Global Warming. Fact or grossly exaggerated??

Whats your opinion on global warming?

  • Its too late! We're all gonne bake, frie and die in a few years

    Votes: 44 30.1%
  • Its not as bad as scientists say. We got at least 100 to 200 years before shit hits the fan

    Votes: 33 22.6%
  • Its not real at all. Its a carbon credit money making scam

    Votes: 45 30.8%
  • Its all a big conspiracy MAN!!!

    Votes: 9 6.2%
  • Its way too cold in Canada, I wish it were real. Start up the SUV's

    Votes: 15 10.3%

  • Total voters
    146
  • Poll closed .
Here is some up to date research from the Royal Society and the US Academy of Science

http://royalsociety.org/uploadedFil...nce-causes/climate-change-evidence-causes.pdf

CLIMATE CHANGE IS ONE OF THE DEFINING ISSUES OF OUR TIME.

It is now more certain than ever, based on many lines of evidence, that humans are changing Earth’s climate. The atmosphere and oceans have warmed, accompanied by sea-level rise, a strong decline in Arctic sea ice, and other climate-related changes. The evidence is clear. However, due to the nature of science, not every single detail is ever totally settled or completely certain. Nor has every pertinent question yet been answered.

Scientific evidence continues to be gathered around the world, and assumptions and findings about climate change are continually analysed and tested. Some areas of active debate and ongoing research include the link between ocean heat content and the rate of warming, estimates of how much warming to expect in the future, and the connections between climate change and extreme weather events.


Graphical data on pg. 3 and 4 clearly show 100 years of temperature increases, 30 years of arctic ice declines, 50 years of ocean temperature increasing, and 60 years of the corresponding sea level rise.

As much as you want to criticize specifics, the overall patter is pretty damn clear.
 
It also answers all sorts of question such as:

"How do scientists know that recent climate change is largely caused by human activities?"

and

"Climate is always changing. Why is climate change of concern now?"


They even include a basics of climate change that should be especially of interest of AK.
 
As much as you want to criticize specifics, the overall patter is pretty damn clear.

I assume "criticize specifics" is a reference to the IPCC's predictions being spectacularly wrong.

In fact, I have advocated for clear criteria for falsifying and verifying the theory of global warming. It is only when clear standards are in place that we'll be able to determine whether the theory is sound.
 
strong decline in Arctic sea ice
Arctic sea ice increased by 50% from 2012 to 2013.
Yes, thats still low compared to 30 years ago, but at least its an improvement:

https://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/

CryoSat suggests thicker ice than in recent years

Preliminary measurements from CryoSat show that the volume of Arctic sea ice in autumn 2013 was about 50% higher than in the autumn of 2012. In October 2013, CryoSat measured approximately 9,000 cubic kilometers (approximately 2,200 cubic miles) of sea ice compared to 6,000 cubic kilometers (approximately 1,400 cubic miles) in October 2012. About 90% of the increase in volume between the two years is due to the retention of thick, multiyear ice around Northern Greenland and the Canadian Archipelago.

However, this apparent recovery in ice volume should be considered in a long-term context. It is estimated that in the early 1980s, October ice volume was around 20,000 cubic kilometers (approximately 4,800 cubic miles), meaning that ice volume in October 2013 still ranks among the lowest of the past 30 years
 
I assume "criticize specifics" is a reference to the IPCC's predictions being spectacularly wrong.....

No matter how many times you repeat that it won't become true. The predictions didn't expect as much heat to be stored in the oceans (which raises ocean levels BTW). The heat is building up on earth. Don't see how it is split between the surface and ocean changes that the earth has been getting warmer for 100+ years.
 
And is that supposed to convince us that Arctic ice levels have a clear pattern of decreasing over the past 30 years?
No, we dont know what caused the arctic ice decrease. Couldve been part of a natural cycle, or it couldve been manmade. I just find it interesting that with so many more CO2's in the air, somehow arctic ice increased 50% over the previous year
 
Not so. All along, the IPCC has been making very specific predictions, starting with its first report in 1990: http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and..._first_assessment_1990_wg1.shtml#.UxPA7c69bAI

Having made specific and alarming predictions in the name of "science," the researchers can't now cry foul because the predictions were wrong.

Furthermore, it's worth remembering that I asked Groggy (who said he has read all the IPCC reports) on the standard for falsification of the theory of global warming. Judging from his response, it seems clear that no such standard exists.

The climate researchers need to set clear standards for the falsification and verification of the theory. Otherwise, the theory has no merit as science.

