Another nominee for The Darwin Awards.

Ceiling Cat

Well-known member
Feb 25, 2009
30,280
2,690
113
Embedded media from this media site is no longer available

At one point, Arroyo started walking toward police, removing clothing covering the item in her right hand, showing what observers thought looked like a handgun, authorities said. She initially aimed it toward the postal building, then turned it toward officers.

The officers fired on Arroyo. In a video, Arroyo is seen wearing a blue-gray T-shirt, plaid pajama pants and flip-flops, authorities said. The mental health specialists tried to talk to Arroyo for more than an hour before gunshots were fired.
 
Based on previous threads, you could have gotten lots more posts feline if you'd said SWAT Team shoots and kills woman with fake gun. Complete with comments about how the SWAT Team didn't give her enough time to prove that it wasn't an actual firearm.
 
Sounds more like suicide by cop than death by stupidity. Darwin awards usually are for people who die from stupidity not because they are trying to kill themselves.

The woman was mentally ill. Watching her movement's I'd guess she was stoned out of her gourd. Perfect time for a Taser...
 
The woman was mentally ill. Watching her movement's I'd guess she was stoned out of her gourd. Perfect time for a Taser...

Clearly mentally ill and not reacting to the reality around her. I cannot blame the cops for what they did. Clearly they must protect themselves. But the incident is a tragedy.

Shame on Ceiling Cat for laughing at it.
:frown:
 
A difficult video to watch and (obviously) a more difficult situation to deal with by the cops at hand.

The lady looked impaired in some way (meds, drugs, or mental illness - you can't tell from 20 seconds of video) and the gun looked real enough to be a threat.

I do wonder whether the cops could have shot at her weapon arm instead of putting (what sounded like) at least a dozen bullets into her torso.
 
The woman was mentally ill. Watching her movement's I'd guess she was stoned out of her gourd. Perfect time for a Taser...
Unless she actually did have a gun.

...
I do wonder whether the cops could have shot at her weapon arm instead of putting (what sounded like) at least a dozen bullets into her torso.

This was discussed endlessly on previous threads. First not protocol, second an extremely tough shot meaning if she had a gun, she likely could have put a dozen bullets into the torso of cops before they hit her arm.
 
Darwin's theory of natural seletion posits that organisms possessing characteristics not well adapted for survival will perish prior to reproducing and passing on said undesirable characteristics. Conversely those organisms possessing characteristics that are well adapted for survival will thrive, will multiply and will pass on such favourable genetic traits.

Although the unfortunate woman in the story definitely is not well adapted for survival, (a) she was not killed or rendered infertile and (b) she has a daughter and therefore has already reproduced.

Darwin and his theory do not apply to this incident.
 
This was discussed endlessly on previous threads. First not protocol, second an extremely tough shot meaning if she had a gun, she likely could have put a dozen bullets into the torso of cops before they hit her arm.
I disagree. First of all, just because something is not "protocol" does not mean it should not be an option. If a good idea is not in the protocol, the obvious solution is to change the protocol. There should either be a good reason not to do something or it should be an option; "not protocol" is not a good reason.

Secondly, there were multiple cops present. There's no reason that they could could not have disabled the woman without taking lethal aim. At least one of the police present probably knows how to use their gun. If they don't feel comfortable shooting at an arm, shoulder, leg, or hand to avoid the kill shot then they should go get trained before they carry a gun professionally.

At the end of the day, sometimes Police have no choice but to use lethal force. However, we have seen in recent months that lethal force is sometime resorted to too quickly.
 
^ The number of people out there who can shoot like Annie Oakley is small and the number of those who also have the temperament and other skills for police work damn close to nil. Further, being shot in the shoulder, arm, hand or leg is not some sort of "magic flesh wound" that will not have extremely severe lifelong consequences. As a matter of fact if they survive it a center mass wound may have fewer handicapping consequences.
 
Last edited:
I disagree. First of all, just because something is not "protocol" does not mean it should not be an option. If a good idea is not in the protocol, the obvious solution is to change the protocol. There should either be a good reason not to do something or it should be an option; "not protocol" is not a good reason.

Secondly, there were multiple cops present. There's no reason that they could could not have disabled the woman without taking lethal aim. At least one of the police present probably knows how to use their gun. If they don't feel comfortable shooting at an arm, shoulder, leg, or hand to avoid the kill shot then they should go get trained before they carry a gun professionally.

At the end of the day, sometimes Police have no choice but to use lethal force. However, we have seen in recent months that lethal force is sometime resorted to too quickly.


In this type of situation, things can escalate in a heartbeat, and quick, decisive judgements need to be made. In addition to weapons training, threat assessment and mental conditioning (making decisions under high-stress) are also a key factors in officer training. A taser could have been utilized if this individual did not have a gun (in the article, the police responded to a gun call, not just a disturbance call). Police have to respond in kind (you don't bring a knife, or in this case, a taser to a gun fight). The use of a taser would not have been an ideal choice in this situation for two reasons. One: the effective deployment range of the taser is about 10.5m, so trying getting in close to use one on a gun-toting suspect would be just be foolhardy. Two: the taser interrupts the ability of the brain to control the muscles in the body, so if this woman had a real gun and had her finger on the trigger, it's possible she would have involuntarily discharged the gun, with no way of controlling where the shot would go.

Also, police, like the military, are trained when using their firearm, to shoot for the center mass of the target, aka the torso (have you noticed on the firing range, the silhouette targets have target rings on the torso, not the limbs). This ensures the maximum chance of neutralizing the assailant and deescalating the situation. Shooting for a limb, or the hand on a moving target is ineffective, almost impossible, and has the potential for collateral damage. Marksmanship of that caliber (pun intended) only happens in the movies.

And after any shooting incident, there is an independent Use of Force assessment done to determine if the use of force was justified, if anything could have been done differently, and what changes (if any) could be made to ensure officer and public safely, which is then integrated into officer training.

I agree that the use of deadly force should only be used in extreme, unavoidable circumstances, but when one is confronted with a situation like this, sometimes the extreme option is the only option.
 
Last edited: