Global Warming. Fact or grossly exaggerated??

Whats your opinion on global warming?

  • Its too late! We're all gonne bake, frie and die in a few years

    Votes: 44 30.1%
  • Its not as bad as scientists say. We got at least 100 to 200 years before shit hits the fan

    Votes: 33 22.6%
  • Its not real at all. Its a carbon credit money making scam

    Votes: 45 30.8%
  • Its all a big conspiracy MAN!!!

    Votes: 9 6.2%
  • Its way too cold in Canada, I wish it were real. Start up the SUV's

    Votes: 15 10.3%

  • Total voters
    146
  • Poll closed .
^^^ exactly blackrock, so if they can't predict the weather properly, they sure as hell can't predict climate either.

And dont give me this shit about climate isnt weather, because weather is part of climate. An inconvenient truth

Not being able to predict weather to your satisfaction doesn't mean they can predict weather or predict climate changes. You are still trying to equate one with the other.
 
So ignoring politics, you realize that average global temperatures have been going up and the polar ice cap is shrinking.

Sure. I also realize the computer model predictions have been spectacularly wrong and that there is no evidence linking man-made carbon dioxide emissions to changes in the climate.

That's not to say that it has been definitively proven that the theory of global warming is false. Rather, the climate is complex and it is doubtful we will be able to make predictions about the climate (which is what the scientists who wrote the first draft of the IPCC's report in 1995 were saying all along).
 
Sure. I also realize the computer model predictions have been spectacularly wrong and that there is no evidence linking man-made carbon dioxide emissions to changes in the climate.

So let's just ignore everything they say and take what comes. The gods would want it that way.
 
So let's just ignore everything they say and take what comes.

Back to Crichton one more time: "The future is unknowable."

When it comes to future developments and technological advancements, you cannot predict what the future holds and it is folly (bordering on insanity) to think otherwise.

That said, I don't object to measures to reduce carbon dioxide emissions. But I don't think we should be guided by dubious "science" and unnecessarily alarmist predictions, regardless of the motives behind them.
 
Not being able to predict weather to your satisfaction doesn't mean they can predict weather or predict climate changes. You are still trying to equate one with the other
Look dude, we had an increase of 1 billion people in earths population last 15 years or so. We also had India and China undergoing their own versions of an industrial age, both associated with heavy increases in CO2's. We should have seen a drastic increase in global temperatures based on that, and yet we didnt.

We didnt see shit!!

So the climate models which predict global warming are either wrong, or highly exaggerated
 
A lot of verbiage above, but it looks like we have a bet!

To recap:

If the Earth's temperature is 0.2 degrees Celsius higher (or more) in 2017 than what it was in 2007, Groggy wins.

If it isn't, I win.

(I'll bookmark this page and we will see who has ultimately called it correctly).

And remember that you've agreed to the bet complete with the footnote paragraph you're too stupid to understand.
This is so easy.......

And as to this:
To quote Michael Crichton again:

Bwaahh haaa haa!

That crackpot author as a reputable source?

Bwahh ha ha!

With a 12 year old quote about a study from nearly 20 years ago?
Ridiculous.

Which reminds me, did you google 'scientific method' yet?
Do you even have any clue to how science works?

And shall we close with the latest words from NASA.
NASA scientists say 2013 tied with 2009 and 2006 for the seventh warmest year since 1880, continuing a long-term trend of rising global temperatures.
With the exception of 1998, the 10 warmest years in the 134-year record have all occurred since 2000, with 2010 and 2005 ranking as the warmest years on record.

http://climate.nasa.gov/news/1029
 
Look dude, we had an increase of 1 billion people in earths population last 15 years or so. We also had India and China undergoing their own versions of an industrial age, both associated with heavy increases in CO2's. We should have seen a drastic increase in global temperatures based on that, and yet we didnt.

Why, how different is the CO2 output now?
How much higher should the temperature be now with the higher CO2 output?
Is it higher then any of the IPCC outlooks?
How much lag time is there before we see results from CO2?
Do you have even the slightest clue about what you are saying?
 
Back to Crichton one more time: "The future is unknowable."

When it comes to future developments and technological advancements, you cannot predict what the future holds and it is folly (bordering on insanity) to think otherwise.

That said, I don't object to measures to reduce carbon dioxide emissions. But I don't think we should be guided by dubious "science" and unnecessarily alarmist predictions, regardless of the motives behind them.

Only of you expect perfection in our prediction.
 
From first hand experience GW is a fact and the research shows that. Deniers want perfection, which won't happen. Is the world arming up, just ask the residents in California, the food basket of the US, who are in the longest and driest draught in over a 100 years

100 yrs is very short periode when you consider how old our planet is (4.5 to 4.6 billion years old). The earth is doing what it always has done, and even way before we were around.
Yes it is a fact and its always happened in our planets history. Personally I'd be more conserned about meteorites and comets and thier sheer size, after all, I truely believe that this happened
at one point in our planets history, it also was the demise, of the reign of dinousaurs.
 