My beliefs will be based on the evidence.


and they have learned exponentially so much since 1990. This reports got people thinking and becoming aware of the possible future. Give me three 'exact' predictions they gave in 1990.
As far as evidence, so was Lomberg analysis but apparently he was really bad, dishonest or uninformed.

Standards of falsification? What the fuck is that?
 
I read it over more carefully this time, and here's the footnote in a nutshell:

When it comes down to global temperatures, everything hinges on the control runs and inherent natural variability of the global coupled climate models. The TAR showed multi-model results for future changes in climate, however since the TAR is an unprecedented internationally coordinated climate change experiment thats been performed by over 23 models from around the world, you tend to get a variable output of surface temperatures versus atmospheric temperatures.

If you then use a mean average of both, you should get an oscillated output, which will give a more accurate global temperature reading. The TAR noted that much of the regional variation of the annual mean warming in the multi-model means is associated with high- to low-latitude contrast. But since you're oscillating both surface temperatures versus atmospheric temperatures, you will get a better model mean in terms of zonal averages

Not bad, you got most of it but still missed the relevant bit for the bet.
Maybe there's hope for you yet.
 
And there have been suggestions that I'm using "talking points"? :D

Actually, the bogus John Cook number you're citing was released in May 2013. The IPCC report with the 95 per cent confidence stat was released in September 2013.
:

Cook study?
No, I was checking Duran, 2009. His number is 97.4% of climatologists and that's backed up by Anderegg, 2010 who puts the number at 97-98%. That's three separate studies. You lose.
 
Arctic sea ice increased by 50% from 2012 to 2013.
Yes, thats still low compared to 30 years ago, but at least its an improvement:

https://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/

Again you picking one year just like the 1922 example. A single year event doesn't make an improvement, I'm very familiar with the NSIDC and know of its work past and present.

http://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/files/2000/02/Fig3_Jan2014_trend-350x261.png

Including 2014, sea ice extent for January is declining at a rate of 3.2% per decade relative to the 1981 to 2012 average, or at a rate of 47,800 square kilometers (18,500 square miles) per year. January 2014 is the fourth lowest extent in the satellite record, behind 2005, 2006, and the record low January 2011.

Ice coverage doesn't involve ice volume, something that has been mentioned before, but clearly you have difficulty retaining.

About 90% of the increase in volume between the two years is due to the retention of thick, multiyear ice around Northern Greenland and the Canadian Archipelago. However, this apparent recovery in ice volume should be considered in a long-term context. It is estimated that in the early 1980s, October ice volume was around 20,000 cubic kilometers (approximately 4,800 cubic miles), meaning that ice volume in October 2013 still ranks among the lowest of the past 30 years. CryoSat will continue to monitor sea ice through the current growth season, and the data will reveal the effect of this past autumn’s increase on ice volume at

http://nsidc.org/arcticseaicenews/files/2014/02/Figure5a-350x280.png

Antarctic sea ice extent continues to track very high in January, reaching the second-highest monthly extent in the 36-year satellite monitoring record. New monthly extent records were set for each month between August and November, and December was tied for the record (within the limits of the precision). Trend maps of sea ice concentration (Figure 5b), however, reveal that the increase is not uniform around the Antarctic continent, nor is the strength of the monthly trends (in percent increase per decade) as great as those for the Arctic, in either winter or summer. While sea ice has increased in the western Ross Sea and the Weddell Sea, it has declined in the Amundsen and Bellingshausen seas.
 
Not so. All along, the IPCC has been making very specific predictions, starting with its first report in 1990: http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and..._first_assessment_1990_wg1.shtml#.UxPA7c69bAI
.

Not true, each report gives a range of possible changes with a range possible inputs and a margin of error. Its only your heartland lobbyists who try to claim they say its one number. You could read the footnote of death for clarification, were you smart enough. Ak47 might be able to help you, he made it about half way through.
 
Not true, each report gives a range of possible changes with a range possible inputs and a margin of error. Its only your heartland lobbyists who try to claim they say its one number. You could read the footnote of death for clarification, were you smart enough. Ak47 might be able to help you, he made it about half way through.

If you thought I misinterpreted the prediction, you shouldn't have accepted the bet.

But you did accept it. There was no range in the terms of the bet. Anything less than 0.2 degrees Celsius and you lose.

Most likely, you're going to lose. Prepare yourself for it.

Cook study?
No, I was checking Duran, 2009. His number is 97.4% of climatologists and that's backed up by Anderegg, 2010 who puts the number at 97-98%. That's three separate studies. You lose.

