Acquital for Zimmerman

Very loaded term. We don't know if that's what happened. It is possible that Martin and Zimmerman both threw but Martin was faster, Zimmerman pushed him, or literally challenged him to a fight.

Maybe I missed it but nowhere does George say what happened between the Martin's question and being on his back nor is there other evidence.

RJ said he threw the first punch. Also, we only have GZ's account but that's evidence too which was not impeached. So I don't think that 'suckered punch' is a very loaded term.
 
Nope. It means I think you should flee from the danger and use force only as a last resort, and only the minimum amount of force reasonably required.

Americans, and Canadians who watch too much American TV, don't like that answer because it flies in the face of their pro-violent and warlike culture.

So is it YOU Fuji who determines what is the minimum amount of force reasonably required/ do you do it in real time? or from the benefit of your sofa days, weeks or months later?
You oughta play w dolls and toy soldiers, where real life isnt an inconvenient variable.
 
No doubt he did surprise him but how do you know that the punch wasn't because Z pulled out a gun or some other violent threat? You just take Z's word for it?

I don't see how a 17 year old is going to counter someone who pulls a gun at arm's length with a punch because that might provoke the other to fire.

If you're a juror, unless the evidence of the Defendant is impeached, you have to consider it. The fact that you ignore it means you're biased. Whatever scenario you speculate here, is not evidence Fuji.
 
Last edited:
if trayvon felt threatened and trapped by the larger GZ on a dark street, then he would be justified in shooting or punching GZ

im not sure "feeling " threatened or trapped would an effective syg or a self defence strategy. even in this case , where there is actual physical evidence of a beating, and testimony from a witness who says he saw TM on top moving as of he were administering the beating half of TERB doesnt accept even that .
 
Very loaded term. We don't know if that's what happened. It is possible that Martin and Zimmerman both threw but Martin was faster, Zimmerman pushed him, or literally challenged him to a fight.

Maybe I missed it but nowhere does George say what happened between the Martin's question and being on his back nor is there other evidence.

wow, basketcase the KING of loaded terms like HUNTED/ STALKED is trying to call out a loaded term. Pot meet kettle.
 
No doubt he did surprise him but how do you know that the punch wasn't because Z pulled out a gun or some other violent threat? You just take Z's word for it?

it does not matter in this case. Because what actually happened could not be proved.
 
in this case who threw the first punch didnt matter, because there was no proof either way. What mattered was Zimmerman legal team convinced the jury he acted in self defence .

Correction. The only 'proof' is the account of the only living witness, George Zimmerman (besides any other witness statements or circumstantial evidence). Unless his credibility is impeached, his statement should stand as evidence adduced for the defendant.

The issue with the first punch is to counter Fuji's assertion that TM also had a SYG right, but that requires that he was attacked first. However, if TM 1st punched, then it was he who attacked GZ, which opens the door for a SYG defense or right for GZ. In this case, as Aardvark154 points out, GZ didn't need a SYG defence since he could not flee while pinned, and used deadly force as his normal right to defend himself.
 
im not sure "feeling " threatened or trapped would an effective syg or a self defence strategy. even in this case , where there is actual physical evidence of a beating, and testimony from a witness who says he saw TM on top moving as of he were administering the beating half of TERB doesnt accept even that .

under syg- couldn't trayvon shoot GZ dead if he felt threatened?
 
So is it YOU Fuji who determines what is the minimum amount of force reasonably required/ do you do it in real time? or from the benefit of your sofa days, weeks or months later?
You oughta play w dolls and toy soldiers, where real life isnt an inconvenient variable.

I think it's from the Canadian perspective. One requires much justification to use deadly force but only if your life is threatened. There's no presumptive law of self-defence here. You can only use a proportional amount of force in your defence.

When I read this SYG law, it sounds crazy. It seems to facilitate a gun owner's right to use his gun to defend his home with deadly force from intruders. However, in light of liberal gun laws in the U.S., that means intruders are also more likely to be armed, so maybe it's a reasonable law in light of that fact.
 
