Hydro and the ice storm

what are the costs to bury the hydro lines versus costs to repair?

it was $8 to $10 million to repair after the ice storm

how much to bury all the lines in toronto?

Apparently, it costs 8 to 10 times as much to bury a power cable than to string it

Also, while burying a cable protects it from some types of weather (e.g. ice storms and falling trees), it becomes more vulnerable during other types of weather (e.g. flooding)

At least, that's what the hydro CEO said during one of their updates when questioned on why all powerlines aren't buried
 
People laughed when Mel "The media hound "Lastman called out the Army to clear snow a few years ago. That could have been done in this case as well!

There is a Reserve Communication Unit in the city ,a Regular Force Unit in Kingston as well as a Reserve Unit in Hamilton that could have been utilized. These people train for this type of stuff.Its not all computers these days.

Communication Regiment is the name used for the old Royal Canadian Corps of Signals. Toronto had two units back in the day. 2nd Divisional Armoured Signal Corps and the 8thSignal Regiment. They merged in the mid sixties to form The Toronto Signal Regiment
 
Last edited:
Of course the crews were paid for working long hours in the cold, and of course they were paid extra as the hours got longer and longer and kept them from their rest, from their families and from their planned holidays. They were working and we customarily pay people for that. Free-enterprise idealogues suggest we'd all benefit if they could charge whatever they could get out of you to reconnect your power and get your light and heat back on.

The folks whose 'work' was questionable at best were idiots claiming we faced a once in a lifetime disaster that was not an emergency, and the managers at Toronto Hydro who still hadn't set up an effective call centre to take downed wire reports after a week.

And just a note about Mayor Lastman, who may have been just as newsworthy as the current incumbent, but was—unlike him—actually a capable Mayor. Mel never called the army to clear snow; he wanted their all-terrain vehicles available to go places ambulances, cop cars and fire trucks couldn't get to in the snow.

A few slightly excessive words like 'selfless' or even 'heroic' are the customary way that good people recognize they owe more to others than just a few bucks.
 
The real question to be asked is why the hydro wires have not been buried? In Denmark and Gernany, and other northern european countries, the hydro wires were buried in the 1950's and 60's, even in rural areas. The web of wires and poles make Canada look very backwards, and the resulting outages are predictable.

Lines are buried downtown, and no one there lost power.
 
Apparently, it costs 8 to 10 times as much to bury a power cable than to string it

Also, while burying a cable protects it from some types of weather (e.g. ice storms and falling trees), it becomes more vulnerable during other types of weather (e.g. flooding)

At least, that's what the hydro CEO said during one of their updates when questioned on why all powerlines aren't buried

Toronto isn't prone to flooding. We are very much prone to having snow and ice and high winds. If we ever have a flood it will be because we built up an area without building sufficient drainage. When union station flooded, that was the cause.

Anyway it is usually transformers that are at risk in a flood, not the wires. The transformers can be kept above ground in areas susceptible to flooding. Insulated cables can be run through water.
 
Lines are buried downtown, and no one there lost power.
Also buried in parts of Riverdale south of the Danforth—a project begun in the eighties and canned due to prospects of ratepayer revolt as real costs started to become clear—so they didn't lose power while it took a full week to do the reconnections a block to the north.
 
the OP has a history of right wing lunacy..........so he took the time here to bash hydro workers, who were joined by outside workers...i thought work ethic was sacred to the right wing lunatics like Dirk..but no..he is concerned about what they are being paid...i guess being a leftie, wing nut, i can question, buyout packages of CEO,s who run their companies into the ground...but guys working in trying circumstances on Christmas day are being overpaid according to one of our resident neo cons..
 
the OP has a history of right wing lunacy..........so he took the time here to bash hydro workers, who were joined by outside workers...i thought work ethic was sacred to the right wing lunatics like Dirk..but no..he is concerned about what they are being paid...i guess being a leftie, wing nut, i can question, buyout packages of CEO,s who run their companies into the ground...but guys working in trying circumstances on Christmas day are being overpaid according to one of our resident neo cons..
Hmm, I've been accused of being one of the "resident neo cons" and I posted the very opposite.
 
Hmm, I've been accused of being one of the "resident neo cons" and I posted the very opposite.

