Global Warming. Fact or grossly exaggerated??

Whats your opinion on global warming?

  • Its too late! We're all gonne bake, frie and die in a few years

    Votes: 44 30.1%
  • Its not as bad as scientists say. We got at least 100 to 200 years before shit hits the fan

    Votes: 33 22.6%
  • Its not real at all. Its a carbon credit money making scam

    Votes: 45 30.8%
  • Its all a big conspiracy MAN!!!

    Votes: 9 6.2%
  • Its way too cold in Canada, I wish it were real. Start up the SUV's

    Votes: 15 10.3%

  • Total voters
    146
  • Poll closed .
That's all you got? You can't refute, so you attack the authors. They have more credibility than you. The primary sources are provided for you.

Another one who thinks if you C&P you don't know what you're talking about. The C&P is simply the quickest way the open you up to the most information about this topic.

Where did you get you information?
If you believe all those explanations at skepticalscience.com, then you're dumber then a bag of bricks. Always beware of someone (or some organization) who has an answer for everything. That usually means they're bullshitting.

Whats even funnier is we could have next 20 years of very cold winters and mild summers, and you guys would still blame it all on global warming. Thats the epitome of stupidity
 
Despite the entire Polar Vortex word buzz, this January was one of the warmest on record
Most Americans live utterly oblivious of anything that didn't happen in their country

My issue with Global Warming though is the fear of melting our ice caps
Fact is for almost all of our planets history there were no ice caps
So despite some people living along coast getting floods or a few species like Polar Bears dieing (to be replaced by new apex predators) fact is world will go on

Also of interest to most people is the fact northern countries (eg Canada) are virtually devoid of life due to freezing temperatures
Places like Brasil or Indonesia have WAY more diverse life than we do, everything from trees to mammals
So it seems heating planet up also is beneficial from an evolution standpoint as well
 
My issue with Global Warming though is the fear of melting our ice caps
Fact is for almost all of our planets history there were no ice caps
So despite some people living along coast getting floods or a few species like Polar Bears dieing (to be replaced by new apex predators) fact is world will go on
Exactly. And its even debatable whether they're melting or not.
They been sounding that alarm since 1922, and the poles are both still there covered in ice.

See here: http://www.snopes.com/politics/science/globalwarming1922.asp
 
If you believe all those explanations at skepticalscience.com, then you're dumber then a bag of bricks. Always beware of someone (or some organization) who has an answer for everything. That usually means they're bullshitting.

Whats even funnier is we could have next 20 years of very cold winters and mild summers, and you guys would still blame it all on global warming. Thats the epitome of stupidity

So still can't tell us where you go this insightful information about the Antarctic ice was increasing or where in the C&P there were errors, figured.

Your basic point is 'don't believe everything you read', which of course I don't, but can't say what's wrong in the article. Are the charts wrong/lying? How are they wrong?

As far as having answers for everything, no one has ever said that in this debate, certainly not I, but generally there are certainly people that know more about GW, climate change and weather forecasting than you and you've proven how little you do know in almost every one of your posts.
 
Exactly. And its even debatable whether they're melting or not.
They been sounding that alarm since 1922, and the poles are both still there covered in ice.

See here: http://www.snopes.com/politics/science/globalwarming1922.asp


No debate from here as I have seen it with my own eyes over a period of nearly 30 in some regions of the world. There are a few members on her who have actually spent time above the arctic circle and you're not one of them, flyovers don't count. You on the other hand are an armchair general in this regards. Rock formation and sedimentary layers that have never seen the light of day in the history of mankind are now exposed to the elements. Polar bears are starving because of declining seal populations and the seal pup being born out of season in layers of thin ice and snow and dying. Polar bears are also having to swim more in open waters than they have had to just to find food, even choosing to try and kill walruses, a dumb move at the best of times, and eating kelp, because there are so few seals. i've seen them in 50 miles open water contrary to a common belief Polar Bears can drown is forced to swim too much.

As far as the 1922 warning, neat, but how was it in 1923?

From the same article you offered;

As interesting as this nearly century-old article might be from a modern perspective, however, it isn't substantive evidence either for or against the concept of anthropogenic global warming. As documented elsewhere, the warming phenomena observed in 1922 proved to be indicative only of a local event in Spitzbergen, not a trend applicable to the Arctic as a whole.

