Gawker Claims Video Exists of Rob Ford Smoking Crack

If you can't get the connection between his example and the findings, we understand one of your problems, reading comprehension.

If you can't understand the difference and different rules that apply to advertising vs news reporting, we understand why you still think Ford is trustworthy.
You probably even still believe that he hasn't raised taxes.
 
Their opinion

Oh my God!!!!

The paranoia just gets worse and worse, you really should get some medication for it.
First it was just the Star out to get the Ford fuckers.
Then the the Globe and Post became 'libtards'.
Even the Sun was added.
Then, the police were suspected as being in on the conspiracy.
Now, even the Press Council.

All that to defend the words of a known liar?
Check your meds, buddy.

What the Press Council reported is absolutely useless.
Did they comment on reports from acknowledged, unbiased "experts" stating that the video is authentic.
Shit even I could make a video showing somebody in a video that has been dead for years.
Did the Press Council see the video.
All they did was take the word of reporters,...and made the grand proclamation that it was "good reporting",...meaningless.

Before you start,...I'm not a Ford fan,...could care less,...but again, you have to realize that he is the result of the Miller ERA, so don't complain.

FAST
 
What the Press Council reported is absolutely useless.
....
blah blah blah
....
Before you start,...I'm not a Ford fan,...could care less,...but again, you have to realize that he is the result of the Miller ERA, so don't complain.

FAST

The original Star report on the video was fair and legit reporting. You should read the article again before you go off on a rant about what you think the reporters said.

And I find it very, very amusing that you are now trying to blame Ford's election on Miller.
 
What the Press Council reported is absolutely useless.
Did they comment on reports from acknowledged, unbiased "experts" stating that the video is authentic.
Shit even I could make a video showing somebody in a video that has been dead for years.
Did the Press Council see the video.
All they did was take the word of reporters,...and made the grand proclamation that it was "good reporting",...meaningless.

Before you start,...I'm not a Ford fan,...could care less,...but again, you have to realize that he is the result of the Miller ERA, so don't complain.

FAST
What? You want them to authenticate a video that may not exist, and may never have been 'real', even if it did exist? That's a job for the folks asking you to pay to see it, or defending themselves form Ford's libel and slander charges if they had.

After months of discussion and thousands of posts here, the one thing proven is the attachment some people, like you have for their own version of the story and how blind and deaf they can make themselves to the facts, which are:

•A news-site and a well-established and reputable newspaper were independently solicited by someone selling what he claimed was phone-vid of Rob Ford smoking crack. Both may be lying independently, as an adult you must decide you opinion of their report, but that's the core of the story. I won't bother repeating this over an over, but it applies throughout, your opinion, however is only yours, and may have somewhat less cred than those employed and certified as professionals in reporting, if they venture beyond recounting the facts. By all means feel free however to stack yours vs. theirs, just not against the reports of facts you have not investigated at all.

•Both sources sent someone to watch the video (the newspaper sent two award-winning reporters) and the independent reports of what they saw are all in substantial agreement.

•Another reputable paper published a story recounting what it had been told by numerous independent sources, who verified each other in detail, about drug-dealing they said Doug had done years ago (Disclaimer: I too heard such tales during the election from more than one guy who grew up in Etobicoke with the Fords, and posted that gossip here).

•A few individuals—not the Fords, and with no known connection to them—complained of lapses of journalistic standards and ethics in these stories. Only one took advantage of the offer to present her complaint in person.*

•The Press Council deals with published journalism, not unseen videos or unheard sources. They judged that what was published by the papers was a) properly in the interest of the public to be ware of, b) that the papers had done due diligence to confirm what they reported, had kept to the facts in their stories and had avoided unconfirmed speculations or accounts, c) that they had made every possible effort to give both Fords full opportunity to confirm, clarify or deny any and every thing in their stories.

You may still be fascinated by the video, and if it ever surfaces, we may learn lots more than we want about video-fakery, as well as how few words a picture is worth these days, but the Press Council deals with the reports in the papers, and it would be beyond stupid to say they should have ignored them until and only if a video was produced for all to see.

And in what media would that be?
----------------
*Like many others she seemed to think the media should report nothing they have not proven to be factual and could again prove to be factual whenever asked. Of course that would make Twitter, Gawker (do look up at the title of Phil's thread) and the like, as well as CNN, and every TV and radio news source utterly impractical. We'd need a whole new word to replace 'news'. It would be the 'outdated but provens'. Of course they could just keep on exactly as before, and hope you picked up on the adult concept of making up your own mind, based on what you know and choose to believe from the reports. Because if they didn't keep up, you'd be feeding your news habit from someone else.

You want only facts? Why are you following 'new's? Why would you imagine the video, any video is showing you 'fact' anyway?
 