Only of you expect perfection in our prediction.

The "perfection" argument (which I have heard elsewhere) is intellectually dishonest.

This isn't a case of the models simply having been a bit off. In fact, the predictions have been spectacularly wrong. Complete failure is quite different from having been less than perfect.

And remember that you've agreed to the bet complete with the footnote paragraph you're too stupid to understand.

It's no wonder Groggy likes websites such as RealClimate.org and SkepticalScience.com, which specialize in revisionist history.

Has anyone besides me noticed that he keeps wanting to say we have a bet but (with his alleged "footnote") that he won't say what he thinks the bet is.

I have been very clear on what the wager should be. Groggy keeps alluding to changes to the bet, but refuses to say what he thinks we're betting on. In true Skeptical Science fashion, he'll wait to clarify or explain his bet until sometime after the results are known.

I suspect that is because Groggy has no faith in the computer-model predictions, for good reason. He simply doesn't want to admit it.
 
Do you even have any clue to how science works?

I sure do. For example, I know that skepticism is central to good science.

I also know that credible science must be completely detached from political objectives and activism. With no exceptions.

Are you seriously suggesting that Michael Mann and James Hansen (two of the leading climate researchers) have never engaged in activist activities? Do you have any idea how easy it is to prove that you are wrong?

In fact, here is all the proof that you need:

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/19/opinion/sunday/if-you-see-something-say-something.html?_r=0
 
Why, how different is the CO2 output now?
With an extra 1.2 billion people on earth of course CO2 output is gonna be a lot higher, smartypants. Unless you erroneously think most of that 1.2 billion lives in huts in Africa somewhere and doesnt create CO2's

How much higher should the temperature be now with the higher CO2 output?
I dunno, quite a bit higher maybe?? More CO2's = higher temperatures according to you "geniuses"

Is it higher then any of the IPCC outlooks?
No, its lower. IPCC has been completely wrong in their predictions. Look it up

How much lag time is there before we see results from CO2?
Oh, so now there's a lag time. Funny, when IPCC predicted calamity back in the mid 1990's they made no mention of a lag time. Now that we have a pause in GW suddenly they've invented a "lag time". How convenient

Do you have even the slightest clue about what you are saying?
No, do you have the slightest clue about what you're saying?

You just regurgitate whatever you read at skepticalscience.com and blindly accept it to be true. Then you'll copy/paste in this thread, pretend you understand all the science, and call anyone who questions it "stupid".

Try to think for yourself sometime
 
The "perfection" argument (which I have heard elsewhere) is intellectually dishonest.

This isn't a case of the models simply having been a bit off. In fact, the predictions have been spectacularly wrong. Complete failure is quite different from having been less than perfect.

It's no wonder Groggy likes websites such as RealClimate.org and SkepticalScience.com, which specialize in revisionist history.

Has anyone besides me noticed that he keeps wanting to say we have a bet but (with his alleged "footnote") that he won't say what he thinks the bet is.

I have been very clear on what the wager should be. Groggy keeps alluding to changes to the bet, but refuses to say what he thinks we're betting on. In true Skeptical Science fashion, he'll wait to clarify or explain his bet until sometime after the results are known.

I suspect that is because Groggy has no faith in the computer-model predictions, for good reason. He simply doesn't want to admit it.

Perhaps i should have said 'near' perfection. As to it being intellectually dishonest, wha?

The failure to predict the winter weather for one year was an isolated event, not a trend. How many seasons did they get right? You and AK keep trying to make isolated events, 1922, the hockey stick graph, this years winter weather, prove that GW is false. As David Phillips puts it, there have been many more high temperature records broken than low temperature records broken. The professional statisticians on TERB will tell you, even using big words to describe it, but one event doesn't make a trend and it doesn't matter how big the devision was, a one off is just that, one off. You then try and find out why it happened, which they have.

SC is far from a revisionist site. I don't know much about RealClimate to comment on it as a whole. They simply take the slew of reports and research done on the subject and present them in one place. The graphs are quite clear to anyone who understand climate weather and high school math.

As far as your bet is concerned, I'm not sure both of you will be on TERB at the end of 2017.
 
The "perfection" argument (which I have heard elsewhere) is intellectually dishonest.

Oh my fucking gord!
Are you still on about this!
How fucking stupid are you?
Let me remind you to google:

The Scientific Method


I hope you didn't miss it this time.



This isn't a case of the models simply having been a bit off. In fact, the predictions have been spectacularly wrong. Complete failure is quite different from having been less than perfect.

OH MY FUCKING GORD!
You're wrong, here let my post that gif on more time, with comparison between IPCC predictions, reality and the clowns you read.
IPCCvsContrarians.gif



Has anyone besides me noticed that he keeps wanting to say we have a bet but (with his alleged "footnote") that he won't say what he thinks the bet is.

