Oscar Pistorius - Guilty or Not Guilty ?

Guity or Not Guilty?

  • Guilty

    Votes: 60 84.5%
  • Not Guilty

    Votes: 6 8.5%
  • Undecided

    Votes: 5 7.0%

  • Total voters
    71
He's an idiot. Even if it was an intruder his attempt was to kill someone.
 
He's an idiot. Even if it was an intruder his attempt was to kill someone.

Well said! Unless South Africa gives a home owner the right to shoot an intruder on sight like some US southern states, the real legal issue is the use of unwarranted, excessive force and not the domestic abuse angle.
 
This guy has no legs, insecurity is expected. In a violent situation he loses badly 100% of the time - unless he has a gun. This insecurity may have led him to killing his girl. We know he shot her, we are not sure if he thought she was a intruder. I don't think they can convict - he did intentionally pull the trigger. How can they ever prove what his thoughts were?
 
Well said! Unless South Africa gives a home owner the right to shoot an intruder on sight like some US southern states, the real legal issue is the use of unwarranted, excessive force and not the domestic abuse angle.

He didn't even shoot on sight! His defense such as it is, is that he fired blindly. Multiple times through a closed door.
But his story doesn't work, and he is beyond guilty, this was premeditated murder.
 
Oscar. He is guilty as sin. All my South African friends think so too. It will be hard to prove it was "premeditated" however. This guy makes me want to hate him, he needs to check that rage.

I thought i'd be addicted to this story, as I was to the OJ trial back in the day. But I can't seem to find any good live feeds of the trial, and news coverage is sparse and wanting. I do have one link from ESPN3, but only at work.

Anyone have any good suggestions for video coverage, preferably live?
 
I'm not buying his argument. Not one bit.

I think he got into a huge row with her and he snapped. Plain and simple.

I think he has a huge temper (as evidenced by his numerous explosions and shooting off guns on several occasions) and he's just plain not a nice guy.

I don't think he premeditated the murder because if that was the case, he's really stupid.

Guilty of second degree murder (IMHO).
 
Guilty as hell
 
They do!
In SA you have actual property rights not like under the Canadian Constitution! Isn't it really like taking your life when you steal someone's property? You work and slave away and save and buy something and some dirt bag can just take it!!?! Isn't it really like taking that time of your life that you put in to be able to buy it? You can't get that back can you? It won't be the same! Even if insurance replaces it, the original inherent enjoyment is gone, you'll fear it will be taken again, you'll never feel safe in your home again, feel violated! If it were just that simple, we wouldn't be upset when someone gets killed either. after all, you can have another child, get another wife or husband!

I think if someone wrongs you to that degree you should have a free pass to snuff the crud!

But sadly, we don't even have a death penalty for clear, confessed murdering pieces of crap!


It's just trespassing for god's sake. WTF is he going to steal? His abode? A hair brush? A roll of toilet paper? Nonsense!
 
I'm not buying his argument. Not one bit.

I think he got into a huge row with her and he snapped. Plain and simple.

I think he has a huge temper (as evidenced by his numerous explosions and shooting off guns on several occasions) and he's just plain not a nice guy.

I don't think he premeditated the murder because if that was the case, he's really stupid.

Guilty of second degree murder (IMHO).


It's also possible that she might have been upset with him over something he did, and she might have made fun of his handicap after he insulted her and told her to F.O., making him snap and shooting her, although he's not claiming temporary insanity or that line of reasoning in his defense.

In any event, no or insufficient justification for him to shoot and claim self-defense.
 
I don't think he premeditated the murder because if that was the case, he's really stupid.

In South Africa, if an accused could reasonably foresee death ensuing as a result of his or her actions, he or she is guilty of premeditated murder. (I'm not a lawyer - I read that somewhere) The prosecution is maintaining that rather than just shooting wildly at the door from a position Pistorius suggests, he moved around and directed the shots directly at the girl cowering in the bathroom. He knew from her yelling she was sitting on the toilet refusing to come out and he knew where to point the gun to shoot her.
 
Not guilty of pre-meditated murder.

Guilty of culpable homicide.

Lots of comments that are being made is made from the viewpoint of Canadian eyes, oblivious of the living conditions in South Africa. Break-ins are much more common in South Africa than in Canada, and often these break-ins happen with a great deal of brutality. Burglar bars in front of windows, or external doors, even between separating the living areas from the bedrooms are common in houses in South Africa - the purpose is to keep intruders out, particularly at night time.

There have been a few other instances where a family member (son/daughter) had been killed by their parents, after they were confused as burglars. The kids came home later than they were expected.

Canada has about 600 murders each year (35m people) - South Africa has more than 15,000 murders each year (53m people).
 
Not guilty of pre-meditated murder.

