Acquital for Zimmerman

RJ said he threw the first punch. Also, we only have GZ's account but that's evidence too which was not impeached. So I don't think that 'suckered punch' is a very loaded term.

She says she thinks TM might have thrown the first punch, but in response to something like GZ grabbing him or something. It is possible GZ found TM and grabbed him by the jacket or something similar, in order to try to arrest him. It is firm that he had a mindset that 'these guys always get away.'

Also possible TM saw him, and decided to forestall any more following from GZ by putting him on the ground.

Also possible TM circled around looking for GZ and jumped him. (A bit less likely though, as he was on the phone leading up to the encounter. Those records are a bit more firm than the testimony of what RJ heard.)

All of this is unknowable, but everyone needs to recognize that and not push forth a single narrative of the truth. The jury found reasonable doubt, not that all the testimony or defense's narrative has been proven true.
 
WHO DECIDES WHAT IS REASONABLE? a jury or a judge. Not your political enemies. Or your cultural or tribal enemies . jesus christ.... put yourself in the defendants seat on trial for your freedom.

I don't quite follow your rant here yolo.

I said that SYG law may be reasonable in light of the American system, basically.

What's reasonable is usually dictated by the rational man on the sidelines argument, or case law or what a judge or jury might decide.
 
it is not proof. It is part of the narrative Zimmermans team built through the admission of Zimmermans statements / walk throughs etc...c by the prosecution!!!! (dumb?) which kept Zim off the stand

Fuji is so off point with his assertions they arent worth countering anymore. He lives in Hypotheticalville. In fact he is the fucking dictator of that sad little burg

Sorry but I disagree, however....

Statements produced at trial enter in the evidence record. They are part of the 'proof'. How that is weighed, or discounted, or disregarded, in considering what is 'proof', is up to the jury. Remember, what you say can be used against you. That's part of the record which is evidence, and evidence is part of the 'proof'.
 
She says she thinks TM might have thrown the first punch, but in response to something like GZ grabbing him or something. It is possible GZ found TM and grabbed him by the jacket or something similar, in order to try to arrest him. It is firm that he had a mindset that 'these guys always get away.'

Also possible TM saw him, and decided to forestall any more following from GZ by putting him on the ground.

Also possible TM circled around looking for GZ and jumped him. (A bit less likely though, as he was on the phone leading up to the encounter. Those records are a bit more firm than the testimony of what RJ heard.)

All of this is unknowable, but everyone needs to recognize that and not push forth a single narrative of the truth. The jury found reasonable doubt, not that all the testimony or defense's narrative has been proven true.

All good points. You'd think that she might know since she was talking to him almost right up until the time of the incident (IIRC).

Didn't she say that he said 'get off' before the call ended abruptly?

Is that hearsay?
 
I have no idea whether you have a point. You seem to be an angry person blathering on with nothing important to say.

You had an inane and ridiculous question there. Obviously we expect a jury to decide what force is reasonable.

then accept their verdict
 
I don't see how a 17 year old is going to counter someone who pulls a gun at arm's length with a punch because that might provoke the other to fire.

You knock the muzzle away first. The punch is then part of the struggle for the gun.

If you're a juror, unless the evidence of the Defendant is impeached, you have to consider it. The fact that you ignore it means you're biased. Whatever scenario you speculate here, is not evidence Fuji.

What we are discussing is that TM s just as innocent as Z. The same ambiguity that acquitted Z would have acquitted TM. The facts leave it unclear who initiated the violence and therefore there is a reasonable doubt both ways.
 
All good points. You'd think that she might know since she was talking to him almost right up until the time of the incident (IIRC).

Didn't she say that he said 'get off' before the call ended abruptly?

Is that hearsay?

That was her testimony that she heard that, and has to be weighed as evidence. She won't likely be impartial, just as GZ's statements are not impartial. A jury has to bear that in mind as they decide what influences their decision. Let's be real, either one can be lying through their teeth. It is a personal matter of how credible you feel they are.

I am not a lawyer though, there are others that could comment far better than me on how evidence is weighed.

Don't know much about hearsay, except there are special considerations when the person who supposedly made the statement is dead. Otherwise, they could testify directly.
 
wow, basketcase the KING of loaded terms like HUNTED/ STALKED is trying to call out a loaded term. Pot meet kettle.