That is a misunderstanding on your part. We think you are a twerp. LOL

Happy New Year, my good friend.
 
Hmm, I've been accused of being one of the "resident neo cons" and I posted the very opposite.

if you are looking for validation from a troll like me..you are in bad shape..lol..just kidding....happy newyear vark..
 
There is no way the real cost of the disruption is not much higher than $10M.

The hydro companies have crews working all summer to trim trees, however obviously not enough crews. You also avoid repairs from lightening strikes, which happen every month in our area.

I am not advocating a massive program to bury all wires next year. Spending let us say $50M every year on burying the wires will eventually solve the problem.

I doubt that the countries in northern europe buried the wires for aestetic reasons.

I agree with you that we need to "bite the bullet" if you will and get projects like this done, but politics will always get in the way of anything that makes sense.

It would have made sense to build a subway under Eglinton 30 years ago, but the Harris government canned it. Instead we built a "stubway" under Sheppard and have to settle for a less than ideal LRT on top and under Eglinton.
 
I agree with you that we need to "bite the bullet" if you will and get projects like this done, but politics will always get in the way of anything that makes sense.

It would have made sense to build a subway under Eglinton 30 years ago, but the Harris government canned it. Instead we built a "stubway" under Sheppard and have to settle for a less than ideal LRT on top and under Eglinton.
When the guy who gets the most votes promised the cheapest city we can stomach …

We deserve our government. We picked it.
 
Originally Posted by danmand View Post

There is no way the real cost of the disruption is not much higher than $10M.

The hydro companies have crews working all summer to trim trees, however obviously not enough crews. You also avoid repairs from lightening strikes, which happen every month in our area.

I am not advocating a massive program to bury all wires next year. Spending let us say $50M every year on burying the wires will eventually solve the problem.

I doubt that the countries in northern europe buried the wires for aestetic reasons
.

Lets take a closer look
if we assume:
1. $10K to bury a line to a house
2. Estimate 500,000 homes in the GTA (see below)
Total cost = $5 B

Spend $50 MM per year
It would take 100 years

While the ice storm was a major problem and a real pain in the ass, there are a number of other infrastructure need where this money would better employed (Transit)


(http://www12.statcan.gc.ca/census-recensement/2011/as-sa/fogs-spg/Facts-cma-eng.cfm?LANG=Eng&GC=535)
there were 1,989,705 private dwellings occupied by usual residents in Toronto in 2011. more in the burbs
Assuming a certain % live in multi-dwelling buildings (apartments), 500,000 homes is probably light, however it works for illustrative purposes
 
When the guy who gets the most votes promised the cheapest city we can stomach …

We deserve our government. We picked it.

When taxes consume 50% of our earnings
Picking the guy who promised the cheapest city we can stomach only seems prudent
 
People laughed when Mel "The media hound "Lastman called out the Army to clear snow a few years ago. That could have been done in this case as well!

There is a Reserve Communication Unit in the city that could have been utilized. These people train for this type of stuff.Its not all computers these days.

How is that? From the Canadian Army website ... "32 Signal Regiment is a reserve communications unit that is part of 32 Canadian Brigade Group (32 CBG), and based in Fort York Armoury in Toronto and CFB Borden. Our 200 members are trained in the operation of military communication and electronic equipment such as radios and mobile satellite communication suites in support of 32 CBG Operations."

So how do these signalers help? I didn't see any mention of the Regiment having bucket tricks, foresters and lineman.
 
How is that? From the Canadian Army website ... "32 Signal Regiment is a reserve communications unit that is part of 32 Canadian Brigade Group (32 CBG), and based in Fort York Armoury in Toronto and CFB Borden. Our 200 members are trained in the operation of military communication and electronic equipment such as radios and mobile satellite communication suites in support of 32 CBG Operations."

So how do these signalers help? I didn't see any mention of the Regiment having bucket tricks, foresters and lineman.

They were basically called out last time because they had the vehicle that could get down some of the sideroads closed to most vehicles.
 
They were basically called out last time because they had the vehicle that could get down some of the sideroads closed to most vehicles.
Yeah, I got the part about all terrain vehicles for the snow storm. But I thought we were talking about this ice storm event. Some folks were saying the army should have been called out, and SpankingMan suggested that the Communications Regiment was trained for this. I still don't see it.