Danes Kill Gentle Giraffe

This sounds more than a bit like the African Painted/Wild Dog incident at the Pittsburgh Zoo - negligence on the parents part, not an excuse to kill the animal.

Sure, lets include that: your child's in the enclosure through your own negligence and about to be killed by the last surviving female of a predatory species. Do you kill the lioness, or accept that your son must die because of your own negligence?

I know I wouldn't hesitate to kill the lioness. I wouldn't even hesitate to kill her if it were a stranger's son. A human child's life is worth more to me than saving a lion species from extinction.
 
A good movie idea to really shock people would have a alien race that has invaded earth and captured humans to be displayed on their world like we do with animals here, and have a scene where they do the same to a human as was done to this poor Giraffe.

Shit.. I bet this kind of shit was done all the time to blacks in america over 200 yrs ago or slaves in ancient Rome .. Too bad directors that cover those periods are to chicken shit to go that far.
 
Sure, lets include that: your child's in the enclosure through your own negligence and about to be killed by the last surviving female of a predatory species. Do you kill the lioness, or accept that your son must die because of your own negligence?

I know I wouldn't hesitate to kill the lioness. I wouldn't even hesitate to kill her if it were a stranger's son. A human child's life is worth more to me than saving a lion species from extinction.
Fuji a name which would live in infamy.
 
A good movie idea to really shock people would have a alien race that has invaded earth and captured humans to be displayed on their world like we do with animals here, and have a scene where they do the same to a human as was done to this poor Giraffe.

Shit.. I bet this kind of shit was done all the time to blacks in america over 200 yrs ago or slaves in ancient Rome .. Too bad directors that cover those periods are to chicken shit to go that far.
Actually it was very rare and if it happened at all probably more in the Roman Empire than in the New World.

As to the movie/television series idea, are you sure it hasn't already been done?
 
Fuji a name which would live in infamy.

So for clarity: You are the zookeeper charged with tending this animal, you have a rifle, a child falls into the pen and is about to be killed. You would just stand there and watch the child die? You wouldn't take the shot?

I find that hard to believe. I think any reasonably moral and ethnical person would take the shot and save the child.
 
1511503_10203130911813588_1132604129_n.jpg
 
Apparently, more information has cropped up on the Internet. According to rumour, the Zoo director had several staring matches with Marius in the fortnight or so before the culminating incident. When the director would stroll round the zoo, he would often spend ten or fifteen minutes outside the giraffe enclosure scowling intently at Marius who would hiss and stamp at the director. The director was overheard to say "Hahaha, you may defy me now, but I promise that you will not defy me long."

This suggests that the entire gene pool story is ex post facto rationalization.
 
Apparently, more information has cropped up on the Internet. According to rumour, the Zoo director had several staring matches with Marius in the fortnight or so before the culminating incident. When the director would stroll round the zoo, he would often spend ten or fifteen minutes outside the giraffe enclosure scowling intently at Marius who would hiss and stamp at the director. The director was overheard to say "Hahaha, you may defy me now, but I promise that you will not defy me long."


Oh come on, that is preposterous, that a scientific director of the zoo would have a grudge against an 18 month old giraffe, described as gentle.



This suggests that the entire gene pool story is ex post facto rationalization.

The gene pool is managed by the organization of european zoos.


The zoo says this was done because the genes of the giraffe, named Marius, were too similar to those of other giraffes in a breeding programme run by the European Association of Zoos and Aquaria (EAZA).

Breeding closely related animals increases the chances that rare, harmful genes are expressed in offspring.

Two copies of a gene are inherited - one version from each parent. One of these copies might be harmful (deleterious), but if the other parent carries a non-harmful version of the gene, pairing them up might not result in any adverse consequences for offspring.

When parents are closely related, it increases the chances that two harmful copies of a gene will pair up.

A spokesman for EAZA stressed that, as an individual, Marius was not particularly inbred, nor was the giraffe suffering from any identifiable health problem. But the spokesman explained that Marius' parents had produced other offspring, so there were already giraffes with similar genes in the organisation's breeding programme.

"That means that the giraffe Marius, unfortunately, cannot add anything further to the breeding programme that does not already exist," an EAZA spokesman told BBC News.
The programme aims to make the most of the genetic diversity that exists, avoiding matings between the most closely related animals available.

He said all alternatives were looked at, but none were found to be viable, describing euthanising animals as a "last resort". When the future survival of a species was at stake, he said, unpalatable decisions sometimes had to be made.

"We need to prioritise - wherever possible - individuals who can help safeguard that future over the long term," said the spokesman.

According to the European stud book for giraffes, which dates back to 1828, only five giraffes have been euthanised for conservation reasons.

Marius was dissected as part of an educational event
According to EAZA, giraffes born in zoos generally need to be moved away from their family group once they reach sexual maturity.

Giraffe breeding groups in zoos are made up of a single bull together with a group of females. So female offspring must be removed to prevent inbreeding, and bulls must be removed around the age of 18-24 months to prevent fighting.

Joerg Jebram, who oversees the European endangered species programme for giraffes, told the AP news agency: "Zoos could design new giraffe facilities, but many don't have that option.

"A young bull could theoretically be sent to an all-female group as stud, but experts prefer a larger, more mature male for that, and Marius didn't fit that bill.

"A final option is sending the giraffe to a zoo that doesn't participate in the EAZA-led breeding programme, but that could leave the giraffe or its offspring being sold into worse circumstances, such as those of a circus or private collection."

Copenhagen Zoo had turned down offers from at least two other zoos to take Marius and an offer from a private individual who wanted to buy the giraffe for 500,000 euros ($680,000).
 
