Global Warming. Fact or grossly exaggerated??

Whats your opinion on global warming?

  • Its too late! We're all gonne bake, frie and die in a few years

    Votes: 44 30.1%
  • Its not as bad as scientists say. We got at least 100 to 200 years before shit hits the fan

    Votes: 33 22.6%
  • Its not real at all. Its a carbon credit money making scam

    Votes: 45 30.8%
  • Its all a big conspiracy MAN!!!

    Votes: 9 6.2%
  • Its way too cold in Canada, I wish it were real. Start up the SUV's

    Votes: 15 10.3%

  • Total voters
    146
  • Poll closed .
You do realize you keep squirming and trying to change tact when faced with arguments right? That's a key characteristic of conspiracy theory believers.

Keep digging. I'll come back to the "conspiracy theory" stupidity.

Right now, I'm basking in my victory over Groggy in our bet.
 
John R. Christy

Background

John R. Christy is a meteorologist at the University of Alabama Huntsville. He is closely associated with climate change skeptic Roy Spencer with whom he collaborated on the George C. Marshall Institute Roundtable discussion on climate change in April 2006.

Christy is the Director of the Earth System Science Center of the University of Alabama in Huntsville and has been Alabama State Climatologist since November, 2000. ,

John Christy has testified on numerous occasions against the mainstream scientific views on man-made climate change.

"About John," University of Alabama in Huntsville. Accessed December 2, 2011.

Stance on Climate Change

"I'm sure the majority (but not all) of my IPCC colleagues cringe when I say this, but I see neither the developing catastrophe nor the smoking gun proving that human activity is to blame for most of the warming we see."

"My Nobel moment." November 1, 2007. The Wall Street Journal.

BUT!!!!!

Affiliations

Heartland Institute — Listed as a "Global Warming Expert" by the Heartland Institute.

Cato Institute — Speaker at a Cato-sponsored event on global warming.

Competetive Enterprise Institute (CEI) — "Contributor."

Independent Institute — On Institute's "Panel on Global Warming."

"Nation’s Leading Global Warming Experts Unveil New Findings on Climate Change" (Press Release), The Independent Institute, July 28, 2003.

Key Deeds

February 14, 2012

Christy released a study that claimed snowfall in the Sierra Nevada has remained consistent for 130 years, with no noticeable effect from climate change.

James Taylor of the Heartland Institute penned a Forbes article where he claimed that Christy's findings "refute frequent assertions by global warming alarmists that global warming is adversely affecting Sierra Nevada snowfall and snowpack." The climate change skeptic blog Watts Up With That also publicized the story.

When asked about the reaction to his paper, Christy said "In general, it depends on what religion you have. If you believe Man is doing horrible things to the planet, then you can’t believe this report. If you believe the other way, then this is a chapter in your bible."

David Pearce, one of John Christy's colleagues, feels that Christy has gone beyond the data in his study, and that Christy is making claims in the media that have not been backed up by the study itself. Pearce adds that it "is unfortunate because peer-review is the process that filters out unsupported personal opinion from what is backed by evidence."

March 8, 2011

Testified (PDF) at a hearing hosted by the Energy and Power Subcommittee to discuss "Climate Science and EPA's Greenhouse Gas Regulations."

Christy concluded that "if the country deems it necessary to de-carbonize civilization's main energy sources, sound and indeed compelling reasons beyond human-induced climate change need to be offered. Climate change alone is a weak leg on which to stand for such a massive undertaking."

February 25, 2009

Testified before the House Ways and Means Committee at the "Hearing on Scientific Objectives for Climate Change Legislation."

Here is a summary of Christy's testimony:

"Dr. John Christy was skeptical whether there was any way for the U.S. to make detectable changes in global warming. He feared that the scale of carbon emissions is 'simply too enormous,' and the only possible solution is to start a large nuclear energy campaign. According to Christy, 'The actions being considered to "stop global warming" will have an imperceptible impact on whatever the climate will do, while making energy more expensive, and thus have a negative impact on the economy as a whole'."

One source responded to Christy's testimony, concluding that "John Christy has added to the science of atmospheric modeling, but he has undercut his credibility by making claims far exceeding his data and by ignoring findings that disagree with his arguments. Then he sins by distorting his testimony for a purely political agenda."

March 8, 2007

Christy appeared in The Great Global Warming Swindle documentary.

The Great Global Warming Swindle also starred fellow skeptics Tim Ball, Roy Spencer, Fred Singer, Pat Michaels, Nir Shaviv, Nigel Lawson, Ian Clark, Piers Corbyn, Philip Stott, Paul Reiter, Richard Lindzen, Patrick Moore, Patrick Michaels, Syun-Ichi Akasofu, Fred Singer, Paul Driessen, and others.

(all well known deniers and affiliated with Heartland and/or Cato. See a pattern?)


July 27, 2006

Testified (PDF) at a hearing hosted by the House Committee on Energy and Commerce on the subject of "Questions Surrounding the 'Hockey Stick' Temperature Studies: Implications for Climate Change Assessments Part II."

Christy cites his previous studies that concluded "greenhouse gases are increasing in concentration is clearly true and therefore the radiation budget of the atmosphere will be altered. In response, the surface temperature should rise due to this additional forcing. In our observational work however, we have not been able to show clear support for the manner or magnitude of this response as has been depicted by the present set of climate models (Christy, 2002, Christy et al. 2006a, Christy and Norris 2006, Christy et al. 2006b)."

May 2, 2007

Appeared on the Glenn Beck Special, "Exposed: The Climate of Fear" alongside other prominent climate skeptics including Tim Ball, Patrick Michaels, Patrick Moore, Chris Horner, Bjorn Lomborg, George Taylor, David Legates, and Roy Spencer.

July 20, 2006

Testified before the House Committee on Government Reform in a Hearing titled "Climate Change: Understanding the Degree of the Problem."

August 12, 2005

According to a New York Times article, John Christy along with fellow skeptic Roy Spencer admitted they made a mistake in their satellite data research that they said demonstrated a cooling in the troposphere (the earth's lowest layer of atmosphere). It turned out that the exact opposite was occurring and the troposphere was getting warmer.

"These papers should lay to rest once and for all the claims by John Christy and other global warming skeptics that a disagreement between tropospheric and surface temperature trends means that there are problems with surface temperature records or with climate models," said Alan Robock, a meteorologist at Rutgers University.

July 28, 2003

Co-author of the Independent Institute report "New Perspectives in Climate Change: What the EPA Isn't Telling Us" that criticized the EPA's 2001 Climate Action Report.

Other authors of the report included S. Fred Singer, Robert E. Davis, David R. Legates, and Wendy M. Novicoff.

"New Perspectives on Climate change" accused The IPCC's 2001 assessment on climate change of being "misleading, inaccurate, unreliable, or simply wrong."

December 12, 2003

Spoke at an event hosted by the Cato Institute titled "Global Warming: The State of the Debate."

Cato claims that the event summarizes "what is known about the science and economics surrounding greenhouse gas concentrations and abatement. Moreover, it tackles squarely what is perhaps the most relevant policy issue at the moment—the potential costs and benefits involved in dealing with scientific uncertainty."

Peter Fimrite. "Study: Sierra snowfall consistent over 130 years," San Francisco Chronicle, February 15, 2012.

and

James Taylor. "Dear Global Warming Alarmists: We're Still Waiting for Declining Snowfall," Forbes, February 29, 2012.
Blackcrock, Christy used to work for the IPCC. He got so sick of their bullshit politics and fear-mongering that he decided to quit:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Christy

In a 2007 editorial in the Wall Street Journal, he wrote: "I'm sure the majority (but not all) of my IPCC colleagues cringe when I say this, but I see neither the developing catastrophe nor the smoking gun proving that human activity is to blame for most of the warming we see."


Listen to what he has to say on GW:

 
....and that doesn't make him a mercenary for the right wing business entities in the US how?
What you dont realize is both sides are biased and use bullshit to advance their agenda(s).

Just an example: http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/european-fraudsters-steal-7b-in-carbon-credit-scam-1.853443

The trick is to figure out for yourself whats true, and what isnt. Right now I'm leaning towards global warming isnt as bad as they're making it out to be. But I'm not arrogant enough to concede I could be wrong some time in the future
 
Good lord, Blackrock. You went to all that effort to post information -- and none of it makes a bit of difference.

The terms of the bet were:

-- That I name three climatologists who don't support the IPCC's reports.
-- That the named climatologists are employed and conduct research at recognized universities.

Regarding the terms of the bet, the only relevant parts are quoted below.

The terms have been satisfied, in full.

I win. Groggy loses.

No, the key word was legit, and you provided three who fail that qualification.

Two paid by heartland and one who supports anthropogenic climate change.

Try again.
 
No, the key word was legit, and you provided three who fail that qualification.

Two paid by heartland and one who supports anthropogenic climate change
Groggy, how can you say that when anthropogenic climate change hinges on global temperatures and natural variability of the global coupled climate models?? The TAR keeps showing multi-model results for future changes in climate, but since TAR is an unprecedented internationally coordinated climate change experiment thats been performed by over 23 models from around the world, how can you get a variable output of surface temperatures versus atmospheric temperatures??

Can you please answer that question for us??
 
No, the key word was legit, and you provided three who fail that qualification.

Two paid by heartland and one who supports anthropogenic climate change.

Try again.

For the record, Curry's position is that we don't know what affect man-made carbon dioxide might be having -- if any -- on the climate. In any event, the bet was whether or not she backs the IPCC's reports. Her position is very clear:

http://opinion.financialpost.com/2013/09/30/ipcc-climate-global-warming/

As for the definition of "legit," it was clearly described in the bet:

Let's be very clear on the word "legit" -- it doesn't have to mean that you like their views. It means that they are employed and conduct research at recognized universities.

