Bizarre 'Schrodinger's Cat' Comes Alive in New Experiments

Quantum mechanics says that it's impossible to know whether the radioactive decay has happened unless one measures it — that is, unless the alpha particle interacts with the environment in some way that an observer can see. Until that happens, the alpha particle is emitted and not emitted at the same time. a state called superposition.

Are they saying nothing occurs at the quantum level unless observed by a consciousness ? or are they saying everything occurs at the quantum level until observed by a consciousness ?


Either way this can't be true !!!!


Another possibility, called the many worlds interpretation, would be even weirder: that all the possible states are real, and we're just experiencing one of many universes that exist simultaneously, in which every possible outcome happens.


I do not believe it
 
Here's a slight modification to the alive/dead cat situation. Now, instead of the emission of the alpha particle releasing the poison and killing the cat, suppose that the release of the alpha particle triggers a bell to ring.

So, (a) no bell = no particle, (b) bell rings = particle released. There is no room for any nonsense of "impossible to know" in this scenario.

Can anyone explain to me what the difference is, which causes clever scientists such amazement and consternation, between a particle that rings a bell and a particle that kills a cat.
 
Here's a slight modification to the alive/dead cat situation. Now, instead of the emission of the alpha particle releasing the poison and killing the cat, suppose that the release of the alpha particle triggers a bell to ring.

So, (a) no bell = no particle, (b) bell rings = particle released. There is no room for any nonsense of "impossible to know" in this scenario.

Can anyone explain to me what the difference is, which causes clever scientists such amazement and consternation, between a particle that rings a bell and a particle that kills a cat.
I'm no quantum physicist, though I do play one on TV*. Your ideer wouldn't wash, since one of the most common interpretations of the whole thing is that a quantum state (in this case, whether the particle has decayed or not) will only resolve itself once it is observed (in this case, when the box is opened and we check Mittens' vital signs). Having the particle ring a bell when it decays is the same as making an observation, so you would in effect be doing the same thing as opening the box.



I do not believe it
You, sir, obviously do not read enough sci fi !





* a crime-fighting doctor/lawyer/quantum physicist, for those of you keeping track
 
You, sir, obviously do not read enough sci fi !
[/SIZE]


it seems to me there would have to be an identical scientist doing the same experiment in a parallel universe at the same time getting opposite results

this means infinite universes does it not? this means the experiment is happening an infinite amount of times throughout infinity

Poor Captain Janeway is confused by the paradox of time travel !

Infinite universes is good stuff for the next Star Trek movie
 
Last edited:
I'm no quantum physicist, though I do play one on TV*. Your ideer wouldn't wash, since one of the most common interpretations of the whole thing is that a quantum state (in this case, whether the particle has decayed or not) will only resolve itself once it is observed (in this case, when the box is opened and we check Mittens' vital signs). Having the particle ring a bell when it decays is the same as making an observation, so you would in effect be doing the same thing as opening the box.

My point was, there is an infinity of situations where you cannot know what state an object is in, until you can observe and perceive what state the object is in.

Why do the top scientists get their knickers twisted over the notion that, because you can't yet tell whether the cat is alive or dead, therefore you have to consider that the cat is both alive and dead at the same time?

What is it about the decaying alpha particle and the cat that makes that apparent-nonsense something that needs to be considered? Why don't they just say: either (a) the alpha particle has been released, or (b) it has not been released (i.e (a) the cat is dead or (b) the cat is alive), but we don't know which?
 
the cat is dead or alive before we have observed
but the decision which we observe has not happened until we observe it so it must be in both states, i think

So, we don't yet know whether the cat is alive or dead. Therefore, we ordinary mortals say: the cat is either dead or alive, but we don't yet know which."

But apparently, this scenario prompts the cleverest and most scholarly scientists to say: "the cat might, right now, be both dead and alive."

How/why are they able to turn our either/or into their both/and?
 
My point was, there is an infinity of situations where you cannot know what state an object is in, until you can observe and perceive what state the object is in.

Why do the top scientists get their knickers twisted over the notion that, because you can't yet tell whether the cat is alive or dead, therefore you have to consider that the cat is both alive and dead at the same time?

What is it about the decaying alpha particle and the cat that makes that apparent-nonsense something that needs to be considered? Why don't they just say: either (a) the alpha particle has been released, or (b) it has not been released (i.e (a) the cat is dead or (b) the cat is alive), but we don't know which?
It's not about the particle and the cat at all. It's all about the idea that a state is not resolved until it is observed. The kitty thought experiment is just a way of illlustrating that.

But why? Because it's fun when science butts up against philosophy. And keep in mind that it ain't just aimless speculation - there are all sorts of sexy math n physics implications that our wee brains can't quite wrap around. Like, crazy blackboard-filling brain numbing math. Fucked if I can follow it, but the eggheads love banging on about. So even though the core idea of "dunno until it is observed" seems simple enough and even a tad silly, dudes with high foreheads and no social skills are devising all sorts of mathematical theorems and proofs that incorporate it. They've even done actual experiments with subatomic particles and the like in such "cat states" of neither one nor the other until observed. Because Science, bitches!
 
So, we don't yet know whether the cat is alive or dead. Therefore, we ordinary mortals say: the cat is either dead or alive, but we don't yet know which."

But apparently, this scenario prompts the cleverest and most scholarly scientists to say: "the cat might, right now, be both dead and alive."

How/why are they able to turn the either/or into the both/and?

because


1 the event has happened (pussy is dead or alive) before we observe it

2 but until we observe it is in both states because the quantum state of the radioactive decay (in this quantum scenario ) is not predetermined and is only determined when we observe so the cat has to be in a both conditions (alive and dead) to satisfy the random nature of observance


quantum states are not determined until observed by a consciousness



Does this mean the evolution of consciousness also evolved quantum states?

how conscious does the observer have to be ??

Can a dolphin be the observer ?

Can Data from Star Trek be the observer?


Me thinks more study is needed
 
Last edited: