Global Warming. Fact or grossly exaggerated??

Whats your opinion on global warming?

  • Its too late! We're all gonne bake, frie and die in a few years

    Votes: 44 30.1%
  • Its not as bad as scientists say. We got at least 100 to 200 years before shit hits the fan

    Votes: 33 22.6%
  • Its not real at all. Its a carbon credit money making scam

    Votes: 45 30.8%
  • Its all a big conspiracy MAN!!!

    Votes: 9 6.2%
  • Its way too cold in Canada, I wish it were real. Start up the SUV's

    Votes: 15 10.3%

  • Total voters
    146
  • Poll closed .
Spoken by someone who's never made it through a full post at skepticalscience.com. I expect.
If you dig deep enough they give you the data and their probabilities in a very straightforward and honest way.
You just have to be smart enough to understand the science
Spoken by someone who just blindly accepts whatever skepticalscience.com says.

Try coming up with your arguments instead of parroting what some website says
 
No, actually, the report released in 2007 was AR4. And I haven't misquoted anything.

https://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/wg1/en/spmsspm-projections-of.html

I don't blame you for not wanting to take the bet. The prediction is almost certain to be spectacularly wrong.


And time for a refresher on the bet.

1) An easy challenge with the same reward was offered - read a single post on skepticalscience on the 'pause' as you like to call it and summarize it in your own words. Offer was made two times, this counts as a third. All you have to do is read something and prove that you understand the basics of the science, but since we've now confirmed that you aren't smart enough to be able to do it, we're stuck taking bets on the IPCC predictions.

2) You like to read summaries, but because you are stupid don't read the full articles. Then you think you understand what you are talking about because you read the summary.

So, in light of 1) and 2), I'll continue to accept the bet which was on the IPCC predictions as written in their full report, just as you offered.
Do you understand that part of the bet?
 
Spoken by someone who just blindly accepts whatever skepticalscience.com says

No need to, since every single article continues references to the original papers the work comes from.
You can read the summary, almost-plain-english-enough-for-moviefan-to-understand level, or you click on intermediate and get a bit more info or you can click on the actual papers and read the research for yourself. If you were smart enough, that is.

But you're not, are you?
 
And time for a refresher on the bet.

1) An easy challenge with the same reward was offered - read a single post on skepticalscience on the 'pause' as you like to call it and summarize it in your own words. Offer was made two times, this counts as a third. All you have to do is read something and prove that you understand the basics of the science, but since we've now confirmed that you aren't smart enough to be able to do it, we're stuck taking bets on the IPCC predictions.

Go back and read my earlier post on this matter. I did summarize it: revisionist history.

If you want me to elaborate: The author decided to rewrite the predictions (calling them "adjusted" predictions) long after the real-world results were already known. It's utterly meaningless. Anyone can retroactively predict events that have already taken place. For example, you don't have to be a military expert to "predict" the Nazis will lose the Second World War. The outcome is already known.

The rewrite of the predictions is useless. The only measure that counts is how the actual predictions (before the real-world results were known) stand up against the evidence. On that count, the predictions were spectacularly wrong.

There you go. I win this bet.

(And you should visit a library to borrow a copy of George Orwell's novel, Nineteen Eighty-Four.)

I'll continue to accept the bet which was on the IPCC predictions as written in their full report, just as you offered. Do you understand that part of the bet?

Let me be certain we're clear on this.

You accept the bet on the IPCC's 2007 prediction in its AR4 report that the Earth's surface temperature will have increased 0.2 degrees Celsius from its 2007 level by 2017?

(Sorry, but I'm not interested in bets that have to run until 2035).

If the 2017 wager is the one you now say you're making -- it's a bet!
 
No need to, since every single article continues references to the original papers the work comes from.
You can read the summary, almost-plain-english-enough-for-moviefan-to-understand level, or you click on intermediate and get a bit more info or you can click on the actual papers and read the research for yourself. If you were smart enough, that is.

But you're not, are you?
Smart enough to know bullshit when I see it, and this whole global warming scam is starting to reek like crazy
 
Go back and read my earlier post on this matter. I did summarize it: revisionist history.

I know you don't understand how science works, but are you really that daft?
Have you heard of this thing called 'the scientific method' and how it works.
Google it, try to read it and then come back to this post.
If you can't understand why it makes the above sentence look really stupid, then repeat until you do.
Please.


If you want me to elaborate: The author decided to rewrite the predictions (calling them "adjusted" predictions) long after the real-world results were already known. It's utterly meaningless. Anyone can retroactively predict events that have already taken place. For example, you don't have to be a military expert to "predict" the Nazis will lose the Second World War. The outcome is already known.

Again, google 'scientific method'.
Its really quite remarkable.


The rewrite of the predictions is useless. The only measure that counts is how the actual predictions (before the real-world results were known) stand up against the evidence. On that count, the predictions were spectacularly wrong.

Oh my god, your still fucking writing about this?
SCIENTIFIC METHOD
Its how they figure things out, make hypothesis that become theories that become laws.
Are you really that stupid?

There you go. I win this bet.

Wait, you're changing the terms again. I thought you were betting about the IPCC predictions, are you really only interested in taking one sentence out of context and using that as the frame of reference? I know you're stupid, but you don't even know what the full predictions were, do you?
How can you offer to bet if you don't know what they predicted?
Stupid.

(And you should visit a library to borrow a copy of George Orwell's novel, Nineteen Eighty-Four.)

So you think that scientists should stick with whatever theory or model they get? They get one chance and then they work only with that model?
And what the fuck does that have do with Orwell's book?
Are you suggesting that the IPCC is really more like the NSA?




Let me be certain we're clear on this.

You accept the bet on the IPCC's 2007 prediction in its AR4 report that the Earth's surface temperature will have increased 0.2 degrees Celsius from its 2007 level by 2017?

Oh, so you're only betting on AR4, not AR5?
Why not go back to 1896 and Arrhenius's work?
His guess wasn't great, but its better then say, Lindzen?

Are you still running DOS, by the way? A man like you needs to make a statement, that when engineers, programmers and scientists make a new theory/program, that you will judge them only by their earlier work. You do keep this attitude towards all of science of course, don't you? Like, refusing MRI's, modern cars or LED lights? Only judge them on their early work.

Ok, now that I've got that out, we can take a look at what you're really trying to do.
You're cherry picking talking points from some contrarian site, aren't you?
You picked some place where that $1 billion of annual contrarian bullshit lives and copied and pasted something.
And of course it hasn't been updated yet, because they like to just hammer on the same stupid and easily debunked crap over and over, don't they?

But if you're really married to this old heritage funded talking point, we can go there.
First, since you're using the quotes, you'll need to accept the relevance of the footnotes to the quotes and the predictions, including this statement:
The concept that the climate system exhibits commitment when radiative forcing has changed is mainly due to the thermal inertia of the oceans, and was discussed independently by Wigley (1984), Hansen et al. (1984) and Siegenthaler and Oeschger (1984). The term ‘commitment’ in this regard was introduced by Ramanathan (1988). In the TAR, this was illustrated in idealised scenarios of doubling and quadrupling atmospheric CO2, and stabilisation at 2050 and 2100 after an IS92a forcing scenario. Various temperature commitment values were reported (about 0.3°C per century with much model dependency), and EMIC simulations were used to illustrate the long-term influence of the ocean owing to long mixing times and the MOC. Subsequent studies have confirmed this behaviour of the climate system and ascribed it to the inherent property of the climate system that the thermal inertia of the ocean introduces a lag to the warming of the climate system after concentrations of greenhouse gases are stabilised (Mitchell et al., 2000; Wetherald et al., 2001; Wigley and Raper, 2003; Hansen et al., 2005b; Meehl et al., 2005c; Wigley, 2005). Climate change commitment as discussed here should not be confused with ‘unavoidable climate change’ over the next half century, which would surely be greater because forcing cannot be instantly stabilised. Furthermore, in the very long term it is plausible that climate change could be less than in a commitment run since forcing could plausibly be reduced below current levels as illustrated in the overshoot simulations and zero emission commitment simulations discussed below..

That's included in the bet, fair?



If the 2017 wager is the one you now say you're making -- it's a bet!

Again, since I've read the reports and projections that are current, and not 7 years old like you, I'm fully aware of the predictions and the confidence of climatologists when they make them. So I'll bet on their 'moderate confidence' over your total lack of understanding and dated sources.

No problem, the bet is on.
 
No problem, the bet is on.

A lot of verbiage above, but it looks like we have a bet!

To recap:

If the Earth's temperature is 0.2 degrees Celsius higher (or more) in 2017 than what it was in 2007, Groggy wins.

If it isn't, I win.

(I'll bookmark this page and we will see who has ultimately called it correctly).
 
A lot of verbiage above, but it looks like we have a bet!

To recap:

If the Earth's temperature is 0.2 degrees Celsius higher (or more) in 2017 than what it was in 2007, Groggy wins.

If it isn't, I win.

(I'll bookmark this page and we will see who has ultimately called it correctly).
Which month of 2017?? I'm assuming all the data up to (and including) December 31st of 2017, right??
 
Just to give you an idea how stupid Liberals are, first they say you cant refute global warming by how cold this winter has been throughout most of North-America. Then they suddenly turn around and say this present California drought CAN be used as evidence global warming is real.

FFWD to 3:50: http://www.mediaite.com/tv/rachel-maddow-cuts-down-bill-maher-and-charles-cooke-like-weeds/

So if climate is measured over decade and/or centuries, then why can the Left use a local drought as evidence GW is real, but I cant use a very long, cold winter as evidence GW might not be real??

Also when Rachel MadCow says this present California drought is worst in history, she is plain wrong. The US has had plenty of long droughts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drought_in_the_United_States

Drought in the United States

There were at least three major droughts in nineteenth century North America: one from the mid-1850s to the mid-1860s, one in the 1870s, and one in the 1890s.

There was also a drought around 1820; the periods from 1816 to 1844 and from 1849 to 1880 were rather dry, and the 19th century overall was a dry century for the Great Plains.

While there was little rain-gauge data from the mid-19th century in the middle of the US, there were plenty of trees, and tree-ring data showed evidence of a major drought from around 1856 to around 1865
 
Just to give you an idea how stupid Liberals are, first they say you cant refute global warming by how cold this winter has been throughout most of North-America. Then they suddenly turn around and say this present California drought CAN be used as evidence global warming is real.

FFWD to 3:50: http://www.mediaite.com/tv/rachel-maddow-cuts-down-bill-maher-and-charles-cooke-like-weeds/

So if climate is measured over decade and/or centuries, then why can the Left use a local drought as evidence GW is real, but I cant use a very long, cold winter as evidence GW might not be real??

Also when Rachel MadCow says this present California drought is worst in history, she is plain wrong. The US has had plenty of long droughts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drought_in_the_United_States

In fact the really cold winter here and drought there appear to both be a result of arctic warming, which changes the dynamics of weather globally. Climate change manifests itself most obviously in new and unusual weather patterns rather then strictly warming or cooling.

A shift of a degree over ten years isn't something you notice on the thermometer, it's something you notice on the barometer.
 
Right, and if that graph is accurate (which I'm not so sure it is) you still can't say its climate thats causing that, it could be just the cyclic weather. Remember you own words, climate has to be taken over many decades or even a century, not just 35 years

Is this just an attempt to ignore the facts?

Science is about using the evidence to come up with the best possible conclusion, not 'it could be'.

And climate is about the patterns created over a long time. The pattern pretty clearly shows sea ice decreasing despite your claims.
 
Just to give you an idea how stupid Liberals are, ...

I see. This isn't about science, it's about politics.



And yes, the North American weather has been colder than usual. What you miss is that higher than normal Arctic temperatures are what is driving this Polar vortex.

Winter: It’s all about Arctic warming

It’s global warming. Or, rather, it stems from the Arctic warming faster than the rest of the planet.

“This is causing the jet stream to take on a wavier path as it travels around the Northern Hemisphere,” said Francis, a research professor at Rutgers University in New Jersey, in a telephone interview Tuesday.

“Those waves create the weather we feel on the surface.”

The jet stream is kind of like a fast-moving river of air about 1,000 metres above us. While there is more than one jet stream, the one that’s made for all our shovelling this winter is the polar jet. It’s relatively narrow — a few hundred kilometres wide — and it takes huge zigzags north and south as the band of wind makes its way east.

The winds of the polar jet have been clocked as high as 398 kilometres an hour, but typically they’re a good deal slower.

The jet stream is fuelled by the spinning of the Earth on its axis and the difference in temperature between the Arctic and mid-latitudes. When there’s less of a temperature difference, it takes a more meandering course like a slow-moving river.

This year, it has headed south along the Rocky Mountains all the way to Georgia before turning north and passing south of Nova Scotia on its way to bringing miserable weather to Britain. Georgia’s also been plagued by snow and ice storms this winter.

The jet stream is not bad to everybody. It depends which side you’re on.

“On one side of the jet stream, you tend to have a rising motion in the air, where moisture rising creates clouds and storms,” Francis said.

“On the other side, you’ll tend to have a descending motion, causing it to be drier.”

The crux is that when the jet stream takes on a long, slow course, as it has this winter, areas tend to get stuck with prolonged periods of either clear and dry or miserable weather, Francis said.

“So the West Coast has all been dry, Alaska is warm, Scandinavia is very warm and so is Sochi (Russia).”

http://thechronicleherald.ca/novascotia/1188024-winter-it-s-all-about-arctic-warming

Maybe some people have tried to explain this cold winter as an exception but scientists are clear that while our weather has been cold, the arctic has been warm.
 
I see. This isn't about science, it's about politics.

Regrettably, in the case of this issue, that has been true for quite some time.

To quote Michael Crichton again:

Just as the earliest studies of nuclear winter stated that the uncertainties were so great that probabilities could never be known, so, too the first pronouncements on global warming argued strong limits on what could be determined with certainty about climate change. The 1995 IPCC draft report said, “Any claims of positive detection of significant climate change are likely to remain controversial until uncertainties in the total natural variability of the climate system are reduced.” It also said, “No study to date has positively attributed all or part of observed climate changes to anthropogenic causes.” Those statements were removed, and in their place appeared: “The balance of evidence suggests a discernable human influence on climate.”

What is clear, however, is that on this issue, science and policy have become inextricably mixed to the point where it will be difficult, if not impossible, to separate them out.

http://stephenschneider.stanford.edu/Publications/PDF_Papers/Crichton2003.pdf
 
^^^ no offense basketcase, but that sounds like a theory the "experts" quickly pulled out of their collective asses.

Especially when they initially said this winter would be milder then usual: http://www.businessweek.com/article...s-dot-government-never-saw-this-winter-coming

You Libs need a better bullshit-detector

... and did you read why they feel they got it wrong? I doubt it, because it explains the mistake quite well, especially to anyone with a climate, geography or science background.

What the Climate Prediction Center hasn’t been able to figure out is why that ridge has maintained its position so persistently. “Sometimes trying to figure out why something happened is as hard as making the forecast of what will happen,” Halpert said in a Feb. 14 interview.

Then we have this;

The techniques that go into three-month climate forecasts are completely different from the ones used for daily weather forecasting. The daily stuff, says Halpert, is based on “initial conditions”—i.e., measuring as precisely as possible the current state of the atmosphere and predicting how it will evolve over the coming few days. Regardless of what Siri (AAPL) might say, weather forecasts have very little accuracy past a week.


Months-ahead climate forecasts are what Halpert calls “boundary-value problems.” Instead of taking a snapshot of the quickly changing atmosphere, climate forecasters focus on things that change more slowly, such as temperatures of the land and oceans. The concept is that these enduring conditions will “force” the daily weather in a certain direction. Climate forecasters can’t say when a storm might hit, but they try to say whether a given three-month period will be wetter, drier, hotter, or colder than average. (Here’s a good description of the difference between weather and climate forecasting from University of Toronto computer scientist Steve Easterbrook.)
 
^^^ exactly blackrock, so if they can't predict the weather properly, they sure as hell can't predict climate either.

And dont give me this shit about climate isnt weather, because weather is part of climate. An inconvenient truth
 
^^^ no offense basketcase, but that sounds like a theory the "experts" quickly pulled out of their collective asses.

Especially when they initially said this winter would be milder then usual: http://www.businessweek.com/article...s-dot-government-never-saw-this-winter-coming

You Libs need a better bullshit-detector

So the actual temperatures in the arctic being higher than normal is bullshit? Who knew.


Why don't you admit you have no interest in the science or evidence but have made up your mind years ago?



Lovey thinks I'm a neanderthal right winger. You think I'm a liberal.
 
So the actual temperatures in the arctic being higher than normal is bullshit? Who knew.


Why don't you admit you have no interest in the science or evidence but have made up your mind years ago?
And temperatures in Antarctica are lower. So what?? Maybe its part of the earth's cycle.

Also if temperatures globally havent warmed up last 16 years then how can the Arctic have gotten so much warmer? It doesnt make sense. The whole thing smells like bullshit

Lovey thinks I'm a neanderthal right winger. You think I'm a liberal
I meant "you Liberals" in general. I dont know your posts well enough call you a Lib or Con