If you didn't agree with that definition of "legit", you shouldn't have accepted the bet.

But you did accept it.

The terms were clear and have been met, in full. You lost.
 
If you didn't agree with that definition of "legit", you shouldn't have accepted the bet.

But you did accept it.

The terms were clear and have been met, in full. You lost
Remember when I told you he was gonna welch on the bet???
 
Remember when I told you he was gonna welch on the bet???

Absolutely. Believe me, I'm not the least bit surprised.

He talks a good game, with his "dares" and his challenges, but doesn't stand behind his challenges.
 
Good lord, Blackrock. You went to all that effort to post information -- and none of it makes a bit of difference.
...

Actually it makes a huge difference. Your whole argument is that the scientific consensus is invalid because some of the scientists also do political advocacy but the three you listed also seem to be engaged in significant advocacy. That would mean by your standards, the three you listed aren't scientists.

Again the conspiracy mentality of applying different standards depending on what you want to believe.



p.s. I notice you chose not to comment on my post that shows the current observations are within the predicted range.
Here is a in depth read of how the 'pause' compares to the previous models.

Worth noting:
- The current temps are at the low end but still within the previous projections
- Deep ocean temperatures have been drastically rising
- Atmospheric temperatures are still increasing though at a lower rate than the previous decade
- Land surface temperatures are still going up

http://www.yaleclimatemediaforum.org/pics/0913_Pause_graphic13.jpg
http://www.yaleclimatemediaforum.org/2013/09/examining-the-recent-slow-down-in-global-warming/
 
Absolutely. Believe me, I'm not the least bit surprised.

He talks a good game, with his "dares" and his challenges, but doesn't stand behind his challenges
Far-left Liberals are a lot like far-right wingers. They're both very predictable. They are almost like little kids, you pretty much know exactly what they're thinking and what their next move will be :)
 
Actually it makes a huge difference. Your whole argument is that the scientific consensus is invalid because some of the scientists also do political advocacy but the three you listed also seem to be engaged in significant advocacy. That would mean by your standards, the three you listed aren't scientists.

Again the conspiracy mentality of applying different standards depending on what you want to believe.



p.s. I notice you chose not to comment on my post that shows the current observations are within the predicted range.

It's funny how you guys do a pile-on, and then if I don't waste my time replying to every single assertion, you somehow conclude that whatever point I didn't get to must be right.

Your post about the "observations" will be covered when I examine, in more detail, your idiotic (or remarkably ill-informed) statements about a "conspiracy theory."

(And for what it's worth, you're confusing two different things. My argument against the contrived "consensus" has nothing to do with the politicization point. The argument against the bogus "consensus" numbers is that they are not a substitute for evidence.)

As for who the good scientists are, the challenge was set by Groggy, not by me. He dared me to name three climatologists who don't back the IPCC reports.

I turned it into a formal bet and made no "argument" in my reply other than to fulfil the terms of the bet. Your characterization of my reply is yet another in the endless series of misrepresentations of my responses.
 
Groggy, how can you say that when anthropogenic climate change hinges on global temperatures and natural variability of the global coupled climate models?? The TAR keeps showing multi-model results for future changes in climate, but since TAR is an unprecedented internationally coordinated climate change experiment thats been performed by over 23 models from around the world, how can you get a variable output of surface temperatures versus atmospheric temperatures??

Can you please answer that question for us??

Sure, I could answer a legit question.
But that one is pure bullshit, it makes no sense.
 
...
(And for what it's worth, you're confusing two different things. My argument against the consensus has nothing to do with the politicization point. The argument against the bogus "consensus" numbers is that they are not a substitute for evidence.)....

So when you said that that the scientific community shouldn't be advocating and then go ahead and then quote political advocates with views you like, you were really saying that it is a non-issue because your extreme minority of scientists are correct and should be advocating but the vast majority of scientists you disagree with are lying and shouldn't advocate?

And I look forward to you explanation of how the vast majority of the scientific community has been falsifying their results for political reasons.
 
Sure, I could answer a legit question.
But that one is pure bullshit, it makes no sense
Sounds like groggy doesnt understand the question.
Its fairly scientifically straight-forward, groggy. Why dont you understand the question??

And why wont you answer the question???
 
So when you said that that the scientific community shouldn't be advocating and then go ahead and then quote political advocates with views you like, you were really saying that it is a non-issue because your extreme minority of scientists are correct and should be advocating but the vast majority of scientists you disagree with are lying and shouldn't advocate?

I said no such thing. In fact, when Blackrock asked earlier in this thread about the politicization on the skeptics' side, I said it was immaterial to my point.

Immaterial is not the same thing as a "non-issue." It's immaterial because if none of the climate research is credible, that doesn't help us one way or the other when it comes to the huge uncertainty about whether man-made carbon dioxide emissions affect the climate.

I say there is no evidence. And I think the debate is politicized on all sides. It's one of the many reasons why we should scrap the IPCC and look for a new approach.