Acquital for Zimmerman

Not true.

There is additional proof in the physical evidence.

Zimmerman's keys were found very close to the "T" in the walkway, exactly where Zimmerman said he was located when Martin first attacked him.

To find Zimmerman's keys there, you need to believe either that Zimmernan dropped them there when Martin attacked him, as he claimed. Or that he placed them there after the fact (perhaps even throwing them there), having started further down the path than he claims.

For anyone to believe that Zimmerman had followed Martin down the path, you need to come up with some credible explanation as to how the keys wound up at the top of the "T". The prosecution had no theory presented in court to explain this fact.

As for SYG, the only application of it was in the Judge's instructions to the Jury, where the jury was informed that Zimmerman did not have a "duty to flee" in order to find Self Defense.

word.
 
This is against the law, and should result in a mistrial.

The only evidence you are allowed to consider, including interpretations of the law, is what you are presented with in Court.

If you have questions, you may ask them, but you may not create answers which are not provided by the Court.

Technically, you may be right but really, the text of the law itself? Anyone can bring books into their hand bags or purses into the jury room (small stuff that would slip by I suppose).


(If I recall correctly, the references to the applicable criminal codes were brought up in court. I only re-read them from my pocket PB book, or established questions therefrom - we didn't try to apply any other provisions).
 
Not true.

There is additional proof in the physical evidence.

Zimmerman's keys were found very close to the "T" in the walkway, exactly where Zimmerman said he was located when Martin first attacked him.

To find Zimmerman's keys there, you need to believe either that Zimmernan dropped them there when Martin attacked him, as he claimed. Or that he placed them there after the fact (perhaps even throwing them there), having started further down the path than he claims.

For anyone to believe that Zimmerman had followed Martin down the path, you need to come up with some credible explanation as to how the keys wound up at the top of the "T". The prosecution had no theory presented in court to explain this fact.

As for SYG, the only application of it was in the Judge's instructions to the Jury, where the jury was informed that Zimmerman did not have a "duty to flee" in order to find Self Defense.


Thank you and I agree on all your points. I didn't mean to exclude physical or direct evidence in my comment.
 
I would have voted to acquit.

On the same evidence if it had been TM on trial I also would have voted to acquit.

There is just no information on who started the violence and thus they both can raise a reasonable doubt that it was self defence.

Only Zimmerman knows who hit first but he could be lying.


At the end of the day, it's irrelevant as to who incited or started the violence.

On the same evidence if it had been TM on trial, I don't think TM's necessarily innocent. It just means that he won control over GZ's gun while GZ tried to defend himself from having his brains spilled onto the pavement.
 
At the end of the day, it's irrelevant as to who incited or started the violence.

On the same evidence if it had been TM on trial, I don't think TM's necessarily innocent. It just means that he won control over GZ's gun while GZ tried to defend himself from having his brains spilled onto the pavement.

Well. If we could prove who started the violence it matters a lot.

One of them is actually guilty but we don't have enough evidence to know which one, which creates a reasonable doubt that means both would be acquitted on the evidence we have.

Without an eye witness and with no evidence as to who initiated the violence neither of them can be convicted.
 
Well. If we could prove who started the violence it matters a lot.

One of them is actually guilty but we don't have enough evidence to know which one, which creates a reasonable doubt that means both would be acquitted on the evidence we have.

Without an eye witness and with no evidence as to who initiated the violence neither of them can be convicted.


The way I see it, it doesn't matter in this case because TM is dead. Even if GZ punched him first, TM didn't necessarily have a right to SYG because at that point, his life wasn't threatened. When TM was pounding his head, it was normal self-defence for GZ.

In other words, the attacker became the defender (hypothetically speaking) but that 'attack' did not constitute a 'threat of death or great bodily harm'.

(If GZ confronted TM with his gun drawn as you hypothesized, then yeah, I guess he would be guilty, but from the circumstantial evidence, I don't think so).
 
Not true.

There is additional proof in the physical evidence.

Zimmerman's keys were found very close to the "T" in the walkway, exactly where Zimmerman said he was located when Martin first attacked him.

To find Zimmerman's keys there, you need to believe either that Zimmernan dropped them there when Martin attacked him, as he claimed. Or that he placed them there after the fact (perhaps even throwing them there), having started further down the path than he claims.

For anyone to believe that Zimmerman had followed Martin down the path, you need to come up with some credible explanation as to how the keys wound up at the top of the "T". The prosecution had no theory presented in court to explain this fact.
...

Depending on which path you are talking about, the accepted fact is that he left his car on one street, walked down the path, past the T to the next street then back to the T where the incident happened.
 
