Made In Bangladesh

Walmart and Joe Fresh have the power to change pay rates and work conditions over there, they seem to have dropped the ball!

Why would they want to change it. They feed us the line that the savings are passed on to the consumer, when in reality, the savings becomes gross profit margin. Shareholders and execs get the spoils.

It is not just Walmart. Its every major clothing retailer in the Western world.

The only way this system would ever change is if the Gov't made sweeping changes to the way our companies were allowed to outsource. If Apple refuses to manufacture in North America, then they can't sell in North America..... If slavery really is illegal, then fine the companies that take advantage of slave labour, and child labour.

Someone above mentioned that Walmart has no control over the working conditions of its sub contractors. The documentary clearly stated the Walmart agents were there at the factory. That a muslim holiday had slowed down production of an order. So the agent instructed that they would need to have another company help fill the order.... 3 days later another huge order was placed, even though the first company was still trying to fill the original order.

Walmart knows exactly what is going on.... They know if the original factory has trouble meeting deadlines, the work gets outsourced to 2nd and 3rd sub-contractors. They however, want to keep your head buried in the sand.

I'm glad I watched this doc. I knew conditions were bad.... But I didn't know how much control the retailers really had. This was an eye opener.
 
The companies buying from the contractors are NOT committing human rights violations,...their own country is,...talk about being in another world !!!

FAST

Ok maybe I am wrong here.... but you are saying that Walmart is ok with knowingly using foreign child labour..... working in buildings with locked doors and barred windows and no fire escapes??? Because they knew that. Days before the fire, a Walmart agent was there. There was no surprise here.

Yes, foreign Governments have the responsibility to create and enforce labour laws and building codes in their own countries. I would argue that companies here also have the social responsibility to avoid using child slave labour to save a few bucks.... I would say minimum standards would be safe working conditions (buildings, equipment, fire escapes) and age limits for the work force. You could go well beyond that I suppose.

Foxcon bent over backwards to make a state of the art facility to gain the Apple contract. They even build extra factories, just in case Apple had extra work for them, and left them vacant until Apple had the work. Apple inspects the facility regularly. I highly doubt that Foxcon would do something like use child labour, in fear of embarrassing Apple, and possibly losing work over it. I could be wrong though. One day it may hit the news that they did in fact use child labour. They'd be fools if they let that happen.
 
Ok maybe I am wrong here.... but you are saying that Walmart is ok with knowingly using foreign child labour..... working in buildings with locked doors and barred windows and no fire escapes??? Because they knew that. Days before the fire, a Walmart agent was there. There was no surprise here.

Yes, foreign Governments have the responsibility to create and enforce labour laws and building codes in their own countries. I would argue that companies here also have the social responsibility to avoid using child slave labour to save a few bucks.... I would say minimum standards would be safe working conditions (buildings, equipment, fire escapes) and age limits for the work force. You could go well beyond that I suppose.

Foxcon bent over backwards to make a state of the art facility to gain the Apple contract. They even build extra factories, just in case Apple had extra work for them, and left them vacant until Apple had the work. Apple inspects the facility regularly. I highly doubt that Foxcon would do something like use child labour, in fear of embarrassing Apple, and possibly losing work over it. I could be wrong though. One day it may hit the news that they did in fact use child labour. They'd be fools if they let that happen.

You must be careful when speaking about Foxconn. There is a lot going on over there that we don't know about, and the stuff that does leak out is the tip of the ice berg I'm sure.

http://topics.nytimes.com/top/news/business/companies/foxconn_technology/index.html

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-24486684

Additionally, the conditions of the places that Foxconn deal with over there to get their supplies are not widely known either.
 
You must be careful when speaking about Foxconn. There is a lot going on over there that we don't know about, and the stuff that does leak out is the tip of the ice berg I'm sure.

http://topics.nytimes.com/top/news/business/companies/foxconn_technology/index.html

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-24486684

Additionally, the conditions of the places that Foxconn deal with over there to get their supplies are not widely known either.

Absolutely agreed. Apple also turns a blind eye to human rights abuses.
 
We should stop doing business with countries that are not democracies, mistreat minorities, gays and women and don't have the same tax system as we do.
 
Commerce

Ok maybe I am wrong here.... but you are saying that Wal-Mart is ok with knowingly using foreign child labour..... working in buildings with locked doors and barred windows and no fire escapes??? Because they knew that. Days before the fire, a Wal-Mart agent was there. There was no surprise here..

It still boils down to WHO is running the country,...and its NOT Wal-Mart,...which by the way,...is a company I personally dislike.

Yes, foreign Governments have the responsibility to create and enforce labour laws and building codes in their own countries. I would argue that companies here also have the social responsibility to avoid using child slave labour to save a few bucks.... I would say minimum standards would be safe working conditions (buildings, equipment, fire escapes) and age limits for the work force. You could go well beyond that I suppose..

If companies had social responsibility,...there would be no cigarette and, NO arms manufacturing ANYPLACE in the world,...also, I would not ever rely on a manufacture's social responsibility for my safety,...just does not work,.. and NOT their responsibility in a foreign country anyway.

Foxcon bent over backwards to make a state of the art facility to gain the Apple contract. They even build extra factories, just in case Apple had extra work for them, and left them vacant until Apple had the work. Apple inspects the facility regularly. I highly doubt that Foxcon would do something like use child labour, in fear of embarrassing Apple, and possibly losing work over it. I could be wrong though. One day it may hit the news that they did in fact use child labour. They'd be fools if they let that happen.

I would think Apple's main concern there is product quality,...NOT the workers quality of life,...big difference, making cell phones and pyjamas.
The end result of needing high quality manufacturing, will automatically raise the workers working conditions.

FAST
 
FAST - All reasonable points, and I agree with them all. To go one further, its already clear that big corporations don't exercise social responsibility. I'm simply pointing out just how cut throat they are. These are only 2 occurrences with mass deaths, and nobody bats an eyelash. Nobody. I think we can make Walmart, and other major retailers aware that this isn't their dirty little secret anymore.

What pisses me off about the entire situation is, western Governments allow companies to close factories here, and ship jobs offshore..... where there are no standards. Not just in clothing manufacturing.... auto, tech, electronics... (We all know that, I get it.) Because its allowed, companies have to do it to stay competitive. So, change the rules.

The only way that will ever change is by sweeping Gov't policy changes. I know that companies will say it will affect what we pay at the cash register. I think it will have a bigger impact on what they, and shareholders take home.

....or, leave the system alone. Keep buying from people who lock women and children in burning buildings to make a few bucks.
 
Rules

FAST - All reasonable points, and I agree with them all. To go one further, its already clear that big corporations don't exercise social responsibility. I'm simply pointing out just how cut throat they are. These are only 2 occurrences with mass deaths, and nobody bats an eyelash. Nobody. I think we can make Wal-Mart, and other major retailers aware that this isn't their dirty little secret anymore.

What pisses me off about the entire situation is, western Governments allow companies to close factories here, and ship jobs offshore..... where there are no standards. Not just in clothing manufacturing.... auto, tech, electronics... (We all know that, I get it.) Because its allowed, companies have to do it to stay competitive. So, change the rules.

The only way that will ever change is by sweeping Gov't policy changes. I know that companies will say it will affect what we pay at the cash register. I think it will have a bigger impact on what they, and shareholders take home.

....or, leave the system alone. Keep buying from people who lock women and children in burning buildings to make a few bucks.

-Problem is,...either the whole western world stops buying from there,...or nobody will,...
-I don't like the idea of shipping jobs to these countries anymore than you do,...or how the governments in these countries treat their own people.

-It would take a world wide organization to create the rules, and enforce them by applying increasingly higher duties, or stopping shipments to ANY part of the world,...one or two countries is NOT going to make any difference.
This I could buy into without a second thought,...but without this world wide "levelling of the playing field",...sorry.

-Again,... it is the contractors who are locking people in burning building,...not western companies.

FAST
 
About this grand idea of exploitive westerners boycotting cheap goods....

I assume you mean the same basic principal as men boycotting the sex trade to protect vulnerable women?

Yeah right.
 
-Problem is,...either the whole western world stops buying from there,...or nobody will,...
-I don't like the idea of shipping jobs to these countries anymore than you do,...or how the governments in these countries treat their own people.

-It would take a world wide organization to create the rules, and enforce them by applying increasingly higher duties, or stopping shipments to ANY part of the world,...one or two countries is NOT going to make any difference.
This I could buy into without a second thought,...but without this world wide "levelling of the playing field",...sorry.

-Again,... it is the contractors who are locking people in burning building,...not western companies.

FAST


Again.... your points are 100% correct. Here's my question then...

Is it wrong for Western companies to openly know about these conditions, and still use these factories when other options are available? I mean its all fine to say the its the Bangladesh factory owners perpetrating the crime.... but if we know they're doing it and use them anyway.... (and we already know the Western Companies have agents on the ground there, even though the factories are hired through a "3rd party".)

Also... for the general membership... would anybody be willing to fire off an email to your MP, or a Western company or 2 questioning their business practices? Would anybody be willing to post the Documentary on their FB page?
 
