Housing bubble? What f'ing housing bubble?

The bubble is already bursting, but in slow motion. I don't think there will be a 50% crash in house prices like in the US in '08/'09 but housing sales are down from last year, it will likely be a gradual 25-30% correction over the next 2 years.

care to cite your sources?
 
why are people so obsessed in buying a house here in TO?

Because they can't find jobs in small towns, at least professional jobs. But then again, a large percentage of income goes to pay for the houses, and so unwittingly their "dream job" becomes slavery to bank lenders and RE.

That's why they say Toronto is Ontario's economic engine. Here is the cycle of engine:
1. Lots of cubical slavery jobs created by corporations getting investments from stock market and banks
=>
2. Income of these cubical slavery jobs goes to pay for housing, but mostly in forms of mortgage which is bank loan. Bank makes money from mortgage interests, and re-invest in stock markets and companies
=>
3. Companies get more money from banks, now need to "expand" so hire more people - usually low wage immigrants or university graduates. these newly arrived people need a place to live in Toronto, especially need to buy a house when they start family. -> goes back to 1.

Side note: a lot of these company jobs are in financial / banking sector which are benefited from rising RE market to start with. See how many new TD branches popping up in the suburbs? many are in construction and real estate also. A few in high tech, but Canadian tech companies always fail, and get bought up by the US competitors. Then there is a huge percentage of public sector jobs which are funded by surplus in oil revenue.

Now you can see, pretty much the only strength of Canadian economy comes from oil and real estate, not much from innovation. The US - even though suffered so much from mis-management of banks and lack of oil resources, still manage to stay pretty well thanks to its innovative spirits in technology. Gold and oil comes and go, but excellence in technology is the true foundation of national economy, which is why I think Canadian economy is on a very shaky ground.
 
George, I think you don't know very much about the Canadian economy.

You know that we export twice as many industrial/machine goods as natural resources, right?

mg02-eng.jpg
 
I have been hearing this for about 10 years. I used to think the bubble will burst but I don't think so anymore. We are like some Asian countries that have no down turn. Housing is a solid investment.

Unless you're younger than 40 you have not been paying attention. In the last 40 years there have been TWO major housing corrections in Canada. Just because you've been "hearing" it for 10 years does not remove the risk or the fact that it HAS happened and likely will again. The Federal governments continued interference with the real estate market, particularly using CMHC should tell you how concerned they are with the overdone market.

I covered US markets for a major bank for several years and I'll tell you this much: the Star article by the OP looks eerily similar to articles and data I was looking over just a short period of time before the US market melted down. Right before these things happen the media is in the middle of reporting how good things are, or do you think these things announce their arrival? If commodity prices don't pick up, lack of growth will be a serious problem in Canada. But all the Central Bank stimulus in the system will still initiate inflation, we could face stagflation, rising interest rates and then housing prices will take a beating, my guess is starting with the overdone condo market.

Only the foolish thinks any asset class has no downside.
 
George, I think you don't know very much about the Canadian economy.

You know that we export twice as many industrial/machine goods as natural resources, right?

You know the 2009 chart you showing is "Export" chart right? It is the GDP that really counts. Also, industrial goods and machines factories don't create a lot of jobs, they are actually a shrinking pie. Most of new jobs are created in services, banking, IT and health care. - mostly cubical slavery... simply put - except for health care.
 
You know the 2009 chart you showing is "Export" chart right? It is the GDP that really counts. Also, industrial goods and machines factories don't create a lot of jobs, they are actually a shrinking pie. Most of new jobs are created in services, banking, IT and health care. - mostly cubical slavery... simply put - except for health care.

All industrialized nations face that shift in their economies. Apple does not create a lot of jobs in the US, if you want to talk innovation -- most of the jobs created by Apple are in China and India. Apple has a relatively small American workforce.

This is a phenomena that exists in every industrialized country. Increasingly the jobs created locally are in the service, transportation, or resource industries -- stuff that cannot be outsourced somewhere else. A small number of high paying, high growth jobs are in the area of professional services and management, and this is one of the reasons why we have GDP growth with a shrinking employment market.

There is a fundamental shift taking place now that raises the question of whether the middle class is going to survive. An optimal economic model for an advanced economy these days might be a landed elite that produces engineers, architects, and managers, served by a massive lower class that drives, cooks lunch, cuts hair, and cleans.

In fact that finance sector you talk about needs to be broken up. It contains a combination of high paying, high growth jobs that net salaries well into the six figures, and below average income clerking jobs that are at risk of being outsourced. Viewing "finance and real estate" as one market segment overlooks that huge schism.

We actually should have an adult conversation about whether that is what we want, ideologically and politically, or whether we should intervene to stop it. There isn't any guarantee that optimal economic solutions are socially optimal.
 
All industrialized nations face that shift in their economies. Apple does not create a lot of jobs in the US, if you want to talk innovation -- most of the jobs created by Apple are in China and India. Apple has a relatively small American workforce.
Not just Apple, also Google, Microsoft, IBM, Oracle, Yahoo, Amazon, Facebook, almost all the big name tech success stories are in the USA. Canada does have innovations too:
Nortel, Blackberry, Corel. Problem is there is always lack of investment and market size is too small for them to compete with US counterpart. I personally worked in a very sucessful small tech startup, got bought by a US company after 1.5 years, and after 8 more years, they cut 1/2 of Canadian staff, and outsourced our jobs to Malaysia.


This is a phenomena that exists in every industrialized country. Increasingly the jobs created locally are in the service, transportation, or resource industries -- stuff that cannot be outsourced somewhere else. A small number of high paying, high growth jobs are in the area of professional services and management, and this is one of the reasons why we have GDP growth with a shrinking employment market.

There is a fundamental shift taking place now that raises the question of whether the middle class is going to survive. An optimal economic model for an advanced economy these days might be a landed elite that produces engineers, architects, and managers, served by a massive lower class that drives, cooks lunch, cuts hair, and cleans.
Yeah I hear ya.. this seems to be the trend..

In fact that finance sector you talk about needs to be broken up. It contains a combination of high paying, high growth jobs that net salaries well into the six figures, and below average income clerking jobs that are at risk of being outsourced. Viewing "finance and real estate" as one market segment overlooks that huge schism.
Not necessarily low paying jobs are at risk of outsourcing, but also high paying brain jobs too. A lot of computer programming jobs are already outsourced to India. Low paying bank tellers or even Starbucks baristas can't be outsourced. In fact there is a growing low wage part time jobs in the US right now, that is skewing the employment data. The best high paying jobs are the ones you have to deal with people. If your job requires minimum face to face communication, then it is at highest risk of being outsourced, no matter how high of skill it requires - there will always be an Indian guy who will work twice as hard as you for 1/10 of the salary. In IT sector I see lots of high paying engineering jobs disappearing, yet server administration, database admin, security experts, help desk staff etc.. jobs requiring relatively low intellectual skills are actually more secure than say - software engineer.

We actually should have an adult conversation about whether that is what we want, ideologically and politically, or whether we should intervene to stop it. There isn't any guarantee that optimal economic solutions are socially optimal.

I think eventually, wages in developing countries will rise and become competitive with developed countries so those jobs will come back some day - long in the future. The question is after such a long time, we will have lost of capabilities and talents and become completely dependent on import from the 3rd world countries. But I think it might be a good thing because it bonds all the nations together by economic ties and less likely to wage wars with one another.
 

I know TREB does year over year and seasonally adjusted numbers. June prices were around $531k and July prices are around $513k. The board still says prices are up. The past few July's have had lower numbers. If they said this was thebest July for GTA prices in the past 4 years that would be more accurate. I don't remember all the numbers but if my property value dropped every month this year, I would question those numbers. It's all in how they report the numbers.
 
The bubble has been suggested for quite some time now.

Kids living at home into their 30s is slowing down when the bubble will burst.

When it bursts I expect more of a plateau before a decline. And the decline will be gradual. Only reason for a sharp drop would be if investors flooded the market with houses and were desperate to sell. More realistically I think investors wouldn't panic in that manner and would be looking to minimize loss/maximize profits.

Edit: parent's helping their kids with getting a mortgage will also slow the bubble burst

For the bubble to burst it invovles all buyers saying we won't play ball..... and that is just not going to happen. They will find ways to make it work.
 
Not necessarily low paying jobs are at risk of outsourcing, but also high paying brain jobs too. A lot of computer programming jobs are already outsourced to India. Low paying bank tellers or even Starbucks baristas can't be outsourced. In fact there is a growing low wage part time jobs in the US right now, that is skewing the employment data. The best high paying jobs are the ones you have to deal with people. If your job requires minimum face to face communication, then it is at highest risk of being outsourced, no matter how high of skill it requires - there will always be an Indian guy who will work twice as hard as you for 1/10 of the salary. In IT sector I see lots of high paying engineering jobs disappearing, yet server administration, database admin, security experts, help desk staff etc.. jobs requiring relatively low intellectual skills are actually more secure than say - software engineer.

Canada's white collar wage structure is under pressure. Cost of living is rising every year but wage growth isn't.

Rates are at a HISTORIC (keyword: historic) low and that's when housing looks affordable on a monthly payment basis. But what if the rates rise a couple of percent but your wages don't?

These home prices are out of the reach of a workforce that's not getting more in terms of wage growth and on the contrary is actually under pressure for job loss scenarios in IT and manufacturing and even areas like law:

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/repo...gal-firms-turn-to-outsourcing/article4570690/

http://www.thestar.com/business/per...s_and_inhouse_lawyers_send_work_to_india.html

Some Toronto law firms and in-house lawyers are also delegating high volume, repetitive work to lawyers in countries like India and the Philippines. Contract reviews, drafting standard documents, and summarizing electronic discovery transcripts are all legal projects suitable for outsourcing abroad.

That’s because a lawyer in India charging $25 per hour is well paid by local standards but much cheaper than a Canadian lawyer who bills hundreds of dollars an hour.

People say we're different than the US. We are not. These trends were emerging in US after 2000 as well till things blew up in 2008/2009.

The world has changed around us and we are not a rich society any more where people have rising wages and job security. But housing prices don't reflect that and that's why this is a bubble.
 
I say that when the housing bubble hits, it will be the condo market that deflates 20-25% quickly. There will be less of a hit with houses, ,maybe a slower deflation of 15-20%
 
I say that when the housing bubble hits, it will be the condo market that deflates 20-25% quickly. There will be less of a hit with houses, ,maybe a slower deflation of 15-20%

LOL> Not happening. Low inventory and high demand still rules. Open your high school economics books Housing ain't crashing.
 
Applications for permits are dropping. That would be building applications. This will obviously result in less available inventory. Resulting in a more balanced demand.

And as I posted earlier. 3 houses within eyesight of my house in the last 3-4 years have been split into 2 properties. I see where a few more will follow I'm sure once they sell.

There is still a lot of demand for housing in this city. And with the Feds tightening up the rules we won't have one of the big issues with the USA.

We don't lend money to people who didn't have a hope in hell of paying it back!