The bet is on, the only problem is that you're too stupid to read and understand the footnote so you'll lose the bet.
Idiot.

I have been very clear on what the wager should be. Groggy keeps alluding to changes to the bet, but refuses to say what he thinks we're betting on. In true Skeptical Science fashion, he'll wait to clarify or explain his bet until sometime after the results are known.

The bet is on the IPCC prediction, you're just so stupid you only read the summary and don't read the full prediction or the footnotes.
Don't blame me for your stupidity.
 
With an extra 1.2 billion people on earth of course CO2 output is gonna be a lot higher, smartypants. Unless you erroneously think most of that 1.2 billion lives in huts in Africa somewhere and doesnt create CO2's

And did you read the IPCC reports?
Are you sure they didn't include population growth in their CO2 projections?
Or are you just guessing?

I dunno, quite a bit higher maybe?? More CO2's = higher temperatures according to you "geniuses"

Did you read the IPCC report, it'll tell you how much higher they think it might get based on different projections of CO2 growth.
And by the way, you don't say "CO2's", makes you look very uninformed.

No, its lower. IPCC has been completely wrong in their predictions. Look it up
I did, its within the range of their predictions, but at the lower end. They now incorporate growth in trade winds and ocean warming into their models because they are much smarter then you.


Oh, so now there's a lag time. Funny, when IPCC predicted calamity back in the mid 1990's they made no mention of a lag time. Now that we have a pause in GW suddenly they've invented a "lag time". How convenient

There's always been a lag time. Don't blame me because you don't understand the science, its all there in the reports you said you read.

No, do you have the slightest clue about what you're saying?
Yup, and will link to the reports that back up my points, not that you could understand them....

You just regurgitate whatever you read at skepticalscience.com and blindly accept it to be true. Then you'll copy/paste in this thread, pretend you understand all the science, and call anyone who questions it "stupid".

No, note that every one these responses is in my own words. That's because I understand the science well enough to be able to read a report and give you a summary of what its about.
Also note that I gave moviefan an easy out to win the bet, all he had to do was read one posting about a report (really a summary) and then summarize what it was about.
He couldn't do it and is now stuck with a bet he'll lose (because he's not smart enough to read the full text) in three years.



Try to think for yourself sometime
Now this is funny.
Did you notice how many questions I asked you in the previous posts?
Did you notice that you couldn't answer a single one?
That's because you've only ever read contrarian sites and only ever parroted their $1 billion funded talking points.
You lack the brains to read the IPCC report and understand what its about and think you're smart enough to think they are wrong.
Loser.
 
100 yrs is very short periode when you consider how old our planet is (4.5 to 4.6 billion years old). The earth is doing what it always has done, and even way before we were around.
Yes it is a fact and its always happened in our planets history. Personally I'd be more conserned about meteorites and comets and thier sheer size, after all, I truely believe that this happened
at one point in our planets history, it also was the demise, of the reign of dinousaurs.

The climate on the earth has changed drastically over the 4.5 billion years, but only been suitable for humans for ~700 million years and in that time we've gone from a population in Southern Africa of less than a few thousand at one point, pushed to the coast by severe drought up north, to now over 7 billion.

The 'giant meteorite killed Barnie' theory is an over simplification of what probably happened and it's still up for debate as to exactly what did cause it. There are a few theories, the two most popular are the "intrinsic gradualists" and the "extrinsic catastrophists" and my feeling is that it's a combination of events. I've heard that the chance of an asteroid hitting earth in my lifetime, ~2040 is ~45,000 to one. I'm not changing my vacation plans for that.
 
You are "Projecting"

No, note that every one these responses is in my own words. That's because I understand the science well enough to be able to read a report and give you a summary of what its about
So please tell us, groggy. What exactly are your academic qualifications on all the science regarding global warming. Could you please list all the courses you took, and any college or university degrees you hold on the subject??
 
You are "Projecting"
No, I think you are a loser now.


So please tell us, groggy. What exactly are your academic qualifications on all the science regarding global warming. Could you please list all the courses you took, and any college or university degrees you hold on the subject??

You don't need courses in climatology, you need basic understandings of science, the scientific method and a reading comprehension above high school as well as an ability to objectively weigh what you are reading. I'm sorry you don't have any of those, and do wish you would at least acknowledge that you aren't smart enough to really understand an IPCC report or the full arguments and instead rely on reading only posts that offer summaries that support your existing beliefs.

If you like, I'll offer you the same challenge I offered moviefan.
You can win the same bet and make me buy whatever contrarian book you like by reading and summarizing in your own words this post:
http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2014/02/going-with-the-wind/

But since we both know you aren't smart enough to be able to do this, I'll just expect you to ignore this post and get back to copying and pasting fossil fuel lobbyist info.