About this grand idea of exploitive westerners boycotting cheap goods....

I assume you mean the same basic principal as men boycotting the sex trade to protect vulnerable women?

Yeah right.

Nobody's talking about boycotting cheap goods.

You can't boycott cheap goods. Most clothes are made in a sweatshop somewhere. As a matter of fact, I wonder how many people can go through their clothes and actually have any shirts or pants made in North America. (Not that North American Sweat Shops are any better..... just ask Kathy Lee)

Also.... because our Governments have allowed it, entire sectors of manufacturing have gone off shore. Name me a brand of TV thats still made in North America? How about small appliances. (In the book Jack, Straight From the Gut) Jack Welch talks about giving up on irons, and selling off that brand of GE business to foreign competitors in the late 80's.
 
Is it wrong for Western companies to openly know about these conditions, and still use these factories when other options are available? I mean its all fine to say the its the Bangladesh factory owners perpetrating the crime.... but if we know they're doing it and use them anyway.... (and we already know the Western Companies have agents on the ground there, even though the factories are hired through a "3rd party".)

Pardon my intrusion.

Morally speaking, it is wrong. Business/legal wise, nothing wrong with it. And what are the other options ? China ? Phillipines ? Vietnam ? Do they have any standards ?

But think about it more broadly. Bangladesh relies heavily on the garment industry. If half of that business goes away from Bangladesh, what kind of jobs would those people ( largely women ) do ? They are poor, don't have much money to feed their family. Would they turn to prostitution ? Robbery ? Violence ? Die a painful death ? Isn't that wrong ?

So then, will disturbing this vicious cycle of sweatshops that are the main economical pillar of a country do more harm than keeping it as is ?

You can say the corporations have the power to influence work and safety standards in these countries but at the end of they day, it is the country's government and the sub contractors that need a kick in the balls repeatedly. And I don't think the corporation's kick would have THAT much of an impact, if any. The governments are too corrupt !
 
Pardon my intrusion.

Morally speaking, it is wrong. Business/legal wise, nothing wrong with it. And what are the other options ? China ? Phillipines ? Vietnam ? Do they have any standards ?

But think about it more broadly. Bangladesh relies heavily on the garment industry. If half of that business goes away from Bangladesh, what kind of jobs would those people ( largely women ) do ? They are poor, don't have much money to feed their family. Would they turn to prostitution ? Robbery ? Violence ? Die a painful death ? Isn't that wrong ?

So then, will disturbing this vicious cycle of sweatshops that are the main economical pillar of a country do more harm than keeping it as is ?

You can say the corporations have the power to influence work and safety standards in these countries but at the end of they day, it is the country's government and the sub contractors that need a kick in the balls repeatedly. And I don't think the corporation's kick would have THAT much of an impact, if any. The governments are too corrupt !

Don't mind the intrusion at all. I'm a fan of good debate.

If Walmart said to supplier A..... "if any garment factory that you contract does not have fire exits and fire escapes by this date, we go with a new supplier" what happens?

I would also think as the worlds number one retailer..... they have all the choice in the world for manufacturing, yet they choose the shit holes on the planet for a reason, even though they can more than afford better. I would also think that the local governments or retailers insisting on new safety standards would also generate some work in construction and renovations, helping the economies. However, nobody wants to pay, and tragedies that don't have to happen will.

Could anybody honestly imagine their son or daughter working there???? Seriously. Try to imagine that for just a second or 2. (you know what I was thankful for on Monday......)
 
If Walmart said to supplier A..... "if any garment factory that you contract does not have fire exits and fire escaped by this date, we go with a new supplier" what happens?

Walmart, Nike! Joe Fresh should have boots on the ground policing this shit, they have the power. Blame is on them for the crap conditions in these bum fuck countries!
 
Don't mind the intrusion at all. I'm a fan of good debate.

If Walmart said to supplier A..... "if any garment factory that you contract does not have fire exits and fire escapes by this date, we go with a new supplier" what happens?

I would also think as the worlds number one retailer..... they have all the choice in the world for manufacturing, yet they choose the shit holes on the planet for a reason, even though they can more than afford better. I would also think that the local governments or retailers insisting on new safety standards would also generate some work in construction and renovations, helping the economies. However, nobody wants to pay, and tragedies that don't have to happen will.

Could anybody honestly imagine their son or daughter working there???? Seriously. Try to imagine that for just a second or 2. (you know what I was thankful for on Monday......)

Glad to have a good old debate.

Sure, Walmart can say all about safety and work place standards in their contracts. The problem is that they don't have the power to legally enforce that. The onus is on the local government, which again is corrupt to begin with. And they don't have a concept of standards as you can see from the conditions of the factories.

