is one aspect, character and their ability to "lead" would be another. Sometimes IQ and character or ability are way off. I would also assume that politics plays an important role, and finding people to fill this position that will be of the mindset you look after to maintain your politic. In theory you explanation makes sense but in practice I would be very surprised if it actually does and that the most deserving people get picked.

Intelligence is only one aspect to measure a person or their ability. There are many intelligent ppl around us despite how we tend believe that they are rare.

Well, answer this riddle (all facts I used came from here: http://omsbf.oma.org/student/factsheet.htm)

Person A spends over $140,000 on medical school. For the first 7 years after graduation, they put over half their take-home pay towards their debt.

Person B gets paid $44k-51k/yr with all expenses related to their medical education paid for, 4-5 weeks of paid vacation each year, full medical and dental coverage, contributing to a full pension. In return, they have to work for the company that's paying for it all for a minimum of 4 years. During those 4 years, they make almost exactly the same as they would working for the province during their residency.

Tell me, which of these two people is smarter?

Further to this one isolated example, let me explain that the Canadian Forces is a thinking military. This means soldiers are not expected to mindless automatons. If I was in charge of a platoon of infantry, and we were huddled in our trenches and shell-scrapes were orders came in to go over the top and charge an enemy machine post, you are absolutely right that they are trained and expected to follow without question. But if I order them to open fire on a village or burn down a hospital, they are expected to challenge me. The higher up you are in the chain, the more valuable this trait is. I know a lot of people that say the army wants to brain wash you or they could never be in the army because they don't like following orders, but let me state, unequivocally, I was treated better, more humanely and with more respect in the army than I ever have been anywhere else in life. Yes, a Sergeant might yell at his men to charge that goddamn machine gun and quit being princesses, but when there aren't bullets flying, he'll also remember the names of their wives and children, know when one of them is sick and think to ask about them, offer you time off when he thinks you've got a lot on your plate unless you happen to be at war. And the result is soldiers who repay that. They don't want to leave war because they could die because they don't want to let their Sergeant down, or the Corporal standing next to them.

The military isn't about being a mindless drone that likes being bossed around. And at the end of the day, if you read about veterans with any frequency, you'll see that the reason they have problems adjusting to civilian life after they get back from war and leave the military is because they don't have that same camaraderie. They're carrying their entire burdens themselves, burdens they shared among men who would die or kill for them, and are now in a cold world where everyone is selfish and no one has any concept of what they went through.

If you really think no one with a high IQ would ever want to join the military, it think you've watched too many American-made movies about the Marine Corps. The military offers lots of advantages to smart people, especially if they don't care about the military but want to get paid to go to school and graduate with no debt and a guaranteed job in their field.
 
@BlueLaser well put my brother!!! Buttercup seems confused and likes to bang his head a lot and refuses to listen to reason. Give him rifle and send him out in real battle and we'll see how far his IQ gets him. You can't describe to these types what it is to be in battle, with your brothers fighting for your country and not knowing when you are going to die. I have never been to the battle, but experienced heavy artillery, and the horrors of war as a young kid under sniper fire when war broke our in the city I used to live. This was life changing, and I could not stop shaking from the experience plus doing everything we had to survive. When you see and experience war first hand it changes you, you see life so much different, and this IQ stuff goes out of the door an your other traits take over. This is when it separates the weak and it shows what ppl are made out of, how much stress and pressure they can handle, and make life changing decisions under these circumstances and such extremes.

Right now I am a proud Canadian, and my family is born here. I deeply respect what you and your brothers do for us and our country. I appreciate you, I salute you, and never forget what you guys do for us. I've been to hell and now am in Canada, such a paradise compared to where I come from and why I've seen, thanks to people like you who are willing to risk it all for us. I know our politics sucks, but you guys are appreciated. Thank you brother!

