Gawker Claims Video Exists of Rob Ford Smoking Crack

No.

Ford is a politician. Using his image/words to report on his character and behavior is fair comment on a public figure. Otherwise politicians could block opposing newspapers from reporting.

"He peddles to sell it in a commercial transaction" and "he is marketing Rob Ford image without Rob Ford permission."



If the video is fake Ford could sue for libel. Bringing a fraud charge would be iffy.

Not talking of civic suit by Rob Ford.

I am talking of criminal case, fraud, laid by the police: "he is marketing a fake product with false pretend."
 
Plenty of somewheres.

Identity theft is when you steal someone's personal data and impersonate them. Nothing of the sort is happening here.

Also, unless it comes out that he tried to blackmail Ford with the video, the possibility of charges regarding sale, use of image, etc etc etc is crazy low.

(Note: I am also not a lawyer though I do play one on TV)

You got it considering he tried so hard to (1) unload to Gawker and The Star (and probably many more other media.) and (2) using this video to plea bargains with the crown.
 
It is the crack part that they can't corroborate from a video. He could have been smoking something else out of a crack pipe.

The article we quoted elaborated one more problem the crown faced: "It isn’t clear who has possession of the video or if it still exists." Its the next paragraph below that "corroborate" paragraph (just for your information)
 
"He peddles to sell it in a commercial transaction" and "he is marketing Rob Ford image without Rob Ford permission."

Which is fair comment. People sell pictures of famous people without their permission every day. Do you think Ford gives the Star permission to run his photo?

I am talking of criminal case, fraud, laid by the police: "he is marketing a fake product with false pretend."

Nope not going to happen. Anyway the guy is already facing dozens of weapons and drug charges so what is the point to even pursue it, especially since it is such a long shot.
 
I think some of you guys are misreading all this, all the cops said was they didnt do that raid for the specific reason to find Ford video, that raid was planned a year ago well before anyone even heard of the Ford video.

but that doesnt mean it doesnt exist, it just means they didnt conduct the raid for that sole reason
 
I think some of you guys are misreading all this, all the cops said was they didnt do that raid for the specific reason to find Ford video, that raid was planned a year ago well before anyone even heard of the Ford video.

but that doesnt mean it doesnt exist, it just means they didnt conduct the raid for that sole reason

Hopefully they put him on the stand as a witness for the prosecution to testify against his dealer. He can tell how much crack he bought on which days and help put the dealer behind bars.
 
We don't have a recall mechanism.

Hmmm...okay no recall mechanism.

Your opinion: do you think the standard should be higher, lower or same level as criminal prosecution to fire (or he make quit) a democratically elected official (in this case the mayor)
 
Hmmm...okay no recall mechanism.

Your opinion: do you think the standard should be higher, lower or same level as criminal prosecution to fire (or he make quit) a democratically elected official (in this case the mayor)

Lower. Much much lower.

In court the burden of proof lies with the side that wants to remove rights by putting someone in prison.

With elected officials the burden of proof rests with the candidates who want the privilege of representing us to prove that they are worthy of our trust.
 
Not a lawyer and just thinking outloud.

With this Siad in police custody, for almost month and half, shouldn't he face additional charge if he actually owns a video of Rob Ford and he peddles to sell it in a commercial transaction?

If the video is real, he is marketing Rob Ford image without Rob Ford permission. Isn't it a identification theft and a criminal offend?
...
Wow, you have an interesting version of the laws.
 
Lower. Much much lower.
That definitely fits with your intense dislike of Ford.

Would you sincerely want it as low if it was somebody that you thought was a great mayor and they were in danger of being ousted?

My suspicion is that your standards would be different for somebody you liked.
 
That definitely fits with your intense dislike of Ford.

Would you sincerely want it as low if it was somebody that you thought was a great mayor and they were in danger of being ousted?

My suspicion is that your standards would be different for somebody you liked.

At the end of the day the standard will be set by the majority of the voters. With his high popularity, hate to tell Fuji, the standard to remove Rob Ford is sky high I am afraid.
 
Lower. Much much lower.

In court the burden of proof lies with the side that wants to remove rights by putting someone in prison.

With elected officials the burden of proof rests with the candidates who want the privilege of representing us to prove that they are worthy of our trust.

You sound confused. I am talking about the standard to remove a democratically elected official (again in this case the mayor who has been on the job for more than half the term) and you are talking of not voting for the candidates with shady characters and who has not been elected yet.
 
That definitely fits with your intense dislike of Ford.

Would you sincerely want it as low if it was somebody that you thought was a great mayor and they were in danger of being ousted?

Yes. You would have to be cheap and somewhat stupid to change your principles to support you're politics.

I realize there are many such hypocrites around here but I am not one
them.
 
You sound confused. I am talking about the standard to remove a democratically elected official (again in this case the mayor who has been on the job for more than half the term) and you are talking of not voting for the candidates has not been elected yet.

You asked the conditions under which he should be made to resign. Much lower than the standard for criminal conviction.

I want better than 'not guilty' from our leadership.
 
You asked the conditions under which he should be made to resign. Much lower than the standard for criminal conviction.

I want better than 'not guilty' from our leadership.



Much lower than the standard for criminal conviction to remove a mayor you don't like even though he was democratically elected?

Any crack video yet? 3 months after? Lucky us you don't have that authority to remove an elected official.
 
Much lower than the standard for criminal conviction to remove a mayor you don't like even though he was democratically elected?

Losing your job is nothing like being forcibly dragged to a prison and locked in a cell. Of course the standard for a criminal conviction should be much, much higher than any other standard of evidence for any other punitive measure anywhere.

Most people use a balance of probabilities standard for most of their decisions. We use the must tougher beyond a reasonable doubt standard for criminal conviction because of the extreme nature of the resulting punishment, essentially the complete removal of even basic rights and freedoms.

If someone gets turfed from the mayor's office for reasons that later prove groundless, well that is a shame. But if someone is locked in a jail cell for ten years of their life and it turns out they were innocent that is unbelievable horrible for that person.

It amazes me that you want to equate these things!
 
Where is that crack video? Anyone?