What the Press Council reported is absolutely useless.
Did they comment on reports from acknowledged, unbiased "experts" stating that the video is authentic.
Shit even I could make a video showing somebody in a video that has been dead for years.
Did the Press Council see the video.
All they did was take the word of reporters,...and made the grand proclamation that it was "good reporting",...meaningless.
Before you start,...I'm not a Ford fan,...could care less,...but again, you have to realize that he is the result of the Miller ERA, so don't complain.
FAST
What? You want them to authenticate a video that may not exist, and may never have been 'real', even if it did exist? That's a job for the folks asking you to pay to see it, or defending themselves form Ford's libel and slander charges if they had.
After months of discussion and thousands of posts here, the one thing proven is the attachment some people, like you have for their own version of the story and how blind and deaf they can make themselves to the facts, which are:
•A news-site and a well-established and reputable newspaper were independently solicited by someone selling what he claimed was phone-vid of Rob Ford smoking crack. Both may be lying independently, as an adult you must decide you opinion of their report, but that's the core of the story. I won't bother repeating this over an over, but it applies throughout, your opinion, however is only yours, and may have somewhat less cred than those employed and certified as professionals in reporting, if they venture beyond recounting the facts. By all means feel free however to stack yours vs. theirs, just not against the reports of facts you have not investigated at all.
•Both sources sent someone to watch the video (the newspaper sent two award-winning reporters) and the independent reports of what they saw are all in substantial agreement.
•Another reputable paper published a story recounting what it had been told by numerous independent sources, who verified each other in detail, about drug-dealing they said Doug had done years ago (Disclaimer: I too heard such tales during the election from more than one guy who grew up in Etobicoke with the Fords, and posted that gossip here).
•A few individuals—not the Fords, and with no known connection to them—complained of lapses of journalistic standards and ethics in these stories. Only one took advantage of the offer to present her complaint in person.*
•The Press Council deals with published journalism, not unseen videos or unheard sources. They judged that what was published by the papers was a) properly in the interest of the public to be ware of, b) that the papers had done due diligence to confirm what they reported, had kept to the facts in their stories and had avoided unconfirmed speculations or accounts, c) that they had made every possible effort to give both Fords full opportunity to confirm, clarify or deny any and every thing in their stories.
You may still be fascinated by the video, and if it ever surfaces, we may learn lots more than we want about video-fakery, as well as how few words a picture is worth these days, but the Press Council deals with the reports in the papers, and it would be beyond stupid to say they should have ignored them until and only if a video was produced for all to see.
And in what media would that be?
----------------
*Like many others she seemed to think the media should report nothing they have not proven to be factual and could again prove to be factual whenever asked. Of course that would make Twitter, Gawker (do look up at the title of
Phil's thread) and the like, as well as CNN, and every TV and radio news source utterly impractical. We'd need a whole new word to replace 'news'. It would be the 'outdated but provens'. Of course they could just keep on
exactly as before, and hope you picked up on the adult concept of making up your own mind, based on what you know and choose to believe from the reports. Because if they didn't keep up, you'd be feeding your
news habit from someone else.
You want only facts? Why are you following 'new's? Why would you imagine the video, any video is showing you 'fact' anyway?