Could independent quebec survive

of course they could survive! they could live off poutine and high mileage strippers! couldn't you?
 
of course they could survive! they could live off poutine and high mileage strippers! couldn't you?
Hey, maybe if Harper makes pay for sex illegal in Canada, an independent Quebec could make pay for sex legal. Of course, Harper could make his illegal sex law applicable to Canadians anywhere in the universe.
 
There's no such thing as an "independent Quebec" since they want to keep the loonie. As for the economy, they've been doing well in the high tech sector for quite some time. Ubisoft and number of other game publishers operate out there. Whether or not that's good enough to keep the economy going is another thing all together.
 
Question: Can a citizen of a separate Quebec opt to be also a citizen of Canada (dual citizen)?

Some communities in the Ottawa Valley, the far north, and Montreal Island have asked a bout or threatened that, saying if Quebec can separated why can't they?
 
Hopefully the Government of Canada would have the gonads to say in 1912 we gave you jurisdiction over the Nouveau-Québec section of Rupert's Land, and guess what, although we probably have to pay you for or allow you to continue to own Hydro-Québec's James Bay Project, Rupert's Land is staying with us.
 
Who gives a flying f*ck what you have to say when you crawl out from under your rock.

That's it, that's all you got, geeesh. Your sum total contribution to this thread is, 'who give a flying fuck', twice over and i'm the one living under a rock.
 
Ok but we will deduct the value of any Federal assets in Quebec from pending equalization/transfer payments should separation occur. Do they owe the Feds anything? What about their share of the Federal debt? Fuck them if they don't pay, we blockade their ports.
They also would not be entitled to all that land mass.
We should be able to annex the English portions to protect our citizens with force if need be as well as the North whose Native pop. would want to stay within Canada. Let the French cry babies get the hell out already so we can concentrate on building up the rest of the Country that is trying the best we can.
 
Remember, a good portion of our armed forces are francophones from Quebec. If they assume their portion of the national debt (how a "fair" portion will be decided is another difficult question) they are entitled to their portion of the national assets, including armed forces equipment and trained personnel. The divisibility of Quebec will be another interesting discussion. Who will determine this-the Cdn Supreme Court? Will an independent Quebec abide by the "Cdn" court decisions? Both the rest of Canada and Quebec will be better off economically to work together after an independence vote rather than thinking emotionally and putting up barriers.
 
Remember, a good portion of our armed forces are francophones from Quebec. If they assume their portion of the national debt (how a "fair" portion will be decided is another difficult question) they are entitled to their portion of the national assets, including armed forces equipment and trained personnel. The divisibility of Quebec will be another interesting discussion. Who will determine this-the Cdn Supreme Court? Will an independent Quebec abide by the "Cdn" court decisions? Both the rest of Canada and Quebec will be better off economically to work together after an independence vote rather than thinking emotionally and putting up barriers.

Memembers like Nuttyboi and Flapjack can't see this though.
 
Things are not as they were during the last two referendums. Quebec is a much more bilingual place than it was in the past, there is much more mingling of French and English culture than at any other time in the past. Gone are the days when I was in university in Montreal where English speaking people would drink at bars on St. Catherine Street and French speaking people would drink on St. Denis Street on Saturday nights. In part because of the internet, young French Canadian kids are all somewhat bilingual, and some are fluently bilingual on purpose to take advantage of opportunities outside of Quebec and Canada. Separatism was dying a horrible writhing painful death until the the Parti Quebecois stumbled upon the Quebec Charter of Values last summer. This Quebec Charter of Values last is very popular with country bumpkins outside Montreal, but it will never pass in the National Assembly because it is not constitutionally sound.
Separation will never happen, Marois is just using it to gain popularity and to show French Canada that she is in charge and kicking Federal ass. With her head swelled with the popularity of the Quebec Charter of Values Marois calls an election. ( breaking her own law on regularly scheduled elections every four years on a specific date ) Marois' mistake was to allow P i e r r e Karl Peladeau ( Billionaire Newspaper/media mogul ) to join her party. The arrogant bastard is trying to take he party over.
 
That's it, that's all you got, geeesh. Your sum total contribution to this thread is, 'who give a flying fuck', twice over and i'm the one living under a rock.

Who gives a flying f*ck what you think. Crawl back under your home. (See the theme here blackcock?)
 
Not anymore, it would become North Louisiana.

Meaning the original Irish, Jewish and Italian immigrants that made up urban Quebec's population in the first half of the 20th Century, were willing to integrate into French culture for freedom of religion. Currently, rural Quebec is predominantly French but it's cities are a melting pot of cultures that speak their native tongues first. In an independent Quebec, the government couldn't impose French only restrictions without being taken to International court.
Were stuck with each other.
 
Why do you talk about referendum? The only party who don't talk about it is the party you accuse to wan't separation. 39% wan't separation actually so they will not have a referendum.
 
Hey, maybe if Harper makes pay for sex illegal in Canada, an independent Quebec could make pay for sex legal. Of course, Harper could make his illegal sex law applicable to Canadians anywhere in the universe.

No, he couldn't. Canadian criminal law is territorially-based.
 
The perennial quebec independence referendum is looming once again. I hope they decide to leave so Canada can move on.
But my feeling is that this issue will never be resolved, and canada will limp along with this dysfunctional provence.

Just take their share of the Canadian debt ( 25% ) with them...by by..
 
It can be done...but then Quebecers will just start migrating to Canada, get their citizenship..sponsor families. Then Canada will just re-acquire that lump of land beside Ottawa and name it Province of Quebec...where Quebecers came from....

If Quebec does hold another referendum Canada must insist that to be valid it must be a registered referendum where the voter's identity is clearly noted on the ballet. People can not vote to break up the country and then move to Ontario to continue their lifestyle. At the same time we cannot forbid people voting for Canada from exiting the province after separation to remain Canadian. I believe a registered vote whereby the people knew they were forfeiting their Canadian rights (passports, federal civil service jobs, residency in the ROC, etc.) and the PQ's will get their ass kicked. Allow the PQ to sell their concept of independence while retaining all the good aspects of being Canadian, the PQ have a legitimate chance of winning. We've got to get tough before a referendum - not after.
 
Quebec will lose its best and brightest to Canada and elsewhere.

Exactly.

Brain drain them.

The Canadian Gov't would offer passports to a huge number of skilled Quebecers (And rightfully so), just as long as they are residents of the remaining provinces.

Toronto would truly stand to gain from an independent Quebec as a huge number of highly skilled Quebecers set out west down the 401
 
Things are not as they were during the last two referendums. Quebec is a much more bilingual place than it was in the past, there is much more mingling of French and English culture than at any other time in the past. Gone are the days when I was in university in Montreal where English speaking people would drink at bars on St. Catherine Street and French speaking people would drink on St. Denis Street on Saturday nights. In part because of the internet, young French Canadian kids are all somewhat bilingual, and some are fluently bilingual on purpose to take advantage of opportunities outside of Quebec and Canada.



Young people in Montreal yes.

Young people in Rimouski, not so much