Guilty of culpable homicide.

Lots of comments that are being made is made from the viewpoint of Canadian eyes, oblivious of the living conditions in South Africa. Break-ins are much more common in South Africa than in Canada, and often these break-ins happen with a great deal of brutality. Burglar bars in front of windows, or external doors, even between separating the living areas from the bedrooms are common in houses in South Africa - the purpose is to keep intruders out, particularly at night time.

There have been a few other instances where a family member (son/daughter) had been killed by their parents, after they were confused as burglars. The kids came home later than they were expected.

Canada has about 600 murders each year (35m people) - South Africa has more than 15,000 murders each year (53m people).

Yes, huge cultural difference and I suspect that the # of SA homicides is likely under-reported as many would occur in ghettoes which would not trust the cops. As well, I do not share the attitude of many on TERB that he over-acted in court. It is an axiom of Canadian law that the ways in which people act and react after a crime or alleged crime is so diverse that no useful conclusion of guilt or innocence can be deduced from it.

But he certainly intended to kill SOMEONE when he shot through the door. Thus, my question as to whether it would matter under SA law if he intended to kill an intruder (who was hiding from him and not directly threatening him) or his girlfriend?

In Canada, if someone breaks into your home and you confront them and they run and seek shelter in the bathroom, locking the door behind them, you can't just blast the fuck out of them. Probably the most you can do is hold your ground while you dial 9-1-1.
 
This is what really pisses me off about you guys... :mad:

Except for some isolated reports, no one has heard all the evidence to date; the case is long way from over; Pistorius has not yet given evidence...

Yet we already have very strong opinions and verdicts... :rolleyes:

Geez!

Is that what you would want from others if it were you on trial? Does the presumption of innocence mean anything to you? Does hearing ALL the evidence and arguments mean nothing?

I am not saying he is innocent. I just don't know, and can't begin to form an opinion until all the evidence is in.

Perry
 
This is what really pisses me off about you guys... :mad:

Except for some isolated reports, no one has heard all the evidence to date; the case is long way from over; Pistorius has not yet given evidence...

Yet we already have very strong opinions and verdicts... :rolleyes:

Geez!

Is that what you would want from others if it were you on trial? Does the presumption of innocence mean anything to you? Does hearing ALL the evidence and arguments mean nothing?

I am not saying he is innocent. I just don't know, and can't begin to form an opinion until all the evidence is in.

Perry

for once, I whole-heartedly agree with Perry. No-one should be deciding guilt at this point. Indeed, no one here is at the trial to observe the witnesses directly. No one here has experienced the dynamics in SA. The best you guys are contributing is mob lynch justice.
 
Well, P Mason is a lawyer even if he only did so on tv.
 
I have no idea if he's innocent or guilty. The media has made a big deal about various juicy pieces of evidence - sensationalized, I'm sure.


It's just trespassing for god's sake. WTF is he going to steal? His abode? A hair brush? A roll of toilet paper? Nonsense!

What is nonsense is that I should somehow allow an unwanted visitor to enter my home.

How do we know if an intruder only intends to trespass? Or steal small, inconsequential items? Where do you draw the line - when he/she threatens you/your family, or do you wait until someone you love is physically assaulted? Are we not entitled to feel safe in our own homes? If so, are we not entitled to defend our homes?

I don't think either extreme is right (Castle Doctrine or the presumption of an offence in a defensive shooting). Unfortunately, Canada is far to the left on this issue. Despite the recent amendments to the CCC on self-defence, the use of deadly force remains an exceptional circumstances (and is specifically not a valid defence for the protection of property).


...I take this to mean that I can shoot the bugger in the leg!
 
for once, I whole-heartedly agree with Perry.
Nah! You have wholly agreed with me once or twice before!!!! :D

Not too often, but c'est la guerre!

And superstar, I am a lawyer in "real life," too!

Perry
 
I have no idea if he's innocent or guilty. The media has made a big deal about various juicy pieces of evidence - sensationalized, I'm sure.




What is nonsense is that I should somehow allow an unwanted visitor to enter my home.

How do we know if an intruder only intends to trespass? Or steal small, inconsequential items? Where do you draw the line - when he/she threatens you/your family, or do you wait until someone you love is physically assaulted? Are we not entitled to feel safe in our own homes? If so, are we not entitled to defend our homes?

I don't think either extreme is right (Castle Doctrine or the presumption of an offence in a defensive shooting). Unfortunately, Canada is far to the left on this issue. Despite the recent amendments to the CCC on self-defence, the use of deadly force remains an exceptional circumstances (and is specifically not a valid defence for the protection of property).

In J'burg, the chances of any intruder is in your home to steel a cup of sugar is near ZERO. They are there to do serious hurt, physically, financially, or emotionally.