Here is the law:

(3) A person who is not engaged in an unlawful activity and who is attacked in any other place where he or she has a right to be has no duty to retreat and has the right to stand his or her ground and meet force with force, including deadly force if he or she reasonably believes it is necessary to do so to prevent death or great bodily harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the commission of a forcible felony.

If TM confronted Z and demanded to know why he was being followed, and Z then pulled a gun on him, that law entitled TM to use deadly force to stop the threat.

Moreover it entitled TM to stand his ground and demand an explanation, he had no obligation to flee or retreat from Z.

right, but he shouldn't have, becasue the other guy had a gun and during the fight he pulled it out and shot him.
TM might have been exercising his right to use deadly force on Zimmerman and may have achieved that goal, if Zimmerman hadnt shot him.
 
I think it's from the Canadian perspective. One requires much justification to use deadly force but only if your life is threatened. There's no presumptive law of self-defence here. You can only use a proportional amount of force in your defence.

When I read this SYG law, it sounds crazy. It seems to facilitate a gun owner's right to use his gun to defend his home with deadly force from intruders. However, in light of liberal gun laws in the U.S., that means intruders are also more likely to be armed, so maybe it's a reasonable law in light of that fact.

WHO DECIDES WHAT IS REASONABLE? a jury or a judge. Not your political enemies. Or your cultural or tribal enemies . jesus christ.... put yourself in the defendants seat on trial for your freedom. Would u want a whackadoodle like Fuji singularly deciding your fate?
 
I am interested that in all the hypotheticals above no one seems to be paying much attention to what Rachel Jeantel has actually admitted in her recent television interviews.
I know I promised not to post again on this thread, but...

Aardvark: stop trying to confuse people with the facts!

Perry
 
Here's the statute itself which was partially quoted by Fuji. Read paragraph 3.

http://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes...ing&URL=0700-0799/0776/Sections/0776.013.html


It's not enough to feel threatened. You must be attacked.

reading further.....

776.012 Use of force in defense of person.—A person is justified in using force, except deadly force, against another when and to the extent that the person reasonably believes that such conduct is necessary to defend himself or herself or another against the other’s imminent use of unlawful force. However, a person is justified in the use of deadly force and does not have a duty to retreat if:
(1) He or she reasonably believes that such force is necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the imminent commission of a forcible felony; or
(2) Under those circumstances permitted pursuant to s. 776.013
 
maybe. but it is irrelevant to this case. That case would turn on the evidence upon which a charge was brought and a defence built.

what this case tells everyone- is make sure the other party is dead. thats your ticket
 
Correction. The only 'proof' is the account of the only living witness, George Zimmerman (besides any other witness statements or circumstantial evidence). Unless his credibility is impeached, his statement should stand as evidence adduced for the defendant.

The issue with the first punch is to counter Fuji's assertion that TM also had a SYG right, but that requires that he was attacked first. However, if TM 1st punched, then it was he who attacked GZ, which opens the door for a SYG defense or right for GZ. In this case, as Aardvark154 points out, GZ didn't need a SYG defence since he could not flee while pinned, and used deadly force as his normal right to defend himself.

it is not proof. It is part of the narrative Zimmermans team built through the admission of Zimmermans statements / walk throughs etc...c by the prosecution!!!! (dumb?) which kept Zim off the stand

Fuji is so off point with his assertions they arent worth countering anymore. He lives in Hypotheticalville. In fact he is the fucking dictator of that sad little burg
 
what this case tells everyone- is make sure the other party is dead. thats your ticket

or dont confront anyone. because you never know.

both outcomes are sad, and seem pretty primal , but look at how jacked up people are !
 
So is it YOU Fuji who determines what is the minimum amount of force reasonably required/ do you do it in real time? or from the benefit of your sofa days, weeks or months later?
You oughta play w dolls and toy soldiers, where real life isnt an inconvenient variable.

I have no idea whether you have a point. You seem to be an angry person blathering on with nothing important to say.

You had an inane and ridiculous question there. Obviously we expect a jury to decide what force is reasonable.