More proof you actually didn't read it.
 
No debate from here as I have seen it with my own eyes over a period of nearly 30 in some regions of the world. There are a few members on her who have actually spent time above the arctic circle and you're not one of them, flyovers don't count. You on the other hand are an armchair general in this regards. Rock formation and sedimentary layers that have never seen the light of day in the history of mankind are now exposed to the elements. Polar bears are starving because the seal pup are being born to late in layers of think ice and snow and dying. Polar bears are also having to swim more in ope waters than they have had to just to find food, even choosing to try and kill walruses, a dumb move at the best of times, and eating kelp, because there are so few seals.

As far as the 1922 warning, neat, but how was it in 1923?

From the same article you offered;


More proof you actually didn't read it.
If they predicted the North Pole would start melting in 1922 and it hasnt happened by now, its most likely complete bullshit. Also, polar bears are doing fine. In fact they are doing so well, the government has increased hunting quotas:

http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424127887323452204578288343627282034

Are Polar Bears Really Disappearing?

Some say they're on the edge of extinction—but locals see a very different reality on the ground

I knew I was in trouble when the biologist from the Manitoba Conservation Department sat down next to me. "The bears look good," he said. "I haven't seen them this fat in years." We'd both been hanging around the tiny town of Churchill, Manitoba, ground zero for everything having to do with polar bears. Every fall the town is overrun with bears waiting for Hudson Bay to freeze. The bears, in turn, are trailed by herds of tourists, tour guides, scientists, green-leaning types and B-list celebrities—all looking for communion with The Most Important Animal of Our Time.

What worried me wasn't what the biologist had to say, but what the woman who had occupied that same seat three minutes earlier had said about the very same bears. A publicist for an environmental advocacy group, she shook her head ruefully. "It's just so sad," she exhaled. "They all look so skinny that it's hard to look at them."

I went north for a simple reason: I wanted to be a hero of the environmental movement and write a poetic obituary for a doomed species. The Center for Biological Diversity—the environmental group that sued the U.S. government to put polar bears on the Endangered Species list—had predicted that "two-thirds of the world's polar bears could be extinct by 2050."

But after months of reporting and hundreds of bear sightings, I kept running up against an inconvenient truth: There were a lot of well-meaning, well-credentialed scientists, wildlife officers and local experts who simply didn't believe that polar bears were one ice cube away from extinction. And they had the numbers to prove it.

Which was good news for the bears…even if it was terrible news for their careers as symbols of environmental doom.

Let's start with what we know. Almost everybody agrees that there are between 20,000 and 25,000 polar bears alive today. Here's another thing almost everyone agrees on: That number is a whole lot bigger than it was 40 years ago.

"Polar bears are one of the biggest conservation success stories in the world," says Drikus Gissing, wildlife director for the Canadian territory of Nunavut. "There are more bears here now than there were in the recent past." And since as many as half of the world's polar bears live in Nunavut, that's not an insignificant statement.

Exactly how much the bear population has grown in recent decades is a subject of intense debate. Some poorly sourced reports placed the earlier number as low as 5,000 animals world-wide, and in 1965, top scientists reported that extinction was in sight. By 1990, the consensus was that the threat had passed, and one expert declared the population could be as high as 40,000. Today, the pendulum has swung back to a gloomy forecast for the future.

The task is complicated by the fact that there isn't one monolithic polar bear population. There are 19 polar bear subpopulations world-wide. Between 1997 and 2004, the bear population of Baffin Bay fell by about one-quarter. Yet in Davis Strait, just to the south, the population has more than doubled since the 1970s.

And in Churchill, where tourists crowd into rumbling "Tundra Buggies" to watch polar bears cavort, the population fell from 1,194 to 935 between 1984 and 2004. After that 2004 count, scientists predicted that the population would crater to 676 bears by 2011. But a recent survey found more than 1,000 bears there, leading some government scientists to enthusiastically endorse increased hunting quotas.

Different factors account for the health of each population. In one area, a ban on the hunting of whitecoat harp seals led to an explosion in the bears' food supply. On the other end of the spectrum, one group of bears appears to be suffering because it has been hunted by indigenous people in both Canada and Greenland. Of the 19 subpopulations, some scientists argue that about one-third are decreasing and one-third are steady or increasing. The rest haven't been studied enough for anyone to know.