Last edited:
You should have just stopped there.
It looked like you understood for a moment, but then went off on some rant about unfair advertising, which is unrelated to reporting on 'news'.

I guess you are more simple minded than I thought. :rolleyes:
 
I guess you are more simple minded than I thought. :blabla:

Speaking of simpleminded, why do you think that parking lot signs are held to the same standards as newspapers?
Are you getting most of your information from your subscription to Park'n'fly?
That would explain things.

:frusty:
:focus:
 
Never mind... I'd explain it to you but apparently you don't grasp the concept of "legally" accurate, and highly deceptive, very well.

I'd be happy to leave alone it now that we've established that the Star report on Rob Ford's crack video was fair and legitimate reporting.


:amen:
 
What the Press Council reported is absolutely useless.
Did they comment on reports from acknowledged, unbiased "experts" stating that the video is authentic.
Shit even I could make a video showing somebody in a video that has been dead for years.
Did the Press Council see the video.
All they did was take the word of reporters,...and made the grand proclamation that it was "good reporting",...meaningless.

Before you start,...I'm not a Ford fan,...could care less,...but again, you have to realize that he is the result of the Miller ERA, so don't complain.

FAST

You are drowning. The Press Council has fully endorsed the quality and integrity of the report. The story about the crack video was high quality, high integrity journalism. So was the story about the Ford family involvement in the drug trade.
 
Talks to himself a lot

Attention OJ

I realise your memory is failing,...so I will remind you once again,...as I told you a while back,...I will not be responding to your posts,...and unless your brain is also not functioning up to par,...that also means that a normal individual would not quote mine. :frusty:

Did you actually think that you had the last word, and I was not capable of replying to you post quoting mine,...idiot ???

If you need help understanding that concept,...please let me know,...I'm here to help you.

Fast

waiting for his diarrhea of the word processor reply,...that shouldn't.
 
I also saw a video once

The original Star report on the video was fair and legit reporting. You should read the article again before you go off on a rant about what you think the reporters said.

And I find it very, very amusing that you are now trying to blame Ford's election on Miller.

So now your a judge of "fair and legit reporting".

Care to respond about my statements regarding the video ???

If you would like me to explain the of how Chairman Miller's era spawned Fords election,...just ask,...I'm here to help you

FAST
 
The STORIES themselves were NOT ruled as being TRUE. They simply ruled that is was "fair and legit" reporting. As I've said from the VERY BEGINNING... I am NOT saying they lied to the letter of the law. They have TEAMS of lawyers that have VERY CAREFULLY worded things in such a way that the they couldn't be help culpable. Its all smoke and mirror legal bullshit. (Some people call this MARKETING.)

For those of you too simple minded to figure that part out, here's a little example for you. I was driving to work this morning and a commercial came on the radio for parking AT the airport which was "about $12.00/ day". I thought: WTF!? I park at the airport all the time, and its WAY more than $12/ day... and then I hear the "fine print": "when you stay for a week or longer." I STILL didn't believe this so I did some research. The "around $12/ day is ONLY at ONE lot, and then ONLY because there is a "deal" for $90 for that 1 lot (farthest from the terminal), and even then only if you stay for a full week. (It actually works out to $12.86/ day, which I guess is "around" $12.00). Parking at that same lot for less than the week will still cost you $18.00/ day... and you have to take the shuttle to the terminal because although the lot is within the airport property, its no where near the terminal. If you REALLY want to park at the airport (within walking distance), its going to cost you $28.00/ day which is WAY more than the "around $12.00" as their radio commercial claims... So: TECHNICALLY, they are legally allowed to say this, but in reality, 99% of the time, its a pile of bullshit.

This is one of the most fucking stupid posts ever. You obviously didn't read any of the articles we are talking about, otherwise you would realize the absurdity of your argument. For those of us too simple minded to figure it out, please give us some examples from those articles were something false might have been written but "TEAMS of lawyers that have VERY CAREFULLY worded things in such a way that they couldn't be held culpable".
 
So now your a judge of "fair and legit reporting".

Care to respond about my statements regarding the video ???
FAST

Let me refresh your memory, I know this happened oh so long ago, around 9am this morning....
The Press Council judged the Star's reporting of Ford's crack smoking, racist and homophobic slurring, video to be fair and legit reporting.
http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2013/10/16/press_council_dismisses_complaints_against_stars_crack_video_report.html

And is your statement about the video:
I also saw a video once
Thereby establishing your credibility on video editing, character judgement, press fairness, press oversight...?
 
Attention OJ

I realise your memory is failing,...so I will remind you once again,...as I told you a while back,...I will not be responding to your posts,...and unless your brain is also not functioning up to par,...that also means that a normal individual would not quote mine. :frusty:

Did you actually think that you had the last word, and I was not capable of replying to you post quoting mine,...idiot ???