You missed my point. I mentioned academics and bookishness a few times so I don't know how you did, but you missed it. They aren't picking people who are fantastic hockey players but morons, they have select criteria which includes demonstration a prowess in the educational system in addition to using something like hockey or other team sports to show leadership. You can be the best hockey player in the country, that won't get you into Military College. But if you're the best hockey player in the country and have a 90% average or higher in core subjects, you're a shoe in. When I went through, my class had an average of 98% in core subjects. In addition to volunteer work and sports/something to show leadership. We ARE talking about high IQ people. And our officer cadre still sucks as far as officer cadres go. If you want to select good leaders, you evaluate people on their ability to lead. Not in high school sports because that's more about being popular, but by sticking people in uniform and seeing how they perform. The British way, the American way, the German way, even the French way. Heck, even the Prussian system used that method and that's one reason why you'll find so many more battlefield commanders of note in the Nazi army than you will on the allied side of the war. Brains don't mean a thing when it comes to commanding soldiers in the field. You can't be a moron, but there are traits much more important than a high IQ. In fact, it's to the point that the CF has changed their recruiting standards. They no longer weight academics as highly as they did in an effort to remedy the problem, but the problem won't be solved so long as you still require leaders to possess a piece of paper that says they learned some book stuff, especially when that stuff can be something as useless to the military as geology. I will say it so there can be no doubt - as a former commissioned officer in Her Majesty's Canadian Armed Forces, coming from a military family that had a focus on military values and traditions, the Canadian Armed Forces system of selected officers who scored high in academics has been to the detriment of the officer corps and the detriment of the service. High IQ has absolutely no bearing, not even a casual one let alone a causational one, on the quality of leaders that are produced.
 
...If you really think no one with a high IQ would ever want to join the military, it think you've watched too many American-made movies about the Marine Corps. The military offers lots of advantages to smart people, especially if they don't care about the military but want to get paid to go to school and graduate with no debt and a guaranteed job in their field.

See my previous posts after the one you quoted...I was demonstrating to buttercup the weakness in his reasoning using his flawed train of thoughts. I respect what u guys do for us, and know what you are saying. Don't let these troll types spread the poison, I am with you and appreciate everything you guys do and have lots of respect.
 
That's cute, but as with most jokes, it's a little off.

Average income for a plumber in Canada: $52,000.
Average income for a lawyer in Canada: $165,000.

Assuming $500/job, that means the plumber only does 104 jobs/year, or 2 jobs a week. I think any plumber would love that schedule. In reality, fixing a leak costs about $150, not $500.


A plumber declares $52K a year......
Everyone knows how the trades work, anyone who believes that is true income is delusional.
 
Buttercup seems confused and likes to bang his head a lot and refuses to listen to reason. Give him rifle and send him out in real battle and we'll see how far his IQ gets him. You can't describe to these types what it is to be in battle, with your brothers fighting for your country and not knowing when you are going to die.

Pablice, baby, you seem to be getting further and further from (what I thought was) the subject of this thread. It started with asking loungers what educational qualifications they have, then it progressed to a discussion of what use is education and qualifications, and touched on how you should go about selecting people for various jobs.

I mentioned that the military, in many countries, many times, have had good results when they have given the candidates an IQ test, and have found that the ones with the best scores make the best officers (not without exception, of course).

Obviously, the military has spent a great deal of effort, over the years, trying to select for courage and strength and the other good qualities you mention. They have regarded those things, like you do, as more important than intelligence. But the fact is that there is no way of detecting those qualities in candidates - not in any reproducible objective test.

Perhaps you think you yourself have the ability to be able to accurately detect whether this or that person will remain proficient under extreme conditions? There have been generals and admirals who were certain they themselves had this happy knack. But no-one has ever been able to do it. In fact, the more certain the general is that he 'knows how to pick em', the less likely he is to be so.

You are arguing about the qualities soldiers should have, and do have, such as courage and strength of character, and that those things are more important than intelligence and IQ scores. OK then -- tell us how you will go about selecting candidates for those exact qualities. Better still, tell the canadian military -- they will be very pleased indeed to learn the secret.

The reality is that there is no known way of testing whether a candidate has the qualities you (like the rest of us) admire. But you can give them all an IQ test.

As it turns out, selecting officers on the basis solely of their IQ scores turns to be unique in that it gives considerably better results than drawing the names out of a hat. Not because intelligence is more important than b**********y, but simply because the IQ test has been found to be a better measure of whether a person will make a good officer than the other methods of measurement that have been tried. No other reason than that.
 
I mentioned that the military, in many countries, many times, have had good results when they have given the candidates an IQ test, and have found that the ones with the best scores make the best officers (not without exception, of course).

In Denmark we interpreted the results of the IQ test this way:

Over 110: disqualified
80-109 : enlisted soldiers
under 80: Officers