Well. If we could prove who started the violence it matters a lot.

One of them is actually guilty but we don't have enough evidence to know which one, which creates a reasonable doubt that means both would be acquitted on the evidence we have.

Without an eye witness and with no evidence as to who initiated the violence neither of them can be convicted.

It depends on the charge . Self defence can be used as a defence against capital charges, felonies (or there can be counter charges etc...) in a fist fight no matter who started it. Why? because that person can claim that they felt they were in immediate danger of being killed or grievous injury, so they acted in self defence to stop that. Then the evidence comes in and the prosecutor has to disprove that claim beyond a reasonable doubt or in the affirmative prove some sort of intent, ill will etc...

in this particular case, if Zimmerman didnt have all of those bruises and the bloody nose ..... which has nothing to do w who initiated the violence .... and if there was no eye witness .... i think the jury could have convicted Zimmerman , simply becasue as so many here focus on, Trayvon was not armed w a gun and Zimmerman was.
 
in this particular case, if Zimmerman didnt have all of those bruises and the bloody nose ..... which has nothing to do w who initiated the violence .... and if there was no eye witness .... i think the jury could have convicted Zimmerman , simply becasue as so many here focus on, Trayvon was not armed w a gun and Zimmerman was.
Yes, but that's along the lines of 'completely changing everything entered into evidence, wouldn't it be possible that. . . .'
 
It depends on the charge . Self defence can be used as a defence against capital charges, felonies (or there can be counter charges etc...) in a fist fight no matter who started it. Why? because that person can claim that they felt they were in immediate danger of being killed or grievous injury, so they acted in self defence to stop that. Then the evidence comes in and the prosecutor has to disprove that claim beyond a reasonable doubt or in the affirmative prove some sort of intent, ill will etc...

in this particular case, if Zimmerman didnt have all of those bruises and the bloody nose ..... which has nothing to do w who initiated the violence .... and if there was no eye witness .... i think the jury could have convicted Zimmerman , simply becasue as so many here focus on, Trayvon was not armed w a gun and Zimmerman was.

Maybe but he did have those bruises. We know for a fact that they both committed violence against each other. We just don't know who started that violence.

We know that Z stalked TM and then TM confronted Z verbally demanding an explanation. We don't know if TM then initiated violence at that point or whether Z did.

We know something about the violence that followed and that it ended with Z bruised and TM shot, and we know that TM briefly had the he upper hand but we don't know how it started.

That doubt acquits them both.
 
All this news coverage reporting 1000's turning out to demonstrate, support for TM and anger against GZ, but I have yet to see a wide shot to truly gauge the size of the crowds in any one location. Makes you wonder how many are actually out.
 
I was somewhat surprised to see that Bill Maher (who is a gun owner) thinks Z is guilty.
 
really this whole business indicates that the police force was totally inadequate in that town. they could have sent 2 undercovers in for a few days, nailed the perps and then none of this would have happened. when the populace has to protect themselves, things can go wrong.
 
really this whole business indicates that the police force was totally inadequate in that town. they could have sent 2 undercovers in for a few days, nailed the perps and then none of this would have happened. when the populace has to protect themselves, things can go wrong.


Or right..... As the jury determined!
 
All this news coverage reporting 1000's turning out to demonstrate, support for TM and anger against GZ, but I have yet to see a wide shot to truly gauge the size of the crowds in any one location. Makes you wonder how many are actually out.
In Philadelphia (which since World War II, has has had a very large Black population) only 700.
 
Or right..... As the jury determined!

The jury did not determine that. All it determined was that there wasn't enough evidence to send Zimmerman to the slammer.

These comments that the acquittal means that he was right to shoot Martin are both ignorant and disturbing.
 
The jury did not determine that. All it determined was that there wasn't enough evidence to send Zimmerman to the slammer.

These comments that the acquittal means that he was right to shoot Martin are both ignorant and disturbing.
You can choose to view this in the negative: that there wasn't enough evidence to convict.

However, it is just as valid to say that the Jury determined that G.Z. was justified in using deadly force against T.M.


The question as to whether G.Z. was "right to shoot Martin" is not really a question the Jury has in it's power to answer. That is really a question for God.
 
However, it is just as valid to say that the Jury determined that G.Z. was justified in using deadly force against T.M.

It is not, and you shouldn't be practising law in a common law jurisdiction if you don't know that.

A juror only needs to have a reasonable doubt to acquit. They do not need to believe he was justified, only that he might be.

Return your law licence if you don't grok what "beyond a reasonable doubt" means.