If you need help understanding that concept,...please let me know,...I'm here to help you.

Fast

waiting for his diarrhea of the word processor reply,...that shouldn't.
How odd to tell me you haven't for awhile and won't now respond to me, by addressing me in boldface and in red. Certainly it's hard to miss that response. As we long ago discussed at much too much length, you promised to put me on Ignore.

Congratulations on being so certain you speak for all normal people. Others may hold differing opinions, about you, and about what is normal, as do I. Likewise most folks here normally manage without name-calling, even if it's normal for you.

However I'm mystified why a guy who says he won't respond to me, imagines that somehow forbids or prevents me from responding to his open posts. Particularly when he then invites me to respond. When you charge me 'with thinking I had the last word, and that you were not capable of replying to my post quoting yours', but don't reference any post in particular, I have to leave you to your imaginings, and cannot take up your invitation.

But were you capable of replying? If so which post should I look at? If indeed, the above rant is your 'reply', it's OT, unresponsive and unhelpful, but won't discourage me from addressing what I choose to in your posts.
 
Keep lying.

IF (and its a big if- because no one can seem to find it...), the alleged video DOES exist, ONLY 3 people of questionable origin and heavily biased opinions, have seen it. The alleged video was of someone that may look like Ford, but may also be digitally inserted, smoking what some VERY questionable witnesses say is crack. That is VERY circumstantial. Furthermore, the allegations are only corroborated by circumstantial evidence, which makes them VERY questionable.

Just because YOU- a self proclaimed hypocrite and liar, believe he is the crack smoking mayor, doesn't make it true fooj.

fuji-ridgeman called you a liar. let us know when you sue him for defamation. if you don't then I guess its true. right?
 
This is one of the most fucking stupid posts ever. You obviously didn't read any of the articles we are talking about, otherwise you would realize the absurdity of your argument. For those of us too simple minded to figure it out, please give us some examples from those articles were something false might have been written but "TEAMS of lawyers that have VERY CAREFULLY worded things in such a way that they couldn't be held culpable".

I read all the articles. It is obvious to me and most of the board that you, fuji and groggy don't have a good understanding of what's really going on here.

The Star/ Globe and any other news source that has regurgitated this story has never said (legally) that Rob Ford is a crack smoking addict. They can't, because they have no proof. They'll use 3rd party witnesses and phrases like "it was reported by", and "our investigation lead to an unconfirmed source", or "un-named witnesses" etc. which they are legally allowed to do... because they aren't actually (LEGALLY) accusing anyone of anything... they are just writing what someone else has said. It doesn't matter that they don't have proof, as long as they include those little disclaimers... So in THAT respect, their reporting is valid, (which is why they have been "cleared" by the press council), so they are legally in the clear, therefore not culpable for anything they wrote. BUT, the press council has not proven or dis-proven the story.

Having said this, a vast majority of individuals don't read the "fine print" and don't speak "legalese" and glaze over those disclaimers, and like you, groggy and da fooj are now convinced that Ford IS a crack smoking addict... when in actuality, none of that has been proven.

The Star knows this, and are actually counting on it. It's their way of controlling public opinion, of at least the weak minded... (In much the same way, advertisers have many believing that parking at the airport is $12.00 a day!)

I myself DON'T believe everything I read, and will do my own additional research and will reserve opinion until real proof is found. :hand:
 
Right. So the Press council, within their own self defined parameters, have determined that the way the Star and the Globe reported the stories don't cross the line they established. That's their decision to make.

Question....who appoints the council? Oh and who pays for it?

But more importantly it doesn't state that anything that they reported was the truth, just the WAY it was reported fell within their own definitions (they should be on their knees praising the creator of the word "alledged" at this point".

That's all I take away from this.....
 
Right. So the Press council, within their own self defined parameters, have determined that the way the Star and the Globe reported the stories don't cross the line they established. That's their decision to make.

Question....who appoints the council? Oh and who pays for it?

But more importantly it doesn't state that anything that they reported was the truth, just the WAY it was reported fell within their own definitions (they should be on their knees praising the creator of the word "alledged" at this point".

That's all I take away from this.....
Of course it doesn't say what the truth is, that's for each of us to decide for ourselves, and even after a Court has pronounced, whether "on the balance of probabilities", on the "preponderance of the evidence" or "beyond any reasonable doubt", we still have the right to decide for ourselves and can easily marshal instances where the most rigorous proceedings got it wrong. Stephen Truscott anyone?

None of that was ever at issue before the Council. Only fools imagine it was, or try to pretend it was in order to discount what the Council determined: Which was that the the newspapers complained of properly conducted themselves well within the standards of news reporting. An entirely appropriate finding as they report what news they find, and are not triers of fact or anything else.

The Ontario Press Council has a website, with its constitution and listing the membership of the Council, as well as providing the complete text of their judgment. That panel was led by a well-respected judge who would be well aware of the difference between what Courts do and what newspapers do, even if the public is not. Have you read the Council's finding or looked to see who actually sits on it?

If you are unhappy with newspapers—like lawyers and doctors—establishing their Council to regulate and maintain their professional and ethical standards, who would you like to see doing it instead, how would that square with a free press and in this instance how would it have changed the reporting?

Here's what I take to be your complaint, and Ridgeman's and the complainant to the Council: The Star/Globe didn't restrict themselves to proven/provable fact, but reported what they had been told as well. If the sources refused to give their names, I take it you think the papers should have pretended they didn't exist and they had heard nothing. No matter how many times and in how many ways they signalled the dubious and unreliable nature of the stories, nor how often they confirmed them, through others equally unwilling to go on record, they should have left these allegations unreported and swirling around unexamined in the realm of rumour, without any examination, or any effort to discount, disprove or deny them. In fact you sneer about every attempt they made to remind readers these are not facts being reported, but the news. And it's spelled 'alleged'.

'Nothing but proven fact' is not how you or anybody consumes news. Just ask fmahovolich who tells us in the Rob's Robocalls thread that Twitter is god! Or Phil C McNasty who broke and publicized the Gawker version right here hours before the Star. And what he reported was that a source—called Gawker—is telling an unsupported tale. Just like Gawker did, just like the Star. That's how the news is circulated, and unlike Twitter, Gawker and TERB, the reporters at the Star, Globe, Sun and Post have standards of accuracy and ethics. Did I miss your vehement condemnation of Phil C, Boy Reporter?

If we ran news the way you seem to be asking, we'd still not have been told about what are alleged to have been nerve gas attacks on what may or may not have been an unpartisan neighbourhood in Syria.
 
Last edited:
I read all the articles. It is obvious to me and most of the board that you, fuji and groggy don't have a good understanding of what's really going on here.

The Star/ Globe and any other news source that has regurgitated this story has never said (legally) that Rob Ford is a crack smoking addict. They can't, because they have no proof. They'll use 3rd party witnesses and phrases like "it was reported by", and "our investigation lead to an unconfirmed source", or "un-named witnesses" etc. which they are legally allowed to do... because they aren't actually (LEGALLY) accusing anyone of anything... they are just writing what someone else has said. It doesn't matter that they don't have proof, as long as they include those little disclaimers... So in THAT respect, their reporting is valid, (which is why they have been "cleared" by the press council), so they are legally in the clear, therefore not culpable for anything they wrote. BUT, the press council has not proven or dis-proven the story.

Having said this, a vast majority of individuals don't read the "fine print" and don't speak "legalese" and glaze over those disclaimers, and like you, groggy and da fooj are now convinced that Ford IS a crack smoking addict... when in actuality, none of that has been proven.

The Star knows this, and are actually counting on it. It's their way of controlling public opinion, of at least the weak minded... (In much the same way, advertisers have many believing that parking at the airport is $12.00 a day!)

I myself DON'T believe everything I read, and will do my own additional research and will reserve opinion until real proof is found. :hand:
Of course you, unlike the Star, only make statements which you can prove by offering solid evidence. So please prove that the vast majority don't read this "fine print', and give examples of just what 'fine print' they ignored. Then give the evidence that proves the specific individuals you cite actually do think as you have flatly—without legalese—reported they do. You unaccountably left out all that important and necessary proof.

I'd be interested as well in the grounds for your personal opinion, which follows on the bit I boldfaced, that seems to be saying that one is entitled to be convinced only by absolute proof. So faith or love or hate or patriotism, or the balance of probability, or the preponderance of the evidence (remembering that evidence and proof are not synonymous), or years of experience, don't entitle anyone to hold a conviction?

You go right ahead and form your own opinion whenever in the process you feel it's justified: Like waiting until you see the flames before calling 911, or even before asking, "do you smell smoke too". But that doesn't make your decision-making process Holy Writ, and it certainly is no argument against getting what information there is when you can, and reading it with an open mind but also with healthy skepticism.

We call that last stuff 'getting the news', and think it a proper concern for adults, who are entitled to decide for themselves what it means to them.
 
Right. So the Press council, within their own self defined parameters, have determined that the way the Star and the Globe reported the stories don't cross the line they established. That's their decision to make.

Question....who appoints the council? Oh and who pays for it?

But more importantly it doesn't state that anything that they reported was the truth, just the WAY it was reported fell within their own definitions (they should be on their knees praising the creator of the word "alledged" at this point".

That's all I take away from this.....

Collectively, the press in Canada. Except Sun Media, which got tired of the Press Council telling it that had to base its stories on actual facts.