So for clarity: You are the zookeeper charged with tending this animal, you have a rifle, a child falls into the pen and is about to be killed. You would just stand there and watch the child die? You wouldn't take the shot?

I find that hard to believe. I think any reasonably moral and ethnical person would take the shot and save the child.
Remember you said that this is not just a normal animal but one of the last 20 members of the species and one of even a smaller number that is capable of reproducing. Now meanwhile the parent was behaving irresponsibly and the child was obviously not paying attention to what any responsible family would have taught them. So destroy the hope of a species because of responsibility? Sorry not me.

You are the same as those who after some act of massive stupidity that results in the animal killing someone, want the animal killed. Years ago that was the norm, no longer.
 
Actually it was very rare and if it happened at all probably more in the Roman Empire than in the New World.

As to the movie/television series idea, are you sure it hasn't already been done?
The only thing i can think of is any Gladiator film where they had a scene showing slaves thrown to the lions in the arena.. but even that is not the same as what happend to the Giraffe. I mean a human getting shot or stabbed to death and then we see the person being cut up and chunks thrown to another creature to be eaten.. Nope.
 
Oh come on, that is preposterous, that a scientific director of the zoo would have a grudge against an 18 month old giraffe, described as gentle.





The gene pool is managed by the organization of european zoos.


The zoo says this was done because the genes of the giraffe, named Marius, were too similar to those of other giraffes in a breeding programme run by the European Association of Zoos and Aquaria (EAZA).

Breeding closely related animals increases the chances that rare, harmful genes are expressed in offspring.

Two copies of a gene are inherited - one version from each parent. One of these copies might be harmful (deleterious), but if the other parent carries a non-harmful version of the gene, pairing them up might not result in any adverse consequences for offspring.

When parents are closely related, it increases the chances that two harmful copies of a gene will pair up.

A spokesman for EAZA stressed that, as an individual, Marius was not particularly inbred, nor was the giraffe suffering from any identifiable health problem. But the spokesman explained that Marius' parents had produced other offspring, so there were already giraffes with similar genes in the organisation's breeding programme.

"That means that the giraffe Marius, unfortunately, cannot add anything further to the breeding programme that does not already exist," an EAZA spokesman told BBC News.
The programme aims to make the most of the genetic diversity that exists, avoiding matings between the most closely related animals available.

He said all alternatives were looked at, but none were found to be viable, describing euthanising animals as a "last resort". When the future survival of a species was at stake, he said, unpalatable decisions sometimes had to be made.

"We need to prioritise - wherever possible - individuals who can help safeguard that future over the long term," said the spokesman.

According to the European stud book for giraffes, which dates back to 1828, only five giraffes have been euthanised for conservation reasons.

Marius was dissected as part of an educational event
According to EAZA, giraffes born in zoos generally need to be moved away from their family group once they reach sexual maturity.

Giraffe breeding groups in zoos are made up of a single bull together with a group of females. So female offspring must be removed to prevent inbreeding, and bulls must be removed around the age of 18-24 months to prevent fighting.

Joerg Jebram, who oversees the European endangered species programme for giraffes, told the AP news agency: "Zoos could design new giraffe facilities, but many don't have that option.

"A young bull could theoretically be sent to an all-female group as stud, but experts prefer a larger, more mature male for that, and Marius didn't fit that bill.

"A final option is sending the giraffe to a zoo that doesn't participate in the EAZA-led breeding programme, but that could leave the giraffe or its offspring being sold into worse circumstances, such as those of a circus or private collection."

Copenhagen Zoo had turned down offers from at least two other zoos to take Marius and an offer from a private individual who wanted to buy the giraffe for 500,000 euros ($680,000).

Danmand, if it was NOT a personal grudge, wouldn't the Copenhagen Zoo have accepted those other zoos' offers? Think about it.
 
Danmand, if it was NOT a personal grudge, wouldn't the Copenhagen Zoo have accepted those other zoos' offers? Think about it.

You must have been drinking. How in the frigging world can you have a grudge against a young giraffe. Get real. Is your theory that Marius made rude comment about the Zoo directors mother???
And you believe he turned down 500,000 euros in order to sadistically kill this young giraffe???
 
You must have been drinking. How in the frigging world can you have a grudge against a young giraffe. Get real. Is your theory that Marius made rude comment about the Zoo directors mother???
And you believe he turned down 500,000 euros in order to sadistically kill this young giraffe???

Well, how then do you explain the bizarre, public nature of this killing?? I have never heard of an event which featured an animal being butchered in front of little children and then identifiable remains fed to lions. These same little children probably petted and fed Marius only a few hours before.

This is not normal. And the 500,000 Euros? That was never going to be his personal money, was it? And it's a mere drop in the bucket compared to the annual operating budget of a major zoo.
 
Remember you said that this is not just a normal animal but one of the last 20 members of the species and one of even a smaller number that is capable of reproducing. Now meanwhile the parent was behaving irresponsibly and the child was obviously not paying attention to what any responsible family would have taught them. So destroy the hope of a species because of responsibility? Sorry not me.

You are the same as those who after some act of massive stupidity that results in the animal killing someone, want the animal killed. Years ago that was the norm, no longer.

Yes, a species going extinct, the lioness being its last chance. If I was there with a rifle watching it attack I would shoot it dead without hesitation rather than let it kill a human child. Yes, after that, the parents should perhaps be sued for their negligent act, but I would not stand there doing nothing when killing the lioness would save the life of a child.

I think you would be hard pressed to find anyone who would not take the shot under those circumstances.
 
I actually think it would be great publicity, and that the Zoo could advertise it an event. Make it an event reserved for people who buy annual Zoo memberships only. No doubt, annual memberships would sell like hot cakes.

Like the Romans used to do with people like you? (Just kidding Fuji - couldn't resist).