Walmart, or any other big retailer can have all the choice they want but they don't have legal power. They can try to enforce some standards but that might involve bribing local officials in order to set up seminars and education about work safety. Problem is, that is a long process and requires more effort than most retailers, heck even the local companies in Bangladesh would not want to waste time in.

It is the countries themselves that need to evolve their infrastructure into the 21st century. For Bangladesh, that is hard to do when you have 150 million people living on land that is smaller than UK and is plagued by poverty.

If you disturb the garments industry in Bangladesh, you are looking at about 5 million workers being affected who contribute a lot to their economy. It is a necessary sweatshop otherwise the country would have nothing much to export. Their economy would suffer a heavy hit, one that might be too much to handle for the country imo.
 
My only problem with your argument is that your basically saying 'every' clothing factory does not comply to standards, and poor Walmart has no choice but to use them. I would argue, they can choose different suppliers, that do comply with their own values and guidelines. Look on their website, they post their ethics!

OK.... I'm not going to change anyone's mind at this point. I know that.

I understand the legal aspects. Walmart does what it does to make profits and shield itself from liability, and keep costs down. I doubt most people will watch the entire video, but rather read a few sentences from the article and move on with their days.... I'm just going to share one more thing. This is the message from the CEO, right off the Walmart ethics page;

Message from the CEO
"Walmart started out with a single discount store in Northwest Arkansas and in less than 50 years grew to become the world’s largest retailer, with thousands of stores and clubs and millions of associates. Our culture of ethics and integrity has been a constant throughout that transformation. From the beginning, it has defined who we are as a company, and how we as associates treat each other, our suppliers and our customers."
Mike Duke, CEO
[insert wonderful picture of mom with her kid laughing on the grass]

I just hope I'v opened up some eyes as to how not just Walmart..... but a lot major retailers, and the reality of where our clothes come from. I've already shared the video on my personal FB page. I would kindly ask, if anybody feels like me, that they should be able to walk in any major retailer and be able to buy a t-shirt that wasn't assembled at a plant using 12 year olds as part of the work force, to also pass it along.... because what I'm asking is a reasonable request. Please don't let these guys post their ethics BS, and then hide the fact of exactly how cut throat they really are. The reality is, they pile on the orders, and don't care if kids are made to work 24 hours straight to fill them. They don't bat an eyelash.

OK.... taking my personal crusade to Facebook now.

Cheers!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4dQGl_lswYY
 
My only problem with your argument is that your basically saying 'every' clothing factory does not comply to standards, and poor Walmart has no choice but to use them. I would argue, they can choose different suppliers, that do comply with their own values and guidelines. Look on their website, they post their ethics!

OK.... I'm not going to change anyone's mind at this point. I know that.

My problem with yours is that you assume 'only' children work in these sweatshops.

In Bangladesh, I doubt there are factories that comply to standards, local or international. Do any of those suppliers or workers care about what is posted on Walmart's website ?

I have watched the whole video and it tries too hard to paint Walmart like the most evil thing ever by getting stuff made at sweatshops. They don't talk about the economic realities of the garments industry and the country, only focusing on personal stories of tragedy to give that human connection feeling to spark rage against corporations. Some children work in sweatshops because they are one of the prime earners in their family. They HAVE to work. I don't think they are working by choice but by necessity and financial circumstances.

Begging on the street or doing crime to earn a living is worse than making some garments in a sweatshop. The root of the problem is the large population that is plagued with poverty and that results in a 'sweatshop' environment where you have a labor force ready to put the hours in on whatever wage/work someone gives them. In their tough life, a constant and steady income is like a godsend even if it comes with other risks.

Lack of education, infrastructure, corrupt governments/officials, economy reliant on handful of industries, etc should be the larger focus. Walmart and other retailers can surely help Bangladesh create better work environments but only to a certain degree. Bangladesh itself has to rise to the occasion with an emphasis on bringing its people to the 21st century.
 
r

My problem with yours is that you assume 'only' children work in these sweatshops.
All your points certainly have some merit with the exception of the assumption that I make a point that its all kids. If we watched the same documentary, why would you assume that. It showed the adults. It interviewed the kids as they were sewing on button for GAP Shorts.... There is no assumption here, and no mention of "all" children.

Again.... Nobody is forced to use Bangladesh. We are not responsible for their economy. They are used to save a buck, even though people die under the circumstances they are forced to work in.

Your points are well taken though. If they raise rates of the factories to make increases, they run the risk of losing business. Its a sad situation.

And they are absolutely allowed to point out Walmarts role. And its not just Walmart. It would not be fair to only point the finger at them.