It's also important to remember that when people talk about decreases in sea ice, they're usually referring to summer sea ice. Nobody is predicting the disappearance of winter sea ice. Polar bears in the southern latitudes have been accustomed to ice-free summers since well before the Industrial Revolution. During these lean months, they don't go into caves but rather experience a "walking hibernation," eating very little and conserving their energy. If northerly bears start to have somewhat longer summers—as southern bears already do—the future might not be as catastrophic as some fear.

Despite the many real bits of heartening news, bad omens abound. Declines in polar-bear body condition have been widely observed. Recently it has become far less common to see adult females bearing twins or triplets. As Lily Peacock, a bear researcher with the U.S. Geological Survey, puts it, "Some populations appear to be doing OK now, but what's frightening is what might happen in the very near future."

Still, there are reasons to be upbeat. For one, the idea that polar bears can survive only on seal meat has been called into question; diet analysis shows that polar bears routinely eat caribou, vegetation and waterfowl. Indeed, the population of snow geese in the north has recently grown dramatically, and one study suggests that the abundance of goose nests could offset some of the nutrients lost because of a shorter seal-hunting season.

Mitch Taylor, who published almost 50 peer-reviewed papers during his 21 years as a polar-bear biologist and wildlife manager for the territorial government of Nunavut, prefers to avoid speculating too much about the unknown. "We don't know what the future holds, but we do know that many current populations are stable. And we have to manage for what we've got right now, not what we might have in the future."

Management decisions must be driven by scientific data, of course. Yet the experience of people who know bears best can't be entirely discounted. I found that people who actually live in polar-bear country say, by a wide margin, that they're seeing more bears than ever before.

One night as Churchill's "bear season" was gearing up, I sat down with Kevin Burke, a man who has lived with polar bears all his life, as both a Churchill native and a ranger in the deep bush country. He has also spent countless hours assisting the Ph.D.'s who study bears and predict their imminent demise. "I'm just starting to resent being told that I'm not seeing what I know abso-flipping-lutely damn well that I'm seeing with my own eyes," he said (using considerably more colorful language). With polar bears, it's not always black and white
 
Exactly. And its even debatable whether they're melting or not.
They been sounding that alarm since 1922, and the poles are both still there covered in ice.

See here: http://www.snopes.com/politics/science/globalwarming1922.asp

Thermal expansion is a much greater risk. Sea levels have risen about 20 cm in the past century and averaging 3.5 mm per year in the last 20. At least half of it is due to ocean water expanding as it warms.
 
And as for the Polar ice cap....


Arctic Sea Ice Sits at Record Low for Mid-February

Published: February 19th, 2014

Arctic sea ice growth has slowed dramatically in recent weeks, thanks in large part to abnormally warm air and water temperatures. Sea ice now sits at record low levels for mid-February.

According to the National Snow and Ice Data Center, as of February 18, sea ice covered about 14.36 million square kilometers in the Arctic. The previous low on this date was 14.37 million square kilometers in 2006.

The main culprit — in addition to the overall trend of global warming — is likely the rash of warm temperatures. With the polar vortex bringing cold air down to the U.S. this winter, warmer temperatures have been the norm in the Arctic. From February 1-17, temperatures were 7.2° to 14.4°F above normal for much of the Arctic. Some areas have been even warmer.

...

The decline in sea ice is one of the key indicators of climate change. Sea ice in January, the last full month for which data is available, has declined 3.2 percent per decade since 1979 compared to the 1981-2012 average. That equals roughly 18,500 square miles in ice lost per decade, the same area as Vermont and New Hampshire combined. This past January ranked as the fourth-lowest year on record, with 2011 being the all-time record lowest.

Summer sea ice decline is even more precipitous, dropping 13.7 percent per decade over the same period according to the Arctic Report Card.

http://www.climatecentral.org/news/arctic-sea-ice-sits-at-record-low-for-mid-february-17093
 
If you believe all those explanations at skepticalscience.com, then you're dumber then a bag of bricks. Always beware of someone (or some organization) who has an answer for everything. That usually means they're bullshitting.

Indeed. It wasn't all that long ago that skepticalscience.com was denying that there had been a pause in surface temperature increases.

http://www.skepticalscience.com/misleading-daily-mail-prebunked-nuccitelli-et-al-2012.html

Whats even funnier is we could have next 20 years of very cold winters and mild summers, and you guys would still blame it all on global warming. Thats the epitome of stupidity

True, although some people are trying to stop the insanity:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs...ld-centerpiece-of-global-warming-discussions/
 
Indeed. It wasn't all that long ago that skepticalscience.com was denying that there had been a pause in surface temperature increases.

http://www.skepticalscience.com/misleading-daily-mail-prebunked-nuccitelli-et-al-2012.html

True, although some people are trying to stop the insanity:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs...ld-centerpiece-of-global-warming-discussions/

First off it's not Sceptical Science making this claim, secondly it's not quite as you say it is. They were reporting on an article in the Guardian reviewing a Mail article written by David Rose.

From that article;

The British newspaper the Mail on Sunday and its writer David Rose are notorious for publishing misleading (at best) climate-related articles, as we have discussed previously here, for example. They have recently struck again, claiming that according to a "quietly released" Met Office report, global warming stopped 16 years ago (a myth which Skeptical Science debunks here and here). This assertion is entirely fabricated, as the Met Office explained by publishing David Rose's inquiry and the Met Office's responses.

"Firstly, the Met Office has not issued a report on this issue. We can only assume the article is referring to the completion of work to update the HadCRUT4 global temperature dataset compiled by ourselves and the University of East Anglia's Climate Research Unit.


We announced that this work was going on in March and it was finished this week. You can see the HadCRUT4 website here."

Rose's factually challenged article was predictably reproduced uncritically by the usual climate denial blogs and referenced by Fox News, perhaps in an attempt to distract from this year's record-breaking Arctic sea ice minimum. However, virtually every point made in the article was factually incorrect, as Rose would have known if he were a Skeptical Science reader, because we recently pre-bunked his piece.


Rose Tries to Lead the Witness Down the Up Escalator


Rose attempted to elicit a statement from the Met Office by asking a question which would be described in court as "leading the witness":


"First, please confirm that they do indeed reveal no warming trend since 1997."


The Skeptical Science temperature trend calculator can be used to test this question. The trend in the HadCRUT4 global surface temperature dataset since 1997 is 0.084 ± 0.152°C per decade (although we have not yet updated the HadCRUT4 data, the GISS and NCDC datasts show a similar warming trend since 1997). While the trend is not statistically significant, the central value is positive, meaning the average surface temperature has most likely warmed over this period.


The Met Office also explained that Rose is essentially trying to go down the up escalator (Figure 1) by focusing on short-term noise while ignoring the long-term trend.


"Over the last 140 years global surface temperatures have risen by about 0.8ºC. However, within this record there have been several periods lasting a decade or more during which temperatures have risen very slowly or cooled. The current period of reduced warming is not unprecedented and 15 year long periods are not unusual."



SkepticsvRealistsv3.gif

It goes on for quite a bit more but i'll leave the rest to anyone who really want to read to do so, but I can hi-light some points.

Rose and Curry Ignore 90+% of Global Warming


Rose quotes Georgia Tech climate scientist Judith Curry (whose claims we have previously examined here and here) as asserting,


"The new data confirms the existence of a pause in global warming"




However, this claim is simply incorrect. Nuccitelli et al. (2012) considered the warming of the oceans (both shallow and deep), land, atmosphere, and ice, and showed that global warming has not slowed in recent years

Rose also quotes Curry as saying,




"Natural variability has been shown over the past two decades to have a magnitude that dominates the greenhouse warming effect"




This statement is also incorrect. There is always a point at which, as long as one only considers sufficiently short timeframes, a long-term signal will be smaller than the noise in the system, which appears to be Curry's argument here. However, for global surface temperatures, that timeframe is less than the two decades Curry specified in this quote.


Even ignoring 90+% of global warming and only considering global surface temperatures, they have warmed 0.4°C over the past two decades, according to HadCRUT4. Swanson et al. (2009) examined the role of natural variability on global surface temperatures and found that it rarely exceeds 0.2–0.3°C, and averages out to approximately zero over longer timeframes

These are just a few of the Rose et al errors.

To sum up, Rose and Curry were simply incorrect in virtually every assertion made in this Mail article.

Global surface temperatures have most likely increased since 1997.

Focusing on short-term temperature changes confuses short-term noise and long-term signal.

Most global warming goes into heating the oceans, and as Nuccitelli et al. (2012) showed, global warming has not slowed.

Natural variability is much smaller than the long-term global warming signal, and smaller even than the global warming signal over the past two decades.

The slowed rate of global surface warming over the past decade is consistent with individual model runs, which show that these 'hiatus decades' are entirely expected.

Over the long-term, the Earth has warmed as much as expected.

Carbon pricing will result in a net benefit the economy as compared to doing nothing and trying to adapt to the consequences.

After this wild goose chase, which seems to say you didn't read the article SS was talking about, I don't really feel like investing more energy on the second link. I'll let someone else do it.
 
First off it's not Sceptical Science making this claim, secondly it's not quite as you say it is. They were reporting on an article in the Guardian reviewing a Mail article written by David Rose.

I think you have it a bit mixed up. It actually was Dana Nuccitelli at Skeptical Science who was making that claim about the David Rose article in the Daily Mail. Nuccitelli's commentary also appeared in the Guardian.

Most significantly, though, the Daily Mail article was essentially correct -- contrary to what Nuccitelli and Skeptical Science were claiming.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencet...-report-quietly-released--chart-prove-it.html
 
I think you have it a bit mixed up. It actually was Dana Nuccitelli at Skeptical Science who was making that claim about the David Rose article in the Daily Mail. Nuccitelli's commentary also appeared in the Guardian.

Most significantly, though, the Daily Mail article was essentially correct -- contrary to what Nuccitelli and Skeptical Science were claiming.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencet...-report-quietly-released--chart-prove-it.html

WTF, 'essentially correct', except for this non exhaustive list of points.

To sum up, Rose and Curry were simply incorrect in virtually every assertion made in this Mail article.


Global surface temperatures have most likely increased since 1997.


Focusing on short-term temperature changes confuses short-term noise and long-term signal.


Most global warming goes into heating the oceans, and as Nuccitelli et al. (2012) showed, global warming has not slowed.


Natural variability is much smaller than the long-term global warming signal, and smaller even than the global warming signal over the past two decades.


The slowed rate of global surface warming over the past decade is consistent with individual model runs, which show that these 'hiatus decades' are entirely expected.


Over the long-term, the Earth has warmed as much as expected.


Carbon pricing will result in a net benefit the economy as compared to doing nothing and trying to adapt to the consequences.
 
WTF, 'essentially correct', except for this non exhaustive list of points.

"Essentially correct" in that the substance of the article correctly reported the Met Office's findings and the substance of the article was confirmed by the United Nations' International Panel on Climate Change in its most recent report.

As for the "non-exhaustive list of points," Nuccitelli is essentially pulling a bait and switch. He attempted to argue that global warming was still occurring by using benchmarks (and unconfirmed theories) that were completely different from the metrics set by the IPCC when it made its predictions.

It was the IPCC that said surface temperatures should be the basis for confirming the computer model predictions, and it was the IPCC that made "per decade" predictions of dramatic increases.
 
If you believe all those explanations at skepticalscience.com, then you're dumber then a bag of bricks. Always beware of someone (or some organization) who has an answer for everything. That usually means they're bullshitting.

Spoken by someone who's never made it through a full post at skepticalscience.com. I expect.
If you dig deep enough they give you the data and their probabilities in a very straightforward and honest way.
You just have to be smart enough to understand the science.
 
I think you have it a bit mixed up. It actually was Dana Nuccitelli at Skeptical Science who was making that claim about the David Rose article in the Daily Mail. Nuccitelli's commentary also appeared in the Guardian.

Most significantly, though, the Daily Mail article was essentially correct -- contrary to what Nuccitelli and Skeptical Science were claiming.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencet...-report-quietly-released--chart-prove-it.html

That article is a year and a half old, and fully debunked for about a year, 5 months and 30 days.
Got anything recent that's relevant to the discussion?
 
You know, you are so right.
Here, I found the chart that really backs up your ever so informed opinion.
2013_Arctic_Escalator_500.gif
Right, and if that graph is accurate (which I'm not so sure it is) you still can't say its climate thats causing that, it could be just the cyclic weather. Remember you own words, climate has to be taken over many decades or even a century, not just 35 years