Gawker Claims Video Exists of Rob Ford Smoking Crack

You may like the wording, but you're misrepresenting it
While that is true, its still a vague accusation made by the Star.

Star should either report that Ford did know he was a convicted or murderer, or didnt know. Or they should have elaborated on what exactly tow-truck driver meant with "Ford somewhat knew".

The way the Star reported is open to too many interpretations
 
While that is true, its still a vague accusation made by the Star.

Star should either report that Ford did know he was a convicted or murderer, or didnt know. Or they should have elaborated on what exactly tow-truck driver meant with "Ford somewhat knew".

The way the Star reported is open to too many interpretations

The Star reported what they knew and that was that the convicted killer claims that Ford "somewhat knew".

Maybe it makes your guy look bad, but it's fair to report on.

It was a fair question for The Star to ask and it was a fair answer for them to report on. Rob Ford won't comment on it, but this guy figures Rob Ford "somewhat knew" about his past.
 
The Star reported what they knew and that was that the convicted killer claims that Ford "somewhat knew".

Maybe it makes your guy look bad, but it's fair to report on.

It was a fair question for The Star to ask and it was a fair answer for them to report on. Rob Ford won't comment on it, but this guy figures Rob Ford "somewhat knew" about his past.

'Somewhat knew' is kind of like somewhat pregnant. You know him or you don't.
 
The Star reported what they knew and that was that the convicted killer claims that Ford "somewhat knew".

Maybe it makes your guy look bad, but it's fair to report on
I never said it wasnt fair, but Star couldve done a little better reporting and asked him exactly what Ford knows about his criminal past. And you'd think, if Ford did know the Star would wanna report that, instead of "somewhat knew"
 
The Star reported what they knew and that was that the convicted killer claims that Ford "somewhat knew".

Maybe it makes your guy look bad, but it's fair to report on.

It was a fair question for The Star to ask and it was a fair answer for them to report on. Rob Ford won't comment on it, but this guy figures Rob Ford "somewhat knew" about his past.

I "somewhat" believe this is one of the Star editorial bias against Rob Ford.
 
While that [Phil misrepresenting the Star's statement*] is true, its still a vague accusation made by the Star.

Star should either report that Ford did know he was a convicted or murderer, or didnt know. Or they should have elaborated on what exactly tow-truck driver meant with "Ford somewhat knew".

The way the Star reported is open to too many interpretations
No. It is the Star reporting and quoting the subject of their story. If there is any accusation, it's one you read into what that person said. I too would like the Star to tell us what Ford knows of knew about this and many other things, but only Ford can do that, and he's not talking to them. I don't think it reasonable to slag the Star for being unable to read his mind. I do think you're unreasonable to demand such content in a story about the doings of some entirely different person Ford is apparently acquainted with.

Since you think they "…should have elaborated on what exactly tow-truck driver meant with "[Ford] somewhat knew", just how would they accomplish that? Since they apparently did not rise to the McNasty Stndard of Journalistic Perseverance, does that mean they should have suppressed the statement he did volunteer? Is this another example of the bizarre and lunatic notion that our newspapers and media should hold the same standards of proof and accuracy as courts of criminal law? Please be sure whatever justification you offer also accounts for your rather slanderous misreporting of the Star's story earlier. Responsible reporting is responsible reporting after all.

If you don't want news that's open to interpretation, or misinterpretation, stick to the 'olds'. Either way, jump to your conclusions just a little more thoughtfully instead of blaming your sources for not stopping you.
----------------
*
Phil C. McNasty in Post #4601 said:
oldjones said:
You may like the wording, but you're misrepresenting it
While that is true, its still a vague accusation made by the Star.
which also illustrates jumping prematurely, as any accusation in the statement was the driver's.
 
Fiddlesticks, clearly from someone who didn't read the story.

Of course, I did "somewhat" read the story.

I "somewhat" think this is another Star "editorial bias" against Rob Ford.

Somehow somewhere in this "somewhat" story.
 
'Somewhat knew' is kind of like somewhat pregnant. You know him or you don't.

Yes, it's still what he said which would be of interest to anybody reading a story about Rob Ford endorsing this moron as a human being. Hence why The Star reported it.

Nothing wrong with that.
 
Yes, it's still what he said which would be of interest to anybody reading a story about Rob Ford endorsing this moron as a human being. Hence why The Star reported it.

Nothing wrong with that.

Of course nothing wrong The Star editors somewhat allow it. (Pretty sure they "somewhat" double-checked with The Star lawyers already)

Somehow somewhere somewhat nothing is wrong if its against Rob Ford.
 
I "somewhat" believe this is one of the Star editorial bias against Rob Ford.
As if that was news, or persuasive. Or even somewhat of a contribution. But at least you're no longer trying to suggest it arises from the facts in the story the grown-ups are discussing
 
Of course nothing wrong The Star editors somewhat allow it. (Pretty sure they "somewhat" double-checked with The Star lawyers already)

Somehow somewhere somewhat nothing is wrong if its against Rob Ford.

Actually in this case nothing is wrong because nothing is wrong.

Again, maybe it makes your guy look bad but it's not dodgy journalism in the least.

This guy is a murderer and was recently endorsed by this city's mayor. When asked if the mayor knew he was a murderer the guy said "somewhat".

Now, does that deserve further investigation.. Absolutely! But for all you or I know The Star pressed him for further comment but he refused to answer. Maybe the guy ended the conversation right then and there. There could be a hundred reasons why they didn't press this guy (or report that they pressed this guy) for more answers.

Now, If they chose to not bother reporting that he said the mayor "somewhat knew" then that would be irresponsible. The people of Toronto deserve to know that this guy believes the mayor had "some" level of understanding of his past as a murderer and still endorsed him anyway. If they mayor wanted to refute it, he was given the opportunity by The Star (as he is every time they run a story on him).
 
Ford's backing of petty criminals is one thing but now that he is supporting murders it's making operation brazen 2 and the Cessna all that more justified.
 
And just how do you know the Star quoted that tow-truck driver accurately, were you there when he said it??

We expect it to be correct since their reporting was found to be legit by the press council.

You have yet to have found one factual error in their reporting, so your worries are obviously due to your extreme Fordophilia, and not based in reality.
 
And just how do you know the Star quoted that tow-truck driver accurately, were you there when he said it??

according to the star, the person they spoke with appeared to be a man, who may or may not have driven a vehicle, that resembled a truck used for towing according to un-named sources. from the star reporter's view it appeared that the alleged tow truck driver was speaking as his mouth appeared to be moving more or less in sync with the words which the star reporter recalled hearing (though it might have been a dream).
 
And just how do you know the Star quoted that tow-truck driver accurately, were you there when he said it??

Do you honestly believe that the Star is making all of this up?
The whole thing is so outrageous that 'truth is stranger then fiction' captures the fact that if you wanted to create a scandal about the Mayor, this would be the last one if you wanted him out of office. If you really wanted to get him out, you'd start a scandal about him stealing money, but a crack video?
Ridiculous.

The number of stories you now have to claim as 'biased' or 'fiction' and the number of sources you slam is just getting way too out of hand.