Sure. Ninety-seven per cent of climatologists in 2009 and 2010 endorsed the IPCC report (the one with the 95% confidence level) that came out in 2013. You're just making this up as you go along.

No matter how many times you repeat that it won't become true.

It most certainly is true.

Your standards for supporting the theory point to everything that is wrong with the theory.

According to you, the IPCC predicted something would happen with the climate, and something did happen. Granted, what some believe actually occurred (and the deep ocean theory hasn't been proven, by the way) is nothing at all like what was predicted. But, well, it was something ... so close enough.

Of course, since climate is always changing, loosening the standards in the way that you would like essentially means that everything becomes "evidence" of global warming.

If we accept your standards, the theory of global warming becomes neither provable nor unprovable. In that case, it's not science. It's religion.
 
Standards of falsification? What the fuck is that?

I may not have the lingo right, but in plain English, it's the setting of clear standards for evidence that would prove the theory is false.

At one time (back in the Climategate emails), Phil Jones of the CRU in East Anglia said if we went 15 years with no warming, that would show there is a problem with the models. Of course, since that 15-year benchmark has been met, he no longer uses it.

But no new standard is in place.

You can't treat every piece of evidence -- no matter what it is -- as verification of the theory. For the theory to verifiable, it also has to be falsifiable. We need to know precisely what facts would be accepted by the IPCC and other climate researchers as evidence that the theory isn't sound.

The climate researchers won't set such a standard. Most likely, because they know there's a good chance the evidence could materialize.
 
I may not have the lingo right, but in plain English, it's the setting of clear standards for evidence that would prove the theory is false.

At one time (back in the Climategate emails), Phil Jones of the CRU in East Anglia said if we went 15 years with no warming, that would show there is a problem with the models. Of course, since that 15-year benchmark has been met, he no longer uses it.

But no new standard is in place.

You can't treat every piece of evidence -- no matter what it is -- as verification of the theory. For the theory to verifiable, it also has to be falsifiable. We need to know precisely what facts would be accepted by the IPCC and other climate researchers as evidence that the theory isn't sound.

The climate researchers won't set such a standard. Most likely, because they know there's a good chance the evidence could materialize.

Huh?

As for your last point, I'm not sure when you got your mind readers licence.

Your post is full of assumptions. Had Phil said 17 years would that have made a difference? The 15 year was a guideline, not a hard and fast rule. Set standards are hard to justify because each case is unique and often affected by unique conditions, but I'm sure the professional statisticians on TERB can give some technical light on a good guess.
 
If you thought I misinterpreted the prediction, you shouldn't have accepted the bet.

But you did accept it. There was no range in the terms of the bet. Anything less than 0.2 degrees Celsius and you lose.

Most likely, you're going to lose. Prepare yourself for it.

I do think you'r too stupid to understand the full prediction by the IPCC, including the footnote, which is why I taunt you daily about your stupidity.
Sure, the bets on, good luck.



Sure. Ninety-seven per cent of climatologists in 2009 and 2010 endorsed the IPCC report (the one with the 95% confidence level) that came out in 2013. You're just making this up as you go along.

Stupid answer.
I gave you three supporting and independent studies backing up my claim and you have nothing.
You lose.






According to you, the IPCC predicted something would happen with the climate, and something did happen. Granted, what some believe actually occurred (and the deep ocean theory hasn't been proven, by the way) is nothing at all like what was predicted. But, well, it was something ... so close enough.

If you were smart enough to read the full report and the full predictions you'd realize that the present climate is within the ranges they predicted when all forcings are considered. The models evolve and get better each year as they include more details and more possible forcings. Just because you're lobbyists and hackers cherry picked a number based off the warmest year ever recorded doesn't mean the models are wrong or the predictions are wrong, they just cheated the numbers to fool idiots like you who aren't smart enough to realize how they are playing you.
 
Hey MovieFan, should let the rest of the forum in on how groggy fell into my trap?? Or should I wait a bit and let him dig an even deeper grave for himself?? :biggrin1:
 
Hey MovieFan, should let the rest of the forum in on how groggy fell into my trap?? Or should I wait a bit and let him dig an even deeper grave for himself?? :biggrin1:

You mean you did get your father to read the footnote of death for you? Or did you get someone from the heartland institute to give you a ready made talking point?
 
Heh, I give groggy a hint and he still doesnt catch on.

I can tell you're a young guy, groggy. I'm guessing between ages of 18 and 24, amiright??