You might want to check my history. Those weren't terms I've used (but why should you start being factually accurate now?).
 
I did. I am pointing out that the same argument would acquit TM.

You might want to reread the thread before commenting further, to avoid more embarrassment.

Like I said, you live in Hypotheticalville. In the country of Intheory. Where the law of the land must be whatever nonsense you write.

But hey, thanks for your opinions on that hypothetical case ! it sure was enlightening. i cant wait for your next spell binding lesson.
 
Like I said, you live in Hypotheticalville. In the country of Intheory. Where the law of the land must be whatever nonsense you write.

But hey, thanks for your opinions on that hypothetical case ! it sure was enlightening. i cant wait for your next spell binding lesson.

Whenever you need another schooling I am here for you.
 
You knock the muzzle away first. The punch is then part of the struggle for the gun.

Only in la la land or unless you're dealing with Bruce Lee.


What we are discussing is that TM s just as innocent as Z. The same ambiguity that acquitted Z would have acquitted TM. The facts leave it unclear who initiated the violence and therefore there is a reasonable doubt both ways.

In my mind, there's doubt that GZ initiated the violence who is both armed, heavier and was getting his head pounded into the pavement.

If GZ ended up dead by his own gun and with the non-fatal trauma to his body, I would surmise that TM ambushed and overcame him.
 
Like I said, you live in Hypotheticalville. In the country of Intheory. Where the law of the land must be whatever nonsense you write.

But hey, thanks for your opinions on that hypothetical case ! it sure was enlightening. i cant wait for your next spell binding lesson.


I'm thinking that Fuji would've caused a hung jury if he was a juror.

(Seriously Fuji, what would you have ruled?)
 
Juror B-37 says if not implies that she/they had to acquit due to SYG law which should be changed.


After educating myself here on this Florida law and learning from some of our American counterparts, I think SYG is irrelevant.

However the fight ensued, the fact is, GZ ended up flat on the ground with TM on top bashing his head against the pavement (judging from the physical or circumstantial evidence). GZ shot him as he apparently had no other choice. Self-defence. Pure and simple.

Regardless of how the jury arrived at their decision, I still think it was the right one.

Still a tragedy and I'll agree with the crowd that feels that GZ should have left the matter entirely up to the police or simply not leave his car.
 
I'm thinking that Fuji would've caused a hung jury if he was a juror.

(Seriously Fuji, what would you have ruled?)

I would have voted to acquit.

On the same evidence if it had been TM on trial I also would have voted to acquit.

There is just no information on who started the violence and thus they both can raise a reasonable doubt that it was self defence.

Only Zimmerman knows who hit first but he could be lying.
 
Thank you Sir. (When I was a juror in a criminal trial, I brought my annotated Pocket Criminal Code of Canada to understand the law in question, and we even asked the judge a couple of questions, to aid in our deliberation).

This is against the law, and should result in a mistrial.

The only evidence you are allowed to consider, including interpretations of the law, is what you are presented with in Court.

If you have questions, you may ask them, but you may not create answers which are not provided by the Court.
 
Correction. The only 'proof' is the account of the only living witness, George Zimmerman (besides any other witness statements or circumstantial evidence). Unless his credibility is impeached, his statement should stand as evidence adduced for the defendant.

The issue with the first punch is to counter Fuji's assertion that TM also had a SYG right, but that requires that he was attacked first. However, if TM 1st punched, then it was he who attacked GZ, which opens the door for a SYG defense or right for GZ. In this case, as Aardvark154 points out, GZ didn't need a SYG defence since he could not flee while pinned, and used deadly force as his normal right to defend himself.

Not true.

There is additional proof in the physical evidence.

Zimmerman's keys were found very close to the "T" in the walkway, exactly where Zimmerman said he was located when Martin first attacked him.

To find Zimmerman's keys there, you need to believe either that Zimmernan dropped them there when Martin attacked him, as he claimed. Or that he placed them there after the fact (perhaps even throwing them there), having started further down the path than he claims.

For anyone to believe that Zimmerman had followed Martin down the path, you need to come up with some credible explanation as to how the keys wound up at the top of the "T". The prosecution had no theory presented in court to explain this fact.

As for SYG, the only application of it was in the Judge's instructions to the Jury, where the jury was informed that Zimmerman did not have a "duty to flee" in order to find Self Defense.